Will AI Growth Reach the Developing World?

Here is the abstract from a new NBER paper by Daniel Björkegren, David Lagakos & Mitchell VanVuren:

This paper explores how economic growth driven by AI will impact the developing world. Our analysis is based on a growth model of a developed and developing economy where AI services are traded on the world market, and may substitute for or complement different labor inputs in production. Preferences allow for the possibility that demand for services provided by AI has an upper bound. The model predicts that developing countries may not benefit as much from AI-driven growth. First, they may lack complementary skills needed to fully utilize AI domestically. Second, they may be priced out of world markets due to their relatively lower productivity. We use our model to simulate how growth and welfare are affected by making workers more complementary to AI, subsidizing compute, speeding technology diffusion, and providing cash transfers. Numerical simulations of the model suggest that the potential for developing countries to be left behind – or having some workers lose in absolute terms – is substantial enough that researchers should study the impacts of AI on developing countries in real time.

I am more optimistic than the authors.  For one thing, in their model AI improves the productivity of legal services in say Africa, but not food.  That mix seems unlikely to me.  AI already makes rainfall prediction and crop management more productive, and it might over time help create more “miracle crops.”  A few other points:

1. I do not expect wealthy and poor countries to converge, and the gap might even increase with AI.  But the poorer countries can sell more of their resources to the wealthy countries, and are likely much better off anyway, compared to no AI.  If you read the authors carefully, they do not (seem to?) deny that, yet it is framed as being “left behind.”

2. You might think that AI and robots discourage the export-oriented industrialization for today’s poor countries.  In my view, that was not going to happen anyway, admittedly that is a subjective judgment.

3. The poorer economies typically have an excess of politics and corruption, even if government spending as a share of gdp is relatively low.  This suggests “AI lawyers” will not put “African lawyers” out of business soon, even if the AI lawyers are very good.  Practicing law is bundled with politics to a very high degree.  That fact is unfortunate, but it implies a high degree of job protection and a centaur model, rather than full work displacement.

4. Will the poor countries satiate in AI-provided services, such as legal services, as is the case in some versions of this model?  That seems unlikely, as more growth can boost the demand for legal services more or less indefinitely.  And so so many people in those countries right now cannot afford decent lawyers.  That prospect of satiation seems very far off indeed.

5. Rather than having a single world market for AI, why not have tiered markets, where the poor countries buy lower-quality AI services but at lower prices and also they avoid being shut out of the prime market?

6. The autors (p.11) hold TFP fixed for many parts of the economy.  Of course that will lower the gains from AI.

7. p.44 argues that developing economies are becoming priced out of AI inputs already.  I would be shocked if that prediction turns out to be true, rather I expect smartphone usage (as opposed to mere cell phones) to continue to increase at a rapid pace.

So overall there is way too much negative framing in this piece, and the negative framings seem deliberately chosen, rather than falling out of a more basic or primitive model.

The post Will AI Growth Reach the Developing World? appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

      

Related Stories

 

Reading List 11/21/2026

Picture Gallery with Views of Modern Rome by Giovanni Paolo Panini, via WikiArt.

Welcome to the reading list, a weekly roundup of news and links related to buildings, infrastructure and industrial technology. This week we look at BAAJA, rayon for missiles, US gas consumption, Cyberarmageddon, and more. Roughly 2/3rds of the reading list is paywalled, so for full access become a paid subscriber.

No essay this week, but I’m working on a long follow up to my technological search essay that should be out next week.

Housing and Cities

A neat dataset showing the relationship between excess deaths and temperature in cities around the world. You can really see the sensitivity to high temperatures in places without AC. [Our World in Data]

The Senate passes the permitting reform bill BAAJA. [NYT] And Kalshi now gives BAAJA a 75% chance of becoming law. [Kalshi] And New Mexican Senator Martin Heinrich is in the Economist arguing for BAAJA. “The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act—which the Senate voted to advance on November 9th and which I co-sponsor with another Democrat and two Republicans—does not remove environmental considerations, the ability to litigate projects or the ability for local communities to comment. Those are necessary. But it does make these reviews a standardised part of a predictable process.” [The Economist]

New type of nimbyism just dropped: people opposed to delivery drones flying over their backyard. [WSJ]

How Dubrovnik, the Croatian city where King’s Landing scenes were shot in Game of Thrones, is coping with huge masses of tourists and (checks notes) Montenegrin drug cartels. [The Times]

Manufacturing

From the annals of manufacturing bottlenecks: producing more Patriot missiles requires, among other things, a specialized rayon fabric called Raycarb, processed by a single US company who sources it from a tiny number of companies (apparently just two), who are unable or unwilling to ramp up capacity as fast as the US would like. “Only one rayon product of this kind is approved for use in the most advanced Patriot missiles, and it comes from the Kansas factory of a single supplier, Park Aerospace. With Patriot stockpiles shrinking, the Pentagon official pushed Park for more rayon to help ramp up missile production. It soon became clear that the company’s hands were tied. The problem lay not in Kansas but thousands of miles across the Atlantic near the vineyards of Bordeaux in France. That’s where Park’s supplier, ArianeGroup—a maker of space rockets and ballistic missiles—produces the carbonized rayon fabric, which it then ships to Park for further processing. ArianeGroup had been clear that supply was limited.” [WSJ]

Manufacturing automation startup Hadrian is buying Kutztown Foundry and Machine, a company that makes castings for, among other things, nuclear submarines. [Manufacturing Dive]

The US Marine Minerals Administration, formerly the BOEM, held an auction for seabed mining rights on 31 million acres of seabed near American Samoa. [Maritime Executive]

China produces a lot of air conditioners. [X]

Apparently Tesla will sell you a Cybercab, under a somewhat strict set of conditions. “Tesla is now inviting “select customers” to buy a Cybercab for personal use at $29,990, but the car won’t move unless you also pay $299 a month for an “Autonomy Subscription.” And it only works inside Tesla’s Robotaxi service areas in Texas and Florida, the same geofences that have turned out to be significantly smaller than what Tesla advertises.” [Electrek] And a factory to produce Tesla’s Optimus is under construction at Giga Texas. [YouTube]

A bunch of planned naval vessels have been cut by the US Senate appropriations committee. [X]

The GAO says the F-35 program has about 26 million spare parts, collectively worth about $31 billion, spread around 700 sites around the world. [Tom’s Hardware]

Read more

★ A Week With the New Privacy Controls in MacOS 27.3 Beta 2

On Monday, when the second betas of the v27.3 OSes came out, I posted about Apple adding the new privacy controls they had promised a month prior, in the wake of Meta’s Muse app surprising some users with what information it had access to (e.g., incoming iMessages) after being granted Full Disk Access — which authorization some users just clicked right through. I also posted a link to Apple’s corresponding new support documents. My initial take on Monday:

I’m installing it now, but from what I’ve seen so far, these changes not only alleviate my concerns that Apple might over-tighten the screws, I actually think they add clarity and give users more, not less, control over their Macs.

After a week, I’m willing to call it: this overhaul of these settings and permissions is a win. I really like the way that, for apps asking for Full Disk Access, users can now grant access to a list of folders instead. That’s what I mean about these new settings giving users more control.

Are these new dialog boxes “scarier”? Yes, and the point is, they should be. You should be slightly jolted into attention when an app prompts for any of these permissions. The question is whether they are unnecessarily scary. I would say no, not at all. The descriptions are fair and accurate. Is it unnecessarily scary to show you thumbnails of your personal photos before permitting Full Disk Access that would grant an application unfettered access to your personal photos? No! It’s a bit of a jolt to see them, but that’s just reducing the abstraction. The words “full disk access” feel different than actually seeing a snapshot of what full disk access entails.

Might this discourage some Mac users from granting Full Disk Access to AI agent apps? Yes. And it should! Users who actually understand the stakes will not be dissuaded by these new permissions — when granting them is what they know they want to do. Additionally, I think these new dialog boxes represent very good UI design. They look like a new modern take on MacOS “system chrome” design — not skinny iPhone-sized alerts.

My only gripe about the new stuff is the prominent menu bar indicator that now appears when one app is controlling another. You can’t turn it off (except via an undocumented hidden defaults setting), and it’s distracting on most Macs, and extra distracting on the new MacBook Pros with PROLED displays because on those Macs, it appears in the Dynamic Island! Chance Miller, on Threads (with screenshots):

Most of the changes in macOS 27.3 are reasonable, but this Live Activity thing for system access has got to go. It’s way too aggressive.

It takes over the Dynamic Island on the new MacBook Pro!

As I write this article on a new MacBook Pro review unit, I have 8 of these indicators in my Dynamic Island: Scroll Reverser, Keyboard Maestro Engine, HazeOver, SteerMouse Manager, Moom, Chest (a promising new utility for managing menu bar icons), System Events, and a new text snippet expansion utility I’m beta testing.

Every one of these apps is running all of the time for me. This indicator being on, all the time, for every one of them isn’t helping me notice unusual activity. If anything, if Apple doesn’t rethink this idea, it’s going to make me miss the indication if an app is taking advantage of access permissions in an unwanted or unexpected way.

Zac Hall, Miller’s colleague at 9to5Mac, published an article on Tuesday showing the command-line defaults incantation to disable this. That’s better than not being able to disable it at all, but I expect Apple to revisit this based on feedback. It seems like a well-intentioned feature that was designed by people who didn’t realize how many always-on utilities “control other apps”.

The U.S. — Utterly Predictably — Has Lost Measles Elimination Status Under Trump and RFK Jr.

Sumathi Reddy, writing for The Wall Street Journal (gift link):

The U.S.’s loss of what is known as measles-elimination status is a massive public-health defeat that begs a question: How long will it take to regain it?

Based on other countries’ experience it could be up to five years, say doctors and epidemiologists. But that assumes the federal government is a robust and willing participant proactively working on measles vaccination.

Without that, it could take even longer.

Nilay Patel, in the headline of his endorsement of Kamala Harris two years ago: “A Vote for Donald Trump Is a Vote for School Shootings and Measles”.

 ★ 

Apple Documents Extra Apple Intelligence Usage Limits Per iCloud+ Paid Tier

Apple Support:

Starting with the 2027 software releases, Siri AI and Apple Intelligence features are available for free for users with a supported device set to a supported language. Some features rely on powerful server models and have limits where increased access is available with eligible iCloud+ plans, starting with the 27.3 release. These include, but aren’t limited to, features in these categories:

  • Siri AI
  • Images: Intelligent Photo Editing Tools including Clean Up, Extend, and Spatial Reframing, and Image Playground
  • Workflows and automation: AFM Cloud and Cloud Pro models in Shortcuts
  • Third-party apps using Apple Foundation Models in Private Cloud Compute

[...]

When you hit your daily usage limit for a particular feature category, you’ll be notified. Each device has its own daily usage limit per feature category. Once you reach a limit, you can wait until your daily usage limit resets on that device or immediately increase your limit by upgrading to an eligible iCloud+ plan.

Here’s Apple’s table with the usage limits by tier:

 ★ 

Saturday 21 November 1663

At the office all the morning and at noon I receive a letter from Mr. Creed, with a token, viz., a very noble parti-coloured Indian gowne for my wife. The letter is oddly writ, over-prizing his present, and little owning any past service of mine, but that this was his genuine respects, and I know not what: I confess I had expectations of a better account from him of my service about his accounts, and so give his boy 12d., and sent it back again, and after having been at the pay of a ship this afternoon at the Treasury, I went by coach to Ludgate, and, by pricing several there, I guess this gowne may be worth about 12l. or 15l. But, however, I expect at least 50l. of him. So in the evening I wrote him a letter telling him clearly my mind, a copy of which I keep and of his letter and so I resolve to have no more such correspondence as I used to have but will have satisfaction of him as I do expect.

So to write my letters, and after all done I went home to supper and to bed, my mind being pretty well at ease from my letter to Creed, and more for my receipt this afternoon of 17l. at the Treasury, for the 17l. paid a year since to the carver for his work at my house, which I did intend to have paid myself, but, finding others to do it, I thought it not amisse to get it too, but I am afeard that we may hear of it to our greater prejudices hereafter.

