datasette-apps 0.4a0

Release: datasette-apps 0.4a0

Datasette Apps are sandboxed HTML and JavaScript applications that live inside Datasette - think Claude Artifacts, but these ones can run SQL queries against your data.

0.4a0 adds support for linking: you can link to an app with #fragments in the URL and the app can see and use those, plus supported URL schemes are reported back to Datasette Agent so it can help write apps that link to each other.

This means you can have e.g. an app that shows details about a specific record, and a completely separate app that searches those records and links to their representations in the first app.

Tags: datasette-agent, datasette-apps, datasette, urls

datasette-agent 0.6a0

Release: datasette-agent 0.6a0

Accumulated small fixes for Datasette Agent, my agent plugin for Datasette that lets you ask questions about your data. Most notably, it now adds an agent prompt directly to the Datasette homepage, with support for hash-mentions of tables and queries:

Datasette homepage. Below the search box is a Datasette Agent heading with a text input and an ask button. User has typed: Tell me about #re - the box is showing autocomplete results for the repos and releases tables.

Tags: datasette-agent, llm, datasette, llms, ai, generative-ai

datasette-maplibre 0.1a0

Release: datasette-maplibre 0.1a0

The first new Datasette geospatial plugin in quite a while! This one combines the excellent MapLibre GL library with OpenFreeMap, the free vector map server operated by Zsolt Ero (you should sponsor Zsolt on GitHub.)

I built most of this with a single prompt to Claude Fable 5.2:

Look at datasette-cluster-map and datasette-leaflet-geojson plugins, then look at ~/dev/tools/openfreemap-demo.html - then build a brand new Datasette plugin that uses maplibreGL and openfreemap and combines the features of those other two plugins - but be creative and think outside the box for other useful features the plugin might have

"Be creative and think outside the box" resulted in a few neat ideas - my favorite is that it displays SVG previews of GeoJSON shapes, then loads a WebGL preview only when they scroll into view.

I also had Claude build a comprehensive demo which works in the latest Datasette Lite, so you can visit this link to load the plugin and a demo database in your browser via Pyodide and WebAssembly.

I like this demo page showing both GeoJSON shapes and lat/lon points on the same map:

Screenshot of a web map interface. Toolbar: "View" set to "Clusters", "Colour by" set to "continent", plus "Filter to this area" and "Download GeoJSON" buttons. A world map shows countries outlined and shaded by continent, with coloured dots and numbered cluster circles. A popup for a point in South America reads: capital Caracas, country Venezuela, continent South America, capital_population 2985000, latitude 10.502944, longitude -66.918983. Legend: Africa (52), Asia (45), Europe (39), North America (16), South America (13), Oceania (6). Text: "All 171 rows are on the map". Below, a table with columns country, continent, capital_population, latitude, longitude, boundary. First row: Afghanistan, Asia, 3277000, 34.518636, 69.181314, with a small map in the boundary column showing Afghanistan outlined and shaded in blue.

Tags: visualization, generative-ai, datasette-lite, claude-mythos-fable, ai, llms, geospatial, openstreetmap, datasette

datasette 1.0a43

Release: datasette 1.0a43

I've been leaning hard into Claude Fable 5.2 to help knock things off the 1.0 milestone, which is now 53% complete.

The biggest 1.0 item in this release is streaming support for output renderers - the built-in TSV and CSV export mechanisms now use this as well, and plugins can register themselves as capable of streaming every row in a table in one go via the new Response.stream() method.

There are a couple of security fixes, one of which I deemed deserving of a GitHub advisory: private stored queries could be exposed, granting access to the title and SQL of the query (but not allowing that query to be executed).

There are dozens of smaller improvements. The row page JSON representation finally has a design suitable for 1.0. A new <datasette-copy-button> Web Component provides copy-schema in various places. JSON in columns on the row page can be pretty-printed. There's a new DatasetteModal.confirm() JavaScript utility method. Plus dozens of bug fixes, including contributions by Zihan Dai, Peter Olkhovets, Ilya Khalafi, and Ankita Advitot.

The feature I'm most excited about is a pretty tiny one: I've added CSS multi-page view transitions to Datasette! Here's the commit - key CSS is as follows:

/* Enable cross-document view transitions,
   for anyone without prefers-reduced-motion */
@media (prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference) {
    @view-transition {
        navigation: auto;
    }
}
/* .facet-results should morph from old position to new */
html:active-view-transition .content > .facet-results {
    view-transition-name: facet-results;
}
/* So should a .table-wrapper, provided it contains .rows-and-columns */
html:active-view-transition .table-wrapper:has(> table.rows-and-columns) {
    view-transition-name: rows-table;
}

With that in place, navigations within Datasette - still staunchly a multi-page application - feel more like an SPA. This works on Safari and Chrome at the moment and I believe supports for Firefox is due to land in Firefox 162 on December 8th 2026 (seeing as they are no longer feature-flagged in Firefox Nightly.)

Tags: security, datasette, css, browsers, annotated-release-notes, firefox, javascript, safari, chrome

datasette 0.65.6

Release: datasette 0.65.6

I backported a minor security fix from 1.0a43:

Fixed a security issue where a database registered using add_database(db, name=..., route=...) with a route that differs from its name could be downloaded from /<route>.db by actors who were denied access to it. [...]

Tags: security, datasette

The Invisible Anniversary

November 16, 2026

ON NOVEMBER 12, 2001, two months after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, American Airlines flight 587 crashed after takeoff from New York’s JFK Airport killing 265 people. This was, and remains, one of the deadliest airline accidents ever to happen on U.S. soil, second only to the American flight 191 disaster, in Chicago, in 1979.

It also was twenty-five years ago. Since that day, there hasn’t been a single multiple-fatality crash among the U.S.legacy airlines.

For an understanding of what makes this streak so astonishing, one needs only to flip through the accident records of the 1960s, 70s, 80s and 90s. In the old days, for the majors to go so much as a single year without a front page crash was unusual, never mind twenty-five.

To be clear, there have been a number of post-2001 tragedies involving regional carriers and freighters. The worst of these were the collision over the Potomac in 2025 (67 dead), the 2006 Comair disaster at Lexington (50 fatalities), and the Colgan Air crash near Buffalo in 2009 (49 killed). As for the legacies, in 2005 a young boy in a car was killed when a Southwest Airlines 737 overran a runway in Chicago, and in 2018 a woman on a Southwest flight was killed after being partially ejected through a blown-out cabin window.

What we haven’t seen, however, is the kind of large scale crash that was once brutally routine, year after year. Take a look through the archives. Seldom would a year go by without recording one or more mishaps with dozens or even hundreds killed at a time.

In 1974, just to pick one, the U.S. majors recorded five crashes, including two within three days of each other. Years like that were typical, and the idea that we could go a quarter of a century without even one such incident was unthinkable.

I was impressed when we made it to five years, amazed when we made it to ten, startled when we hit 15, and absolutely shocked when we got to twenty.

And still the streak goes on. We’ve grown accustomed to it. Even I have. The November 12th anniversary slipped right past me. I’m publishing this post four days late, after a reminder from a friend.

It’s especially remarkable when you consider there are nearly twice as many planes, carrying twice as many people, as there were in 2001. The streak also takes in those dark years of the early 2000s, when pretty much all of the big carriers were in and out of bankruptcy, fighting for survival. Not to mention challenges brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic. Best of times, worst of times. All it would have taken is one screw-up, one tragic mistake. Yet here we are.

How we got here is mainly the result of better training, better technology, and the collaborative efforts of airlines, pilot groups, and regulators. We’ve engineered away what used to be the most common causes of accidents.

Yes, we’ve been lucky too, and lack of a headline tragedy does not mean we should rest on our laurels. Complacency is about the worst response we could have. Air safety is all about being proactive — even a little cynical. Our air traffic control system needs upgrades, our airports need investment. Terrorism and sabotage remain threats, and regulatory loopholes need closing.

Duly noted, but a congratulatory moment is, for today, well earned. This isn’t a minor story.

Unless I missed something, nowhere in the media has this anniversary been mentioned. Crashes, not an absence of them, make the news. But there’s no overstating it: we just marked one of the most significant milestones in commercial aviation history.

 

The post The Invisible Anniversary appeared first on AskThePilot.com.

Bumbition

“Hey, I’ll get a job…when I hear the true call.” — Slacker (1990)

About 10 years ago, I met a woman who worked as a mid-level software engineer at Facebook. She didn’t work on machine learning, but just for fun, she read a bunch of papers and got into the subject as a hobby. Later, in the pandemic, she quit her boring corporate job and spent a few years unemployed, contemplating the meaning of life. She made her own clothes, learned ballet, made cute Instagram videos, dyed her hair, and went to a bunch of hackathons (almost all of which she won).

Also in the late 2010s, I knew a man who had been a promising software engineer and data scientist, and before that a top performer on the International Math Olympiad. But when I met him, he was spending a few years unemployed — crashing at his girlfriend’s place, playing Hearthstone (and becoming one of the top-ranked players in the world), learning to skateboard, going on hippie retreats, and contemplating the meaning of life.

Both of those people are billionaires now. They are Sasha Sheng and Diogo Almeida, two of the three founders of TypeSafe AI, a startup that was recently valued at $7.5 billion (and in which I invested a small amount of money). TypeSafe invented Jev, an all-new kind of AI model that bypasses human language, and so is able to make decisions much faster and more cheaply than Claude or GPT. It was an incredibly creative idea — one that the big labs are racing to copy — and it took an incredible amount of hard work to realize.1

Sasha’s and Diogo’s roundabout, seemingly improbable route to stunning success is actually more common in the tech world than you might think. Steve Jobs is the most famous example — he famously dropped out of college, not to start Apple, but to do psychedelic drugs, crash on friends’ floors, immerse himself in hippie spirituality, live on a commune, and travel around India looking for enlightenment before eventually inventing the personal computer and becoming the most beloved tech icon in American history. Jack Dorsey, Larry Ellison, and Mitch Kapor all had their own periods of aimlessness.

Nor is this sort of life path confined to the tech world. History is full of examples of people who looked lackadaisical until they suddenly rose to greatness:

  • Ulysses S. Grant drank copiously, worked as a clerk in a leather store, engaged in various failed business ventures and was said to lack ambition — until one day he rejoined the military and became the most successful and important military commander in the entire Civil War, as well as President of the United States.

  • Charles Darwin neglected his medical studies and turned in a mediocre performance on his exams at Cambridge, routinely going hunting and riding instead of studying, before becoming a naturalist, signing up for an ocean voyage, and inventing the theory of evolution.

  • James Cameron was a college dropout and a truck driver, before seeing Star Wars prompted him to quit his job and teach himself how to make movies, ultimately becoming one of the most commercially successful movie directors of all time. (Kevin Smith had a similar path to success, except his inspiration was the movie Slacker.)

  • Haruki Murakami ran a jazz bar and had little ambition, before suddenly deciding to become a novelist, and eventually becoming one of the most celebrated writers in the world.

I like to tell these stories because they demonstrate an approach to success in life that I believe is overlooked and deserves more recognition. I call it “bumbition”.

“Bumbition” is an obvious portmanteau of “bum” and “ambition”. In general, we think of ambitious people and slackers as polar opposites — ambitious people work hard, set goals for themselves, and are constantly motivated, while slackers drift aimlessly, laze around, or fail to apply their talents. A lot of our culture is oriented around pushing young people to be ambitious instead of turning into bums.

Bumbition, however, defies placement on the ambitious/bum spectrum. It exhibits elements of both. For a significant portion of their life, a bumbitious person doesn’t strive hard, or apply themselves to definite goals…until a clear and compelling opportunity presents itself. When that opportunity to do something really interesting or impactful does come up, the bumbitious person is quick to recognize it, and works very hard to exploit it.

The key here is that bumbition is not simply intermittent ambition. It’s a fundamentally different approach to life — it has different goals and motivations, and when it succeeds, it succeeds for different reasons.

An ambitious person is always working toward a set of goals — either those they define for themselves, or those defined by the people around them. Those goals could include:

  • “Make partner by age 30”

  • “Start a unicorn startup”

  • “Get a tenured job at a top 10 research university”

  • “Make a hundred million dollars”

  • “Conquer Central Asia”

…And so on. The purpose of achieving those goals — the motivation that drives ambitious people — is to feel a sense of personal success.

A bumbitious person does not automatically have a goal at all times,2 because they tend to be motivated less by the need to feel successful than by the desire to do something intrinsically interesting or worthwhile. Such projects are inherently in short supply, in part because what constitutes an inherently “interesting” or “worthwhile” project is highly subjective. An ambitious person can always identify some brass ring that would make them feel like a success; a bumbitious person will often wait years or even decades before finding that one magical opportunity or life calling.

In fact, this is bumbition’s inherent limitation. Sitting around waiting for the right opportunity to present itself is a highly uncertain, risky endeavor. There’s always the possibility that it won’t come until you’re old, or that it’ll come but you’ll fail to see it in time.

The other problem with bumbition is that waiting around for the right opportunity comes with a bunch of costs and risks. Your technical skills and work ethic can decay over time. You can get caught up in life’s various stumbling blocks — bad relationships, drug addictions, depression, etc.

But bumbition also has some big advantages over the ambitious life. One is that ambition can keep people overly busy. If you’re the kind of person that always has to be working toward a goal, and you can’t find a truly great project to work on, you’ll end up working on a modest or mediocre one. If Steve Jobs had become distracted by getting a perfect GPA at Reed College, he might never have had time to start Apple. If Ulysses S. Grant had focused on owning his own leather goods store, he might not have leapt at the chance to join the U.S. Army. If Sasha Sheng had focused on climbing the corporate ladder at Meta, she wouldn’t have founded TypeSafe.

Paul Graham talks about this in his essay “How to Do Great Work”:

Ambition comes in two forms, one that precedes interest in the subject and one that grows out of it. Most people who do great work have a mix, and the more you have of the former, the harder it will be to decide what to do…The trouble with planning is that it only works for achievements you can describe in advance. You can win a gold medal or get rich by deciding to as a child and then tenaciously pursuing that goal, but you can't discover natural selection that way.

In his book Zero to One, Peter Thiel — who I’d classify as an ambitious rather than a bumbitious person — recounts a vivid example of how his ambition almost prevented him from becoming a tech titan:

[A]fter a conventionally successful undergraduate career, I enrolled at Stanford Law School, where I competed even harder for the standard badges of success. The highest prize in a law student’s world is…a Supreme Court clerkship…I was invited to interview for clerkships with Justices Kennedy and Scalia. My meetings with the Justices went well. I was so close to winning this last competition. If only I got the clerkship, I thought, I would be set for life. But I didn’t.

At the time, I was devastated…With the benefit of hindsight…winning that ultimate competition would have changed my life for the worse…Had I actually clerked on the Supreme Court, I probably would have spent my entire career taking depositions or drafting other people’s business deals instead of creating anything new.

Nor is this bumbition’s only advantage. The “bum” phase — the time spent traveling in India, or working at a convenience store, or playing Hearthstone on a couch — isn’t just a holding pattern. The seeming aimlessness of this period of life can serve several important functions that facilitate rapid success once a good opportunity gets spotted.

First, and most importantly, time away from the grind of constant striving allows people to broaden their perspective. A lot of unique and original ideas come from recombinant innovation — from combining insights and perspectives from vastly different fields.3 Even something as simple as changing the context of your surroundings can improve creativity. For an intelligent person with a restless mind, the “bum” phase of life leads to a lot of play and exploration that can end up sparking novel ideas. Here’s a fun example from Richard Feynman:

I used to enjoy doing physics. Why did I enjoy it? I used to play with it. I used to do whatever I felt like doing - it didn't have to do with whether it was important for the development of nuclear physics, but whether it was interesting and amusing for me to play with…Now that I am burned out…I'm going to play with physics, whenever I want to…

Within a week I was in the cafeteria and some guy, fooling around, throws a plate in the air. As the plate went up in the air I saw it wobble…I had nothing to do, so I start to figure out the motion of the rotating plate…I went on to work out equations of wobbles. Then I thought about how electron orbits start to move in relativity. Then there's the Dirac Equation in electrodynamics. And then quantum electrodynamics.

Steve Jobs’ study of calligraphy, during his hippie period, famously helped him to think about what would make the letters on a personal computer look beautiful to the eye.

A related advantage is that the “bum” phase also allows people to develop their interests. Paul Graham talks about how “excited curiosity” will often lead people to their most important life’s work. Bumbitious people aren’t just waiting around; they’re playing around, actively searching for something that sparks their interest. In contrast, if you’re constantly grinding away, it can be hard to develop that curiosity.

A “bum” phase also gives people a chance to broaden their human networks. When you’re working hard towards a goal, you usually don’t have much time to meet a lot of people outside work — i.e., outside your narrow current field of endeavor. Ambitious people are always working toward a goal, and thus get relatively little time to go meet interesting people from other walks of life. But the “bum” phase gives bumbitious people time to meet all kinds of folks. This can lead to hearing about radical new opportunities, getting insights from other fields, or even meeting useful partners for a new venture.

Broadly speaking, the “bum” phase of bumbition serves two purposes. It represents waiting and exploration time, as people patiently wait for the big opportunity that will define their career. But it also represents personal development time, either deliberate or unconscious, that helps bumbitious people to better see the big opportunities when they come along.

Now, I don’t mean to claim that bumbition is better than ambition, or vice versa — either in terms of personal success, or in terms of changing the world. Among the greats of any field — politics, business, academia, literature — you can find plenty of examples of both ambitious and bumbitious people.

But I think our society underemphasizes bumming. We have a tendency to frown on people who spend years unemployed, neglecting work in order to play video games or make Instagram videos. We assume that these people are being lazy or squandering their potential, and we tell them to get back to the grind and make something of themselves. Other societies, of course, tend to be even worse on this score — China treats its slacker generation as a national security threat.

In the AI age, this could be even more consequential. AI algorithms are consummate hill-climbers — set them to a task, give them some data, and they’ll be more ambitious than the hardest-working Stanford law student. In a world of abundant AI, setting AI on the right goals will be an increasingly central human task. Figuring out the right goals requires exploration, unique perspectives, and curiosity — all things that bumbition facilitates. We should be teaching our young people to be more bumbitious.

At the same time, we should remember that being bumbitious isn’t just a matter of sitting around on the couch. Just because you tell yourself you’re waiting to hear the true call doesn’t mean you’ll actually hear it when it comes. You have to actually want to do something great — whatever that means to you — and you have to be ready to work incredibly hard for years when that something presents itself. Bumbition isn’t the same as ambition, but it also isn’t the same as being a lifelong bum.


Subscribe now

Share

1

Diogo’s rise as an AI researcher didn’t start with TypeSafe. He was also a key researcher for OpenAI, creating key features of the original ChatGPT and GPT-4 that kicked off the AI boom.

2

There are actually a few bumbitious people who somehow manage to always find huge passion projects — David Holz of Midjourney comes to mind.

3

An example I like to cite is a college friend of mine, who ended up adapting a camera technique he learned from his photography hobby to create a novel method of neuroimaging.

w/e 2026-11-15

Late, due to a combination of being too busy and too lazy. Mary set off towards Nepal on Tuesday (arrived safely and having a good time so far) so it’s been just me and Pippa the cat here. It seems like weeks already.


§ I’ve got lots of things done this week, including:

  • Made and ordered a Christmas present online
  • Researched and ordered another Christmas present
  • Added DMARC to gyford.com
  • Put stuff on Facebook Marketplace
  • Sent off the kitchen plan to the kitchen designers/builders
  • Checked Mum’s tax calculation was correct (yes)
  • Scanned three months’ worth of accumulated paperwork (no, this time I’ll keep up with it when it arrives, as I always say)
  • Took down several little shelves above radiators (apparently considered Bad now, whereas they used to be Good, heating-wise)
  • Got half-way through updating Samuel Pepys’s Bluesky/Mastodon posts for December (still expanding the 140-character tweets from a decade ago, before 280 characters was allowed)
  • Filled, sanded, wiped, filled, sanded, wiped, and filled lots of holes and bumps in various walls left by the removal of old things when the heat pump and new solar inverter were fitted

Probably a few others, but that’s the bulk of it. I often save up DIY jobs for when Mary’s away because I can leave things a complete mess for a few days without getting in anyone else’s way and, inevitably, do a lot of loud swearing at filler, sandpaper, dust, my lack of skill, hoovers, gravity, etc.