Read the annotations

Life is Better in GTA VI Except When It’s Not

Life is better in GTA VI except when it's not

Life is better in GTA VI except when it's not · youtu.be

I’m still very early in my GTA VI experience — Chapter One — a prologue that sets the standard for a 10+ hour tutorial for one of the best games you’ll ever play. Two brief thoughts:

First, prior to GTA, I’ve been an avid ARC Raiders player during my long post-Destiny depression. Whether you like extraction shooters or not, you can’t argue the game is gorgeous. There are times I just want to wander around on one of those maps. GTA is that level of detail, except it’s a mind-boggling open world with fewer killer robots. I’ll go further: it’s the most realized open world I’ve ever experienced.

Second, one of the games I play while playing is “I wonder if…” For example, there are iguanas everywhere. I stood at the side of the road as one of the iguanas ran across the road, and I thought, “I wonder if… the iguana will be killed.” It was.

Immersion is broken when you play I-wonder-if, and it fails to meet your expectations. GTA meets all I-wonder-if expectations and usually exceeds them.

But, yeah, there are a few bugs.

Links 11/21/26

Links for you. Science:

NIH director calls for new probe of controversial COVID-19 origin paper. Bhattacharya wants Nature Medicine to review whether former NIH leaders ghostwrote manuscript challenging theory an engineered virus caused pandemic (there’s no evidence that they did for what it’s worth)
Bacterial toxin produced by E coli leading suspect in rise in bowel cancer among under-50s (needs to be a lot more work done here, but interesting; B2 group E. coli have been implicated in several gut diseases before and those hypotheses didn’t pan out)
The US Lost Its Measles Elimination Status. It’ll Take Years to Get It Back
With measles spreading, do you need a booster shot?
The return of endemic measles is a likely harbinger of future crises
‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness
This year’s humpback whale migration was missing something vital – the calves and their mothers

Other:

Oh, Elon Musk is ‘moderate’ now, is he? After spending nearly half a billion dollars to thwart Democrats, Musk tries to distance himself from MAGA.
Patch Me If You Can
Susie Madrak Lost Her Battle with Cancer, and with Our Healthcare System
If Democrats hope to do anything useful, they need to kill the filibuster (more and more people are saying this!)
Metro May Cut Bus Routes and Reduce Rail Service to Make Up Budget Gap
Hourly workers are living with 7.86% inflation. No wonder they voted against the AI boom
‘What Should the Leader Say?’: Hakeem Jeffries Staffer Built an AI Program for Surveillance and Advice
Don’t ICEwash or Griftwash the Midterms
Who Will Be Musk’s Candidates
The Trump DOJ Quietly Intervened to Ink a Huge Payout to a Trump Golf Pro
Bo French loses Texas country club membership (imagine how awful you must be for this to happen)
After gutting newsrooms, McClatchy plans to rebuild itself around AI (the executives sound like they are AI)
Jared Kushner Is Negotiating for Peace While Profiting From War
How D.C.’s Cash Payment Law Went Bankrupt
In a landmark judgment, top UN court says Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya
Republicans get the Hispanic backlash half-right. Trump’s draconian immigration policies played a big role in Latinos revolting against the Republican Party–but it’s not the whole story
Tech World Vibe Check: The tech barons are wilding out right now
Jeffries understands the assignment. Does Schumer?
Five Takeaways From the Most Detailed Data We Have on Midterm Voters
Copilot is “the new OS for work,” and now Office runs inside of it
Hillary Clinton: What Trump Should Have Said to Putin
It’s Rs, Not Ds, Who Are In Trouble in ‘28
Affordability Requires Class War
The Far Right Is The Butt Of The Joke In ‘GTA VI.’ They’re Angry For An Entirely Different Reason. (they’re so weird)
After the Logan Circle Shooting, an Old Foe Comes Back Into Focus: Mold
D.C. delays Medicaid work requirements, but thousands may still lose their health insurance next year
Before You Sign That Lease: A New Website Ranks D.C.’s “Worst Landlords”
The D.C. Jail’s food has been a health hazard for too long
Leaked: How Silicon Valley Elites Bankrolled an Anti-Migrant, Pro-Israel Propaganda Machine
2 Senators Block Trump Nominee Who Said Capitol Wasn’t Attacked On Jan. 6, 2021

SpaceX's Starshield troubles in Ukraine could threaten its broader military business

The representative in the US House expected to chair the House Intelligence Committee in January, Jim Himes (D-Conn.), has threatened to withhold support for funding government-owned systems from SpaceX amid the ongoing inquiry into the use of Starshield in Ukraine.

"SpaceX's potentially unilateral modification of a U.S. Government contract, combined with its lack of responsiveness to congressional oversight, calls into question every contract the U.S. Government has with SpaceX," Himes wrote in a letter to SpaceX founder Elon Musk on Friday.

CNN first reported the letter's existence. The network also reported that Himes sent a classified communication to Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton with a similar message that it would be difficult for Congress to authorize funding for systems with SpaceX as the primary vendor.

Read full article

Comments

Quoting Ravi Vakil

Alessandro Masullo has a proposed proof of [Generalized Riemann Hypothesis], and Brian Conrad has been looking closely at it for months and gave extensive feedback which is being incorporated, and it is so far looking good. It is all human, with no AI. The hope was to bring Alessandro to Stanford for a year to polish the writing and then announce it after running it by enough people. Now it seems best to put out the current draft.

— Ravi Vakil, Hurried Announcement: Alessandro Masullo GRH

Tags: mathematics

Saturday assorted links

1. Many federal agencies are hiring economists.

2. Theodore Zeldin, RIP.

3. Henry Oliver on Paradise Lost.

4. Quantum computing even weirder than you think? (NYT)  And an article bullish on quantum computing (NYT).

5. Good AI policy ideas from Joshua Saxe.

6. Podcast with SBF from prison, have not had a chance to listen, looks interesting.

7.. Possible implications of the generalized Riemann proof?

The post Saturday assorted links appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

The Explorer Pattern for product invention and development.

tl;dr: the Explorer Pattern is one individual or team building a functional implementation that minimizes cross-team and cross-functional impacts as much as humanly possible, and then reconciling the details with other teams after that prototype is completed, accepting that this approach can require very substantial rework to that initial development.

Why write this?

Imprint previously called this the “Tech-led” or “Engineering-led” development model, but it’s pretty unclear to folks what that means. This writeup provides a more defined term, the “Explorer Pattern”, and explains in more detail how this works.

Why do we need to adjust the way we work?

Before 2026:

  • Code is expensive, and we design process to minimize implementation and rework

In and after 2026:

  • Writing software is extremely cheap, but it’s a wider phenomenon: generating output is effectively-free across many dimensions. Code is nearly free — if we have appropriate constraints. Designs are nearly free — if they follow patterns. Analysis is nearly free — if we’ve instrumented things properly
  • Reworking software is extremely cheap. Historically industry has optimized around avoiding engineering rework because engineering was the highest cost / narrowest constraint. In many companies this was interpreted as writing code being the constraint, which was never true, but many common practices were designed as if that were true (e.g. bringing engineering into problem-solving late “to protect their time”)
  • Working on the system is much more effective than historically if we get automated integration and feedback loops right, e.g. not improving a one-off design but improving the design system. Any place where improving the higher-leverage process is slower than solving the one-off is a bug in our process

Explorer Pattern: primary-and-replicas metaphor

Database replication diagram: three Writer boxes feed a single Primary database, which fans out to a chain of Secondary replicas

The easiest metaphor to think about the Explorer Pattern is database replication. Databases like MySQL and PostgreSQL have a primary database, where writes are performed. Every write is verified at that point, and once it’s verified, you know that the writes will flow downstream to various secondary replicas. Those downstream replicas can be delayed but they can’t be wrong because writes are verified upstream. (I’ve resisted the desire to talk about the CAP theorem.)

Diagram of three Writers writing to three separate Primary databases, with the write paths crossing and tangling to show inconsistency

A different model for database design is that used by Dynamo or Cassandra (or MongoDB to a certain extent), where you have a replica set, and have to get an acknowledgement from the majority of the replica set for a write to be strongly consistent. This is a very reliable setup, because it means you can tolerate losing a node, but it also introduces inconsistencies, and on a fixed amount of hardware they tend to be much, much slower than running a primary-secondary setup (or rely on bad performance metrics that don’t fsync to disk to create the illusion of throughput).

The Explorer Pattern is the former primary-secondary model, where the vast majority of the work is done by the working individual or team. This makes all work internally consistent because it’s passed through the same small group. It doesn’t, however, mean that the work is perfect. For example, you can always insert data that meets the table’s requirements but is still inherently wrong (e.g. 200 is a valid integer, but it doesn’t mean that my credit limit was supposed to be 200, that depends on the surrounding application logic).

Other teams become aware of the changes downstream, not synchronously upfront, and it’s instead the working group’s responsibility to both rationalize approach and create visibility into their work for other teams to engage in a non-blocking fashion.

Example: Support for Financial Aggregators

A concrete example of this practice at Imprint was rolling out financial aggregator support, e.g. allowing folks to connect to their Imprint powered accounts via Plaid. This has always been something folks want, but it’s particularly important in the realm of agentic commerce where more folks’ agents are analyzing their financial state for them. For this project, one of our engineering leaders (Ron), built the first pass of the feature at a low-burn while understanding the shape of the problem in a private alpha. He chatted through some of the details periodically to keep other teams aware, but it was a bit of a side project.

However, once he found the full shape of the problem and had implemented a full solution, we cut the replica-lag across teams down to near-zero, identified and ran through the small number of remaining issues, and shipped it. Like many of our projects this year, it was never officially on a roadmap, and shipped a quality feature that our members have wanted for some time.

How to follow the Explorer pattern

The rough rules for following the Explorer pattern:

  1. Know your goal and sponsor: every initiative ultimately has to have a specific outcome it’s pursuing and a sponsor who’s bankrolling that pursuit. This doesn’t always need to be explicit, especially for smaller projects, but once a project goes beyond ~3 weeks of effort, if you can’t very explicitly identify who the stakeholder is sponsoring your project and they would not enthusiastically agree, then you are likely closer to “lost” than “exploring”
  2. Small working group is small: at most 5 people, and preferably smaller. Everyone in the group has to keep the entire project in their head for as long as possible to detect problems and opportunities
  3. Small working group is flexible: folks in small working groups have to “find a way to yes” rather than “find a way to no”. Exploring is about uncovering the fundamental shape of a problem rather than pretending we know the fundamental shape
  4. Publish progress in a public channel: explorers have to report home with the progress they are making so others are aware. This is both a Linear Project and a Slack channel.
  5. Make the narrowest viable changes to what already exists: when we introduce unnecessary changes, we invalidate others’ mental models about how the world works. When we haven’t made those changes with care, we’re not only invalidating others’ mental model, we are creating the expectation that we’ve done it very intentionally for a good reason, which has a chilling effect on others improving them later, which is very expensive, whereas the Explorer pattern depends on being as inexpensive as possible
  6. Exercise good judgment to identify reasonable hypotheses: discard bad ideas immediately, and then filter the rest by trying to implement them as quickly as possible. Once you see the shape of the implementation, you can figure out which of the remainders are interesting
  7. Hold assumptions constant to avoid getting stuck: the only way to navigate complex ambiguous problems is to hold things constant, even when you know they are imperfect. For example, to do headcount planning we have to know our revenue, to know our revenue we have to forecast it, to forecast it we have to know the day that partners will go live next year. We don’t truly know any of those things, so just anchoring on a plausible guess to unblock us is much more valuable than trying to get them accurate. A little prework is useful, but a lot is just artificial precision that’s a distraction from progress
  8. Hold space for being totally wrong: when we move fast, with low information, we always find the way out, but often it’s not the way out we anticipated when we got started. Being open to throwing it all away, and starting a second, third, fourth time
  9. Ship all the way to production behind a feature flag: features and products move fast when we get the pieces working every step from frontend to backend to data pulls. This is the first step of exploration. Just make sure it’s behind a feature flag that’s only enabled for internal folks!

Live coverage: SpaceX to launch intelligence-gathering satellites for the National Reconnaissance Office

A Falcon 9 rocket stands poised to launch from the Space Launch Complex 4E at Vandenberg Space Force Base in California. File Photo: SpaceX

SpaceX will launch a batch of intelligence-gathering satellites to low Earth orbit on behalf of the National Reconnaissance Office on Sunday morning. It’s Falcon 9 rocket will take off from Vandenberg Space Force Base in California.

The mission, designated NROL-136, will add an undisclosed number of satellites to the NRO’s satellite constellation that it refers to as its proliferated architecture. This will be the fourth such launch this year and the 15th to date.

Liftoff from Space Launch Complex 4E at Vandenberg Space Force Base is scheduled for 4:23 a.m. PST (7:23 a.m. EST / 1223 UTC).

Spaceflight Now will have live coverage beginning about 30 minutes prior to liftoff.

SpaceX will launch the mission using the Falcon 9 first stage booster with the tail number B1097. This will be its 14th flight following the launches of NROL-172, USSF-259, Transporter-17, Twilight, Sentinel-6B, and eight batches of Starlink satellites.

Roughly 7.5 minutes after liftoff, B1097 will target a landing at Landing Zone 4, adjacent to the launch pad. If successful, this will be the 38th landing at this site and the 680th Falcon booster landing to date.

A simple observation

The Riemann proof seems like a true surprise.  Yet on the same day Anthropic shares fell about ten percent.  In other words, the market feels that “capabilities” do not necessarily translate into significant social and economic outcomes.

Yet cybersecurity stocks are up considerably over the last few months, due to heightened cyber risk.  So the market is hardly unaware of AI and its potential, when the connection is real and evident.

Just a simple point to ponder.  Here are good comments from Alex Imas and Seb Krier.

The post A simple observation appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Central Pacific Tropical Weather Outlook


Central North Pacific 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Central North Pacific 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ACPN50 PHFO 220500
TWOCP

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS Central Pacific Hurricane Center Honolulu HI
Issued by NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
800 PM HST Sat Nov 21 2026

For the central North Pacific...between 140W and 180W:

Tropical cyclone formation is not expected during the next 7 days.

$$
Forecaster Cangialosi
NNNN


The Powerful and the Pitiful

Image

Marketing note: I have a new ebook, Navigating the Chaos: Chronicles of Economic and Political Madness, which uses material from this Substack to construct a thematic narrative of the past two years and the issues that Democrats must now address to build an enduring progressive movement. Available from Amazon, Kobo,Bookshop, and Nook.

I’ve had a busy week, ending with a nasty cold. So no video/podcast today. But I thought I’d put up a brief note about the summit meeting that just took place in China, and its aftermath.

Clearly both Trump and Putin wanted Shenzhen to look like the Yalta conference in 1945: The leaders of three great powers, on the cusp of victory in World War II, divvying up the world.

The reality, however, is that late 2026 is nothing like early 1945. And the Chinese, at least, understood the difference perfectly well.

First of all, Russia simply isn’t a great power. Here’s 2025 GDP for the 6 largest economies, in current dollars:

These numbers look a bit different if we adjust for purchasing power, in which case China is #1. But Russia is just not a major player in the world economy.

Before Putin invaded Ukraine, many people on the US right nonetheless imagined that Russia was at least a military great power. After all, the Russians were manly, presumably with high testosterone. They weren’t woke! Surely they were great at warrior ethos and lethality!

But they have failed to conquer Ukraine, and in fact seem to be losing their war. Just before the summit the Ukrainians rubbed in how badly Putin’s war is going by taking down the central span of his beloved Kerch bridge.

The Chinese understand Russia’s true place in the world. As the photo at the top of this post — taken from Phillips O’Brien — shows, they literally didn’t even put Putin with Xi and Trump at the formal banquet. They seated him at the kiddie table.

America, by contrast, is a great power, with an immense, productive economy and a large military. However, our economic power is less than Trump imagined: At this point most of the world has realized that it can cope with Trumpian tariffs, and just shrugs off his economic threats. Meanwhile our military — its competence greatly degraded under Pete Hegseth’s leadership — has performed remarkably poorly in Trump’s war on Iran, while depleting its stock of advanced munitions.

America as a nation still has many strengths. But Trump himself is a deeply weakened leader, whose party just suffered the worst midterm defeat in half a century. And other nations have basically stopped taking him seriously. When the Pentagon’s top policy official criticized Ukraine’s policy of long-range strikes on Russia, Germany’s Defense Minister Boris Pistorius called it “quite a stupid thing.” Pistorius later apologized for his language — but didn’t back down on the substance.

The meeting in Shenzhen, then, was supposed to be a major event but ended up being a Potemkin Yalta. That is, it presented the façade of a great power summit, but the reality was that it was a meeting between one genuinely powerful autocrat, Premier Xi, and two wannabe world leaders, Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump, each of whom now cuts a pitiful figure on the global stage.

PS: Yes, I’m aware that Wile E. Coyote looked down yesterday, and it sure looks as if the AI bubble is popping. But I have a healthcare primer to finish, so The Market will have to wait until Monday.

NONMUSICAL CODA

So my IMF event is up. My presentation starts about 23 minutes in:

The Merge Is Upon Us: A Decade Of Neuralink

Photo Credit: Poupay Pinyodoonyachet

Over the past decade, I’ve visited Neuralink dozens of times. Its research labs and surgical centers. Its animal care facilities. Its brain implant production lines. I’ve also spent many weeks hanging out with patients who have received one of Neuralink’s implants. No other journalist has documented the evolution of Neuralink and its technology as closely.

The culmination of this reporting arrives today via a partnership between Core Memory and Life. We’ve produced a 10,000-word story that is part of Life’s spectacular return in print and online. It’s the tale of one of the most ambitious and controversial companies around and is based on hundreds of hours of reporting and interviews.

Subscribe now

You can read the story here and also obtain a beautiful, printed copy.

The first return issue of Life, now in an oversized, 11x16” keepsake anthology weighing almost 3 lbs, features full bleed imagery from this story, and the first Neuralink patient - Noland Arbaugh - on one of its covers. All Life subscribers will also receive a separately printed copy of the full Neuralink piece.

Photo Credit: Poupay Pinyodoonyachet

We’re also thrilled to announce that we’ve produced two documentary films on Neuralink and its clinical trial patients that will be premiering with Life in December.

Life is such an iconic brand and has been a storied force in journalism for decades. We welcome its return with unbridled enthusiasm and encourage you all to check out the work others have done to make the magazine sing.

We’d also like to give a big nod of thanks to Figma. Its technology played a massive role in the redesign of Life by helping the team move fast and bring their full creative vision to fruition.

Here’s a taste of the story:

Come November, the nights start getting cool in Yuma, Arizona, so Noland Arbaugh and his family will sometimes head to their back patio, toss some wood in the firebox, and hang out in the crisp desert air. It’s usually the three of them: Noland; his mother, Mia; and his stepdad, David, along with a menagerie of animals, both loose and caged, that includes dogs, chickens, quail, ducks, and goats. The most attention- seeking of these companions is Hope, a turkey who thinks she’s a dog. Hope cruises around the dirt backyard, then comes over to the family, pressing up against them to elicit pats and kind words.

The scene seems like it could take place anywhere in America, but that’s not the truth. That’s because this prefab house has Arbaugh in it, and he is the closest thing we have to a cyborg. He is the harbinger of a future way of life that can feel glorious, unnerving, or both, depending on how you look at it.

On January 28, 2024, Arbaugh became the first person to receive a brain implant made by Neuralink, the company founded by Elon Musk. At nearby Barrow Neurological Institute in Phoenix, a surgeon removed a circular piece of his skull so that a robot made by Neuralink could sew a series of very fine electrode-laced wire threads into his motor cortex. The electrodes nestle right up against his neurons, which allow them to read the electrical signals produced by his brain activity.

In 2016 just after he had graduated from college, Arbaugh had been horsing around with some friends at a lake when he was hit in the head and almost drowned. He was left as a quadriplegic, paralyzed from the neck down and able to communicate only with the aid of a computer, relying on a cumbersome mouth stick to tap a screen and move a cursor. He spent the next eight years in a wheelchair, spinning through cycles of complacency at best and depression at worst about his condition and the burden it placed on his family. They were not well off, and the care and time required to tend to him only made getting by that much harder. “I just draw in resources,” he says, “and give nothing out.”

Keep reading here.

Share

NASA’s new Moon plan is taking shape, but some big questions remain

SpaceX's successful recovery of its Starship rocket last weekend cleared a major hurdle on NASA's path to the Moon, opening up possibilities for higher launch rates and an all-important, long-delayed orbital refueling demo next year.

For SpaceX's purposes, Saturday's mid-air rocket catch will help engineers learn how to rapidly reuse Starships. That should expedite SpaceX's deployment of its newest generation of Starlink Internet satellites. NASA, meanwhile, believes a higher launch cadence will lead to faster learning as SpaceX develops a deep space version of Starship to ferry astronaut crews to the surface of the Moon.

Early next year, SpaceX plans to bring online a second Starship launch site at Kennedy Space Center, Florida. A second Starship factory is also under construction at Kennedy, joining SpaceX's existing SpaceX production line at Starbase, Texas. With two launch sites, SpaceX will have the pieces in place to take the next leap with Starship.

Read full article

Comments

Jlateh Vincent Jappah (remarkable job market candidate) in his own words

 Vincent Jappah, who I blogged about the other day, posted his own description of his remarkable personal and academic journey here.  He's a target of opportunity for any university interested in health and Africa and market design.

 The Question I Couldn’t Stop Asking
A student's journey from medicine to blood donation research

by Jlateh Vincent Jappah,  November 17 2026

########

Earlier: 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

 

Paul Litvak’s Evidence Guide

I’m excited to announce the launch of Evidence Guide, the place to store and find computational audits of papers. I built it to fill a major gap in research quality evaluation.

Here is the rest of the thread.  Here is the site.  This is happening quickly, people.  Via Andrea.

The post Paul Litvak’s Evidence Guide appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

The summit of the authoritarians

Get more from Paul Waldman in the Substack app
Available for iOS and Android

November 20, 2026

On November 19—yesterday—the United States president, Donald J. Trump, met with Chinese president Xi Jinping and Russia’s president Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen, China, on the sidelines of the summit of economic leaders from the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum. Putin attended the APEC summit for the first time in nine years.

APEC was founded in 1989, and its 21 members account for about 40% of the global population and more than 60% of the global gross domestic product (GDP). It includes Australia, Brunei Darussalam (a wealthy sultanate on the northern coast of the island of Borneo), Canada, Chile, China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Japan, Republic of Korea, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, Peru, the Philippines, Russia, Singapore, Taiwan, Thailand, the United States, and Vietnam.

The work of the APEC forum was overshadowed this year by the trilateral summit.

From the beginning, the fact that the president of the United States would meet with the leaders of China and Russia was bizarre because, as Phillips Payson O’Brien noted on social media yesterday and in an article in The Atlantic today, both China and Russia have been helping Iran in its current fight against Americans in the war Trump launched in February 2026. O’Brien notes that instead of protecting Americans, Trump is celebrating his inclusion in the company of leaders who have helped Iran kill American service members.

Trump appeared to want the meeting because he loves the glitz and attention of foreign visits, and Xi played that up, greeting Trump at his airplane. As foreign affairs journalist Anne Applebaum wrote yesterday in The Atlantic, Trump gushed about “the fanfare, the beauty, the pageantry, the thousands of people, the young children, the soldiers, the whole thing.” Hemmed in by the courts, shellacked in the midterms after telling people to vote as if he were on the ballot, and facing two years as a lame duck, he appeared to bask in the idea he was doing something vitally important with the eyes of the world upon him.

Putin appeared to want the summit because it would suggest he and Russia are on the same plane as the U.S. and China. It was, as former U.S. ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul suggested, a photo op that would help Putin “push the myth that Russia is respected [as a] great power.”

In fact, Russia is not a great power. Its per capita GDP is lower than that of Poland or, for that matter, that of California, Texas, or New York. Russia’s GDP is $2.8 trillion; by comparison, the European Union, which Trump disdains, has a GDP of $22.8 trillion. The GDP of the U.S. is $32.6 trillion; that of China, $21.5 trillion.