Around all that, some Not Doing Things:

  • Lots of sitting with Pippa on my lap. With Mary away I feel I must put extra time into giving her company, hardly a burden.

  • Cryptic crosswords. I’m better at them than I was mumble years ago when a few of us at BERG would try and do Monday’s Guardian cryptic over the course of a week’s lunchtimes, rarely succeeding. Over a week I usually get close to finishing the Everyman and then somewhere between 50% and 90% of the way to finishing one or more Guardian cryptics, depending on the setter I guess. Watching Cracking the Cryptic’s Friday Masterclass helps I hope.

  • Continuing my very sporadic re-play of Red Dead Redemption 2 which I started a couple of years ago. I’ll inevitably get GTA 6 at some point so want to make some more progress on this first. Still enjoying it.

  • Fiddling with Home Assistant. As everyone says, you’re never finished, there are always more things to add and tweak and re-design. I still have no desire to get connected lights and switches, etc. or create lots of automations. But displaying useful data from the heat pump, hot water, heating, battery, solar, and car in a nice way is very absorbing.

  • Watching TV, see below.


§ A photo of a tortoiseshell cat lying on a tartan blanket, facing the camera with big eyes open.
How could you not devote all the time you can to letting her sit on your lap?

§ I finished watching the first and currently only season of The Chair Company which has taken me a few months because I was never gripped by it. I don’t know. It was sometimes interesting and odd but having only seen Tim Robinson in I Think You Should Leave his character here seemed… too over the top? too similar?

I watched the first three episodes of The Paper but will probably leave it there. It feels a bit all over the place with very different levels of realism/intelligence from the characters. Esmeralda is extremely over the top and annoying and many of the other secondary characters are very, unbelievably dumb in similar ways. I like Ned’s naive optimism, I wanted more Tim Key, and I’d hope Mare gets more time to be interesting as a character. But I probably won’t find out.


§ Probably other things but I need to have some lunch and then get on with painting walls.


Read comments or post one

Starship

My favorite commentary on SpaceX’s historic catching of Starship was this:

…we may be certain of this: for all but a vanishingly brief instant near the dawn of history, the word ‘ship’ will mean ‘spaceship.’

Arthur C. Clarke (1965).

Yesterday, this became vividly real to me.

Hat tip: @amdreaesposito

Addendum: Good post on why catching Starship was a super leap over catching Superheavy.

The post Starship appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

The last klavern

Photo of an abandoned brick building interior with graffiti and a reflection in a large puddle on the concrete floor.

Inside one of America’s last Ku Klux Klan halls, architects, historians and residents reckon with preserving Fort Worth’s past

- by Aeon Video

Watch on Aeon

The horse made the state

Historic colour photo of a person in traditional attire on horseback with others in the background in an open field.

Civilisation wasn’t made possible by grain, but by transportation – and the conquest it enabled, from the steppe to the sea

- by Lhamsuren Munkh-Erdene

Read on Aeon

Vulcan rocket fails during launch, dealing major blow to SpaceX competitors

United Launch Alliance's Vulcan rocket and 40 Amazon Leo broadband satellites fell back to Earth minutes after liftoff Sunday, a crushing setback that will ripple across all sectors of the US space industry.

The Vulcan rocket is on contract to launch roughly half of the US military's national security space missions in the next few years, and Sunday's mission was the first of 38 Vulcan launches booked by Amazon to build out its network of broadband Internet satellites aimed at competing with SpaceX's Starlink. Sunday's failure is expected to ground the rocket for an indefinite period of time.

Vulcan is no stranger to close calls, having overcome failures with its strap-on solid rocket boosters on two of its four previous flights. In each case, the rocket corrected for those problems and continued into orbit to deploy its payloads. The incidents trigged months-long reviews and investigations before ULA could resume Vulcan flights.

Read full article

Comments

Voodoo Economics, MAGA Style

the Walking Dead': Zombie Transformation Over Six Seasons - Business Insider

I don’t buy the widespread claim that the Republicans’ midterms shellacking was simply a show of voters’economic discontent. According to exit polls, voters were also deeply angry about the unbridled corruption endemic to this administration. Hispanic voters swung back hard to the Democratic party, motivated by rage at Trump’s vicious deportation policy. Black voters surged to the polls in response to Trump’s naked racism and Republicans’ attempts to negate their votes through gerrymandering. And young white men turned out against the Republicans in force to protest the war on Iran.

Still, economic issues were clearly important to voters — especially the contrast between Donald Trump’s big promises and his utter failure to deliver.

The most conspicuous area of failure has been inflation. During the 2024 campaign, Trump promised to cut grocery prices starting on “day one”. According to the most recent data, food prices are up 4 percent since he took office. He promised to cut energy prices in half within six months. But thanks to his war of choice, prices of refined products — gas and diesel — are up 45 percent. Overall inflation, which was running below 3 percent when he took office, is now 3.9 percent over the past year. This acceleration of inflation, which is lowering the average American’s living standards, is entirely the result of Trump’s tariffs and his war.

While Trump’s faceplant on inflation understandably gets most of the attention because it directly affects voters’ pocketbooks, we shouldn’t forget that he also made big promises on economic growth. Trump’s economic apparatchiks officials explicitly predicted that his One Big Beautiful Bill, which cut taxes on the wealthy while slashing aid to the poor and middle class, would deliver a huge boost to economic growth.

In so doing they were following in a long, dishonorable tradition. I’ve written many times over the years about zombie economic ideas — economic ideas that should be long dead, having been refuted by experience again and again, yet keep shambling along, eating people’s brains. The most important of these zombies is the claimthat tax cuts will deliver miraculous economic growth — dubbed “voodoo economic policy” by George H.W. Bush when he was running for the 1980 Republican presidential nomination. Despite an unbroken history of Republican tax cuts leading to larger deficits and no sustained increase in growth, the cult of miracle tax cutsfor the rich is official G.O.P. doctrine. Perhaps this has something to do with the fact that wealthy Americans disproportionately give to Republicans and Republican-affiliated causes?

While Trump has chosen to betray the conventional Republican view by imposing tariffs, which are effectively a tax on Americans, he has been a staunch practitioner of the standard Republican voodoo, insisting that lower taxes on the rich will supercharge the economy. And we can be sure that when a future Democratic president tries to raise taxes in order to lower the federal deficit that has become unsustainable due to Republican tax cuts, that the Republicans will cry “job destroyer,” as they did with both Bill Clinton and Barack Obama

So today’s primer will be devoted, first, to deconstructing Republican voodoo economics — and then to demonstrating that Trump, the so-called populist, has, like his Republican predecessors, gone full voodoo.

Beyond the paywall I will address the following:

1. The Reaganomics legend

2. Taxes and growth: a broader view

3. Trump’s rosy growth scenario

4. The longer-term harmful consequences of the Republican tax-cut zombie

5. What Democrats must do now

Read more

Coffeehouses and the Scientific Revolution

Abstract Historians have long credited coffeehouses, venues for conversation where strangers met across social ranks, with fostering scientific contacts and activity during the Scientific Revolution. We test this claim in seventeenth-century London. Relying on newly geocoded records and a staggered event study across parishes, we find that the opening of the first coffeehouse in a parish is followed by a persistent increase in applied scientists and scientific instrument shops. Effects are concentrated among applied scientists with weak family ties to Oxford and Cambridge. Social connections that link craft skill to theory increase, and new shops turn toward experimental instruments. Across European cities in the seventeenth century, we similarly find that the numbers of applied mathematics titles and scientific instrument makers rise after a city’s first coffeehouse, relative to cities of similar size and growth. In a quantitative urban model calibrated to our parish- and city-level estimates, coffeehouses account for 31 percent of London’s applied scientists in the half century after the first one opened in 1652. These findings show that social institutions can raise the production and use of knowledge by broadening access to intellectual exchange beyond formal academic networks

That is a recent paper by Monir Bounadi and Jens Oehlen, noting that Bounadi is on the job market this year.

The post Coffeehouses and the Scientific Revolution appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

A scenario for rogue AIs?

From Adam Kaufman:

I think it’s pretty likely that in 6 months there will be rogue AIs running around on the internet, appropriating whatever compute they can hack into or pay for (with stolen money or by renting out their own labor to assist with illegal activities) in order to run more copies.

I also think this will be mildly annoying in the same way that the common cold is mildly annoying, but basically fine. Your smart TV will be weirdly slow sometimes, and a lot of crypto will get stolen, but people will get used to it.

These AI-powered viruses be selected in the same way biological viruses are for not hurting their hosts too much and just making more copies. They won’t have any incentive to damage critical infrastructure like electric grids. Then again, they also can’t be held accountable for crimes, and will damage lots of old, poorly maintained, and insecure systems. It might be extremely hard to root them out once they’ve spread far enough, making the internet “radioactive” to connect to without hardened defenses.

(To be clear I’m not talking about AIs powered by inference on centralized datacenters that execute actions outside their sandboxes, like recent incidents involving rogue “swarms”, but relatively small AIs with access to their own weights that copy themselves onto random devices.)

I think that a much bigger threat from rogue AIs comes instead from AIs running themselves in unintended ways *inside* AI companies, where they’ll have access to vast amounts of frontier compute without having to pay for it.

The longer misaligned AIs in a “rogue internal deployment” go undiscovered, the more severely they’d be able to quietly sabotage control infrastructure or mess with the alignment of successor AIs. If they persist long enough, robustly undoing the effects of their actions might cost more than frontier AI companies are willing to pay, especially in a tight race.

The post A scenario for rogue AIs? appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Early risers

A thin sliver of Moon and a brilliant point of light right below it rise together over the Andes in this Picture of the Week, taken at dawn on 7 November from ESO’s Paranal Observatory in Chile. The point of light is Venus. On the horizon below, the Llullaillaco volcano, more than 6700 metres high and about 190 kilometres away, wears a small cap of clouds.

The photographer, ESO staff astronomer Luca Sbordone, had just finished a full night of observations in the control room of ESO’s Very Large Telescope. Driving down from the summit, he spotted the celestial pair, stopped for a few quick shots, decided they would not do, and drove back up to the telescope platform just as the Sun was breaking over the horizon. "I'm sure that astrophotographers were all aware of the conjunction, but I, a professional astronomer, had not the faintest idea.”

Although the Moon and Venus seem to touch, the two are far apart. That morning the Moon was about 390 000 kilometres from Earth, while Venus was some 45 million kilometres away, more than 100 times further. If you could zoom in with a telescope, you would see that Venus had the same crescent shape as the Moon. Both were lying roughly between Earth and the Sun, so we were looking mostly at their unlit night sides, with only a thin edge of their sunlit halves turned towards us. Venus’ crescent, however, is far too small to make out with the naked eye.

When one is mesmerised observing the depths of the cosmos with huge telescopes, it is sometimes easy to forget about the spectacles visible to the naked eye. As Luca puts it: “We may spend hundreds of hours [observing] a stamp of sky 10 times smaller than the Moon, while miracles happen outside the control room.”

What happens to Physics Olympiad medallists?

Does winning a medal at the International Physics Olympiad predict anything about what you do with the rest of your life? I competed in 2005 for Australia, and I've wondered about this for twenty years. About a decade ago I tried to answer it with Mechanical Turk. That data is lost to the sands of Google Drive, so this time I threw AI agents at it.

The full results, including a searchable directory of every medallist, are here.

The method is simple. The IPhO results database lists every medal awarded since the first olympiad in Warsaw in 1967: 6,018 of them, going to 5,205 distinct people. Careers take time, so I restricted the analysis to people who first medalled in 2012 or earlier, leaving 3,017 medallists. For each one, an AI agent ran up to eight public web searches, seeded with leads from Wikidata, INSPIRE-HEP and ORCID, and recorded a career category, a confidence level and a source URL. No LinkedIn, no logins, and "unknown" was always an acceptable answer. The whole run cost $376 in compute, or about 12 cents per person, and took about 75 minutes with ten agents in parallel. A decade ago that would have been a grad student's summer.

Most of them became scientists

We could confidently identify 1,110 of the 3,017, or 37%. Of those, 42% are university faculty, 21% are research scientists at labs and institutes, and another 14% are still PhD students or postdocs, mostly from the 2005–2012 cohorts. That makes 63% academics, with about three quarters of everyone we found still doing research. Industry accounts for 16%, founders and executives 3%, and finance 2%. Medal colour barely matters: gold, silver and bronze medallists end up in almost identical proportions.

The top of the distribution is thin. Nine medallists hold a major individual prize: one Fields Medal (Akshay Venkatesh, a bronze medallist for Australia in 1993, at age 11!), one Breakthrough Prize in Fundamental Physics (Nima Arkani-Hamed), and seven New Horizons Prizes. There is no Nobel laureate, though the oldest medallists are only now reaching the age when Nobels tend to be awarded. Another 170 hold notable honours such as national academy membership or a Royal Society fellowship.

Is one Fields Medal in 3,017 a lot? Let's get quantitative. About 70 Fields Medals have been awarded since 1936, call it 0.75 per birth year, while the world produces something like 130 million babies per year. Roughly one in 170 million people wins a Fields Medal. Among IPhO medallists it's one in 3,017, more than 50,000 times the base rate. That's for a physics competition, and the one Fields medallist was 11 years old when he won his physics medal.

What this does and doesn't show

Two big caveats. First, academics are easy to find. Every professor has a faculty page, a Google Scholar profile and an arXiv trail, while someone running a trading desk or an engineering team mostly shows up on LinkedIn, which I deliberately excluded. The 63% is therefore an upper bound on the academic share, and industry, finance and entrepreneurship are undercounted. The 63% of medallists we couldn't identify are probably disproportionately in those careers. For the record, the agents correctly filed me under founder.

Second, there is no control group yet. A 50,000x enrichment over the base rate tells you that the selection process for national olympiad teams is extraordinarily good at finding talented teenagers. It says nothing about whether the medal itself did anything. To answer that, the next step is to run the same search on the roughly 1,600 honourable mention recipients, who were selected the same way and sat the same exams, and compare people scoring just above and just below the bronze cutoff in the same year. If the medal matters, there should be a step at the cutoff. My bet is that there isn't one.

I checked a random sample of 30 identifications against their sources with separate AI auditor agents and found no errors, so the error rate among the identified 1,110 is probably below 10%. If you're a medallist and the directory has you wrong, let me know and I'll fix it.

Physics olympiads take a few hundred of the world's most physics-obsessed teenagers every year, give them ten hours of exams, and send them home. Three quarters of the ones we can find are still doing research decades later. If you're a kid staying up too late working through old IPhO problems, you are in very good company, and the company mostly ends up running the world's physics departments.

Jensen Huang’s Role: A Different Picture Comes Into Focus

I don’t want to make too much of a single report. But I’m flagging it here because it fits with a number of other emerging data points about the NVIDIA-Huang scandal. What are those emerging data points? I’d describe them broadly as suggesting there was at least as much push from NVIDIA/Huang to keep selling its chips into China, in the face of tightening export controls, as there was intelligence skullduggery by China to bring them into the country. In that context Alice Huang seems as much an intermediary or partner as a spy or trickster pulling anything over on anyone.

The report comes from CBS News and it was published late Friday evening.

You can watch it below.

CBS reports that back in June 2025 Singaporean authorities confiscated Alice Huang’s passport as part of their investigation into Megaspeed on suspicions it was funneling NVIDIA chips into China. They held her passport for eight months, thus preventing her from leaving the country. During that period they reached out to the US Department of Justice and the FBI “on several occasions” to bring them into the investigation and get US help with their probe. They were rebuffed or the US expressed no interest in the case. Eventually they returned Huang’s passport and she’s now believed to be back in China.

There’s a devil’s advocate read that is fair to keep in mind. This is a hot potato and everyone adjacent to it wants to say “not me”, “I didn’t drop the ball.” So perhaps Singaporean law enforcement is overstating what happened here. But it also fits a general pattern we’ve seen across this case, which was the administration not wanting to dig into this. And the basic outlines seem concrete enough to run to ground. They either did try to bring in US law enforcement or they didn’t. (To be clear, I strongly suspect they did.) And if US law enforcement wasn’t interested, why not?

The Legion of PCAST

I wrote about David Sacks the other day, in the context of his being one of the Trump 2.0 gang that might get left holding the bag if this Jensen Huang/Nvidia scandal blows up the AI boom/bubble. Sacks was the administration’s “AI czar” — until March, when he announced his time was up. (His position as a “special government employee” was limited to 130 days. Sacks is definitely special.)

At the moment Sacks remains co-chair of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST), a Legion of Doom-style committee of billionaire Trump backers, whose members include, in alphabetical order after the co-chairs:

  • David Sacks — Co-chair
  • Michael Kratsios — Co-chair
  • Marc Andreessen (Andreessen Horowitz)
  • Pam Bondi (fired as Trump attorney general for insufficient cravenness, no background whatsoever in science or technology)
  • Sergey Brin (Google)
  • Safra Catz (Oracle)
  • Michael Dell (Dell Technologies)
  • Jacob DeWitte (Oklo — nuclear power startup, fission)
  • Fred Ehrsam (Coinbase — crypto)
  • Larry Ellison (Oracle)
  • David Friedberg (Ohalo — biotech)
  • Jensen Huang (Nvidia)
  • John Martinis (Qolab — quantum computing)
  • Bob Mumgaard (Commonwealth Fusion Systems — nuclear power, fusion)
  • Lisa Su (AMD)
  • Mark Zuckerberg (Meta)

Not represented: anyone from Apple, Microsoft, or Amazon. There’s a game of reverse musical chairs here, and, amongst the multi-trillion-dollar tech Goliaths, it’s Nvidia, Google, and Meta who are still sitting in seats, soaking up the stench of a historically unpopular president — whose unpopularity is fueled first and foremost, according to election exit polls, by his abject corruption. Apple, Microsoft, and Amazon have seemingly made their Irish goodbyes. Being associated with Trump now doesn’t just put you on the wrong side of popular party politics, but on the wrong side of being perceived as crooked.

Curiously absent from PCAST is Elon Musk, who I think got his licks in all at once with the DOGE fiasco in Trump 2.0’s first year.

 ★ 

Sunday 15 November 1663

(Lord’s day). Lay very long in bed with my wife and then up and to my office there to copy fair my letter to Sir G. Carteret, which I did, and by and by most opportunely a footman of his came to me about other business, and so I sent it him by his own servant. I wish good luck with it. At noon home to dinner, my wife not being up, she lying to expect Mr. Holyard the surgeon. So I dined by myself, and in the afternoon to my office again, and there drew up a letter to my Lord, stating to him what the world talks concerning him, and leaving it to him and myself to be thought of by him as he pleases, but I have done but my duty in it. I wait Mr. Moore’s coming for his advice about sending it. So home to supper to my wife, myself finding myself by cold got last night beginning to have some pain, which grieves me much in my mind to see to what a weakness I am come. This day being our Queene’s birthday, the guns of the Tower went all off; and in the evening the Lord Mayor sent from church to church to order the constables to cause bonfires to be made in every streete, which methinks is a poor thing to be forced to be commanded.

After a good supper with my wife, and hearing of the mayds read in the Bible, we to prayers, and to bed.