Especially as his war on Ukraine is going poorly, a tripartite summit with the U.S. and China would be a public relations coup for Putin. His war on Ukraine is approaching the five-year mark and has cost 1.5 million casualties. Ukraine has destroyed half of Russia’s ability to refine oil and, even as Putin headed off to China, struck his prized Kerch Strait Bridge. The war is forcing Russia to borrow, but sanctions mean that the government must borrow most of its money at home, mostly from the major banks, at high interest rates. Yesterday, the government enacted higher taxes and spending cuts, neither of which will be welcome at home.

For all that Trump claimed his waiver of sanctions on the global sale of Russian diesel was designed to bring down prices in the U.S., in fact the lifting of those sanctions has primarily helped pump desperately needed funds into Russia. On November 15, the editorial board of the Wall Street Journal noted what the deal really did and wrote: “It’s increasingly hard to resist the conclusion that Mr. Trump’s real goal is to appease Mr. Putin.”

Indeed.

Yesterday, Trump entered the room where he was to meet Putin and, pointing at Putin, said to his aides with a smile, “Who is he?” Then he answered his own questions, saying: “He’s my friend,” crossing to shake Putin’s hand and say quietly “Nice to see you, nice to see you” before saying something to Putin under his breath that made the Russian leader laugh.

Trump told reporters: “We look forward to our meeting. We’ve had a great relationship for many years. We know each other for a long time. And I think a lot of wonderful things can come out of this.”

Xi also used the meeting to broadcast propaganda around the world. Applebaum noted that Trump cooperated as Xi showed America’s decline. As the White House pushed pictures and video of Trump at the center of the event, it was also celebrating Chinese power while Trump appeared to fall asleep during the meetings. At the same time, Xi humiliated Putin by seating him away from the head table at dinner, reminding the world that Russia is dependent on China.

As Applebaum noted, the actual purpose of the meeting was “to produce propaganda photographs and video clips that each of the three leaders will now use to mask their political failures.” And, as Applebaum added, the event made China look like “the only serious country in the room.”

But behind the propaganda, the larger story is the destruction of the post–World War II rules-based international order that prohibited countries from violating the sovereignty of other countries. In its place, Putin has advocated dividing the world among superpowers that control nations around them in “spheres of influence.” Back in 2019, former White House advisor Fiona Hill told Congress that Russian officials suggested that they would give the U.S. free rein in Venezuela by stopping their support for Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro if the U.S. would let Russia do as it wished in Ukraine.

At the time, Trump sent Hill to Moscow to say “Ukraine and Venezuela are not related to each other.” But Trump has apparently come around to the idea of dividing the world by spheres of influence.

In a long, rambling press conference today, Trump made it clear he considered Russia, China, and the U.S. the three more important nations in the world not because of their economic might or their alliances or even their conventional military forces but because together they control, he said, 92% of the world’s nuclear weapons. Today he justified calling Putin a friend, saying “it’s nice to have people that have 4,000 nuclear weapons as a friend as opposed to an enemy.”

At the end of their ninety minutes of talks, the three leaders issued a statement together; the very fact of such a joint declaration with the U.S. siding with Russia and China rather than its democratic allies was itself a statement. The vague “joint declaration toward peace” called for increasing the production of fossil fuels and decreasing restrictions on the behavior of the three leaders and their nations. They vowed to “reform the UN” and weaken “the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies,” calling “respect for immunities of State officials…of paramount importance.”

Putin is already under indictment by the ICC for war crimes.

Former senior diplomat Ned Price told Michael Birnbaum of the Washington Post, “They’re basically saying, ‘We want to do away with these rules of the road, the rules of the road that have worked in our favor for the past 80 years in the favor of liberal, democratic, open systems around the world, and we want to replace them with something very different.’”

On his way home from the meeting, Trump made a surprise call to European leaders gathered in Berlin. The “Coalition of the Willing,” a group of more than 35 countries supporting Ukraine against Russian aggression, was gathered in Berlin for discussions with Ukraine’s president Volodymyr Zelensky. Birnbaum reported that Trump told the leaders that Putin wanted peace and that ending the war in Ukraine would free up more money for their own countries.

After the summit, Russia launched a barrage of missiles and drones at Ukraine’s civilian infrastructure. Poland’s minister of national defense said that two Russian missiles and a jet drone fell on Poland during Russia’s massive attack on Ukraine overnight. Poland’s prime minister Donald Tusk called it “an intentional provocation” from Russia. As Claudia Ciobanu, Samya Kuliab, and Barry Hatton of the Associated Press reported, European leaders condemned Russia’s actions.

NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte said Russia had committed “grave violations” of that country’s airspace. “This incident is clearly dangerous—a consequence of Russia’s ongoing war against Ukraine,” Rutte posted. “I condemn Russia’s attacks as well as its ongoing war. We continue to stand united as Allies and will continue to support Ukraine.”

Henry Foy, Anne-Sylvaine Chassany, Max Seddon, Christopher Miller, and Amy Mackinnon of the Financial Times reported today that Trump administration officials have told officials in Europe and Ukraine they want a peace deal between Ukraine and Russia before Democrats take control of Congress. They expect Democrats will increase the support for Ukraine that Trump has cut off, and restore sanctions against Russia.

—

Notes:

https://www.state.gov/asia-pacific-economic-cooperation

https://apnews.com/article/apec-economy-china-trump-xi-putin-asia-bb61e50e4b0bb0b975b0695dc4f7b64a

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/11/trump-shenzhen-summit-xi-putin/689522/

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/11/trump-xi-putin-summit/689503/

https://www.ipi.org/ipi_issues/detail/russias-minuscule-economy-the-mouse-that-roars

https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/NGDPD@WEO/EU/EURO/EUQ/RUS

https://united24media.com/world/russia-slashes-social-programs-and-healthcare-to-fund-record-2027-military-expansion-24539

https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-budget-healthcare-regions-military-spending/33889735.html

https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/09/28/russia-has-a-budget-problem-borrowing-its-way-out-wont-be-so-simple-a93804

https://www.wsj.com/opinion/donald-trump-diesel-deal-vladimir-putin-russia-7c282795

https://apnews.com/article/russia-venezuela-putin-maduro-fiona-hill-b26a94ceaba69c6ddd9193e2b31cb97f

https://www.reuters.com/world/china/trumps-historic-meeting-with-xi-putin-headlines-asia-trip-2026-11-18/

https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/2026/11/u-s-russia-china-heads-of-state-declaration-toward-peace/

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/11/19/trump-putin-xi-agreed-work-jointly-reduce-constraints-power/

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/nato-calls-russian-missiles-landing-in-poland-a-grave-violation-of-airspace

https://www.ft.com/content/6c1b8a64-35f9-4aba-8605-45a4abdce6b8?syn-25a6b1a6=1

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/19/opinion/hillary-clinton-trump-putin-ukraine.html

X:

McFaul/status/2122565940269490550

adammocklerr/status/2123282338985443632

SecGenNATO/status/2123750678459752875

YouTube:

watch?v=XgyH17iZJKk (at 31:50)

Bluesky:

phillipspobrien.bsky.social/post/3n2osgoftpc2k

nicoreijns.bsky.social/post/3n2osvtubbc2q

mcfaulmike.bsky.social/post/3n2oxlqnw322n

ronfilipkowski.bsky.social/post/3n2qlk5dpgs27

maks23.bsky.social/post/3n2qecqbghs2w

united24media.com/post/3n2qfkxy2oc2d

Share

Lawyers for Democracy | Skye Perryman

Preparing for Investigations

To read this letter, click here:

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

You can also find Heather at:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

It’s a laugh (what a laugh)

There is a little-known song by Hall & Oates titled, “It’s a Laugh.” It was birthed nearly 50 years ago, on the duo’s lightly regarded “Along the Red Ledge” album.

The chorus goes something like this …

It's a laugh, what a laugh
It's so stupid, I gotta laugh

For some reason, the tune has always done something for me. I think, really, it’s the simplicity. Some things are so stupid, so trite, so inane, so inept … that you just have to laugh.

You just have to.

•••

I bring this up because, two nights ago, I attended the Westminster City Council meeting, and—after writing this recap—walked away feeling somewhat good about the ultimate resolution. I mean, it wasn’t perfect. But it seemed like Chi Charlie Nguyen, the outgoing Republican mayor and a stubborn ol’ boot, had given in on some points, and acknowledged he was messing up his exodus from the spotlight.

It’s a laugh

It felt like enough of us spoke up and spoke out, and we were heard.

What a laugh

It felt like democracy prevailed.

It’s so stupid, I gotta laugh

Um, no.

It turns out the whole thing was—to the Republican majority and their POS mayor—a laugh. A lark. A game. A gag. Nonsense. Bullshit. Hell, earlier in the evening someone deep in the local governmental know sidled up to me inside Westminster’s city hall and whispered, “They’re playing chess, and we’re playing checkers.”

I didn’t fully believe it.

Well, I was wrong.

When none of us were looking, the MAGA majority played chess. Or, put differently: They placed an item to be discussed (and voted upon) in the next meeting (on Nov. 30) that is nothing short of diabolical and disgusting and anti-democratic. In short, if they have their way, beginning in December (after Democrat Carlos Manzo jumps in as mayor) it will take three council members to put anything on the agenda. In other words: As we speak, in Westminster all that is necessary to have an agenda item is the mayor bringing forth, well, an agenda item.

That will likely change.

The Republicans know precisely what they’re doing. Come December, Manzo will take over as mayor, and Democrat David Johnson will join the council after his victory over MAGA nasal cavity Amy Phan West. That means the five-person committee will—going forward—have two Democrats, three Republicans. And, if you made it through kindergarten, you know three is bigger than two.

Hence, if you need three votes to push forth an agenda item, but there are only two of you …

You’re handcuffed and limited and fucked.

It’s a laugh.

What a laugh.

Australia is unable to control inflation

On 3 November the RBA raised the cash rate to 4.85%, its fifth hike this year and the highest since 2008. Trimmed mean inflation is 3.6% and unemployment is 4.9%, and both are going up. Despite this, the RBA keeps saying it can get inflation back to target while holding on to the gains in employment.

There's a recurring bit in The Castle where Darryl Kerrigan hears what someone is offering and has only one reply: "Tell him he's dreaming." I think that's the right reply to anyone promising low inflation, low unemployment and high wages all at once, with zero productivity growth. You might be able to have three of those at the same time, but not all four.

Video (open the post to see it)

I predict that Australian unemployment will scream past 5% before trimmed mean inflation falls below 3%. This isn't strictly the RBA's fault, it's just that their lever no longer connects to a sufficiently large part of the economy.

In April I argued that Australia will run an overt command economy by 2040. The government already pays for and sets prices across a third of the economy. Set prices cause shortages, and politicians respond to shortages the same way every time: subsidizing demand while ignoring supply, then price controls, then nationalization.

What inflation actually is

So what is inflation? It's what happens when the supply of money grows faster than the supply of stuff for that money to buy. Every dollar is ultimately a claim on some goods or services, so when more dollars are chasing the same amount of stuff, each dollar buys less. Printing money is easy. Making stuff is hard, because it takes workers, energy, materials, and the know-how to combine them more efficiently over time. Creating more money doesn't necessarily create any more stuff, so all it does is debase the currency.

In Australia the government doesn't literally run the printing presses. It spends more than it collects in tax and borrows the difference, and banks create new money every time they write a loan. The effect is the same: more dollars in people's pockets. That leaves exactly two ways to control inflation. You can slow the growth of money, which is the Reserve Bank's job, and its only tool is interest rates, which control the cost of borrowing. Or you can speed up the growth of stuff, which means productivity, and that's everyone else's job. This post is about why Australia has become structurally incapable of doing the second, and what that does to the first.

What the RBA is telling us

By central bank standards, the RBA has been pretty clear about this. In February a parliamentary committee asked Governor Bullock whether government spending adds to demand. Her answer was "Yes, it does … Because what it often does is it transfers money to people, and it gives them money to spend." With the economy at capacity, she added, "anything that adds to aggregate demand adds to those capacity constraints, be it public or private." When she was pressed in March to say which kind of spending was the problem, she said "Value judgments on private versus public are not for me to make. They are for the government." You can read between the lines there. Meanwhile Deputy Governor Hauser said last month that productivity is "pretty much around zero per cent growth, and it's been zero cumulatively for the last decade or more." This is a shocking statement in a world of rapidly accelerating technology.

If I were Bullock I'd be tempted to ask Canberra what exactly they want me to do. The government's inflation policy amounts to pointing at the RBA and hoping it can tame a second wave of inflation without pushing up unemployment and triggering a recession. Australia managed to ride out the 2008 GFC without a recession thanks to Chinese demand for iron ore, record rate cuts, and Rudd's massive injection of liquidity into the economy that was always going to cause an inflationary hangover if productivity didn't rise enough to slurp it up. But productivity didn't rise anywhere near enough and governments got drunk on cheap money. Meanwhile the Australian economy hasn't had a proper recession, and associated flushing out of unproductive nonsense business practices, since 1991. The brief 2020 COVID recession doesn't count, because JobKeeper paid firms to keep everyone exactly where they were.

The arithmetic

Inflation isn't about whether wages are high. High relative to what? It's about whether wages grow faster than the amount each hour of work produces. Roughly:

The Wage Price Index rose 3.2% in the year to June 2026, while labor productivity has averaged about 0.3% a year for the past decade. Subtract one from the other and unit labor costs are rising at about 2.9% a year, before you even get to oil, housing or insurance premiums. That puts a floor under domestic inflation right at the top of the RBA's 2–3% target band, with no room left over for shocks.

The RBA can't do anything about productivity. The only lever it has on this equation is to raise unemployment (i.e. increase spare labor supply) until wage growth falls back to whatever the economy is actually producing. Governor Bullock said as much in September, putting the unemployment rate needed to ease inflation at somewhere between 4.5 and 5%. Why? Unemployed people buy less stuff, reducing aggregate demand, and increase supply of labor, pushing down wages. Treasury's Intergenerational Report puts the non-inflationary rate at about 4.25%. The gap between those two numbers is what a decade of flat productivity costs us, and it gets paid for in jobs.

This is the bit that never makes it into the press releases. Low inflation with low unemployment was a realistic promise when productivity grew 2% a year and could absorb 3–4% pay rises. With productivity at 0.3%... you're dreaming.

Who pays for the hike

Interest rates are a blunt instrument, but they don't hit everyone equally. They hit people who borrow, like mortgage holders, home builders, businesses thinking about investing (including in productivity-enhancing technology), and shops selling things people can put off buying. They barely touch spending the government funds at a fixed price.

The non-market sector (health, social assistance, education and public administration) accounted for around 55% of new jobs over the five years to March 2025, and in 2024 alone 80% of job creation was in the public or non-market sectors. A lot of that is the NDIS, which bills by the hour at a regulated price and couldn't care less what the cash rate is. The RBA estimates the shift into this sector knocked about 0.3 percentage points a year off productivity growth between 2017/18 and 2023/24, and in the year to December 2025 non-market productivity fell 0.7% while the market sector grew 1.5%.

So every dollar of public spending that ignores interest rates and labor supply forces the RBA to squeeze the private economy harder to hit the same overall number. RBA can hike rates, decreasing private sector consumption and investment, but this has no real effect on wages if the government slurps up most of the newly unemployed into highly bureaucratized jobs-for-life. Private sector employers, whose tax pays for the whole thing, get hit from both sides: More expensive debt and more expensive labor, predictably further reducing supply of their products! So Treasury has its foot on the accelerator, the RBA is standing on the brake, and the private sector is the brake pad. And the sector getting squeezed is the one where productivity is actually growing, while the sector being spared is the one where it's shrinking, so every rate hike shifts the economy further toward the part that makes inflation worse.

In other words, not all spending in the economy is equal. Government spending on flat productivity schemes pumps up the supply of money in the economy, and thus consumer demand, without increasing the supply of stuff. Since money is ultimately traded for stuff, excess money drives down the value of money and pushes up inflation.

Worse, the actually dynamic, competitive, productive part of the Australian economy is being throttled ever tighter between the twisting coils of the vastly overgrown public sector, exploiting its monopoly on force to drive taxes higher and higher. If family finances are tight, you can choose not to take that vacation or purchase a new car, but you can't opt out of taxes! Yet a tax policy that skins the sheep rather than shearing them quickly runs out of sheep, and so it is with the Australian economy and its inevitable slide towards government control.

How Australia pays its way

If productivity is flat, why are Australians still relatively rich, that is to say, as rich as the median American c. 1995?

Mining exports. Iron ore, coal, LNG and gold bring in enough foreign currency to hold the Australian dollar up. A strong dollar makes imports cheap, so real wages stay high even though nobody is producing more per hour. Cheap Chinese consumer goods are a side effect of the exchange rate, not something anyone planned, and they snuff out any hint of dynamism in Australian secondary manufacturing, the one industrial sector which actually generates multiplicative wealth.

Additionally, cheap imports help with goods inflation, but not with services, which is where inflation is stickiest. Services are mostly wages, and productivity in services has barely moved. A haircut costs an hour of the hairdresser's time plus rent, insurance, licensing and compliance, and none of that got any cheaper because a bulk carrier left Port Hedland. Your imported Taiwanese computers and Korean televisions got radically cheaper and better, but anything that involves an Australian service worker in the loop (healthcare, housing, education...) has shot out of reach for the middle class.

The floating dollar is meant to act as a shock absorber. When commodity prices fall, the dollar falls with them, imports get more expensive, and real wages adjust without anyone having to take a pay cut. It worked in 1997, 2008 and 2015. It works a lot less well when there's no tradeable sector left to soak up workers on the way down. The dollar slipped below 70 US cents on the day of the RBA's 3 November hike, and by 19 November it was below 67 cents, its lowest since January, after unemployment jumped to 4.9%. Keep an eye on it.

Chart (open the post to see it) · FRED / OECD series CCUSMA02AUQ618N, inverted to US cents per A$ · quarterly, 1984 Q1–2026 Q3

Blame the capitalists!

The fashionable alternative to arithmetic is blaming profits. A few days after the hike, Paul Bongiorno, a Saturday Paper columnist and 35-year veteran of the Canberra Press Gallery, argued the fix for inflation was an excess-profits tax on big companies. He quoted Greg Jericho, chief economist at the progressive think tank the Australia Institute: "ordinary Australians … are not causing inflation. Inflation is being driven by the cost of fuel … and corporate profits." This doesn't make sense - if corporations are sucking excess cash out of the economy and either saving it, moving it offshore, or investing it in long term capital projects, it would have the effect of reducing inflation by reducing the over-abundance of money.

Bullock dealt with the fuel argument in the same press conference, saying monetary policy "cannot impact global oil prices" and that the hike was meant to "address domestic capacity pressures." The ABS excluded automotive fuel from the September trimmed mean anyway, and the biggest single contributor to inflation was housing, up 5.2%. Housing is getting more expensive because we don't let people build houses, not because of anything happening in the Middle East.

The column's two main examples of greed don't hold up either.

  • Ampol. Its first-half profit rose 376%. Refining margins always blow out during a supply shock, and that margin is the price signal that pulls in fuel cargoes and pays for keeping stocks on hand while the Strait of Hormuz is closed. When margins collapse, Canberra pays Ampol and Viva a Fuel Security Services Payment to keep their two remaining refineries open. If you subsidize the losses and tax the gains, you end up with exactly what Australia has, which is no new refining capacity, ever. Australia spent four decades building eight refineries and less than two decades closing six of them, and having squandered domestic oil self-sufficiency now complains about a lack of refined diesel on the continent(!).

  • The banks. The Australia Institute estimates the big four make about $12,200 in the first year of an average $731,000 owner-occupier loan. By their own method that's a pre-tax margin of about 1.7% after funding costs, running costs and bad debts, up from 1.51% in April as banks pass on rate rises faster than they pay them out to depositors. That hurts borrowers, but it can't be what's driving measured inflation, because mortgage interest hasn't been counted in Australia's CPI since 1998.

This is the same pattern I described in April. The government sets prices across a third of the economy and funds demand that interest rates can't reach. When the resulting inflation shows up in the other two thirds, the proposed fix is to tax whoever is still making money. Each time this happens, another chunk of the economy moves from market prices to prices set by bureaucrats. It is not somehow a moral failing to be good at creating wealth.

Australia's spending plans are built on wildly unrealistic assumptions

The latest Intergenerational Report assumes productivity grows 1.2% a year for the next forty years. Almost every figure in it, from tax receipts to NDIS affordability to debt, is built on that number. The past decade delivered 0.3%. The RBA's own medium-term assumption is 0.7%. Multifactor productivity fell 0.5% in 2024–25.

Over forty years, the difference between 1.2% and 0.3% growth compounds to an economy 43% larger. That's how big the hole is if the assumption is wrong, and nothing in current policy explains why it should be right. As HSBC's chief economist Paul Bloxham put it: "We are not building enough housing. We haven't got enough cheap energy. We haven't got enough infrastructure. How is AI going to solve all those problems?"

This is where inflation and the budget collide. If productivity growth does recover, 3.2% wage growth is compatible with on-target inflation and low unemployment, and the budget math works. If it doesn't, the only thing left to adjust is unemployment, and the RBA will adjust it. The RBA is pricing in reality. As for Treasury, "they're dreaming." Bullock herself admitted the last couple of hikes "haven't even started to flow through yet," and three board members voted to wait. They're right about the lags, but waiting won't change where we end up.

What would work?

If we expect the RBA to control inflation, then the economy has to be re-sensitized to interest rates, which means that it has to actually pay for the cost of borrowing money. Debt transports value through time and space - an extremely useful trick, but it's not free. Fiddling with the interest rates won't actually solve the root problem.

  1. Stop adding rate-proof demand to sectors that are already short of capacity. Any growth in NDIS and care spending above population growth plus inflation pushes up the cash rate for everyone else. Hold spending to that line (or below, since in the real world 16% of 6 year old boys don't need a lifelong disability scheme) and the RBA can cut.

  2. Pay for outcomes, not hours. Under hourly billing, a provider that gets more efficient earns less. Fund outcomes, or pay per participant, and let providers keep the gains.

  3. Build houses. Housing was the biggest single contributor to inflation in the year to September. Zoning reform and replacing stamp duty with (unimproved) land tax are the biggest supply-side levers we have, and both lower the unemployment rate the economy can sustain without inflation. It is literally impossible at this point for Australia to accidentally build too much housing. It could double supply in a decade and there would still not be enough.

  4. Make energy cheap. Fuel drove headline inflation this quarter. An economy that makes its own cheap energy is less exposed to the Strait of Hormuz, and can rebuild industry that doesn't depend on cheap labor. Australia is awash with every natural resource it could possibly want. There is simply no excuse for expensive energy.

  5. Let firms fail and pay workers to move. At full employment, most productivity growth comes from workers moving from weak firms to strong ones. Stop protecting jobs that should disappear. Australia's "job protections" actually discourage hiring, because they push the cost of an employee who isn't working out onto the employer, and through the employer onto every colleague who is pulling their weight. Any business owner knows a bad hire you can't let go is worse than no hire at all, so they hire less, and the people who lose out are the ones who could have been given a chance. There have to actually be consequences for failure.

  6. Try not to penalize success. Radical improvements in productivity are typically driven by new business models and innovative businesses starting new cores of cumulative wealth generation, rather than established businesses spontaneously getting religion on, eg, email. And yet Australian taxation policy could scarcely be better designed to drive Australia's innovators out of business and/or overseas. San Francisco is crawling with tens of thousands of Australians who found barren soil for their ambition in their home country and instead contribute billions of dollars to the US tax base.

Time to wake up

Arithmetic is not on Canberra's side. Wages are growing at 3.2% and productivity at 0.3%, and if productivity doesn't give, jobs will. The math doesn't care about your feelings.

So the next time the RBA promises to bring inflation down while protecting jobs, without anyone in Canberra doing a single thing to raise output per hour, there's only one sensible reply.

Tell him he's dreaming.

Atlantic Tropical Weather Outlook


Atlantic 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Atlantic 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ABNT20 KNHC 220501
TWOAT

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
100 AM EST Sun Nov 22 2026

For the North Atlantic...Caribbean Sea and the Gulf of America:

Offshore of the Southeast U.S. Coast:
A non-tropical gale-force low pressure area centered a few hundred
miles southeast of the North Carolina coast is producing
disorganized showers and thunderstorms primarily along its
associated stationary front. This low is forecast to move northward
into unfavorable environmental conditions, and development into a
tropical or subtropical system is no longer expected.