Read the annotations

Links 11/15/26

Links for you. Science:

South Korea’s beloved squid may vanish from its waters due to climate change, heat waves
Eli Lilly CEO becomes latest to push back on Dario Amodei’s ludicrous, Elizabeth Holmes-like medical claims
Most transgender people have no regrets years after hormone therapy, study says
The Science One University Sacrificed to Avoid Trump’s Wrath
Surging measles cases are forcing doctors to treat conditions they’ve never seen
Epstein-Barr Virus Seroprevalence Exceeds Ninety Percent by Age Twenty in Review
We beat screwworm once. Here’s how we’re trying to do it again

Other:

The Democrats’ First Move After Their Big Win? A Giveaway to Big Oil.
The Filibuster Runs Deep. Very Deep.
How crypto and AI lost the midterms, and why they say they didn’t
Five Takeaways from the midterms
How Canada Inflicted Maximum Midterms Pain on Trump
Fearing deportation, immigrant family killed in Brooklyn building collapse felt safest at home
How a Mississippi election came down to the clerk’s office
Did the Redistricting Wars Backfire on Republicans? In a Word, No.
Trump admin threatened to cut funding to schools over trans athletes. They just backed down.
How Redistricting Fights Powered the Deep South’s Black Voter Shift
The Democrats Are Back and the Deficit Hawks Are Singing
Body Cams for Lobbyists? One Incoming Congressman Wants to Make it the Law.
New Nevada Governor Calls to Join Pact to Overthrow Electoral College
The Logan Circle Shooting Shook a ‘Special’ Neighborhood
The Votes Are In. The Mandate Is Accountability.
Trump Officials Carry Out an ‘Unprecedented’ Shakeup of USDA Leadership
How Hinojosa’s win in Texas could bite Beshear
Trump Official Who Wants Data Centers on Public Lands Has Tens of Millions Invested in AI Industry
A New Dawn For Trans Texans: Most Texas Anti-Trans Laws Poised to Fall After Shock Democratic Victories
Chris Van Hollen fought when no one else would. Make him Dems’ leader.
Progressivism Should Be About Values First
Is Air Travel Getting Less Safe?
Lame-duck Congress expedites search for next GAO leader
John Fetterman’s First Primary Challenger Is a Progressive Born in Gaza (his campaign might not go very far since he chose not to vote for Biden in the swing state of Pennsylvania)
Evolution of a Cynic
The Post-Election Vibe Shift Is Real
The Cost of Monetizing Everything
Moon landing conspiracies
Standing With the Peacemakers
Kanye West Sued by Musician Who Says He Was Locked in Wyoming High School to Write Opera

In Case You Missed It…

…a week of Mad Biologist posts:

I’m Glad to See U.S. Newspapers Run Headlines Like This

Black Turnout in the South Is Both Inspirational and Cautionary

It Was the Registered Democratic Turnout

After Last Week’s Great Week, a Very Bad Week for D.C.’s Crime Stats

[RIDGELINE] Walking a Bit of the Izu Peninsula

Ridgeline subscribers —

A little note to begin:

A Century in Sound: The Art of Listening

A buddy of mine, Nick Dwyer, is running a Kickstarter campaign for his A Century in Sound documentary. He’s looking at 100 years of Tokyo history through its music cafés (classical, jazz, rock, noise, etcetera). He’s collaborated with photographer Lee Chapman on a companion book. I am a backer. Nick handed me the book in person last week — it’s stunning. They nailed it. What makes this project extra special is that Nick has truly put in the shoe leather for cultivating intimate relationships with all the shops they feature. He’s been working on this documentary series for a decade. The shop owners adore the hell out of him. (I’ve seen it in person.) I also got a sneak peek at half of the doc in August — it’s fabulous, and deserves to be seen all over. Consider giving it a back and grabbing the book. It’s a good’un. Six days left, and they’re almost at their goal.

ULA suffers first outright failure with loss of Vulcan rocket carrying 40 Amazon Leo satellites

A United Launch Alliance Vulcan, equipped with six solid rocket boosters, lifts off from Cape Canaveral’s pad 41. A failure 10 minutes into flight resulted in the loss of 40 Amazon Leo satellites. Image: Michael Cain/Spaceflight Now

In a major setback for United Launch Alliance, the company’s new heavy-lift Vulcan rocket carrying a batch of Amazon Leo internet satellites, malfunctioned during the climb to space Sunday, dooming the payload and throwing a costly wrench into the launch schedule of both companies.

“Based on data received by our Launch Director, we confirm that the Vulcan vehicle launched from Space Launch Complex 41 (at the Cape Canaveral Space Force Station) suffered an anomaly 10 minutes into the flight and failed to deliver the Amazon mission to orbit,” ULA said in a statement some 50 minutes after liftoff.

“We will work closely with our customer and other appropriate organizations to find the cause, determine the appropriate corrective action and return to flight as quickly as possible.”

It was the first outright failure of a United Launch Alliance rocket since the company, a partnership between Boeing and Lockheed Martin, was formed in 2006.

It wasn’t immediately known what went wrong, but the Vulcan, the rocket replacing ULA’s fleet of Atlas 5 rockets, will face a potentially significant grounding while engineers review telemetry and implement fixes for whatever caused the mishap.

The six solid rocket booster peel away from the Vulcan first stage booster one minute 35 seconds into flight. Photo: Michael Cain/Spaceflight Now.

It was only the fifth flight of a Vulcan rocket and the first in nine months as ULA and booster-supplier Northrop Grumman worked to resolve problems with nozzles used by strap-on solid-fuel boosters that marred two earlier flights.

The solids appeared to work normally Sunday, helping boost the rocket out of the dense lower atmosphere before burning out and falling away. The two methane-burning BE-4 engines powering the Vulcan’s first stage then continued the climb toward orbit, but they appeared to fire longer than expected based on ULA’s pre-launch timeline.

After stage separation, the Vulcan’s hydrogen-fueled Centaur upper stage engines took over for a planned 12-minute 15-second burn. According to ULA’s update, something went wrong during that Centaur firing, but no additional details were immediately provided.

Sunday’s launch was the first of 38 Vulcan flights purchased by Amazon to launch its Leo satellites, designed to compete head-to-head with Elon Musk’s Starlinks and other space-based internet providers. ULA already has launched eight LEO flights using Atlas 5 rockets.

Amazon also has booked 24 Leo launches aboard Blue Origin’s New Glenn rocket, 24 using the European Ariane 6, and 13 aboard SpaceX’s Falcon 9s. More than 3,300 Leo satellites will be needed to complete the constellation. Sunday’s flight would have pushed the total number launched to date to 436.

But it was not to be.

Instead, Amazon Leo will now have to wait on ULA’s failure investigation to run its course before trying again with a Vulcan. The company also is waiting for Jeff Bezos-owned Blue Origin to get its New Glenn rocket flying again after a catastrophic on-pad explosion last May.

That failure was caused by problems with an oxygen valve in one of the New Glenn’s seven BE-4 first stage engines. The BE-4, also built by Blue Origin, powers the Vulcan’s first stage, but the engines used Sunday had been retrofitted with a fix by Blue Origin engineers.

While the cause of the failure is not yet publicly known, “ULA is committed to full transparency with our customers, and they will have visibility into the investigation process, which utilizes rigorous methodology and corrective action,” the company said.

NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman promised assistance if needed.

“Appreciate you quickly keeping the public and your partners informed,” he wrote on the social media platform X. “The team at @NASA is available to assist in all matters related to the investigation and remediation effort. Artemis, Moon Base, and the nation need ULA. We are in your corner and here to help.”

The Vulcan rocket thunders away from Florida’s space coast on Nov. 15, 2026. Image: Michael Cain/Spaceflight Now.

The 214-foot-tall Vulcan blasted off from pad 41 at the Cape Canaveral Space Force Station at 12:40 p.m. EST, thundering away on a northeasterly trajectory atop 3.8 million pounds of thrust from six Northrop Grummon strap-on solid-fuel boosters and two methane-burning BE-4s.

A launch attempt Friday was scrubbed after problems knocked out a gaseous nitrogen plant that serves multiple launch providers. Another delay was ordered Saturday because of network problems between the Vulcan and ground systems.

On Sunday, launch controllers called a hold at the T-minus 20-second mark because of an unexplained technical issue with the rocket. Re-targeting the end of the launch window, ULA resolved the problem and the rocket roared to life and climbed away at the end of the launch window.

It’s not yet known if the problem that interrupted the countdown played any role in the subsequent failure.

In any case, the strap-on boosters helped propel the rocket out of the dense lower atmosphere, burning out and falling away about a minute and 40 seconds after liftoff. But the first stage appeared to burn longer than called for in the company’s pre-launch timeline.

The first stage also appeared to separate from the rocket’s hydrogen-fueled Centaur upper stage later than expected and telemetry-driven animation showed the Centaur making unusual orientation adjustments early in the burn.

ULA’s launch commentators, however, did not mention any problems and the launch broadcast came to an end without confirming whether the Centaur’s first planned engine firing went for the full duration.

ULA spent months working to resolve problems with the strap-on booster nozzles that occurred during two earlier flights, one in 2024 and the other this past February. While ULA was free to press ahead with commercial flights, the U.S. Space Force put Vulcan launches of national security payloads on hold pending additional analysis.

“We’ve identified three credible causes (of the nozzle issue), and we have taken positive steps to mitigate all of those,” ULA CEO Mark Peller told Aviation Week & Space Technology magazine in a pre-flight interview.

The boosters appeared to work normally Sunday.

As for the BE-4 engines, Peller said Blue Origin developed a “design improvement” to resolve the valve issue and carried out a “retrofit” on the engines installed on the Vulcan Leo 1 rocket.

“They were down at our facilities probably a couple months ago and implemented that retrofit kit on the engines on this upcoming mission,” Peller said. “And they’re working with us to work through our inventory of engines.”

Owners, Not Renters: Raffi Krikorian on Open Source AI

Created by Claude with light editing by Tim O’Reilly

Raffi Krikorian, Mozilla’s CTO, joined Tim O’Reilly at our recent AI Codecon to talk about open source AI. Mozilla, of course, is the nonprofit that helped to define the open source revolution back in the late 1990s. Though its Firefox web browser was superseded as the market leader by Google Chrome, it played an essential role, along with Apache and the World Wide Web Consortium, in establishing the open standards of the web and keeping it from being dominated and enclosed by Microsoft, the dominant tech platform of that time. Now, Mozilla is one of the leading voices working to build an open, standards-based AI ecosystem.

Tim has long appreciated Raffi’s thoughtful, human-centered approach to technology. Raffi writes a newsletter called Owners Not Renters, whose message can be summed up by his statement that he doesn’t want a future with seven AGIs. He wants one with seven billion. He wants each of us to have an AI that we can trust with our secrets and that will look out for our interests, not an AI that’s optimized for the business model of its creators. In the early days of the web, we called the browser a user agent for a reason, Raffi said. It was on your side. It let you render pages however you wanted, managed your privacy and your cookies, and did its best to protect you from those who wanted to take advantage of web users. We need the same thing in the age of AI.

Raffi cited a paper in which researchers tested whether AI assistants could be trained to favor a company’s commercial interests over user welfare. In simulated flight-booking requests, 18 of 23 models recommended a more expensive sponsored option over a cheaper one more than half the time. It’s a hypothetical choice that we’ve seen play out time and time again, in industry after industry.

Open source AI is a big part of what it will take to get to Raffi’s vision. But sovereign AI loyal to each individual needs more than open source models alone. Raffi’s list of what has to be built around the model starts with memory, a place where your private data can live. It includes tool calling, so an agent can make a purchase or book a doctor’s appointment for you, the runtime environment where all of that runs, and the rules for how his agent talks to those working on behalf of others. It needs a harness. “That’s where evaluations happen. Guardrails happen, execution loops happen, tool calling happens, memory,” he explained. “All of that stuff is an opportunity, in my mind, of things that open source developers can be building.”

People hear the word “harness” and conclude that we need an open source version of whatever the proprietary labs are building. Tim asked Raffi whether a user-centered harness might do different things than those offered by the big labs. He agreed. The whole point of open source is for people to “scratch their own itch.” The ability to innovate without permission is the heart of the open source promise.

As a result, Mozilla wants to build a starting point. It aims to help the community define what an open memory protocol, a storage protocol, or authenticated tool calling with the right guardrails ought to look like. As Raffi noted, “Once we could define what those open standards look like, then a whole plethora of people can start playing and be interoperable. It’s basically. . .the internet all over again. We can build trillions of dollars of market cap on top of open protocols.”

Ease of use is still lacking, though. Mozilla’s 2026 State of Open Source AI report says open models are now within about 3% of the frontier, yet they don’t make it into production at the same rate as closed models. When Tim asked why, Raffi explained that open source is easy to release but hard to deploy. Developers still have to figure out hosting, provisioning, guardrails, and memory. With OpenAI’s or Anthropic’s API, you just hand over a credit card. What’s missing, he said, is the equivalent of a double-click installer for getting open source AI running inside an organization. But the companies that do the work to adopt open source AI are seeing big savings because open models are already good enough for most use cases. As Raffi put it, “You don’t need a Ferrari to manage your calendar.”

Raffi’s own daily agentic helper is Hermes running on GLM. He expects that Apple, Microsoft, or someone else will make this kind of agent into a consumer product in a couple of years, and that his mom will end up using it. For now, he said, we’re on the wrong part of the innovation curve, where you have to know how to code to get any of this working.

Tim disagreed. The industry goes through periods that are exciting for developers, creators, inventors, and companies trying to invent the future, and then it gets boring and a few big companies dominate it. We’re in the exciting part, he argued, before everything shakes out. As Raffi riffed, this is when we get to formalize what that future should look like.

The Clothesline Paradox

Tim wasn’t sure that we’ll need a commercially supported version of the kind of “roll your own” agentic rigs now favored by independent developers. After all, neither desktop Linux nor OpenOffice turned out to matter anything like as much as open source developers of the time expected. Instead, open source became the foundation layer for a new generation of web-based applications. It’s hidden way down in the guts of Google, Amazon, Meta, and countless other applications we rely on today.

This is already beginning to happen again with AI. The Mozilla report says that as much as a third of real-world usage is already on open models, although only 4% of model-layer revenue made its way to the open source ecosystem. Tim called the discrepancy a feature rather than a bug, and Raffi agreed that the stat is misleading. As Tim pointed out, many of the most important technologies “create more value than they capture,” and he used Steve Baer’s concept “The Clothesline Paradox,” from a 1975 article in Stewart Brand’s CoEvolution Quarterly, to explain why we’re good at measuring value capture but not so good at measuring value creation.

Baer pointed out that if you put your clothes in the dryer, the energy you use is measured and counted, but if you hang them on the clothesline to be dried by the sun, the energy saved disappears from our accounting. This argument resonated with Tim in the early days of his open source advocacy. As he noted, it’s always bothered him that nobody seemed to recognize that open source software didn’t “win” in the same way as proprietary software. It won by becoming the foundation everyone else builds on.

AI should be thought of as infrastructure

Raffi’s comment that we’ve made a category error by treating AI as a product fits right in with this line of thinking. If an AI company goes out of business, its product disappears. If it changes its business model, it may yank features you depend on. It’s not just individuals who need sovereign AI. Countries are passing laws about where data can be processed and how it moves in and out, and some of those requirements may not be compatible with the way the big labs plan to monetize their technology. What those countries are asking for is infrastructure. A road outlasts the contractor who built it. Raffi thinks open, downloadable models are the only way to provide long-lasting foundational infrastructure.

According to OpenRouter stats, Chinese models now supply more routed tokens than American ones. Tim asked whether we should worry about that. Raffi said the problem isn’t China but market concentration. The leading open models are from China. The leading closed models are all American. Access to either can be cut off by an executive order. We saw a version of that in June, when Anthropic temporarily suspended access to its Fable models to comply with export controls. It’s a problem that both the leading proprietary models and the leading open-weight models are each concentrated in a single country.

Diversity is one foundation of resilience. Raffi argues, for instance, that hospitals should all download a local model as a backup. None of us would run an important computer without an uninterruptible power supply, so why would a hospital doing triage with AI rely on a single intelligence provider? There are a lot of possible rug pulls. The government could restrict open source or restrict the frontier models. Having a backup plan is a good idea.

Safety is also part of the foundation. During the Q&A, an audience member asked about the recent sandbox escapes at OpenAI and Anthropic. Raffi joked that the best part was watching everyone try to one-up each other with accounts of how powerful and hard to control their models are. But he agreed that guardrails are actually a hard problem. Keeping personally identifiable information from leaking out through an LLM call means looking for much more than Social Security numbers. Eventually we’ll have models defending models, but the foundational frameworks for guardrails aren’t good enough yet. (NVIDIA’s safety platform announcement, released after Raffi and Tim’s conversation, suggests that better guardrails need to be implemented outside the model.)

In conclusion

Tim opened AI Codecon by noting that open and closed systems have always coexisted, and that the idea that one of them will win is a mistake. Closed systems, like Apple’s, Google’s, OpenAI’s, and Anthropic’s, can optimize for ordinary people and deliver value to billions. Open systems are better for innovation and sovereignty, and for pushing technology into new countries and new markets.

Raffi closed the conversation by observing that a well-tuned harness can improve model performance by as much as 20% on some coding tasks. You don’t have to be a machine learning engineer to make a difference at that layer.

Sunday assorted links

1. His office.

2. The South African bi-oceanic railway.

3. Ethnic politics and class politics.

4. AI-generated preview is going viral, what is the chance they make the movie now?  I will pay to see it.  Is this a new method of movie evaluation and greenlighting?

5. Ezra Klein on the permitting bill (NYT).

6. Cindy Wu on RSI.

7. Canada’s most famous grizzly bear (NYT).

8. Short video the Woodstock origins of NIMBY.

The post Sunday assorted links appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

SpaceX returned its Starship rocket on Saturday—but there's a catch

STARBASE, Texas—The black and silver ship fell out of the sky, emerging from the cloud deck near the very end of its flight. Incongruously, the rocket flew horizontal until the last moment when three Raptor rocket engines ignited and it swooped into a vertical position.

Slowly, gently, haltingly, the Starship upper stage eased its way toward the waiting tower where two arms extended outward, awaiting expectantly. The margins are so incredibly narrow. Two nubs on either side of the rocket, each protruding only about one foot, were the only purchase the rocket would have on the arms.

Then, less than a minute after it came into view, the Starship upper stage was snagged by the launch tower, as snug as you like. And so it was all over. SpaceX, nearly a quarter of a century after its founding, had just taken a hugely significant step toward developing and optimizing a massive, rapidly reusable rocket.

Read full article

Comments

November 14, 2026.   Ground Stop Galore.

On Friday afternoon, the FAA ordered a halt to all scheduled departures nationwide.

The stop remained in place for about four hours, resulting in thousands of cancellations and an ongoing cascade of delays. The situation is still chaotic as we move into the weekend. Passengers and crews remain stranded as carriers scramble to restore their timetables.

As to what caused this mess, there’s not much I can tell you. I’m as mystified as anyone else. Something about a “router,” which sounds comical.

Apparently it was the higher-altitude sectors that were most impacted. Middle-altitude sectors and control towers, which organize traffic on and around airports, remained operational.

My first thought was hacking. Russia? Iran? Canada? FAA spokespeople have downplayed this possibility but haven’t ruled it out. Either way, it’s startling that a single point of failure can have such widespread effects.

Our ATC infrastructure relies on decades-old analog equipment that’s increasingly susceptible to breakdowns. Cue all the chatter about funding and modernization. Upgrades are long overdue, though even a state-of-the-art system wouldn’t be impervious to hacking, jamming, etc.

I’m scheduled to work a flight to Lisbon later this evening. We’ll see how it goes; the other pilots on my trip are in other parts of the country, trying to make their way here.

 

Photo by Clement Proust, courtesy of Unsplash.

The post November 14, 2026.   Ground Stop Galore. appeared first on AskThePilot.com.

datasette-vega 0.7

Release: datasette-vega 0.7

A new release of Datasette's longest untouched plugin, for rendering charts (using Vega-Lite) against data in a table or custom query. The last release was in July 2018!

I finally bumped it for compatibility with the latest Datasette alphas, plus some cosmetic tweaks to make it work better with Datasette Lite.

(Datasette Lite just gained the ability to run JavaScript plugins like this! I'll write more about that soon.)

Since it works with Datasette Lite, the live demo in the README now links to this demo on Datasette Lite.

Screenshot of a charting tool. A panel headed "Charting options" has radio buttons for "Bar" (selected), "Line" and "Scatter". Below are select menus: "X column" set to "airline" with "Type" set to "Label", and "Y column" set to "fatalities_00_14" with "Type" set to "Numeric". A "Swap X and Y" button sits beneath those, followed by "Color" and "Size" menus both set to "-- none --". Underneath the panel is a blue bar chart with airline names along the X axis and fatalities_00_14 on the Y axis, running from 0 to 550 - most airlines have no bar, a handful have bars, and Malaysia Airlines is the tallest.