Regardless of the system's status, this large weather system is
still expected to produce heavy rains, gusty winds, dangerous surf,
rip currents, and coastal flooding along portions of the southeast
and mid-Atlantic U.S. coasts into early next week. Additional
information on this system, including Gale Warnings, can be found in
High Seas Forecasts issued by the National Weather Service, as well
as products issued by your local National Weather Service forecast
office.
* Formation chance through 48 hours...low...near 0 percent.
* Formation chance through 7 days...low...near 0 percent.

&&
High Seas Forecasts issued by the National Weather Service can be
found under AWIPS header NFDHSFAT1, WMO header FZNT01 KWBC, and
online at ocean.weather.gov/shtml/NFDHSFAT1.php

$$
Forecaster Cangialosi


Eastern Pacific Tropical Weather Outlook


Eastern North Pacific 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Eastern North Pacific 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ABPZ20 KNHC 220500
TWOEP

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
1000 PM PST Sat Nov 21 2026

For the eastern and central North Pacific east of 180 longitude:

Tropical cyclone formation is not expected during the next 7 days.

$$
Forecaster Cangialosi


*The Great Enrichment*

The author is my colleague Vincent Geloso and the subtitle is A New History of American Growth and Inequality, 1865-1945.  Here is an excerpt from the very beginning:

…regardless of what improvements you think occurred during the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era, you are underestimating how much improvement there truly was.  From 1870 to the start off World War I, America experienced the fastest and most stunning rise in the quality of life of the downtrodden, the poor, the unskilled, the midskilled, and the average Joe (i.e., the poorest 90% of Americans) ever seen in human history up to that point.  Second, it was the period from World War I to the end of World War II that was marked by slower — though still substantial — gains for people at the bottom of the income ladder.  Third, the improvements in the living standards of the poorest 90 percent of the population were faster than those of the top 10 percent and as fast as those of the top 1 percent from 1870 to 191.  During those four decades, America was a lean and mean egalitarian growth machine.  Fourth, this machine was fueled by America’s exceptionally dynamic market economy, which allowed people to move to pursue better opportunities (either in terms of industries or in terms of geography).  While some state actions did contribute to this machine, market forces own the lion’s share, and, in many cases, they actually made government actions more effective.  Fifth, America developed a welfare state only because, in the aftermath of World War I, the growth machine slowed down.

An excellent and much-needed book, definitely recommended.

The post *The Great Enrichment* appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Emergent Ventures, 60th cohort

Faris Allafi, Abu Dhabi, 13, train AI models.

Eliel Selin, Helsinki, 18, AI agents.

Robert Boswall, London area, energy information for the UK.

Alex Yang, Harvard, genetics for better organ transplants.

Stanislaw Tomaszewski, Warsaw area, AI agents and the organization of trucking.

Jonas Dolezal, London, nuclear fusion.

Shawnak Shivakumar, Stanford, longevity research.

Ruzgar Albayrak, Izmir, 15, on-device AI.

Kaya Bora Hoşgör, Eleutheros Tech, Istanbul, 17, AI companion.

Jude Wallis, Hermosa Beach, 17, build an economics learning site with agents.

Ben Cope, London, superior connectivity for the UK.

Yigit Kiran, Samsun, Turkey, 16, AI agents.

Angadh Nanjangudh, London, science, AI, and space.

The post Emergent Ventures, 60th cohort appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

It’s Golden Dukes Time of Year – Golden Stefaniks?

If you’re a long time TPM Reader you’ll know we have a special place in our hearts for members of Congress who have mystery buyers buy their houses for wildly more than their worth. So we put together this quick explainer about the breaking story about Rep. Elise Stefanik’s mystery home buyer.

Everything is Breaking

The markets are crashing. AI is out. Doomsday prepping is in. Today on TPM’s Friday Live Show (Name TBA), we’re going to talk about the week that was, and what a week it was. So join myself, Nicole LaFond, Hunter Walker, and Derick Dirmaier at 1 p.m. ET on YouTube to discuss.

The Talk Show: ‘A Whoopsie Treason’

Christina Warren returns for a jam-packed show: Jensen Huang-gate at Nvidia, the HomeView, the new iPad Mini, more on the iPhone Duo, and Robert “R-Patz” Pattinson taking the role of James Bond.

Sponsored by:

  • Uncommon Goods: Out of the ordinary gifts, great for the holidays. Save 15% off your next purchase after following that link.
  • WorkOS: Let agents sign up for your app without a browser.
 ★ 

America’s Earliest Globe

Speaking of the Library of Congress, I also enjoyed this post exploring the earliest-dated globe made in the United States. “Created in 1811 by James Wilson, the first commercial globemaker in the United States, it… More

Maps and Copyright

A fascinating post on Worlds Revealed, the Library of Congress map blog, about some of the difficulties the Library faces when navigating map copyright. In particular, how global crises—World War II and the collapse of… More

The Week Observed: November 20, 2026

What City Observatory Did This Week

Portland’s Carmaggedon:  Almost no net change in commute times. Portland’s five-week closure of a portion of Interstate 5 through Portland had very little overall effect on travel times. For Vancouver-to-Portland commuters, average weekday morning (southbound) commutes were about 11 minutes slower, but average evening commutes home were about 10 minutes faster.

ODOT claims that travel times would “double or triple” because of the closure didn’t materialize. The worst-affected travel time between downtown Vancouver and downtown Portland (at about 8 a.m.) increased by 48 percent, from 26 minutes to 37 minutes. Nearly all of this lost time was made up by faster afternoon (northbound) commutes.

Like every other predicted “Carmageddon,” devastation failed to occur because travelers quickly changed their travel times, routes, and modes, or combined trips, reducing travel volumes. The much-reduced northbound peak-hour travel times show the positive effects of travel demand management—our highway system works better if traffic is not allowed to exceed capacity.

Overall, this experiment again confirms that travel demand is highly elastic and responds to available capacity, which is why widening highways never produces sustained improvements in traffic congestion. It’s proof positive that throwing $3.6 billion at widening a mile-and-a-half-long stretch of I-5 near the Rose Quarter is a massive waste of money.

Must Read

The rise of the socialist YIMBY mayor: The November election marked the ascendance of two more left-leaning, pro-housing mayors in the nation’s largest cities: Nithya Raman in Los Angeles and Janeese Lewis-George in Washington, D.C. Writing at The New Republic, Ned Resnikoff says that this wave, following on elections of similarly styled mayors in New York and Seattle, has important implications both for our politics and housing policy. Each of these candidates is unabashedly pro-housing and endorses YIMBY (Yes in My Backyard) policies aiming to make it easier to produce more housing. While that seems like an uncomfortable endorsement of markets to many traditional socialists, Resnikoff points out that the new positioning better reflects the nature of class divides in today’s America:

In this case, the thing that defines one’s class position is not one’s relationship to the means of production but one’s relationship to real estate. YIMBYs are representing an emergent urban tenant class against the entrenched landowner class that has long dominated urban America.

In each of these cities, an important bloc of voters was urban renters, among whose chief concerns was housing unaffordability. Election results cleaved along housing class lines: each of these socialist mayors drew most of their support from renter-dominated neighborhoods; they challenged incumbents who leaned much more heavily on single-family-homeowner-dominated neighborhoods.

The high, high cost of affordable housing.  Portland seems to be close to setting a new record for expensive “affordable” housing: The Oregon Journalism Project reports that state officials just approved financing for a project that will build 57 apartments for a cost of about $56 million, which works out to about $985,000 per apartment. The project started out to be much less costly, but protracted disputes over whether the builder would have to pay prevailing wages led to significant delays (and damage to the partially built project). Despite misgivings, the state board reviewing the project allowed it to move forward:

Council member Ed McNamara, a retired Portland affordable housing developer, registered his objection by abstaining from the vote, but not before saying: “It’s extraordinarily expensive…it’s astronomical.” Another member, Javier Mena, the affordable housing manager for the city of Beaverton, also abstained. “It’s just way overpriced,” Mena said.

At nearly $1 million per apartment—in a neighborhood where existing single-family homes sell for about half that amount—this approach hardly seems like a scalable or fiscally feasible solution to housing affordability.

LA turns down funding for widening freeways–at least for now. Streetsblog LA reports that Metro, LA County’s transit and transportation agency, voted down funding for a series of freeway expansion projects. As Joe Linton explains, Metro’s governing body routinely rubber-stamps freeway projects, and there is a strong ethic of log-rolling. But at this meeting, Long Beach Mayor Rex Richardson questioned  the case for a project in his part of the region, arguing that a wider freeway was unlikely to be the best way to accommodate freight traffic. The proposed funding failed to get the needed four votes to move forward.

Today’s rejection slows a handful of freeway expansions that Metro sought to fast-track. It’s unlikely that this setback will permanently kill any of these widenings. Even when one funding source has been denied, these projects tend to come back over and over, like zombies. It would be surprising if these projects do not return to the board within a couple of months. At that time, the harmful widening may face further scrutiny, as Mayor-elect Nithya Raman replaces outgoing Mayor Karen Bass.

In the News

The Vancouver Columbian quoted Joe Cortright’s testimony to the Joint Oregon-Washington Legislative Committee on the I-5 bridge, calling out the financial risks of moving forward with a single bidder.

The Oregon Capital Chronicle highlighted Kiewit’s history of major cost overruns on highway projects, and quoted City Observatory’s analysis of the high risk of further cost increases on the $15 billion project due to the proposed progressive design build contracting process.

The Oregonian also reported on the same contracting risks.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Friday 20 November 1663

Up, and as soon as I could to my Lord Sandwich’s lodgings, but he was gone out before, and so I am defeated of my expectation of being eased one way or other in the business of my Lord. But I went up to Mr. Howe, who I saw this day the first time in a periwigg, which becomes him very well, and discoursed with him. He tells me that my Lord is of a sudden much changed, and he do believe that he do take my letter well. However, we do both bless God that it hath so good an effect upon him. Thence I home again, calling at the Wardrobe, where I found my Lord, but so busy with Mr. Townsend making up accounts there that I was unwilling to trouble him, and so went away. By and by to the Exchange, and there met by agreement Mr. Howe, and took him with a barrel of oysters home to dinner, where we were very merry, and indeed I observe him to be a very hopeful young man, but only a little conceited.

After dinner I took him and my wife, and setting her in Covent Garden at her mother’s, he and I to my Lord’s, and thence I with Mr. Moore to White Hall, there the King and Council being close, and I thinking it an improper place to meet my Lord first upon the business; I took coach, and calling my wife went home, setting Mr. Moore down by the way, and having been late at the office alone looking over some plates of the Northern seas, the White seas, and Archangell river, I went home, and, after supper, to bed.

My wife tells me that she and her brother have had a great falling out to-night, he taking upon him to challenge great obligation upon her, and taxing her for not being so as she ought to be to her friends, and that she can do more with me than she pretends, and I know not what, but God be thanked she cannot.

A great talke there is today of a crush between some of the Fanatiques up in arms, and the King’s men in the North; but whether true I know not yet.

Read the annotations

Opening a 400-Year-Old Cryptex

Researchers used CT scanning technology to recover the code and open a 400-year-old cryptex padlock.

You can buy a USB-drive cryptex.

Collections: On the ‘Sullan Republic’

This week, we’re going to talk about the version of the Roman Republic created by the murderous dictator Lucius Cornelius Sulla in the late-80s B.C., what I am going to term here the ‘Sullan Republic.’ In particular, I want to lay out the nature of that political order, stressing the important ways in which it was not a continuation of the Roman Republic which had existed from 509 to 88 B.C. (or even the ‘republic of the nobiles‘ which had existed from c. 300 to 88) but in many ways a new thing. Viewed in that context, the fact that it failed utterly in just three decades speaks to how much less capable constructed it was than the earlier Roman political orders.

I think this is worth focusing on for two reasons. The first is simply that this distinction is often lost on students and enthusiasts. We have so much more evidence (as recently discussed!) for the Late Republic and specifically for the period of the ‘Sullan Republic’ that it tends to drown out everything else: Cicero’s republic gets understandably processed as the res publica as if it was the only one and that things had always worked that way.

Second, you may notice that the title structure for this post mirrors my retrospectives on Cleopatra VII and Alexander III. That is intentional: this is, in effect, my commentary on Sulla himself. My reasoning here is straight forward: almost any attempt to rehabilitate Sulla proceeds from his effort to ‘restore’ or ‘save’ the Roman Republic. It observes that Sulla seems to have been a sincere patriot who really believed in the republic (in an oligarchic, reactionary form) and then posits that he set out to ‘save’ the Republic and in some level did so. The reason for this approach is equally straight-forward: there is little else to defend in the man. There is no hint of the military virtuoso of a Caesar or Alexander in Sulla; he was certainly a very competent general, to be sure, but few of his military achievements were spectacular.1 In his conduct, there is nothing of the occasional glimpse of Alexander’s chivalry or Caesar’s mercy or even Octavian’s later-in-life forbearance – Sulla was cruel, ruthless and rapacious with some consistency.

So any defense of Sulla’s life and methods has to be predicated on the idea that he ‘saved the republic’ or some such thing. And I argue here that he did no such thing; rather than save the republic as it had been, he buried it (already slain by others) and built a new, inferior version atop its grave. That inferior version began falling apart almost immediately and wholly decomposed in 49, all within a single generation. Sulla thus ought to be judged a fairly comprehensive failure – all of his butchery and greed neither saved nor conserved anything and instead if anything further weakened what was left of Rome’s republican traditions.

But first, if you like what you are reading here, please share it, as I rely on word of mouth to reach new readers. If you really like it, you can support me, my academic work and my public writing, including this project on Patreon! If you want updates whenever a new post appears or want to hear my more bite-sized musings on history, security affairs and current events, you can follow me on Bluesky (@bretdevereaux.bsky.social). I am also active on Threads (bretdevereaux) and maintain a de minimis presence on Twitter (@bretdevereaux).

(Bibliography note: This can be a fairly short one – I am for the most part here following H.I. Flower, Roman Republics (2010) in the interpretation of the Sullan Republic, which Flower terms ‘Republic 6’ and which runs notionally to at least 60. There is more beyond this, such as A. Lintott, The Constitution of the Roman Republic (1999) and E. Gruen, The Last Generation of the Roman Republic (1995), and A. Keaveney, The Army in the Roman Revolution (2007), but for the most part one may find the relevant works in Flower’s bibliography. For the reader looking to get a grasp on the wider sequence of events in this period, H.H. Scullard, From the Gracchi to Nero (1959) remains a capable narrative, although I will be pushing back on its interpretation of Sulla as presenting mere ‘reforms’ that ‘restored’ elements of the pre-91 republic; more recent and also very solid is the aforementioned E. Gruen, The Last Generation of the Roman Republic (1995). Finally, this entire topic is unavoidably cast in the very long shadow of R. Syme, The Roman Revolution (1939), although it spares just a few pages for Sulla – but here I am also at variance with Syme’s review that presents Sulla’s bloodstained dictatorship as largely just reaffirming the Roman oligarchy that was already failing.)

The Situation

It is worth laying the groundwork here for the situation that Sulla and the Roman people were in by the period 83-81 when Sulla is in a position to impose his new republic. There is a tendency for this period to get somewhat limited mention in world history courses (often just treated as ‘Marius and Sulla’ as if they were dueling dynasts in the same way that Caesar and Pompey and Octavian and Antonius were) and thus often a failure to recognize how nearly total a break from what came before this moment was.

First we should note that in the run up to the explosion of civil war in 91 (note 91, not 88), there had been tremors. Our sources – most notably Appian – tend to begin their understanding of this period with the tribunates of Tiberius (133) and Gaius (123, 122) Gracchus and their violent ends. We’ve already discussed these, so no need to belabor the point. Modern historians often reach back a little further, recognizing in the irregular career of P. Cornelius Scipio Aemilianus (cos. 147, 134) many of the patterns – a general popular enough to buck the Senate, taking volunteers, holding office in defiance of the mos maiorum and/or the law – that would bear such poisonous fruit later. But Scipio Aemilianus never makes a disruptive play for power and dies in any event in 129, so if he posed any danger, it passed.

The boiling political issue from 122 to 91 was the question of citizenship for the socii. We’ve discussed this institution before – the subordinated communities of Italy got a ‘deal’ from Rome (which the Romans euphemistically referred to as an alliance) in which the socii were bound to Rome and required to supply troops to Roman armies but in exchange got protection from Rome, a (fairly ample) share in the loot of Roman conquests and no Roman taxes levied on them. This had been a good deal for a long time, but Roman overseas conquests altered the balance: increasingly Rome was getting not loot but tax revenue (of which the socii had no share) from its conquests and using those revenues – after the Gracchi – to pay for benefits (land distribution, grain distribution) which were restricted to Roman citizens. The balance of the deal had shifted and of course behind this was the understandable desire by the socii who had fought for Rome’s new empire for generations to share in legal equality at the top of it.

Social Classes in the Roman Republic. The left side of the diagram shows Roman citizen communities, the right side the communities of the socii.

The response across Italy was clearly split – some socii ‘wanted in’ (wanted citizenship) and some ‘wanted out’ (wanted to dismantle Rome’s imperial system over Italy). From 123 to 91, we see repeated attempts to resolve this problem politically: various figures (e.g. Marcus Fulvius Flaccus (in 125), Gaius Gracchus (in 122), L. Appuleius Saturninus (in 100), and Marcus Livius Drusus (in 91)) had tried to advance various schemes to resolve this issue by expanding – to a greater or lesser degree – Roman citizenship in Italy. These efforts had failed for a few reasons: immediately, the Roman voters were mostly sour on these plans, recognizing that expanding citizenship would dilute their votes and share of the revenues of empire. Behind that, I think, it seems clear that while the Roman political elite increasingly understood this needed to be done, whoever did it would suddenly have the gratitude (and clientage) of millions of new citizens and thus be an unmatched political powerhouse – so this needed to get done but no one could afford to let their political opponents be the ones to do it. As a result, the Senate drag their feet on the issue rather than – as they had with hard geostrategic choices in the fourth and third centuries – presenting a united front to the Roman people.

The discontent of the socii after repeated failed efforts then boils over in 91, leading to the Social War (91-88). This is very important because it creates the ‘state of exception’ in which all of the chaos happens. The wild events of 88 (which set the stage for everything else) are, I think, impossible to understand except that they are occurring already in the context of a huge rupture of norms and traditions in which the same state is being shaken so hard it is experiencing a kind of political liquefaction.

Via Wikipedia, a map of Roman Italy c. 100, with the territory of the socii marked in shades of red.

In the event, the Roman Senate finally does the obvious thing in response to the mass rebellion of the socii: it offers citizenship to the socii if they will lay down arms. That works to separate the ‘hard cases’ (most notably the Samnites) who ‘wanted out’ from the ones that mostly ‘wanted in’ and allows Rome to win the war. But it creates a huge secondary question concerning on what terms the new citizens will be enrolled and that furthers the state of exception here: now not only is there an ongoing civil war but also we’re adding a huge number of new citizens to the Republic.

That leads to the events of 88. P. Sulpicius Rufus, an ambitious tribune (politically somewhat cornered by being in no small amount of debt) pivoted to trying to alter the distribution of the socii in Rome’s voting tribes to be more equal (and thus swamp existing Roman voters) and enlisted the aging Gaius Marius to help him. Marius’ price was one last chance in the saddle – command of an army to fight Mithridates VI of Pontus who had tried to pry Rome out of the Aegean while the Romans were distracted with the socii (the command had been delegated to Sulla, as something of a reward for his hard fighting in Italy, itself an echo of Marius’ own bad precedent from 107 to 100). Blocked legally, Marius and Sulpicius worked up a riot (including some of Marius’ veterans) and thereby pushed through a law giving Marius his command and redistributing the Italians; Sulla, who was consul in 88 had been in Rome to veto the proposal and was forced to flee the city by the mob violence.

Sulla then famously marches his army on Rome. Sulla presumably understood himself to be acting, as the consul, to restore order. His soldiers – who had been fighting under him for at least two years in the Social War – seem to have had economic motivations: Marius was likely to enlist his own army if he went East and this would mean the rich plunder of a war in Greece would go to others. Sulla’s officers nearly all deserted him, recognizing that Sulla’s action in turning his army on Rome was unconscionable. In the event, Marius and his supporters fled; Sulla outlawed 12 of them, but only Sulpicius Rufus was caught and killed. Sulla then reversed Sulpicius’ acts before departing for the East.

Once Sulla and his army were gone, Marius and his partisans (most notably L. Cornelius Cinna, consul for 87, who seems to have been elected because he did not appear to have been a partisan of either Marius or Sulla, but who hopped onto Marius’ side for political expediency once elected; this faction is later led by Gnaeus Papirius Carbo) swooped back into Rome and essentially set up what we ought best to describe as a military junta of sorts which governs the city from 87 to 83. They murdered at least a hundred of their political opponents and at this point (if not earlier), we can say the res publica is no longer functioning.

Via Wikipedia, a coin of Sulla’s, minted in 82, depicting Roma on the obverse and Sulla in a triumphal chariot (for his triumph over Mithridates) on the reverse.

Sulla sweeps back from the East in 83, defeating the Marians at the Battle of the Colline Gate (in late 82). Sulla then has himself declared dictator rei publicae constituendae causa (“for reforming the constitution of the Republic”) in a matter that broke wholly with the traditional limits on dictators’ powers, scope and terms of office. In practice, Sulla had replaced the Marian military junta of Cinna and Carbo with his own. I stress this point because understanding the republic Sulla is about to create requires understanding just how substantial the rupture of the republic as it had been was.

Sulla secured his rule through a program of mass political violence. At the top of this program were the proscriptions, a published list of 520 of Sulla’s political enemies from the upper-classes who were to be made outlaws, killed if they could be captured and their property seized. The list included every Roman elected to office between 87 and 82 who had not defected to Sulla. Thus in practice between the Marians and Sulla himself, an entire generation of political talent in the Roman Republic had been wiped out. Sulla also butchered the prisoners he took in his civil war. The Samnites (the Oscan-speaking peoples who inhabited the uplands of southern Italy) were especially singled out for reprisals and seems to have perpetrated something close to a genocide against them (e.g. Strabo 5.4.249). That is not to say Sulla’s civil war was over at this point – a Marian-faction general, Quintus Sertorius, had a republic-in-exile in Spain that wouldn’t be crushed until 72, while civil war within Sulla’s coalition was to briefly break out in 78, immediately after Sulla’s death with Marcus Aemilius Lepidus (the elder, cos. 78)’s failed coup attempt.

It is in this context, with a knife to the throat of what was left of the Senate and the res publica, that Sulla set about his reforms.

The Reforms and Their Flaws

In getting a sense of how substantial Sulla’s departure from the Roman system of the Middle Republic was, it may help to read up on its overall structure. While Sulla’s ‘reforms’ are often presented as a restoration of the old Roman ‘oligarchy,’ in practice they represented a novel form of republican governance. In practice, we can pull out into a half-dozen major alterations Sulla made to the Roman political order, most of which were bad ideas which were either swiftly repealed or contributed meaningfully to the collapse of republican governance into the inferno of civil war in 49; the odd remainders were just laws that failed to understand that inscribing a norm into written law did not make it self-enforcing. The main of these were (grouped only by expedience for discussion):

  • Perhaps most dramatically, crippling the tribunate.
  • Formalizing the cursus honorum, specifying a rigid route to the Roman political career
  • Enlarging the Senate and increasing the number of quaestors and praetors
  • Setting formal rules for Roman provincial governors/commanders, whose orders are set by the Senate and who are required to remain in their geographically defined provinces
  • Setting the juries of the permanent jury courts to consist of senators, rather than members of the equites more broadly.
  • Finally, part of the pattern set by Sulla – though not, perhaps, in law – was of having more praetors and both consuls stay in Rome for most (if not all) of their year in elected office

In any event, it is worth noting that Sulla implements his reforms in 82 and 81, retires from public life in 80 and dies of old age in 78, by which point his system is already beginning to unravel (the above-mentioned coup attempt by Lepidus).