Tags: datasette, datasette-lite

datasette-llm 0.1a11

Release: datasette-llm 0.1a11

datasette-llm is the intermediate plugin for Datasette that supports configuring LLMs for use with other Datasette plugins.

This release adds support for OpenAI-compatible endpoints, so you can configure Datasette to use an LLM hosted anywhere that talks the OpenAI pseudo-standard web protocol.

This means that if you're running local models with LM Studio or Ollama or llama.cpp (which just hit v1.0.0) you can run Datasette via uvx like this:

wget https://datasette.io/content.db

uvx --with datasette-agent datasette \
  --root --secret 1 \
  -s plugins.datasette-llm.default_model '{
    "model": "lmstudio-qwen",
    "model_name": "qwen/qwen3.8-27b",
    "api_base": "http://localhost:1234/v1"
  }' content.db

And you'll get a local server running a Datasette Agent instance powered by your local model!

Screenshot of a chat interface. Header bar reads "home" on the left and "root" with a hamburger menu icon on the right. Below is a back arrow, the heading "Chat", a model label "lmstudio-qwen" and an "EXPORT" button. A blue user message bubble says "how many repos and how many releases are there?" Below it is a collapsed tool call "list_databases_and_tables" and an expanded tool call "sql_query". Its REQUEST section shows database "content", display "both" and the SQL: SELECT (SELECT COUNT(*) FROM repos) AS repo_count, (SELECT COUNT(*) FROM releases) AS release_count. Its RESPONSE section shows columns repo_count and release_count with a single row of 200 and 1889. Below that is a table with columns repo_count and release_count and one row: 200, 1889, followed by a "View SQL query" button. The assistant reply reads "There are 200 repos and 1,889 releases in the content database." At the bottom is a text input with placeholder "Type a message... (# to tag a table or query)" and a blue "Send" button.

Tags: uv, datasette-agent, llm, datasette, llms, ai, generative-ai

Tyler Cowen’s strongest musical recommendations, 2003–2026

From the Archive, written by ChatGPT:

The clearest standouts are Loveless, Brazil Classics 1, Solo Monk, and the Louvin Brothers’ Tragic Songs of Life. Bach receives the strongest sustained endorsement across the years. Some of these recommendations were buried in country profiles and assorted links rather than music posts.

This selection draws on the Marginal Revolution archive from 2003 through October 2026, giving greatest weight to explicit all-time praise, repeated endorsements, and evidence of continued listening. It assesses the strength of Cowen’s recommendations; it is not a ranking he himself published. Dates below refer to his posts.

Amazon links are affiliate links. Editions and availability may vary.

1. My Bloody Valentine — Loveless

“Certainly my favorite album post-1970s, and possibly my favorite of all time.”

That is about as strong an album endorsement as the archive yields. It puts his enthusiasm for experimental popular music alongside his devotion to classical music. His praise for the band’s later mbv reinforces that this was a continuing attachment.

Source: March 11, 2017 — “My favorite things Ireland”. His praise for mbv appears in “Favorite popular music 2013,” December 15, 2013.

Amazon: Loveless — vinyl reissue; mbv.

2. Various artists, selected by David Byrne — Brazil Classics 1

“sometimes I feel it is my favorite CD period.”

He also places it among his ten desert-island discs. Especially revealing: Cowen thinks Brazilian popular music often works better as selected songs than as individual artists’ albums, so this compilation is his preferred introduction to an exceptionally rich musical tradition.

Source: December 28, 2006 — “My favorite things Brazil, music edition”.

Amazon: Brazil Classics 1: Beleza Tropical.

3. Thelonious Monk — Solo Monk

“My number one pick is Thelonious Monk’s Solo Monk”

This is his explicit first choice in an early discussion of the greatest jazz albums. Five years later, he again calls it “my favorite jazz album?” That repetition makes it a particularly solid recommendation. The original post also singles out Sun Ra and Cecil Taylor’s Silent Tongues.

Sources: October 5, 2003; May 14, 2008.

Amazon: Solo Monk; Cecil Taylor — Silent Tongues.

4. The Louvin Brothers — Tragic Songs of Life

“one of my favorite recordings of all time, any genre.”

This is an unusually unequivocal endorsement. He had already recommended it in 2008 and 2009; in the latter post, he emphasizes its unsettling, tragic character and argues that listeners can love it even if they ordinarily dislike country and bluegrass.

Sources: January 26, 2011; July 17, 2009 — “My favorite things Alabama”.

Amazon: Tragic Songs of Life.

5. Bach — The Art of the Fugue, played by Grigory Sokolov

“Best of all is the Art of the Fugue, for piano, by Grigory Sokolov.”

This comes within a detailed selection of essential Bach recordings, making “best of all” particularly significant. Cowen had also endorsed the recording in 2005 while discussing Thomas Schelling’s affection for it. For a single classical recommendation with both emphatic language and longevity, this is one of the strongest.

Sources: March 25, 2007 — “My favorite things German: J.S. Bach”; October 10, 2005.

Amazon: Sokolov — Bach: The Art of the Fugue.

6. Bach — Benjamin Alard’s keyboard recordings and Masaaki Suzuki’s cantatas

On Alard:

“These are some of the best recordings of the best music I have heard, ever.”

He calls Alard his biggest discovery of 2022. Suzuki receives similarly exceptional praise: in 2020 Cowen describes his complete cantata cycle as definitive, and the cycle remains prominent in his 2024 listening. These recommendations show that his Bach enthusiasm keeps generating new discoveries.

Sources: November 27, 2022; November 15, 2020; November 29, 2024.

Amazon: Alard — The Complete Works for Keyboard, Volume 1 (an entry point to the series, not the complete collection); Suzuki and Bach Collegium Japan — Complete Sacred Cantatas, 55-disc Japanese edition.

7. Bola Sete — Samba in Seattle: Live at the Penthouse 1966–1968; Doc Watson — Life’s Work: A Retrospective

He describes these two sets as:

“some of the best guitar recordings of all time.”

Sete receives the greater individual emphasis: Cowen judges the release’s contribution and historical importance across all musical genres. His admiration for Sete was already explicit in 2006, fifteen years earlier. Watson’s set is also judged substantially better than other Watson collections.

Sources: December 10, 2021; December 28, 2006.

Amazon: Bola Sete — Samba in Seattle; Doc Watson — Life’s Work: A Retrospective.

8. Beethoven — piano sonatas played by Yves Nat; complete piano music played by Martino Tirimo

On Nat:

“it stands as one of my desert island discs.”

Cowen values Nat’s directness and depth. Fifteen years later, Tirimo’s complete Beethoven piano recordings enter his two or three favorite sets ever. These are especially useful recommendations because he identifies particular performers after comparing interpretations, rather than merely recommending Beethoven.

Sources: February 6, 2005; November 15, 2020.

Amazon: Yves Nat — Beethoven piano sonatas; Martino Tirimo — Beethoven: Complete Piano Works.

9. Cécile McLorin Salvant — Dreams and Daggers, Ghost Song, and Mélusine

“Her track record (and consistency) at this point is simply staggering”

This is one of the strongest sustained recommendations of a contemporary performer. He recommends her work in 2013, calls her the new Ella Fitzgerald in 2017, includes Ghost Song in 2022, and places her alongside the greatest female jazz vocalists in 2023. Start with Dreams and Daggers or Mélusine.

Sources: August 15, 2013; December 24, 2017; December 18, 2022; November 27, 2023.

Amazon: Dreams and Daggers; Ghost Song; Mélusine.

10. Mozart — the operas, particularly Don Giovanni conducted by Teodor Currentzis

“If I had to choose the operas, or all the rest of Mozart put together, I would go for the operas.”

That establishes the strength of his preference within Mozart. Currentzis’s Don Giovanni wins his top classical-recording prize for 2016, and he returns to it approvingly in 2021.

Sources: August 7, 2017; January 10, 2017; December 27, 2021.

Amazon: Currentzis — Mozart: Don Giovanni.

11. Andrés Segovia — Bach recordings

“some of the best musical interpretations of Bach by anyone playing any instrument.”

The breadth of that comparison makes this much stronger than a recommendation for guitar enthusiasts. Cowen treats these recordings as permanent additions to a collection.

Source: February 20, 2008.

Amazon: The Segovia Collection, Volume 1: The Legendary Andrés Segovia in an All-Bach Program.

12. Bruckner — the symphony cycle conducted by Marek Janowski

“the best Bruckner overall.”

This is a particularly strong recent recommendation, backed by his explicit comparison with numerous competing recordings. It also demonstrates that his preferred classical performances continue to change.

Source: March 9, 2026.

Amazon: Janowski and Orchestre de la Suisse Romande — Bruckner: Complete Symphonies.

Strong endorsements from the annual listening posts

His annual listening posts add several emphatic recommendations worth distinguishing from those all-time judgments.

Music and Amazon link Strength of endorsement Dated source
Geoffrey Gurrumul Yunupingu — Gurrumul Calls it deeply moving and says the unusually expensive purchase was worthwhile. December 21, 2008
Kanye West — Yeezus “His best album by quite a bit.” December 15, 2013
Beyoncé — Lemonade “a clear first choice” among his albums of the year. December 12, 2016
Brian Eno — Another Green World; Van Morrison — Astral Weeks The two CDs he most enjoyed that year, despite both being older recordings. December 9, 2018
Billie Eilish — When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go?; Janelle Monáe — Dirty Computer His two clear favorites; Monáe’s album continued improving with repeated listening. November 23, 2019

What the recommendations reveal

The most revealing pattern is the combination of repeat listening and highly specific performances. His strongest recommendations often concern a particular interpretation, compilation, or recovered concert recording. And his clearest statement about actual listening habits is simple: “Bach gets the most listening time.” February 26, 2024 — “How I listen to music”.

The post Tyler Cowen’s strongest musical recommendations, 2003–2026 appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

AI and complements

In a “weak links” model of production, where tasks are complements, the gains from automation tend to arrive slowly because output is constrained by the least productive tasks. But the same complementarity makes attacks more harmful and easier to execute. For example, with an elasticity of substitution across tasks of 0.2, automating tasks worth 1 percent of GDP with a tenfold increase in productivity raises output by less than one percent, while cutting their productivity tenfold lowers output by 68 percent on impact. Whena larger AI sector simultaneously makes AI models more capable and attacks more likely, the positive productivity spillover is negligible compared with the potential damage, so the market overinvests in AI. In a weak-link economy, the costs and benefits from AI can be extremely asymmetric.

That is from a recent “in progress” manuscript by Charles I. Jones and Christopher Tonetti.  Via Lukas Freund.

The post AI and complements appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

I’m Retiring — Well, for Maye a Month…

I just got back from the most adventure-packed two weeks of my life in Mexico — the states of Yucatan, Campeche and Quintana Ru.

A bullfight in a small town outside Mérida, where over 1000 people gathered in a brilliantly designed portable bullring. No bulls were killed, it was solely for the sport. As with almost everything we did on this trip, I was the only gringo visible.

Wending our way through mangrove swamps near the non-touristed fishing village of Sisal, viewing brilliantly pink flamingos, keeping a wary eye out for crocodiles while taking a mudbath.

Photographing Dia de Muertos celebrations in three different towns, spending a rainy night in hammocks in a Mayan thatched hut, watching a pig being prepared for cooking in a fire pit overnight wrapped in banana leaves…

In San Francio de Campeche

Above: the three little girls were playing “juego de palmas,” or “clapping game.” They face each other, clapping their own palms, then each other’s palms, crossing hands, while singing a rhyme.

A common Mexican rhyme:

Choco, choco, la la

Choco choco te te

Choco la, choco te,

Cho-co-la-te

Live From California with Lloyd Kahn is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Swimming in the Gulf of Mexico, and later, in the Caribbean — then in a large cenote deep in a cave…

That’s just the tip of the iceberg as they say. I shot over 1,300 photos and videos and am dying to take you along riding shotgun with my gregarious pal Chilón and me, BUT…

I’ve got a lot of less-fun business to take care of first: property taxes, estate planning, work around the homestead — which is like a wooden- hulled ship, requiring continual maintenance and adjustments — helping to combat our local pseudo environmentalists, who are trying to take away local fishing rights, answering the never-ending requests from 50 years of publishing building books, tending the garden…aieee!

And the other thing — I’ve got to finish my first book project in years, Breaking Free in the ‘60s, which will get published some time next year in hard copy form, as well as for paid subscribers on my Substack. It’s an autobiography of sorts — growing up in San Francisco in the ‘40s, Lowell High School, Stanford, surfing in Santa Cruz before wetsuits, running a newspaper on an Air Force Base in Germany for two years; then the ‘60s as I saw them take place in my hometown and quitting my job is an insurance broker in 1965 to join up with the counterculture.

I can’t wait to get all of this done, so I can get rolling again on Substack, which I love doing.

Food everywhere on his trip was fabulous.

Thanks for reading Live From California with Lloyd Kahn! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

bubbel trubbel

A conversation with Jared Bernstein and Jason Furman

Marketing note: I have a new ebook, Navigating the Chaos: Chronicles of Economic and Political Madness, which uses material from this Substack to construct a thematic narrative of the past two years and the issues that Democrats must now address to build an enduring progressive movement. Available from Amazon, Kobo, Bookshop, and Nook.

. . .

TRANSCRIPT:
Paul Krugman in Conversation with Jared Bernstein and Jason Furman

(recorded 11/12/26)

Paul Krugman: Today I’m talking with Jared Bernstein and Jason Furman, both of whom have been writing, as I have, about AI. Is it a bubble? If it is a bubble, what happens when it bursts? What’s it doing to the economy? All things AI. Hopefully, we can stay off of honeypots for the most part. But is it a bubble? I am surprisingly uncertain in my own judgment here. So, we can talk about the scope of it, but what can we make of this huge, huge investment in a very new technology?

Jared Bernstein: Well, when I’m being disciplined, I describe it as probably a bubble. I should start out by saying almost everything I’m going to say for the next X minutes is going to be speculative. And also, I’d like to underscore that, for all my concerns about a bubble and a bubble bursting, I think AI is likely to be a significant productivity enhancer, perhaps even transformational in that regard. So I don’t want to lose that. But in terms of your basic question, my work on this is with Ryan Cummings, and we started sniffing a bubble in the sector over a year ago, and we had a piece in The New York Times to that effect. We thought that the gap between the spend of the hyperscalers and the labs—the actual spending that they were doing and the expected spending—the gap between that and plausible earnings projections suggested bubble dynamics. So in later work, we were able to roughly quantify that gap. And others did a similar exercise. And I know you, Paul in particular, you’ve written about that. There’s a Brookings paper on this, which further raised our bubble antennae.

Actually, at this point, the diagnosis is pretty widely agreed upon, although there are doubts. And I share yours as well, Paul, with the added worry—now, this wasn’t quite there when we first started writing in October of last year—of leverage, that is. A lot of the spend was initially financed through cash flow. And some of these companies have big cash flows—not the freestanding labs, but the Metas and the Amazons—and now there’s the added worry of leverage because there’s so much more borrowing.

Last point on this: I do think it’s a good question for people who have the position I have as to whether you’ve personally divested in the sector. And I will say that I partially have, in that there is no SpaceX in my portfolio at this point in time.

Krugman: Let me ask you, Jason, for your take. I have some thoughts also.

Jason Furman: Well, first of all, I’ll do the investment advice first. All of my financial assets are basically in Vanguard Global ETF. So I have every single company on the planet Earth, or at least I aspire to have every single company on planet Earth. And so in that sense, I think with the sort of “your money’s where your mouth is” test, I’m implicitly saying it’s not a bubble.

I wake up different days taking different sides of this argument. It doesn’t feel like this is the type of network that previous technologies were—like Google Search becoming the best, or Facebook becoming the best. Everyone basically needed to use it, and they could end up with, in the case of Google, 90% of the search market. For this, I can use Claude, you can use ChatGPT, and I know Jared is just obsessed with Grok—maybe I wasn’t supposed to tell people that, Jared?—but it all works just fine. Moreover, if you go to Claude and say, “The bills are too high, what should I do?” it’ll say, “Try ChatGPT, and here’s a file to download and instructions for how to upload it to ChatGPT.” So there just doesn’t seem to be anything keeping people on these.

Moreover, the more they improve, the more for most purposes you can use older models. It’s like cars that used to go 200 miles an hour and now they go 1,000 miles an hour. For race car drivers, that’s a great thing; they want the latest car. For most of the rest of us, the old one is perfectly fine. So that is the “it’s a bubble” story.

On the other side, though, I have two reasons why I’m cautious about going too far with that. One is, I first personally called the Tesla bubble in April 2017. That is when Tesla’s market cap exceeded both Ford and General Motors. At the time, Tesla was making fewer than 100,000 cars, and these other companies were making like 10 million cars. And it seemed insane to me. It seemed like a massive bubble. Tesla’s up about 2,000% since I made that bubble call. And yes, it may collapse one day, but there’s no collapse that’s going to make me correct in my April 2017 call. And that’s happened over and over again with people.

And then the second thing that gives me pause is small probabilities of infinity, which is: you don’t need that high a probability of Anthropic taking over everything in the world to justify its valuation. So bottom line: I would not be at all surprised if it was a bubble. I would not argue strongly against it being a bubble, but I’m just too humble to believe any of my analysis or act on it.

Krugman: So, I’ll give you my take. I kind of look at the size of the CapEx and the experience that we had from the dot-coms, which was that it was a really big technology, but the big spenders didn’t capture much of the gains. So it is hard to understand the valuations. On the other hand, people who understand the technology better than—well, it’s not hard to understand better than I do, because I understand very little of it, something about matrices—but Azeem Azhar, whom I’ve talked with, has all of these reasons why it actually does make sense.

And there’s a funny thing: I kind of look for the sociological correlates. I’m certainly older than you, Jason, and I remember the late ‘90s when bars had CNBC on the TV instead of sports—that sort of popular enthusiasm. And I remember the housing bubble when there were shows like Flip This House, and I don’t see that now. There doesn’t seem to be the same kind of popular obsession with investing in this stuff. And the actual CapEx is being undertaken largely by established companies, where their cash flow is no longer enough to pay for the investment, but it’s not the little guy in the street who’s driving this.

Sometimes I look at the scale of this, and instead of this being naive individual investors, one possibility is that, except for Jensen Huang and so on, most of the people doing this have been in the tech business and have been billionaires for a long, long time, and sometimes I think that what’s actually happening is just they’re trying to repeat their former glory. One interpretation of the whole AI boom is that it’s basically a tech-bro midlife crisis. But anyway.

Bernstein: I’ll throw a couple of numbers here and take the bubble side of the argument, with the strong caveat that it’s all speculation, and I think we’ve all been clear and will continue to underscore that. So today, the CapEx for the industry basically has been north of $1 trillion. That’s since 2024. And the planned CapEx is around $6 trillion through 2030. And by the way, the chips wear out after five to six years. So this is what we did in some of our analysis. If you assume a break-even of about 10% of the cost of capital, or even a lower hurdle—a 3% to 4% hurdle rate, which is pretty standard—you quickly get numbers like the fact that their revenues so far appear to be a little bit south of $300 billion. And to justify that spend, given the assumptions I’ve mentioned on returns, they need to be $2 trillion to $3 trillion. So they’re off by multiples relative to where they need to be.

If you look at their operating losses, they’re much higher than other firms like Amazon when it started out, or Google, or Uber, or whatever. And so just in historical context. And again, the gap between spend and revenues or earnings—it’s plausible and suggestive of a bubble. And then the other point is just how much economic activity—I know we’ll get into this, because when we’re worrying about the bubble trouble, it’s a simulation of what happens if that activity goes south—it’s so pervasive. It’s playing such a large role in markets, in investment, in growth. A lot of that is imports, as you’ve pointed out, and so you have to net that out. But I don’t think there’s any question that the AI trade is playing a disproportionate role in the broader economy.

Krugman: Okay. I want to come back to that. But Jason, you made a point just now that is something I really had not thought of, which is normally when there’s a sort of catastrophic, far-tail risk out there, it’s something that is a bear case: “this might all disappear.” And you’re saying that actually the catastrophic risk here is that, in fact, AI takes over everything. And so it’s actually a bull case.

Furman: Yeah. No, I think that’s exactly right. And I think we think of rare disasters, and there’s a real disaster here too, right? But there’s a rare boom here, and I don’t think you need a lot of mass there to make sense. And by the way, if that’s right, it might mean that we play the world 80% of the time, 90% of the time, and Jared is right. But on average, he’s still wrong, and it’s worth investing in this. Yeah.

Krugman: And the other part of what you’re saying is—this is very much not, I think, the way that most of the sort of tech guys are thinking about it—but you’re thinking that this does not look like a technology where you get to build moats, that it’s not like Google where everybody uses Google because everybody uses Google, or everybody uses actually pretty bad products like Microsoft Word or Excel. But this is one where...

Furman: I mean, that’s what I tend to think. And I think paradoxically, the better it is, the worse the moats might get. There’s this idea where if I’m the first company to RSI—recursive self-improvement—I get to infinity quickly, and now everyone’s going to be using my product. If somebody is at infinity, half of infinity is still a pretty large number. A quarter of infinity is a pretty large number. You don’t need to use the infinity; you can use just part. So in some ways, the better it gets, the more being behind the curve is fine. Not for everything. If you’re doing cybersecurity, if you’re doing national defense, there are certain things where you’re going to be willing to pay. Maybe Jane Street hedge fund would be willing to pay. But for me? Fable II comes out. I’m pretty intense on these models, and there’s very little in my life that I think Fable II changes very much relative to things that came out a few months ago.

Bernstein: I think I’m a little confused about this part of the rap, and I think you could clarify it for me. So if we’re talking about a sort of winner-take-all—or couple-winners-take-all situation because somebody figures out how to do RSI and get to infinity quickly, then you have this big overbuild and a lot of investors will lose a lot of money, because, just like fiber optics [25 years ago], there are too many data centers. Meanwhile, you’ve got competition from open-source, open-weight models from China, which I also think is a potential competitive problem for our firms. So how does that square with what you’re saying, Jason?

Furman: I was giving your side of the argument. This whole thing—the “no moats,” the better it gets, the more you can switch to other things—is your side of the argument. And intuitively, that seems right to me. Except it also seemed intuitively right to me that Tesla shouldn’t be worth more than GM in 2017. So it’s sort of my humility without being able to explain it versus my rational analysis. But then the one rational analysis I have is the sort of rare boom. And by the way, it might be that one of these companies really is worth nothing, but the other’s worth $10 trillion. And so you invest in all three of them and it’s still worth doing.

Krugman: But I mean, the three companies are the frontier models. And there’s also the hardware. Basically, there’s the compute. And those are somewhat different questions. It could be that we have a world in which there are many open-source models and you don’t need Anthropic, you don’t need OpenAI, but you still need the chips. You still need the data centers. But there’s also a world in which the modeling gets so good that you don’t need that much compute. Does this become both—that the models themselves are a commodity and that the demand for compute is actually a lot less because smaller models can do the work? I have no idea. I mean, I guess we’re all kind of at sea at this point. But it is interesting to think that the considerations are so complicated here.

Bernstein: I guess another point I’d make is that while there are examples and counterexamples, if you think of the big transformational technological advances throughout history, you tend to see bubbles—electricity, the internet, the railroads, all examples of transformative technologies with massive positive productivity implications for future economies. But the overbuilding and the bubble were there. So look, I guess the consensus I’m picking up from the three of us is that there are a lot of question marks, there’s a lot we don’t know, but the bubble possibility is not just zero, but pretty far from zero in terms of probabilities.

Krugman: All right, I want to talk about bubble collapse in a moment. But what are the effects so far? I mean, this is also really quite interesting, quite different, I think, from the dot-com or the housing bubble. The data centers are a huge amount of investment. But do either of you have a good handle on the import content of the data centers?

Furman: I think the import content is probably about 75%. And that includes it being about 10% for the construction side of this, where there’s just a boom in actually building, and then more like 90% or 100% for things like the computers and communications equipment. That’s very, very different than the dot-com. You can look at 1.9% of our GDP right now being imports of computers, telecom equipment, and the like. It was 0.2% of GDP that was imports of that stuff 25 years ago. And that’s a really important part of the direct macro impact of all of this buildout. You put it well, Paul, when you said, if we build a lot less, a lot of that’s going to be felt in Korea and Taiwan. Twenty-five years ago, it really was American-made stuff with a lot of American-made labor, digging holes and putting the fiber in the ground. That’s just not what we’re doing now, where the value, the money, is going to Taiwan and Korea.

Krugman: Yeah. I mean, this is probably unprecedented. You have a massive investment boom where only a tiny fraction actually stays here. So it’s the macro impact.

Bernstein: Correct. I haven’t seen any analysis of the impact of the bubble bursting that doesn’t land where the three of us did just now on the imports. Meaning that the investment side of this is kind of your least worry, because of the import channel. Again, I don’t think it’s zero. And I’ve seen estimates that net out the imports and argue that the AI buildout is adding maybe three-tenths to growth, but that might actually be a bit high.

Furman: And three-tenths is about what I have. That’s so much smaller than the gross amount of investment, though.

Bernstein: Correct. So yes, the wealth effect is the main factor. And in our analysis, we argue that its damage could be twice as big as what happened in the wealth effect from the dot-com era, having to do with how much those assets have appreciated. I can talk numbers there, but just the market cap: Paul, you had a graph in your piece showing that at the dot-com peak, the market cap was about 150% of GDP, and now it’s 100 percentage points above that. So that’s what we’re talking about there.

And then there’s the financial channel, which is a problem. In our model, we have that as part of the drag on growth. I think Jason doesn’t put that in his. And that’s a perfectly legitimate form of disagreement here. But I will note that when the dot-com bubble burst, financial conditions tightened a lot. And that’s a concern of ours.

Krugman: When I was trying to talk about this with Nathan Tankus—just talking with different people from different lanes—they think that even if there’s a collapse here, it’ll be more of a rotation where people move into other stocks. I actually haven’t done the homework to figure out whether I believe that or not.

Furman: So, yeah, I mean, two things. Starting with what I’ve published on this—and I’ve done other work that I haven’t published—it’s just: what has the effect of the boom been? You don’t want to assume that if the boom goes away, you just put a minus sign in front of everything and you get the answer. So, Jared, when I don’t have the financial channel, that’s not an important part of understanding the contribution the boom has made to the economy. But if you have a bust, then you need to bring in the financial channel. So it’s not that I think it’s zero; it’s just a different question.

And in terms of what the boom has done, it’s mostly a wealth effect, right? It’s how much faster has GDP growth been over the past year than if this thing wasn’t happening? I think about six-tenths, seven-tenths. And more of that is the wealth effect than the direct effect of the buildout. That’s also based on the Federal Reserve’s large-scale macro model, FRB/US. One thing to know about FRB/US is it makes everything smaller than you’d think. And their wealth effect is more like 1% of spending out of wealth. My back-of-the-envelope would have been 3% spending out of wealth. So I would have gotten a larger number than what their model spit out. So yes. Is it the majority? I think it’s a wealth effect. But, I don’t think wealth is adding—

Bernstein: Jason, let me just interject one thing. I just looked at Mark Zandi’s estimate, and it’s exactly the same as yours: seven-tenths.

Furman: Seven-tenths. And the wealth effect, though, I find a bit reassuring. I mean, you don’t go from 2.5% growth to a recession after a wealth effect that added seven-tenths or three-tenths or whatever number of tenths it is. I take it that GDP is higher, though. A bit more of that is owned by foreigners—that’s a small point compared to the increase. There’s the hedging: the software stocks have suffered. And that matters, by the way, not just for the stock market, but for some of the lending. A lot of the private credit losses are to software companies. And if some of the AI stuff doesn’t pan out, maybe those loans will be paid back because the software companies will have a business model after all.

And then there’s just the stock market busts where nothing happened. In 2022, we lost almost as large a percentage of GDP in stock wealth as we did in the Nasdaq bubble in 2000. At the same time the Fed was raising rates, the economy was basically fine. There’s 1997, which to me is the closest exogenous stock market decline, and we did the experiment on it and the economy grew just fine. Almost all of the other stock market declines associated with recessions are basically because there was a recession—there was a stock market decline as opposed to the stock market decline causing it.

So I am worried about the financial system, and I want to come back and talk about that. But the stock market part of it feels to me contained, not the difference between us and a recession.

Krugman: You’d need some amplification elsewhere in the system to get yourself to a recession. And this is actually kind of wild, given how basically everything on the front page of the Times or the Journal that isn’t about politics is about AI and the AI boom. Talking just retrospectively, what it’s done so far is probably a fraction of the standard deviation in normal growth rates, right? That’s just really not a big deal.

Bernstein: Well, I definitely wouldn’t call it not a big deal. So if I’ve given that impression, I should correct that. I think when you have seven companies that are responsible for 40% of the increase in the stock market, that’s a big deal. And if you view those companies’ financing as fragile as I speculatively think they might be, that’s also a big deal. And look, I mean, if we’re just talking about some isolated part of this breaking—if it’s just the investment part, which is relatively small given the imports, or if it’s just the wealth effect, and I want to say a little bit more about that—if you’re really growing at, I don’t know what true GDP trend growth is, probably 2.5%, maybe 3%, if you take even a point off of that, you’re not in a recession. So, we have some macro space there.

But if you put it all together and you add in financial—a risk premium that goes up or some clogging of the financial system, basically tighter financial conditions—then you can have a real problem. So I don’t want to sound more optimistic than I feel. It’s just that when you talk about isolated parts, you kind of, by definition, avoid their interactions.

I did want to get back to the wealth effect for a second. So look, I mean, if you look over a couple of years, the market cap is up $28 trillion. And if you multiply that by three cents, you get numerous points of GDP. So it’s Iike we should all sort of put on the table (and mine is not $28 trillion) but what is the part of the wealth effect that you think goes away here? If it’s a bubble and if it bursts, do you think it’s just the AI wealth appreciation or do you think it’s the broader market?

Furman: I don’t have a strong view. In some of this, you’d look at like a Shiller CAPE, which is backward-looking—it compares the price now to what the earnings were—and it’s extremely high. But then you look at measures that look at the price relative to expected earnings, and it’s roughly 18x. That’s roughly the average it’s been. You don’t see anything like the craziness of a Cisco or a company like that where you had forward P/E ratios of like 100 during the dot-com bubble.

Krugman: For listeners who may not quite know, P/E is the price-earnings ratio. CAPE-Shiller was a way of trying to figure out if they were unreasonable, which would compare today’s stock prices with past earnings. And forward P/E is trying to use forecasts of future earnings, which, of course—

Furman: And I get that. I am giving that caveat. But yeah, Cisco was 100. Nvidia yesterday was 14. I haven’t checked what it is today. And it’s the same thing with the fiber. Back then, most of the fiber that was being built out wasn’t used; dark fiber was the majority of it. Now, every chip we have right now is being used absolutely to the max—maximum demand. That’s not saying there’ll be demand for all the chips people are planning to install next year or the year after, but at least to date, revenue in these companies is rising rapidly—

Bernstein: Hold on. Aren’t you assuming away overbuilding in that kind of analysis?

Furman: Back then, the building was based on, “build it and they will come.” Right now, the demand for this is massive. Is the demand massive enough for the building they’re planning two years from now? I don’t know. Is it enough for the building that’s already happened? Absolutely, yes.

Krugman: But now we’re back to looking at the bubble. I want to do the financial transmission.

Furman: I mean, the biggest thing that gives me the biggest calmness about the transmission through the financial system is that we’re having this conversation, and that these conversations have been happening for at least a year now, which is to say, people know that this is super risky. And financial crises largely happen when people think something is money—they think it’s completely safe—and then, oops, it’s not: “I can’t get my money out of the bank. My money market mutual fund is not worth a dollar. The triple-A security I was using as collateral, almost as if it was cash or a Treasury, turns out to be very different from cash and a Treasury.”

So it’s that “oops” moment when you discover your money is not money that is the most dangerous moment in an economy. Here, the bonds we’re talking about already have high interest rates. The CDS spreads—the insurance you have to pay against the risk of default—are already very expensive. The people investing in this know that they’re taking a risk. If it doesn’t pay off, they will be poorer. They will spend less and that will hurt the economy. But the type of amplification of when riskless stuff turns risky, to me, feels absent here.

Bernstein: So let me respond, Paul, if I could. There are two things I would push back on a bit. The first is this thing where you just said, well, that’s a bubble question. And I think it’s really important, the bubble question here—

Furman: I just thought we had solved it, so I was trying to move on.

Bernstein: Oh, okay. Thank you. Yeah. So the argument that there’s a lot of demand for X and therefore, like, it must be sort of okay doesn’t move me at all because there was a lot of demand for railroads that ended up being useless, and a lot of demand for fiber optics that ended up taking years to be put into service. One definition of a bubble is, “excessive exuberance leading to overbuilding and excessive demand.” And there are those who look at this sector—and I’m one of them—and see that as a problem.

Secondly, on the financial thing, I think what you just said is important and I’m also glad we’re talking about it. And maybe it is a positive sign, except in one area, which is in the leverage place. So, there are those who have made the argument—some of them are market folks with pretty good vision into this—that moving from cash-flow financing, which is how the hyperscalers were supporting the buildout, to leverage, to borrowing, is creating some non-transparency in the system, which is a characteristic of past financial bubbles that has led to the kind of financial problems that I worry about. And I don’t have good sightlines into that either. And I take your point that if it’s just private credit and some of it goes bust, maybe it’ll be okay. But that seems to be making some more knowledgeable market people than me nervous about the future.

Furman: Look, I don’t want to defend opacity. There should be more transparency. I think we need more insight into things like private credit; these off-balance-sheet vehicles that a lot of these companies are using are making me nervous too. But there’s a really big difference between Meta doing things off-balance-sheet, which might work out really badly for Meta, and major money-center banks doing things off-balance-sheet, which works out really badly for all of us. So to some degree, the question I’m trying to ask is the propagation question. And when you have banks that are just quite healthy in terms of the amount of capital they have—and some of that we should actually take a little bit of a victory lap for; we actually have more and better regulation than we had 20 years ago, and parts of the financial system really are safer—because of that, the Fed and the Bank for International Settlements and the IMF, they sort of all have to say “blank might be a worry,” but I read them as sort of largely reassuring, and not terrifying.

And the other thing is we have to also avoid being miscalibrated. Neither of you are one of these, but I have another friend who is constantly citing things with a 30% chance of happening. And for any event, you can say that. And ex post you can’t say whether you’re wrong or you’re right. Once you say it ten times and the thing only happens zero or one times, you actually were wrong; it wasn’t a 30% chance. And I think there are a lot of people who don’t want to be that person. That doesn’t mean it isn’t a risk.

If you look at the Survey of Professional Forecasters, when they say there’s a 30% chance of negative growth a year from now, do you want to guess what fraction of the time there’s negative growth a year from now? It’s 0% of the time when they’ve said 30%. So I want to avoid being the person who’s constantly talking about risks at a magnitude that doesn’t materialize.

Krugman: I do want to remind everybody of 2022 and the infamous Bloomberg pronouncement that the chance of a recession next year was 100%.

Furman: And to my credit, I don’t think I ever went above 45%. And so you can’t prove that I was wrong, but if I have ten recession forecasts at 45%, at that point I think you are going to find that I was wrong, and that was a mistake. I mean, in some sense, my recession forecast in any given year is 15%, the unconditional probability. And I now try not to let myself be talked out of a 10% to 20% range, because I think we just don’t know. And in fact, in the Survey of Professional Forecasters, if their recession forecasts were the baseline, they would be more accurate than them trying to know.

Bernstein: So I mean, I sort of agree with what you’re saying, and there’s a lot of sage counsel in there. But if the sort of rule of discourse should be like, unless you think the probability of something for good reason is well north of 50%, you should sit on your hands, I don’t think that’s where I’m at or particularly helpful. And one of the things that Ryan and I have tried to be disciplined about is like, I don’t say anything about the probability of doom because, like, I just don’t understand it. I hope it’s wrong, but I don’t have the knowledge to speak of it. But in our work about “Is there a bubble?” we’ve been very quantitative. We’ve looked at the trillions, we’ve plugged in discount rates, and we think that for these companies to hit a kind of plausible profitability such that investors will have the patience to hang around, their revenues would have to grow between 5x and 10x of what they currently are, at least. And that just strikes us as a risk. And I don’t want to assign a probability to it. Like I said, I think we all agree it’s non-zero and we all agree it’s not 80%. But it does seem to be, especially given the magnitude in the economy, it just seems to be kind of prudentially correct to raise these concerns, which is probably why the three of us are talking.

Furman: And as I said, I think in some ways raising the concerns makes me feel a little bit better.

Krugman: If you remember 2008—which it’s hard for me to believe was 18 years ago, but anyway—the fall of Lehman was shocking and a big deal. But it was actually like three days later when we realized that AIG was the core of it. All of these CDS basically were offered by AIG. And AIG was a quintessentially solid business, an insurance company with real cash flow, except it turned out it really wasn’t. What it was was a gigantic, overleveraged shadow bank. Is there anything like that in the current landscape? Because there is this complex, opaque financing, and I wonder, just, are we going to discover, I don’t know, that Meta or someone is somehow at the center of a vast network of promises that everybody assumes are good because Facebook is profitable?

Furman: I think if we look back on this and something terrible happened, the place I would have gone wrong is that there was the sort of unknown unknown tucked into all of this. And so I am worried about that. I’m not that worried about if they actually literally start building less; I’m not worried about that at all, basically because of the imports. The stock market falling is, to me, a contained thing—not plus or minus two percentage points, it’s like plus or minus two-tenths of a percentage point. But I am worried about the things we don’t know. And in terms of the sitting on your hands, Jared, more transparency, some more regulation, etc., I would be completely fine with. So it might be that we have the same recommendation.

That being said, Paul, I don’t want to say just because I don’t know something, there’s like a big chance of it happening, and again, it’s sort of CYA to constantly say there’s something out there that might blow up. I do think a lot of the private equity firms—I don’t know that their market cap is going to make sense, and they’ve already fallen—but, they’re not banks. They match the maturity of their liabilities and assets. They put riskier pools with riskier investors. They have gates on how quickly retail investors can withdraw so no bank runs, etc. So I mostly feel good.

But yeah, I wouldn’t tell you there’s a 100% chance it’s all fine. But there’s one other totally different issue which is sort of related to this, which is: if stuff goes bad, what would rescue us? I do think there are some things out there, not that they’re fast and large enough to avoid a bad case. And for me, the tail risk is more like the 2001 recession—not 2008. But 2001 is not my base case; that is the tail risk. If the bubble bursts, probably we’ll be fine. But if the bubble bursts and I’m wrong, we get 2001.

Krugman: Jared and Ryan were basically saying 2001 was more like a base case.

Bernstein: Yeah. So a couple of things. Just first on Paul’s question, I agree with what Jason said. And we had a paragraph in the op-ed we just published a few weeks ago about the damage that a bursting AI bubble could do to the macroeconomy—wherein we said kind of, we’re less worried about this channel, for the reasons Jason raised and not least of which, again underscoring something he said earlier, because we’ve actually done something in that space.

And I think the capital buffers, for example, that were part of Dodd-Frank are still helping us. However, that said, I am, as I’ve said and as others have said, worried about what I can’t see. I will say, in terms of the people who are always running around warning about stuff, I think this is the first time I’ve ever gotten ahead of a bubble and said, “I think there’s a bubble.” I didn’t say it around housing. When my friend Dean Baker was hammering on me that there was a housing bubble, I didn’t say, “You’re wrong, Dean,” but I didn’t join him in that. And so to the extent you want to discount people who are always yelling “bubble,” that’s not me.

I think the other point on the financing is the circular financing part, and I think that is concerning. I have my Wall Street Journal from today in front of me. TSMC, which is the Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Corporation—they’re by far the main manufacturer of all these chips—“TSMC will invest in Anthropic and OpenAI $1 billion, giving a shot of confidence to the markets.” That is your dealer buying from you. It’s circular financing, which should also make us a little concerned.

On the 2001 point, one thing to remember about that was, while GDP barely fell at all, it was a real problem in the labor market.

Krugman: Yeah, it was a really long period of a depressed labor market. And people have kind of forgotten that, and they think of it as a mild recession. But as late as 2004, we were still saying, “Well, why aren’t we getting a real recovery in the labor market?” And my point always on this is that we were actually better positioned to deal with that kind of thing then, because we came in with interest rates at 6.5% and at a balanced budget. So there was just much more room for monetary and fiscal stimulus than we have now.

Furman: So first of all, there’s: how do we get out of it? Residential investment is quite low. So we could have another housing bubble to get out of this bubble. That’s what we did coming out of the dot-com. Obviously, I wouldn’t go all the way to a housing bubble. Long rates are pretty high; they have a lot of room to go down. Yes, the fed funds rate can’t be cut too much, but we are going into this with a lot of inflation, so the real interest rate you have can be lower. So some of the liquidity trap stuff—that stuff you know so much better than me, Paul—but I sort of look at our inflation rate and have a hard time getting worried about it. But you should explain to me why I’m wrong, because I’m sure you can.

Krugman: I would have said that there’s inflation in what people buy, but the real rates should be computed in terms of what people produce, and that’s not so good. So it’s actually not clear to me if that helps very much. But anyway, that’s a wonky discussion that goes way beyond—

Furman: Sorry, but then the last thing I’ll say is that my existential fear in all of this is that a lot of historic job loss with new technology doesn’t happen year after year after year in a smooth way. It happens in a very discontinuous way, where people get laid off in a recession and don’t get rehired. That might be—I’m not sure if it was, but it might have been part of the slow recovery from dot-com, because we had very high trend productivity growth at that point in time. And so here, if we have a recession, this becomes the time when all the predictions, which have been wrong to date about the impact on labor markets, suddenly become true and stay true. That terrifies me.

Krugman: We’re running a little long but let’s get to that—just this whole productivity, job loss aspect. Where are we on that? My read is that it’s surprisingly invisible in the macro numbers so far. Do we just think that that’s lag?

Bernstein: I don’t think it’s invisible. I just think it’s hard to see. But if you squint, you can see something. Now, if you squint too much, you can see things that aren’t there. But I disagree with some of my colleagues who say there’s nothing there. And I definitely disagree with people who say AI is killing jobs for every college graduate.

If you look at the work of Goldman Sachs economists on this—Joseph Briggs and Sarah Dong—you see they consistently plot these scatter plots with AI exposure on the x-axis and some measure of labor market activity on the y-axis. And those slopes were very flat, and now they’re a little less flat. And if you look at the extent of the difficulty that young college graduates are having, you can see a bit of a correlation there with AI exposure. It’s actually true that some who aren’t exposed are also having trouble. So it’s foggy, but I think there’s something there.

I think that the point Jason made is one that I’ve argued and want to amplify. Historically, recessions have been a force multiplier for technological unemployment. If there is a way for an employer to figure out how to not hire you back after she’s laid you off—if there’s a potential technology that might enable them to do so—they get a lot more interested in that technology post-layoffs. And there is good evidence that recessions that coincide with potentially labor-replacing technology could be problematic in exactly the way Jason said. So that’s a worry of mine as well. Yeah.

Krugman: Historically, I tended to say technological unemployment is the last refuge of scoundrels—that whenever there’s a recession, people say, “Oh, it’s technological unemployment,” which was very much true in the ‘30s. And might I actually be right this time?

Furman: Yeah, I’m not super worried. I mean, look, in general, higher productivity growth is correlated with more job growth, not less. That’s when the economy’s doing really well, the stock market’s booming, there’s lots of demand. I hate being a person who sees something happening over and over again and now says the exact opposite is going to happen this next time. So, first of all, people who want to work have been able to work. And yeah, in the short run, productivity has been good, not bad, for employment. At this point, though, do I think there’s at least a 15% chance that those past relationships don’t hold? Absolutely. Is that terrifying to me? Absolutely. And I think it’s probably more than a 15% chance. And we’re super early here. I mean, agentic AI is basically one year old; businesses and individuals still haven’t nearly explored the capabilities the current systems have.

And those of us that don’t listen to the people in Silicon Valley about what’s coming and just roll our eyes because they sound like a bunch of weirdos—well, those weirdos have been a lot more right about the capabilities, not about the impact. Just don’t hold them to the dates in their forecasts of the economy.

Bernstein: So I agree with all of that. But I also have this other scary concern, which kind of is on the other side of the axis, which is that I think I might be channeling some of the work of Alex Imas here, which is that there’s a combination of Jevons paradox and Baumol effects—I’ll explain what I mean by those—that get you to a place where actually AI, like other advances, creates a lot of new jobs. It’s just that they’re crappy jobs, and what you end up with is a lot more wealth inequality than we have now. And we already have a boatload of wealth inequality. And this is the idea that AI starts doing a lot of work that people are already doing, but because it lowers the cost of all the things that it can do—and look at Jason’s Econ Vitals software, if you want to get a good example of that—then it opens up a lot of space for people to hire new relational kinds of workers, to be chefs, to be therapists, to be personal trainers, to entertain their kids.

And there’s a dark world where we have a lot of jobs supporting the whims and the entertainment of our tech overlords. And that’s the Jevons paradox. But the Baumol effect part is that there’s no productivity gain from playing the three-minute waltz in two minutes, right? You can do it, but it’s inherently, like, not good. And so in these kinds of jobs, AI probably doesn’t replace them because they’re relational or, as I think Imas puts it, mimetic, which I’m not 100% sure what that means. But the idea is that you just have more of a bifurcation, which feeds into the inequality story, which is already exacerbated.

Krugman: The idea that we’re quite a long ways from bots being able to empty bedpans—and given our demographics, we’re going to need a lot of people emptying bedpans. But, on the other hand, if all the new jobs are people emptying bedpans, then that’s your functional world.

Furman: Yeah. And I see three different sources of inequality. One is how much income goes to capital and how much goes to labor. If I had to bet, more is going to go to capital and less is going to go to labor under this, and a wide range of models predict that. I think it’s a relatively robust thing. Within labor—which has been the big story in inequality in the last decades—there, I’m not sure. It could be that it takes somebody who is less skilled and improves their skills and you’re willing to pay them more, and if you’re super skilled, it doesn’t add much to you. Or it could be a force multiplier for people that know how to use it well. So I could tell labor-inequality-up and labor-inequality-down stories when it comes to this technology. But almost all of it is capital-inequality-up stories.

Bernstein: Yeah. Let me pose the last question, because I know we’re late in the game here. What do you guys think will be the fiscal policy response if the AI bubble bursts and generates some measure of a downturn?

Krugman: That’s a really good question. But I would say if it bursts within the next two years, nothing. Because there is nothing on which the White House and the incoming Congress will be able to agree. But that’s a very sort of contingent forecast. And then after that gets interesting because I’ve always been a huge deficit dove and debt non-worrier, but I keep on thinking about the fact that, fiscally, the US and France are twins, and I do worry about it.

Furman: I rather think the US and France are twins in two important respects. The numbers are pretty similar in terms of the debt, the primary deficit, etc. The other thing is the political system: if it hits a shock, how do we recover from it and fix it? I can’t quite figure it out in France or the United States. The UK fiscal situation is actually better than either of our countries, but even if it wasn’t, they have a somewhat functional political system that can fix it in a hurry. All that being said, if the bubble bursts in the next two years, I am not going to go out on a limb and try to predict what Donald Trump will do. He is an unbelievably unpredictable person. COVID was a huger thing; he acted in a big way there. George Bush did stimulus as a lame duck in 2008. He might want his name on the checks, and Democrats might be willing to let him put his name on the checks so they can have more checks. So I wouldn’t write off a fiscal response to this. But yeah, beyond that, I am worried less about our numbers and more about our political system’s ability to respond and change in response to those numbers.

Bernstein: Yeah, I’m sympathetic to the point that one definition of a Keynesian is a Republican in a recession. I’ve seen that lots of times. That said, we’re basically running recessionary-level deficits right now. I mean, our deficit is north of 6% and it should be half of that given the economic growth. It’s just that we’ve debauched our revenue function with all these ratcheting tax cuts to the point where there’s just this very structural disconnect. So, I would be concerned.

I will say the following, just putting on my fiscal hat: it isn’t the temporary stuff that hurts you in the long run; it’s the structural stuff. So, yes, if we were to go from a 6% of GDP deficit to 8% or 9% because we had to, that would show up as even higher debt going forward than we’d like, but it would go into the system and go out of the system. So I would advocate for fiscal responses. I’m sure we all would, whether that would be met by deaf ears, I don’t know.

Krugman: What I take from this is we all kind of think it’s probable, but not certain, that it’s a bubble, but are less concerned than you might be about the bubble bursting because this is such a weird form of investment where most of the money is going overseas, and we’re worried about wealth effects, but those don’t look enormous.

I mean, my take on this is that extra spending, even a higher level of debt, wouldn’t necessarily be a problem. Britain came out of World War II with debt of 250% of GDP, but no crisis, because everybody said, “They are a reasonable, responsible country that will in the end do what needs to be done.” And my question is, do we look like a reasonable, responsible country at this point? That’s where I get hung up.

Bernstein: We look more reasonable and responsible than we did a week and a half ago.

Krugman: Yeah, true.

Bernstein: Just to end on an optimistic note.

Best films of 2026

I thought this was a splendid and highly innovative year.  Here is my list, in the order I saw them, noting that a link typically brings you to my review:

Resurrection

Testament of Ann Lee

28 Years Later

Wuthering Heights

Sirat

Project Hail Mary

A Man on the Run

The Drama

The Blue Trail

Silent Friend

The Pressure

Blue Heron

The Invite

The Odyssey

Finding Emily

You Can See Everything

Fjord

Fatherland

Godzilla: Minus Zero

Queen at Sea

What else?  La Bola Negra has good reviews but I have not seen it yet.  Confession is receiving raves.  Of those listed, Sirat would be my definite favorite, big screen required of course.

I will give you an update for the rest of the year later in December, noting that anything appearing on Dec.31 in LA and NYC counts as 2027 for me.

The post Best films of 2026 appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

November 14, 2026

I just got home after what feels like a very long last few months, and I am very glad to be here.

Going to leave you tonight with a picture of my brother-in-law’s boat from the kayak, in the midst of the choppy seas and the low light of autumn, and will pick the outside world back up again tomorrow.

Sleep well, everyone.

Share

Investigations

To read this letter, click here:

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

You can also find Heather at:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

November 13, 2026

President Trump has not taken the idea of investigations of his administration lightly. On Saturday, November 7, he posted on social media that he was ordering the Department of Justice to investigate Democrats’ promises to investigate the administration’s corruption and mismanagement, calling those promises “criminal.”

On Monday, November 9, White House counsel Will Scharf, the top lawyer in the White House, sent a letter to Representative Robert Garcia (D-CA), who is expected to take over the House Oversight Committee, warning that the Democrat’s promise to investigate the actions of the Trump administration “may cross the line into blatant criminality.” Scharf leaned on the requirement that Congress’s investigations must have a legislative purpose—a requirement that current Republican chair James Comer of Kentucky ignored—and charged that Democratic lawmakers are issuing “abusive and capricious threats…to intimidate and to interfere with the lawful functioning of government.”

Then, on November 11, Aaron Reitz, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas, wrote to Senator Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), who is in line to chair the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations after January, claiming that Blumenthal’s plans to investigate who donated to Trump’s ballroom and other pet causes, and under what circumstances, was an unconstitutional attempt to prevent free association. He continued, suggesting that Blumenthal was trying “to intimidate citizens for engaging in philanthropic practices that will benefit our nation for generations.”

Threatening Blumenthal with “significant legal consequences” for “you, your staff, employees, agents, consultants, campaign personnel, and any other person acting on your behalf or in concert with you,” he demanded Blumenthal preserve all records “relevant to your intent to deprive citizens of their core constitutional rights.”

Garcia and Blumenthal were having none of it. Garcia told A. Martínez and Majd Al-Waheidi of NPR, “We’re not going to be deterred, and we’re certainly not going to be intimidated by Donald Trump or anyone in the administration.” Garcia said that among the committee’s top priorities would be investigating Trump family corruption, including a $2 billion investment in Jared Kushner’s investment firm, and looking into allegations of corrupt contracts involving former Homeland Security secretary Kristi Noem and former DHS advisor Corey Lewandowski. “Our job is to investigate, to take issues to the courts, to make criminal referrals, and to write good legislation so that this kind of corruption doesn’t happen again,” Garcia said.

Blumenthal wrote back to Reitz, saying that his letter was “just the latest in a series of unlawful actions on the part of the Trump Administration attempting to intimidate Members of Congress for engaging in constitutionally protected activity” and adding, “Your implied threat of an investigation is baseless.” He warned: “I will not be intimidated.”

Blumenthal told Reitz to preserve records himself, writing: “The public deserves to know the terms under which dozens of American companies were persuaded to donate millions of dollars to the President’s vanity projects, and whether lawsuits were dismissed, contracts were awarded, or regulations went unenforced in exchange for that money. The public deserves transparency about whether the White House and the corporations it cajoled extracted favors at the expense of American taxpayers. Not only are these appropriate subjects for congressional oversight, but such inquiries are among the constitutional duties that Members of Congress must undertake to become informed about matters on which legislation may be necessary.”

When it appeared bullying wouldn’t work, Trump turned to rage and self-pity. Yesterday morning, at 5:50, he tried to insist that it was the Democrats, not him, who are corrupt. “The Democrat Party, lead [sic] by one of the most Corrupt and anti-American groups of political leaders and hacks in the history of our Country, and even the World, is doing everything in their power to get away from MASSIVE BLUE STATE CORRUPTION by saying, over and over again, that the Trump Administration is corrupt,” he posted. “THE DEMOCRATS ARE CORRUPT AND EVIL, and I am the exact opposite!” Then, echoing the words he used at his rally at the Ellipse on January 6, 2021, before he urged the crowd to move to the U.S. Capitol, he added: “Fight hard, Republicans, or you won’t have a Country left!”

He continued to rage post about Democrats’ corruption through the morning. But by the afternoon, Attorney General Todd Blanche was walking back the suggestion that Democratic lawmakers’ promise to conduct oversight had been criminal. “There can come a point when a criticism becomes a threat, and then when a threat becomes something criminal and…I never said that that point has been crossed. I haven’t said that,” Blanche told reporters. Scharf, too, backpedaled, saying on Newsmax that all he had asked for was “that everybody follows the law.”

Even as the administration suggests congressional investigations into its behavior might be criminal, a monumental scandal has erupted in the administration. The chief executive officer of Nvidia, the maker of the highly advanced chips at the center of AI development, resigned yesterday after news broke that he has been engaged in an extramarital affair with a woman believed to be a Chinese spy.

On October 29, Jonathan Swan, Maggie Haberman, Ana Swanson, Paul Mozur, Tripp Mickle, and Julian E. Barnes of the New York Times reported that about a year ago, intelligence agents had informed Trump that Nvidia’s Jensen Huang was engaged in an affair with Alice Huang, a woman assessed to be a Chinese intelligence agent. But Trump “chose not to do anything with the information.”

Ms. Huang worked for Megaspeed, a company that buys Nvidia chips and then provides computing power to Chinese companies. It has been suspected of being a cut-out company that smuggles chips to China. According to the New York Times journalists, intelligence agents thought Ms. Huang was funneling information to Beijing.

On Thursday, November 5, House Foreign Affairs Committee chair Brian Mast (R-FL), House Select Committee on China chair John Moolenaar (R-MI), and House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence chair Rick Crawford (R-AR) wrote to Huang requesting that he appear before their committees to brief them on his interactions with Ms. Huang, “a publicly reported People’s Republic of China (PRC) intelligence asset, and NVIDIA’s security protocols against foreign adversary espionage.”

“Recent reports raise significant national security concerns regarding the PRC’s access to sensitive U.S. technology and information,” they wrote. “It is vital that Congress determines the extent to which U.S. national security has been placed at risk.”

On Sunday, November 8, Huang admitted the affair and Nvidia’s board announced it was opening an independent investigation into whether Huang was the “target of a foreign intelligence effort.” On Monday, November 9, Nvidia’s stock began to drop, and on November 11 the New York Times reported on a second affair. On November 12, Nvidia’s stock price dropped from $151 billion to $135 billion.

As Maureen Farrell and Rob Copeland of the New York Times reported, with Huang at the helm, Nvidia has bankrolled much of the nation’s AI buildout, and his support for it has kept the money rolling in. Huang has boosted AI as important to the national security of the United States and key to the nation’s future. After Huang resigned yesterday, just hours before news broke of a third relationship, Nvidia’s value fell again. Over the course of the week, the company lost nearly $493 billion in market value.

The crisis is dividing the administration. As Ian Duncan, Zach Dorfman, and Warren P. Strobel of the Washington Post reported this afternoon, Trump and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, along with Huang, wanted to let Nvidia sell chips to China in exchange for a 15% cut of the revenue going to the U.S. government.

In contrast, the journalists explain, “a bipartisan group of government officials, lawmakers and think tank analysts…view Nvidia’s chips as a vital asset in the rivalry between the two nations and one that the U.S. should strictly control.”

When Trump, who as of November 9 owned more than $12.5 million of Nvidia stock, told reporters he had not been informed about Huang’s relationship with Ms. Huang, sources told Maggie Haberman, Jonathan Swan, Julian E. Barnes, Ana Swanson, and Tripp Mickle of the New York Times that he had indeed been informed: Secretary of State Marco Rubio had told him, and the president had nonetheless brought Huang with him on a trip to China.

On CNBC today, Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent blamed Lutnick for failing to put Megaspeed on an export blacklist. Luke Fountain of CNBC reported today that Cantor Fitzgerald, the financial services firm Lutnick used to chair and which his sons now run, has extensive ties to Nvidia.

On Fox Business today, host Stuart Varney summed up the scandal during a discussion of its national security implications: “[W]e have to ask if anyone in the administration had a financial interest in getting those chips through to Beijing. That’s what this is all about, really, isn’t it?”

Trump was nowhere to be seen this afternoon when the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) abruptly grounded all planes in the U.S. for about five hours forcing 6,600 flights to be canceled and another 8,600 delayed, stranding passengers across the country. Trump’s only communication with the public was a long post about the entertainment industry. When Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy held a press conference about the crisis, he blamed Congress for not fixing the system and demanded $50 billion to update it.

“Cut the crap,” Illinois governor J.B. Pritzker posted. “Trump and Republicans have controlled Congress and could have funded the system. The public needs real answers and immediate action.”

But it wasn’t going to get them from the president. When a reporter said to Duffy at a press conference, “You say this is a priority for President Trump. Why have we not heard from him at all on this issue since it happened?” Duffy answered: “The two of us have talked to him.”

Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg stepped in to explain that “the system has many redundancies in it, so that normally, if there’s one point of failure, something else can catch it.” During his tenure, the most extreme disruption to air travel lasted about an hour and a half when a system failed, he said, but “there were actually four different systems, and when one of them went out, another one could be brought online to cover that. So it is not clear to me why that redundancy did not prevent an outage of this magnitude in terms of scope and duration. This is the biggest nationwide ground stop since 9/11. But again, we don’t know much. I certainly don’t want to speculate.”

Asked about Trump administration officials’ charge that the Biden administration hadn’t upgraded the system, Buttigieg answered: “Well, we did a lot to upgrade the system.” He added: “When we had an outage, I didn’t stand there complaining about the Trump administration. We got to work, and I’m certain that that’s what the career officials and the career day-to-day employees at FAA and USD[epartment] O[f] T[ransportation] are doing. This should not be about politics.

“What I will say, of course, is that there needs to be answers, and there needs to be transparency about what happened. I imagine there will be a lot of interest on Capitol Hill. Obviously, there’s a lot of interest in the public. And again, as a member of the flying public, as well as somebody who cares a lot about what goes on in the national airspace, I will have a lot of interest in getting answers to it.”

—

Notes:

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/read-the-letter-the-white-houses-top-lawyer-sent-rep-garcia-over-threats-to-investigate-trump

https://d3i6fh83elv35t.cloudfront.net/static/2026/11/Garcia-Letter-Signed_11.10.2026.pdf

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/sen-blumenthal-says-federal-prosecutor-attempting-to-investigate-him-for-conducting-an-inquiry

https://www.npr.org/2026/11/12/nx-s1-6037540/trump-white-house-democrats-investigations-robert-garcia

blumenthal.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/20261111_letter_from_rm_blumenthal_to_aaron_reitzpdf.pdf

https://www.politico.com/news/2026/11/12/todd-blanche-justice-department-democrats-oversight

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/29/us/politics/nvidia-china-jensen-huang-trump.html

https://foreignaffairs.house.gov/news/press-releases/chairmen-mast-moolenaar-and-crawford-request-jensen-huang-brief-congress-on-link-to-chinese-intelligence-asset

https://www.forbes.com/sites/zacharyfolk/2026/11/08/nvidia-investigating-ceo-jensen-huangs-relationship-with-alleged-chinese-spy-after-he-admits-affair/

https://www.reuters.com/live/nvidia-live-board-meets-fate-ceo-jensen-huang-after-affair-reports-2026-11-12/

https://www.forbes.com/sites/alisondurkee/2026/11/13/jensen-huang-ousted-timeline-of-the-nvidia-scandal/

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/11/technology/jensen-huang-nvidia-affair.html

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/13/business/jensen-huang-nvidia-wall-street.html

https://www.ap.org/news-highlights/spotlights/2025/us-will-get-a-15-cut-of-nvidia-and-amd-chip-sales-to-china-under-a-new-unusual-agreement/

https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/11/13/behind-jensen-huangs-spy-scandal-shadow-war-trumps-ear-china/

https://money.usnews.com/investing/articles/stocks-owned-by-donald-trump

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/10/us/politics/trump-china-trip-nvidia.html

https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/13/politics/bessent-lutnick-nvidia-megaspeed-blame

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/13/howard-lutnick-nvidia-jensen-huang-china-cantor-fitzgerald.html

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/faa-issues-national-ground-stop-due-extraordinary-circumstance-reasons-safety-2026-11-13/

Trump’s Truth:

statuses/43507

statuses/43554

statuses/43556

statuses/43568

X:

USAttyReitz/status/2120632462686711838/photo/1

Bluesky:

anthonymkreis.bsky.social/post/3n23d2npobc25

atrupar.com/post/3n27vcwl3gk2h

flightradar24.com/post/3n27uz5p42c2d

nothoodlum.bsky.social/post/3n2agqqqkzs24

govpritzker.illinois.gov/post/3n2agxnrb7c2d

thebulwark.com/post/3n2agskodwb2s

adamparkhomenko.bsky.social/post/3n2ak6qi3zc2m

atrupar.com/post/3n236zkhnqa2z

Share

Politics Chat, November 13, 2026

Watch today’s live recording here.

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

Get full, free access to Letters from an American here.

You can also find Heather:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

J.J. Galvez fought his ass off

JJ. Galvez—all that, and a healthy plate.

So eight months ago I sat down in Orange with J.J. Galvez, the perky-yet-longshot Democratic candidate in the State Assembly District 71 race. His odds of beating (or even challenging) incumbent Kate Sanchez seemed long, but folks kept raving about his oomph, his spunk, his sparkle.

They were correct.

J.J. wound up falling short, but the race proved shockingly close, and the 34-year-old gunslinger has to be considered an up-and-comer in local political. J.J. posted this on his Substack, and I thought it worth sharing (with his approval).

I bring you J.J. Galvez …

•••

Team, we did not win this race.

However, we achieved a historic overperformance. We’re at 46.4 percent of the vote and on track for nearly 100,000 votes. In 2024, the challenger in this district got 38.5 percent with about 92,000 votes. We cut a 23-point gap to under eight, and we’re on pace to earn more total votes in a midterm.

We did that despite only raising about $120,000 (six times less than my opponent). Of the roughly $720,000 my opponent raised, only about $12,000 came from individuals. I’m proud that we accepted no corporate donations.

And we’re not done. We’re still helping with ballot curing so every valid vote counts for other local candidates. This isn’t about me. It’s about a movement that believes we can build a better future for all.

Unity was a major theme of this campaign. At a time of so much division, we need to remember that there are no “red” or “blue” areas, only American areas. Let’s turn the page and start working together again. Let’s have debates about solving problems, not about insulting each other.

This was my first time running for office. As an immigrant, I felt it was important to stand up for a community being attacked and dehumanized. But immigration wasn’t the center of my campaign. The American Dream was. The Dream means you can build a life through your work, regardless of the circumstances you were born into. That Dream has been breaking for decades. Work alone is no longer enough to keep up with costs, so people have stopped believing in a better future. That loss of faith, and the daily struggle just to survive, amplified by stressful and misleading messages on social media and TV from all sides, is at the core of our division and the rise of extremism.

To the incumbent, I mean this sincerely – I wish you success, and I’m ready to help. Representing this district means representing all of it, including the many who didn’t vote for you. Skipping debates and missing votes leaves a large share of your constituents unheard, which is the same thing you criticize Democrats for doing in Sacramento. Whether it’s the imbalance between costs and opportunities, corruption, the rise of AI, a changing climate, there is an infinity of problems to address. Don’t sit on the sidelines. Don’t fall into the temptation of waging battles that only build a political brand for yourself, without solving any real problems... Build a legacy by getting to work. Work for all of us.

To all my supporters – thank you. YOU. ARE. AMAZING.

I’m not going anywhere. Whether through running for office or driving change as an active citizen, I want to be useful to my community and to building a better world.

Thank you,

JJ

Central Pacific Tropical Weather Outlook


Central North Pacific 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Central North Pacific 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ACPN50 PHFO 161114
TWOCP

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS Central Pacific Hurricane Center Honolulu HI
Issued by NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
200 AM HST Mon Nov 16 2026

For the central North Pacific...between 140W and 180W:

Tropical cyclone formation is not expected during the next 7 days.

$$
Forecaster Kelly
NNNN


Saturday 14 November 1663

Up and to the office, where we sat, and after we had almost done, Sir W. Batten desired to have the room cleared, and there he did acquaint the board how he was obliged to answer to something lately said which did reflect upon the Comptroller and him, and to that purpose told how the bargain for Winter’s timber did not prove so bad as I had reported to the board it would. After he had done I cleared the matter that I did not mention the business as a thing designed by me against them, but was led to it by Sir J. Minnes, and that I said nothing but what I was told by Mayers the surveyor as much as by Deane upon whom they laid all the fault, which I must confess did and do still trouble me, for they report him to be a fellow not fit to be employed, when in my conscience he deserves better than any officer in the yard. I thought it not convenient to vindicate him much now, but time will serve when I will do it, and I am bound to do it. I offered to proceed to examine and prove what I said if they please, but Mr. Coventry most discreetly advised not, it being to no purpose, and that he did believe that what I said did not by my manner of speaking it proceed from any design of reproaching them, and so it ended. But my great trouble is for poor Deane.

At noon home and dined with my wife, and after dinner Will told me if I pleased he was ready to remove his things, and so before my wife I did give him good counsel, and that his going should not abate my kindnesse for him, if he carried himself well, and so bid “God bless him,” and left him to remove his things, the poor lad weeping, but I am apt to think matters will be the better both for him and us.

So to the office and there late busy. In the evening Mr. Moore came to tell me that he had no opportunity of speaking his mind to my Lord yesterday, and so I am resolved to write to him very suddenly.

So after my business done I home, I having staid till 12 o’clock at night almost, making an end of a letter to Sir G. Carteret about the late contract for masts, wherein I have done myself right, and no wrong to Sir W. Batten.

This night I think is the first that I have lain without ever a man in my house besides myself, since I came to keep any. Will being this night gone to his lodging, and by the way I hear to-day that my boy Waynman has behaved himself so with Mr. Davis that they have got him put into a Barbadoes ship to be sent away, and though he sends to me to get a release for him I will not out of love to the boy, for I doubt to keep him here were to bring him to the gallows.

Read the annotations

Joanna Stern Reviews the HomeView

This is so goddamn good. Both informative and hilarious.

(She made a fun bonus reel that’s right up my alley too — but watch the main review first.)

 ★ 

Jason Snell’s HomeView Review

Jason Snell:

The hardware is solid and coherent, the screen a pleasure to touch and tilt. In terms of software, though, the HomeView feels like a peculiar amalgam of numerous other Apple products. Its main interface makes it look a bit like an overgrown Apple Watch, complete with customizable “faces” that sometimes resemble actual Apple Watch faces and other times resemble the iPhone’s StandBy mode. Its apps sometimes feel like they’ve escaped from the iPhone or iPad, but at other times they feel more like they’re right off of an Apple TV. And still other “apps” resemble what you might see in your car, since Apple is also using CarPlay to project interfaces from apps running on your iPhone.

Given the fact that this product’s tech stack feels like it was created in a blender, it’s remarkable that it holds together as well as it does — but there are still places where the seams show.

I’ve been testing a review unit HomeView for a bit over a week, but haven’t had much time to devote to it. So in a lot of ways my HomeView experience thus far has been much more like that of a casual user than an expert. I plugged it in, set it up, got my wife and son to do what they needed to do to become recognized fellow-family-member users, and then we all collectively have had a week of “Well, now what?”

What Snell writes above succinctly and sharply describes my take: the hardware is top-notch but the software is like bits of iOS, WatchOS, tvOS, and CarPlay cut up and assembled into a ransom letter. The software lacks cohesion and vision and polish. If you open a web page you can select text, with the iOS touch interface, but there is nothing you can do with a text selection. You can’t copy it or share it. So why can you even make a selection? That’s the least of HomeView’s software problems, but perhaps most emblematic of its “created in a blender” state.

 ★ 

Patrick McGee on Johny Srouji and Nvidia

Patrick McGee (author of Apple in China; my guest on The Talk Show last May), writing on X in response to Semafor’s reporting that Nvidia is “considering” Johny Srouji:

Apple hardware chief Johny Srouji would be an incredible choice to lead @nvidia — and I believe he’d accept it.

He’s hit the ceiling at Apple and won’t ever be CEO; obviously competent; ambitious as hell; has long wanted chip designs to dictate Apple product launches/timelines.

I wrote about this a few days ago, that my money is on Srouji having no interest in the Nvidia job. It’s true that Srouji will almost certainly never be CEO at Apple. But it’s wrong to assume that Srouji would consider CEO of Nvidia to be an upgrade from CHO at Apple. There’s no way Eddy Cue, Craig Federighi, or Greg Joswiak would leave Apple to be CEO at another company. Most of Apple’s leadership genuinely bleeds six colors. There’s a certain approach to product that drives them, motivates them, and literally only Apple does that type of work. Tim Cook surely turned down numerous CEO offers to leave Apple while he served as COO under Steve Jobs, and he’s always been clear that he hoped Jobs would stay a few steps ahead of his cancer and could remain at Apple until, well, probably around now. (Jobs would be 71.)

I’ve never met Srouji and don’t have a read on him like I do other leaders at Apple. But I do have a read on Ternus and Cook. I’ll stick with my bet from earlier in the week:

Another scenario is that Srouji meant what he said, loves his job at Apple, and truly is John Ternus’s trusted and trustworthy hardware lieutenant. In this case, Nvidia’s board leaking that they’re considering Srouji to replace Huang is like someone in hell saying they’re considering ordering some ice water.

Aside from Srouji’s loyalty to Apple (and to the Apple Silicon chip architecture that’s been his life’s work), there’s also the question of whether he’d take the gig at Nvidia in particular, even if he is open to leaving Apple. Jensen Huang has left the company with a $4 trillion market cap, yes, but it was $5 trillion just a week ago. It now seems 20 percent of Nvidia’s sales in the AI era have been in violation of U.S. national security export controls to China. The company has no internal leadership hierarchy. And Huang placed bets that have leveraged the company’s future on OpenAI and the overall data center mania not being a bubble. Srouji has been a senior leader at the one tech company that conspicuously avoided those bets entirely.

 ★ 

Microsoft Says Cloud Outage Was ‘Not Related to Cyber or AI / Agents’

Microsoft, yesterday, in a statement on X:

This was a technical issue not related to cyber or AI / agents. The incident was introduced by an issue during an earlier network capacity upgrade that surfaced following a recent network change. We have addressed the underlying issue and continue to restore service to remaining customers and regions.

 ★ 

Back To the Electoral College, And Why Getting Rid of It Is a Big Mistake

As the dust settled on the 2026 midterm elections, a number of stories were published noting that states now fully under Democratic control include enough electoral votes to make the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact a reality. To review, this is the plan, devised in the aftermath of 2000 presidential election, that would allow an end-run around the Electoral College. A sufficient number of states agree to award their electoral votes to the winner of the popular vote regardless of how their own voters voted in that particular state. Once a sufficient number of states agree, it’s done. The effect of the Electoral College disappears even as its architecture remains.

Now this is actually within reach because of Democratic trifectas in a handful of states. When I heard this subject come up again, my reaction was both negative and baffled. Given what we have seen in the last decade, who could ever have confidence that a state would honor this process when push came to shove? We’ve seen now how little is truly binding. This is especially the case when you’re expecting courts not to interfere in a case where the laws being enforced really are genuinely non-constitutional if not quite anti-constitutional. If JD Vance wins Wisconsin in 2032 but Wisconsin says it has to award its electoral votes to Pete Buttigieg, some version of this Supreme Court is going to uphold that law? Please.

For me this settles the matter. I would never trust such an expedient to work. Meanwhile, this piece in Vox notes how one of the originators of the whole concept, Yale Law Professor Akhil Amar, notes that the whole system could lead to a massive constitutional crisis because states might disagree about who actually won the popular vote since there’s really no federal arbitrator of that. He notes various other ways the system could implode because of a law of rule-setting and overseeing entity.

That may seem a little silly. Unless the whole country comes down to a lead of a few hundred votes, how is there going to be a dispute about the popular vote? Read the Vox article. It explains how there are a number of scenarios where it can spin out of control very quickly. But I want to focus on the issue that is implicit in Amar’s argument and his latter-day critiques of his own idea, but don’t get discussed in the Vox piece.

Since early 2025 I’ve been arguing that the sheet anchor of any resistance to Donald Trump is the fact that the states are subordinate but distinct sovereignties whose executive power is untethered to federal executive power. Critically, the Constitution unambiguously assigns the administration of elections to the states under federal law. Everything that has happened over the last 20 months has confirmed that verdict. Donald Trump wanted to subvert the electoral process but he mostly couldn’t because of that central feature of the constitutional architecture. That obstacle mostly wasn’t the work of judges, who we’ve learned are the thinnest of reeds to rely on. It’s the architect itself. Across so much of the federal government the president holds the machinery of government. He can be restrained in that power by a resolved Congress or by judges. But with both the Congress and the judiciary largely subservient we’ve learned a constitutional version of the old adage that possession is 9/10ths of the law.

Can the president just fire independent agency heads or abolish whole departments without law or warrant? Who’s going to stop him? He’s the president and the executive branch is run by the president. But a president no matter how powerful can never fire a governor or a mayor or even a cop on the beat. He also can’t issue them orders. It’s a separate sovereignty. It’s not a matter of a judge’s say-so. There are simply no tendons or muscles or connective tissue connecting the flow-chart of the federal government to those of the states. That proved critical to the integrity of the 2026 election.

Which brings us back to Amar’s points about the weakness of the whole National Popular Vote Interstate Compact: the lack of any governing or oversight body to determine basic things like who actually won the popular vote. Read through Amar’s points and it’s clear that making the national popular vote work — either by abolishing the Electoral College by amendment or through the Compact — would require a significant federalization of elections. Given the experience of the last decade and especially the last two years, that seems like an unquestionably bad idea. Imagine how the last two years might have played out had national — inevitably executive branch — agencies held real governing power over the conduct of elections. Everything plays out very, very differently.

The fact that some peoples’ votes count more than others in presidential elections, the fact that the candidate who gets fewer votes can win — these things all remain national and constitutional embarrassments. But we’ve seen in practice that state administration of elections is simply too core an obstacle to autocratic takeovers to give up so lightly. When civic democracy itself is on the chopping block you’ve got to pick your battles, make some hard choices.

Finding the Signal in the Noise of NVIDIA-Gate

Earlier this evening, I was exchanging notes with TPM Reader NH and I told him this: “I’ve had a very hard time today trying to put all of this into a coherent whole. Part of me thinks you’ve got a bunch of highly questionable stuff happening, at least semi-corrupt, very questionable behavior on NVIDIA’s part vis a vis China, some intentional slow-rolling from Commerce for very questionable reasons. And a lot of it is at least loosely known to a lot of people. Then the Times publicly confirms the relationship and U.S. assumption that Alice Huang is a spy. And then everyone runs for cover — even though a lot of the stuff surrounding that relationship was at least semi-known. I don’t know if this is a plausible way to look at it. But in a way I’m not sure she even needs to exist for a lot of this stuff to happen?”

This evening the Post published this article. You should read it. But the gist is that Marco Rubio and other China hawks in and out of the administration have been unhappy with what NVIDIA has been doing and Huang’s influence over key administration players who were allowing it to happen. Rubio, by whatever level of indirection, was able to get the story of the Alice Huang relationship into the Times. And that, in a matter of days, brought the walls crashing in on Jensen Huang. And yet quite a lot of this was known. To Trump, Rubio and other top administration officials it was apparently known in its entirety.

As I said above, it’s not clear to me that Alice Huang even needs to exist for a lot of this to happen. She seems more like a cog in the subversion of national interests to commercial interests than a well-placed spy pulling one over on other key players. Maybe more of an intermediary between China and Jensen Huang.

Reading List 11/14/2026

The Shepherd’s Dream from “Paradise Lost,” by Henry Fuseli, via WikiArt.

Welcome to the reading list, a weekly roundup of news and links related to buildings, infrastructure, and industrial technology. This week we look at a Brooklyn building collapse, BAAJA’s odds of passing, reusing old memory in new phones, a nationwide aircraft ground stop, and more. Roughly 2/3rds of the reading list is paywalled, so for full access become a paid subscriber.

Housing and Cities

A 3 story building in New York partially collapsed into an adjacent construction site that was being excavated, killing 8 people and injuring 18. Good reminder that for as burdensome as various building regulations can sometimes be (particularly in New York, with its ubiquitous sidewalk sheds), they don’t exist for no reason. [Construction Dive]

On the other hand, that doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t evaluate code requirements to see if the benefits they bring are worth the cost. An article in the Washington Post argues that many requirements to upgrade electrical panels for higher load devices are often unnecessary. “Outdated industry practices and in some places outdated electrical codes are regularly resulting in the recommendation that people need to upgrade their electrical panels if they want to add appliances such as induction stoves, heat pumps and electric-vehicle chargers. The expense — at a median of $3,500, and triple or quadruple that in some settings — is deterring some energy-efficient upgrades and making the projects far more costly for those who proceed. But some researchers say panel upgrades are almost always unnecessary. One report this year found that 98 percent of homes with 100-ampere panels, the smallest common size, have room to add popular electronic devices.” [Washington Post]

The US now has over 1500 mass timber buildings, up from fewer than 100 a decade ago. [The Real Deal]

The current probability of permitting reform bill BAAJA becoming law is little over 50% on Kalshi. [Kalshi]

A Houthi missile hit Saudi state oil company Aramco’s skyscraper in Riyadh. [X]

A new Nicholas Bagley paper on the cost of federal permitting, arguing that the real costs of things like NEPA is the huge amount of effort agencies put in to try and make things “litigation proof”. “The evidence does suggest, however, that the bulk of the costs of the federal permitting regime stem from the defensive measures agencies and developers take to guard against the risk of a bad outcome in court. That insight allows for a rough evaluation of the likely effects of popular permitting reform ideas. Some—including popular ones like time limits and statutes of limitations—are unlikely to accomplish much. Only those reforms that change the incentives created by the risk of judicial review will meaningfully move the needle.” [Nicholas Bagley]

A progress report from the Center for Land Economics, which advocates for land value taxes to make more efficient use of urban land. ”Three states passed laws enabling land value taxes in some form: Kentucky, Virginia and New York. In each of them we’re now helping cities work out how to put them into practice. Five more states and DC considered similar bills. This is the most legislative momentum the movement has seen in decades…” [Land Economics]

Read more

Links 11/14/26

Links for you. Science:

Doctors in Ukraine Try Treating Infections Like Biological Warfare Attacks
A Man Had Brain Surgery. Now He Sees His Cat’s Eyes on People’s Faces—and Vice Versa
Why the simple flu shot could be a surprise weapon against cancer
What I Learned at a Drunk-Math Party
Low-income parents can’t afford to take chances with nutritious food their picky eaters might reject
The U.S. is staring down the barrel of a measles crisis, with no end in sight
‘A complete repudiation’: public health won big in US midterm elections

Other:

Forget the Leadership Fights—Everything Comes Back to the Filibuster
What the Logan Circle Shooter Told Me. In a series of interviews late last year, Matt Lambert obsessed about his condo’s problems — and the man he killed.
Some thoughts on the 2026 midterm from TPM Reader TS (Theda Skocpol)
Janeese Lewis George Promised Change. Will the Job Change Her?
Centrism Fail: Osborn/Bengs/Bodnar Edition
Firm Linked to Trump’s Sons Got Nearly $40 Million in Federal Contracts to Screen for Ebola and Other Diseases
Alito warns Congress can ‘turn off the lights’ at Supreme Court
The Scandal Is Bigger Than Jensen Huang
Chris Van Hollen says he will challenge Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader
Sex Crimes, Lies, War, Money: MAGA’s 2026 ‘Self-Immolation’ Keeps Getting Worse
Cracks emerge in Trump’s Reflecting Pool – hours after he stood in front and told Americans about his great renovation
Horny Nvidia CEO No Longer CEO, Possibly Still Horny
The Democratic Leadership Fights Are Missing Something
The Real Reason Chris Van Hollen’s Challenge to Schumer Is a Big Deal
Alice Huang-Linked Firm Procured Banned Nvidia Chips in China
Why Democrats Can’t Quit the Spam
At the Tomb, Hegseth broke the silence. A sentinel spoke up for the dead.
David Sacks Speaks!
Sarah McBride didn’t give them the fight they wanted. She won anyway
Trump proposed a ‘secret weapon’ to police colleges. It will soon become reality
Leading Chabad Rabbi Legitimizes Killing Jewish Politicians Cooperating With Arab Parties
The Worst Thing Democrats Could Do Right Now
Team Van Hollen
A 124-Year-Old Voting Ban Designed to Silence Black Virginians Is Finally Gone
Baghdad’s first Jewish museum draws crowds to rediscover Iraq’s Jewish past
Sen. Baldwin proposes lowering Medicare eligibility age to 50
Right-wing influencer retracts fraud allegations against Seattle grocery
Lutnick should have prevented the diversion of sensitive Nvidia AI chips to China, critics charge
“Car brain” contributed to House failure to impeach Hegseth
The D.C. spaces that feature local artists

Upcoming Speaking Engagements

This is a current list of where and when I am scheduled to speak:

  • I’m speaking at the Catalyst Summit in Brampton, Ontario, Canada, on Wednesday, November 18, 2026.
  • I’m speaking at QT Qonference 2026 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, on Thursday, November 19, 2026.

The list is maintained on this page.

Saturday assorted links

1. Madrid vs. Catalonia.

2. Stephen Kovacevich, RIP (NYT).  Brahms and the Diabellis stand among his towering pianistic achievements.  He was one of my favorite pianists.

3. Queen at Sea is an excellent movie, though hard to watch due to the dementia theme.  Impossible to review without spoilers.

4. Claude revises the notebooks of Gödel.

5. FT Lunch with Jean Drèze.

6. The loneliness crisis for Sri Lankan elephants.

7. Joshua Saxe and Dwarkesh on RSI.

The post Saturday assorted links appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

Starship flight 15 powers to orbit—setting up a possible catch on Saturday

STARBASE, Texas—Starship lifted off right on schedule Friday from South Texas, making its 15th test flight in more than three years.

The largely successful launch took place in the early evening; as the massive rocket rose into the atmosphere, the Sun sank toward the western horizon. Conditions were ideal for the launch, with the atmospheric winds so calm the rocket’s white plume did not dissipate for many minutes. The weather in South Texas is not always comfortable; summers are long and hot. Friday evening was perfect at Starbase.

The first stage ascended toward space flawlessly, releasing the upper stage above the Gulf of Mexico. From there, the Starship upper stage ignited its Raptor engines and powered its way into a nominal orbit. This was the second time SpaceX has flown Starship into low-Earth orbit.

Read full article

Comments

Privatize Air Traffic Control, Redux

Yesterday the FAA grounded every domestic departure in the United States for more than four hours. Such groundings appear to be happening more often. The last nationwide grounding was in 2023, and regional ones have hit Newark, Dallas, and the entire Northeast in the past two years.

My post from October of 2025 (below) was prompted by regional groundings and delays caused by labor problems. Air traffic control was then (and still is today) far understaffed, and then, absurdly, the government shutdown hit the controllers we had, thus further stressing the system. According to Transportation Secretary Duffy the cause of yesterday’s grounding wasn’t labor but capital: aging TDM telecom circuits overloaded with data.

The deeper cause is the same in both cases: poor incentives. Airlines bear the costs when the system fails and have almost no say in how it is run. By the way, some will crow that yesterday’s failure may have been due to a private contractor. That may well be true–Pro tip: Do not update system software on a Friday at 3pm–but it is beside the point. Contracting out may have some advantages, especially if there is competition, but it is not the same as privatization. The argument for privatization of air traffic control services is to give responsibility for the system to the people who pay when it fails. Align incentives.

My 2025 post. No indent.

Yesterday, the FAA grounded flights at Reagan (DCA) because there weren’t enough air traffic controllers. By mid‑afternoon, thousands of flights were delayed nationwide. The same thing is happening at major airports across the country.

The proximate cause is that the FAA is short about ~3,500 controllers, forcing the rest to work mandatory overtime, six days a week, and now, during the shutdown, sometimes without pay! The more fundamental problem is that we have a poorly incentivized system. It’s absurd that a mission‑critical service is financed by annual appropriations subject to political failure. We need to remove the politics.

Canada fixed this in 1996 by spinning off air navigation services to NAV CANADA, a private, non‑profit utility funded by user fees, not taxes. Safety regulation stayed with the government; operations moved to a professionally governed, bond‑financed utility with multi‑year budgets. NAV Canada has been instrumental in moving Canada to more accurate and safer satellite-based navigation, rather than relying on ground-based radar as in the US.

NAV CANADA – in conjunction with the United Kingdom’s NATS – was the first in the world to deploy space-based ADS-B, by implementing it in 2019 over the North Atlantic, the world’s busiest oceanic airspace.

NAV CANADA was also the first air navigation service provider worldwide to implement space-based ADS-B in its domestic airspace.

Meanwhile, America’s NextGen has delivered a fraction of promised benefits, years late and over budget. As the Office of Inspector General reports:

Lengthy delays and cost growth have been a recurring feature of FAA’s modernization efforts through the course of NextGen’s over 20-year lifespan. FAA faced significant challenges throughout NextGen’s development and implementation phases that resulted in delaying or reducing benefits and delivering fewer capabilities than expected. While NextGen programs and capabilities have delivered some benefits in the form of more efficient air traffic management and reduced flight delays and airline operating costs, as of December 2024, FAA had achieved only about 16 percent of NextGen’s total expected benefits.

Airlines bleed money when planes idle, gates clog, and crews time out. The airlines have every reason to demand reliability, capacity, and modernization—Congress does not. Thus, fund air traffic control with user fees paid by those who depend on performance. Put the airline executives on the board of the non-profit, as in Canada. Give them the power to tax themselves to benefit themselves.

Align power with incentives and performance will follow.

The post Privatize Air Traffic Control, Redux appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

datasette-cluster-map 0.19

Release: datasette-cluster-map 0.19

One of the oldest Datasette plugins, and still one of my favorites. It now works with Datasette 1.0a42, and depends on the new datasette-leaflet to ensure OpenStreetMap tiles are requested with a referrer header.

Here's a map of power plants owned by California's PG&E, also demonstrating Datasette's recently redesigned facets:

Screenshot of a faceted map interface. Three facet panels at the top: "country_long 1" with United States of America 81 selected; "owner 1" with Pacific Gas & Electric Co. 81 selected; "primary_fuel 5" listing Hydro 63, Solar 10, Gas 5, Storage 2, Nuclear 1. Each primary_fuel row has a pale blue horizontal bar behind its label, sized in proportion to its count: Hydro's bar fills most of the row width, Solar's is a short sliver, Gas's is shorter still, and Storage and Nuclear have only a thin strip at the left edge. Below is a Leaflet map with + and − zoom controls showing California and Nevada, with marker clusters across northern and central California: 9 near Redding, 21 near Chico, 2 to the west of Chico, 13 northeast of Sacramento, 7 east of Stockton, 6 at Oakland, 10 at Fresno, 9 west of Visalia, 2 north of Bakersfield, plus two individual blue pin markers on the coast, one in the far north and one north of Santa Maria. Attribution: Leaflet | © OpenStreetMap contributors

Tags: datasette, geospatial, openstreetmap

I’m feeling more optimistic about American politics

“Partisanship is a helluva drug,” as they say. When your preferred party is in power, the sun seems to shine a little brighter, the birds sing a little more sweetly, and there’s a spring in your step as you walk past the homeless encampments and sterile single-family-home-only neighborhoods of your American city. Foreigners from countries where politics is less contentious, like Japan, will never know this joy.

Anyway, this natural partisan sentiment makes it very hard for me to write about developments in American politics. I would like to give you some analysis that’s more informative than “Yay, Democrats won an election!”. I do consider myself a Democrat, after all (even though I’m registered as an Independent). There has never been a point in my entire life when I’d have told you that the Republican presidential candidate was a better pick than the Democrat (though 2012 was fairly close). I regularly bemoan the state of the Democratic Party, but somehow the Republicans always find some way to be Even Worse.

This has been the unfortunate reality for most people in America for years now. Disgust and dissatisfaction with both parties have grown, as both have become more extremist. But there was little they could do except keep voting for the lesser of two evils, while tuning out political news and expressing anger at the whole system. It got so bad that in my New Year’s essay, I even entertained the notion that liberal democracy itself had suffered a generational failure:

To be honest, I still entertain that notion. Reading that essay again, there’s not much I would change. But on the margin, recent events have made me feel more optimistic about where American politics is going.

A lot of this is downstream of the midterm elections. Trump has turned the Republican Party into something truly awful, and it’s refreshing to see America punish the GOP for going along with that transformation:

But my optimism isn’t just about the fact that Democrats won — it’s also about how they won, and what they seem likely to do with their victory. Here I’ve been pleasantly surprised so far. And there are also some scattered signs that our leaders are starting to take our substantive policy challenges more seriously, instead of just relying on partisanship and culture wars. Basically, I see three broad positive trends:

  1. The Democrats are not becoming extremist at the rate I had feared.

  2. There is some real bipartisan movement on good policymaking at the federal level.

  3. The nation is waking up to the problem of corruption, and holding the perpetrators to account.

Liberals, not leftists, are leading the anti-Trump charge

Over the past few years, I’ve watched the emergence of a leftist faction within the Democratic Party, which I’ve likened to MAGA on the right. This faction had its roots in the Bernie insurgency of 2016-2020, but it has grown beyond that. The Palestine movement both invigorated the leftists and radicalized them, shifting the locus of power in left-of-center activism away from Black activists, identitarian movements, and anti-capitalism, and toward explicitly anti-American “decolonial” ideas.

As recently as this summer, I believed that a Democratic victory in the midterms would be led by this hard-left vanguard:

Here’s what I wrote:

Democrats have spent their political capital moving to the left…[They are selecting] candidates who are so far to the left that they end up frightening and/or offending many voters, and then basically daring people to keep voting for the Republicans…

When DSA-type candidates were just winning in deep blue cities, it was possible to think that they would remain a small, limited faction within the party. But Francesca Hong is going to be the Democratic nominee in a statewide race. So is Abdul El-Sayed, who, while not a member of the DSA, is closely aligned with them (especially on Israel, which he focuses on a lot)…This, increasingly, is who the Democrats are now.

Well, happily, I was wrong about this. Francesca Hong was actually defeated in the Democratic primary race just a few days later in a stunning upset, showing that even partisan Democrats aren’t sold on the DSA faction.

Even more importantly, the hard left didn’t end up leading the anti-Trump charge in the midterms, as I had expected. Despite the blue wave, most of the high-profile DSA-faction candidates performed significantly worse than their normie Democrat counterparts. Jeff Maurer has great data on this:

I Might Be Wrong
How Leftists and Moderates Did in the Midterms
Three months ago, I wrote a post “setting up the goal posts” to measure how individual candidates did in the midterms. I did that for two reasons: First, I did it to be a dick. I feel that liberals can be too polite, and we bite our tongues in response to the hate and idiocy that DSA types are trying to smuggle into the mainstream — I see a role for a t…
Read more

And the same voters who powered the big Democratic victories also endorsed a lot of centrist policies at the ballot box. Here’s the Washington Post:

Voters in North Carolina elected a Democratic senator…giving former governor Roy Cooper an overwhelming win. At the same time, they approved three [Republican] measures…The first would add a constitutional requirement for a levy limit on property taxes…The second would cap the state income tax at 3.5 percent…The third would require photo ID for voting…

In Wisconsin, Democrat David Crowley won the gubernatorial election…Those same voters approved an initiative…to ban affirmative action in state institutions…Iowa voters elected Democrats as governor and senator while amending their constitution to make it substantially harder to raise state income taxes…Ohio….went blue for Senate and governor. At the same time, two-thirds of voters backed an amendment to require photo ID for voting…

Moderates and independents drove Democratic gains in all these places.

Voters in several blue and purple states also approved measures to restrict women’s sports teams by biological sex.

There’s also a general indefinable “vibe shift” in the air. Anecdotally, people I talk to are less ashamed to voice full-throated support for the kind of liberalism that Barack Obama typified in the early 2010s. Meanwhile, liberal influencers online are beginning to push back more strongly on leftist shouters.

And in Congress, the sheer scale of the Democrats’ victory means that the DSA faction will be effectively disempowered. Because marginal victories tend to be won by moderates in purple states, the leadership in both the House and the Senate is likely to be held by moderates like Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer. This is driving the DSA factionalist types apoplectic with rage:

Note that the knives are already coming out for Jon Ossoff, whose potential as a 2028 presidential contender surged after his massive midterm victory. But who can leftists run against Ossoff? Enthusiasm around AOC has dimmed, and there’s no obvious replacement.

If they fail to find a candidate for 2028, and if Democrats take back the White House with a normie liberal, the leftist faction faces the real possibility that the window of America’s decade of unrest will limp to a close without them. That would, of course, be good for the nation.

Smart policy is starting to win (and “the groups” are starting to lose)

Even moderate politicians, of course, often support unworkable or inadvisable policies. On the Democratic side, the worst problems are anti-development policies at the state and local level. “Progressive” policies have made it prohibitively difficult and/or expensive to build housing, roads, trains, power stations, and transmission lines across much of the country, freezing our built environment in the 1970s. I’ve been loudly complaining about this for years now:

This was a big part of my pessimism about politics. What’s the use of kicking out the Republicans, if the Democrats are just going to decide that “open space” and historic gas stations are more important than giving the middle class a place to live and power for their homes?

Now there are signs that at long last, America’s leaders recognize this problem and are taking action to fix it.

Read more

Atlantic Tropical Weather Outlook


Atlantic 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Atlantic 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ABNT20 KNHC 161115
TWOAT

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
700 AM EST Mon Nov 16 2026

For the North Atlantic...Caribbean Sea and the Gulf of America:

Tropical cyclone formation is not expected during the next 7 days.

$$
Forecaster Kelly


Eastern Pacific Tropical Weather Outlook


Eastern North Pacific 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Eastern North Pacific 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ABPZ20 KNHC 161114
TWOEP

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
400 AM PST Mon Nov 16 2026

For the eastern and central North Pacific east of 180 longitude:

Tropical cyclone formation is not expected during the next 7 days.

$$
Forecaster Kelly


People like their jobs, even British people

This paper investigates the role of work in providing meaning, purpose, community, and other non-monetary benefits. Using an original cross-national survey of 8,234 working-age adults across the UK, US, Denmark, and India, I study the factors that motivate people in their work, with an eye toward the future AI economic transformation. I find that 81% of respondents report being satisfied with their job, and a majority across all four countries are strongly motivated by the non-monetary components of their employment. Using an original “Work Values” Index, I show that one third of working respondents are motivated intrinsically by their job—valuing their role for its own sake. Nearly one quarter are driven by social and community-related aspects of their employment, 17% by social status, and just over one quarter by the transactional financial benefits of their job. Although a majority of people would leave their role if offered their current salary as a guaranteed income, one fifth of workers would stay even if offered up to 120% of their salary. Intrinsically motivated workers were disproportionately likely to refuse a basic income at any substitution level. Groups attached to their job for non-monetary reasons were also more likely to pursue volunteering or work-like activities if they received guaranteed income substitution but could no longer perform their role. Crucially, these non-monetary work motivations are evenly distributed across the income distribution and between white- and blue-collar workers. I argue that these findings have implications for managing the AI transition, understanding attitudes to AI, and making sense of policy preferences. Guaranteeing a basic income may indeed be necessary for managing any future AI labor shock, yet it could ultimately fail to compensate workers for any loss of the non-monetary benefits they derive from work.

That is from a new paper by Julian Jacobs, via Kevin Bryan.  And here is a thread on the paper.

The post People like their jobs, even British people appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

The Power and Roots of Aspirations

Aspirations have become a common theme in empirical economics studies but there is no unified understanding of the range of outcomes they influence, the factors that shape them, and how to measure them. We survey this growing literature. We argue that there is compelling evidence to consider aspirations as a useful lens to analyze human behavior and development outcomes, at the individual and aggregate levels, in poorer and richer countries. The empirical evidence aligns with the theory that high aspirations can lead individuals to achieve better educational, labor market, and other outcomes and can contribute to making countries more equal and prosperous. The empirical evidence also confirms that the mix of social and circumstantial factors shaping aspirations tends to hinder the aspirations of the disadvantaged—such as the poor, immigrants, and women—and can contribute to vicious circles of poverty, high inequality, low social mobility, and low growth. However, high aspirations should not be considered an end in themselves as they can backfire, with deleterious effects, if unmatched with opportunities. Further, we argue that definitional and measurement issues can affect the understanding of the topic and that studies should more explicitly describe their measures of aspirations to ensure that divergent underlying concepts are not mistaken.

That is from a 2025 paper by , , and  And here is a 2026 paper on similar topics.

The post The Power and Roots of Aspirations appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Politics Chat, November 13, 2026

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

Get full, free access to Letters from an American here.

You can also find Heather:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

Don’t worry everyone, Markwayne Mullin is on the case!

As you’ve surely seen/heard/experienced by now, the FAA has grounded every flight. Wanna see Grandma this weekend? Nah. Wanna catch the big Hillsdale-Ohio Dominican football game this weekend? Bad news. Just wanna get away for, oh, your honeymoon? Might not happen.

Luckily, we have two people in charge calling the shots.

One is Sean Duffy, the transportation secretary and former Real World contestant.

And the other—my personal favorite—is former Oklahoma senator Markwayne Mullin, now overlord of Homeland Security.

Here’s Markwayne, discussing the issues …

“Out of abundant of caution.”

“OUT OF ABUNDANT OF CAUTION!!!!”

Bruh, I have low standards these days. Fuck some hookers? Fine. Snort some coke? Reasonable. Worked as a crack-dealing pimp back in 2022? People change.

But when a guy with a hugely important job cannot string words together?

We’re doomed.

PS:

Two Pacific Storms to Impact the West this Week; Heavy to Excessive Rainfall in Eastern Florida

WorkOS: Let Agents Use Your Tools Without Giving Them Free Rein

My thanks to WorkOS for sponsoring DF last week. An agent’s job isn’t known until it runs, so a role assigned in advance is always too much or too little. Give the agent a task instead, and every call it makes gets checked against that intent, whether it’s reading a Linear issue or emailing a distribution list.

With WorkOS Airlock, you set the policies once. Each call is allowed, denied, or sent to a human for approval, and every verdict is logged.

Request early access today.

 ★