The first pair is formalizing the cursus honorum and crippling the tribunate, which have in common that they are both effectively undone by the end of 70 BC. On the first, Sulla crippled the tribunate, removing the ability of the tribunes to put legislation to the concilium plebis, their ability to obstruct other magistrates were curtailed and they were barred from seeking further office, making the tribunate a dead-end office and thus unattractive for any Roman with political ambitions. This was, by all indications, very unpopular (it represented a reversal of one of the earliest gains by the Plebians in the Struggle of the Orders) and also posed a legislative problem, since the tribunes were normally at the heart of a lot of regular law-making. These changes last about a decade before being repealed by Sulla’s two lieutenants, Gnaeus Pompeius (Pompey) and Marcus Licinius Crassus when they jointly held the consulship in 70.

The customary cursus honorum as it stood through the second century BC

On the latter, Sulla had specified a rigid career path for holding Roman office, which specified terms as pro-magistrates when leaving office, a compulsory ten-year delay before seeking any office for a second time (which really only matters for the consulship), and age requirements for these offices. Now in theory these laws remained on the books through the end of the Republic. In practice the whole point of laws like this were not to govern the careers of typical Roman politicians – whose careers had followed the customary cursus honorum in any case – but to restrain exceptional politicians and in this they were an utter failure as the very next exceptional politician, Gnaeus Pompeius – again, one of Sulla’s lieutenants, just 23 when he rushed to Sulla’s side with a legion he raised himself as a private citizen – blew through all of these rules.

Sulla’s revised cursus honorum, with the plebian tribune effectively removed and the number of quaestors and praetors increased.

Under Sulla’s rules, Roman politicians were supposed to move through the offices in sequence and serve as pro-magistrates after holding the relevant officers – pro-praetor after being praetor, pro-consul after being consul. Pompey is already serving illegally in a pro-praetorian command (he has never been and will never be a praetor) under Sulla and is appointed to another illegal pro-praetorian command against Lepidus in 78, when he is 28 years old – eleven years too young to even be a praetor. And while notionally the purpose of the ‘ten year gap’ rule between office-holding was to prevent the kind of careers Sulla and Marius had – continuously in command year after year – Pompey bounces from one pro-praetorian command to another basically non-stop until he wins the consulship in 70.

Pompey’s consulship in 70 was illegal under Sulla’s fancy new written rules in multiple ways! First, Pompey has not followed the rigid plan of the cursus honorum; he hasn’t skipped one step, he has skipped all of them, having never actually held elected office before. He is also too young (36 when he should be 42) and he’s held back to back military commands basically continuously through the 70s and is going to straight into another set of back-to-back commands from 67 to 62. It did not particularly matter if Sulla’s new laws could contain the ambitions of men like – insert the sound of me drawing from a hat here – Lucius Octavius (cos. 75, d. 74); its purpose was to contain the ambitions of men like Marius and Sulla and the very next such man blew through it like paper, in part (as we’ll come to) due to weaknesses created by the rest of Sulla’s system.

Next we have the core of Sulla’s changes, aimed at placing the Senate clearly at the core of the Roman system. Sulla expands the Senate from 300 members to 600, while also substantially increasing the number of lower offices that fed into it: going from just eight quaestors to twenty and from six praetors to eight. The idea seems to have been that a larger Senate would have been more powerful as the collective influence of aristocratic men in it. In practice, the effort dilutes the Senate. The ranks of the Senate must already have been badly thinned from both Marian and then Sullan purges and Sulla’s rapid expansion of the Senate must thus have pulled in large numbers of relatively mediocre political figures. That wouldn’t change as time went on: with the ratio of quaestors to praetors going from 4:3 to 5:2, a lot more senators in the new Senate would have been junior men of insignificant accomplishments with no real hope of rising to higher office. The result was an increasingly two-tier Senate larded up with back-benchers whose presence added functionally nothing to the influence of the body.

A chart of the composition of the Roman Senate during the second century, where you can see the core groups, with consulars representing a little over 10% of the body and current/former praetors representing another 25%, giving experienced magistrates a very strong presence in the body.

Worse yet, increasing the number of quaestors and praetors made the ‘elimination contest’ of Roman politics sharper meaning, almost inevitably, that the ‘log jam’ for ambitious men seeking to earn the consulship would get worse, a problem that explodes in 63 with Catiline’s conspiracy (Catiline had tried to run in 66, been blocked from doing so and then had run for and failed to win the consulship in 64 and 63 and lost both times).

A chart of Sulla’s expanded Senate, showing that the number of men eligible to hold commands has not massively increased, but there is a huge expansion in the number of back-benchers. Consulars now make up only 6% of the body and former/current praetors just 17%. The role of the censors in selecting the most junior senators is largely obviating – the large number of quaestors now produce enough men to fill the benches, albeit one imagines of limited quality.
Note that this is a ‘steady state’ model, but for the first thirty years, the number of consulars and former praetors will have been lower and the back benches will have been filled with cronies selected by Sulla for personal loyalty. The system would only have stabilized into this form about thirty-years on from Sulla’s dictatorship as the first batch of post-Sullan quaestors neared their average life expectancy. Notably, thirty years on from the first open elections post-Sulla would have been 48, the year after the civil wars reignited, obliterating this system – so it never truly reached ‘steady state’ operation.

Going along with this were Sulla’s setting formal rules for provincial governors (that is, at this point, pro-magistrates) and shifting the permanent jury courts – which mostly judged political crimes like official corruption or political violence – to have purely senatorial juries. The idea is that there are now rules for the conduct of pro-magistrates in the provinces (no more freelancing!) and that senatorial juries will now stand in judgement of the conduct of senators in the provinces. Previously, the juries of these courts had been composed in whole or in part (their composition had been a political football kicked back and forth for a while) of equites – wealthy Romans who hadn’t gone into politics – rather than senators.

Now, we should be clear on something: our sources for these events mostly write later, in the imperial period, when the senatorial class was a distinct, defined group separate from the equites and they often retroject this clean division back on to the republic. But in fact, in the period of the republic, senators were equites too, as there was no ordo senatorius yet. So the shift here is from “the conduct of Roman politicians will be judged by other Roman aristocrats” to “the conduct of Roman politicians will be judged by other Roman politicians.” Honestly, to look at what these courts do on a regular basis, it’s not actually clear to me at all that this changed very much.

But the idea here is clear: the Senate is bigger (and thus, notionally, more powerful) and is given formal powers (through the new laws and juries) to police the actions of the pro-magistrates it appoints. That small army of back-bencher senators thus are primarily there to sit on juries judging Roman provincial pro-magistrates. What needs stressing here, however is that this is a formalization of power the Senate already had in practice. The Senate had been informally giving command directives to Roman commanders in the field since at least the late 300s if not earlier. The Senate absolutely dominates theater-level Roman strategy and the distribution of resources across Rome’s typically-multiple-fronts from 218 onward.2 In that period, the Senate was not afraid to occasionally censure commanders who got out of line and such senatorial rebukes could open the door wide for action in the courts or bring political careers to a sudden end.

The problem that had emerged, visible with Scipio Aemilianus, Gaius Marius and Sulla himself, was commanders becoming ‘too big’ as political figures – having too much popularity or influence – for the Senate to discipline them. That problem would, of course, remain even if the Senate was given more formal means for discipline.

And that problem was made worse by the change in consular habits namely the consuls of the year spending most if not all of the year in Rome rather than abroad in their provinces. Now, this is a point of some dispute – most scholars continue to follow Theodor Mommsen in assuming there was an (otherwise unattested) lex Cornelia de provinciis ordinandis which set a rule requiring the consuls to remain in Rome.3 The scholarly problem, as noted by several scholars over the years, most recently by Francisco Pina Polo in The Consul at Rome (2011), is that there’s no evidence of such a law, no ancient source reports it and the consuls don’t always seem to follow this rule in any event.4

What we do know is that it seems that after Sulla the consuls do develop a pattern of staying in Rome for most of their year in office: most seem to have remained for the whole year and some (about a third) departed Rome for assigned provinces (assigned for the next year) early. But there clearly an established expectation post-80 that the primary duties of both consuls would be in Rome. When consuls are given military forces, it is almost invariably to deal with military threats in Italy, like Lepidus’ rebellion in 78, Spartacus’ revolt in 73 or Catiline’s conspiracy in 63. So while we can’t say that Sulla passed a law formalizing this expectation, there is clearly an expectation here that is new – as recently as the last decade of the 100s, it went without saying that the commanders for Rome’s most important in any given year would generally be be the consuls elected for that year.

This change in practice meant, first and foremost, that a lot more of Rome’s magistrates would be in the city of Rome at any given time. And certainly the strong impression is that this creates a lot more political friction in Rome. Under the previous system, where two-thirds of the praetors and one or even both consuls were usually out of the city, the magistrates were operating essentially alone in their own spheres of responsibility (the coordination being provided by the Senate informally through its auctoritas), so while conflicts could happen, they certainly seem less frequent. Sulla’s system certainly seems to make these problems a lot more common and we run into ‘the consuls can’t agree’ problems almost immediately (Lepidus and his colleague, Q. Lutatius Catulus, are quarreling badly in 78 in the run up to Lepidus’ rebellion).

That also meant that most of Rome’s armies would be commanded by pro-magistrates rather than current, elected magistrates. Now we are never given the reasoning for this change, but it is often suggested that it was to ensure the consuls were in Rome to protect the city and maintain order. If that was the intent, it was a very foolish idea: what power would the consuls have to wield against rogue generals when – because Italy was rarely the focus of Roman military activity – they would almost invariably have few troops at their disposal? Sulla himself ought to have known this, having been – as consul in 88! – chased out of Rome by Sulpicius Rufus’ mob when he tried to use his legal, consular powers.

But pro-magistrate command created its own problems: elected offices were strictly for one year and they thus rotated regularly. But pro-magistracies had flexible duration and had been like that for some time, to enable to Senate to keep a commander mid-campaign in the field across campaigning seasons. Perhaps notionally Sulla’s notion was that by modestly increasing the number of praetors there would be enough candidates to rotate pro-magistracies annually, but that not only doesn’t happen, Sulla is instrumental in setting the first instance where it doesn’t happen, which is – again – Gnaeus Pompey.

The combined effect of these changes was to create a new version of the Roman republic, rather than reaffirming or trying to reinforce an old one. Perhaps most notably, Sulla efforts here to expand the Senate’s reach into realms where its influence had previously been limited by more clearly directing legislation to run through it and trying to make magistrates more responsible to it. He also seems to be trying to shift the system of official accountability from the tribunate, which he clearly despises, to the Senate.

To be fair to Sulla’s reforms for a moment, it was clear by this point that the powers of the tribunate had become a problem – every political crisis in the last several decades had involved an ambitious tribune (Tiberius Gracchus in 133, Gaius Gracchus in 122, Lucius Appuleius Saturninus in 100, Marcus Livius Drusus in 91, Publius Sulpicius Rufus in 88). But Sulla’s solution was to attempt to close the valve on one of the major feedback mechanisms the Roman people had to register frustration with the aristocracy. I would go so far as to say that Sulla is not – contra Syme – reinforcing or reestablishing a Roman oligarchy, but creating one.

And that oligarchy turned out to be unstable and fragile.

Things Fall Apart

Perhaps the single most famous modern scholarly verdict on Sulla is Syme’s, “But even Sulla could not abolish his own example and preclude a successor to his domination.”5

And that is quite clearly correct but I also think substantially incomplete. It is true that Sulla’s example would go on to haunt the remains of the republic, with one ambitious general after another attempting to repeat his feat of using their army to dominate the republic. One of the oddest elements of this sort of imitatio Sullae is oddly geographic: one Roman civil war general after another will attempt to repeat Sulla’s very specific ‘go East, get money, enrich the army, swing back to Italy’ sequence, which becomes very visible because it never works again but they keep doing it.6 Julius Caesar’s resort to the idea of the dictatorship – once again, as with Sulla, without the real form of it – also goes into this category.

But what I think is more striking is that Sulla does almost nothing actually effective to make his example harder to imitate. The one major thing he seems to have done is that he makes it illegal to actually swing back to Italy with your army (confining pro-magistrates to their provinces), but of course by the time a pro-magistrate is contemplating bringing their army to Italy, the horses are out of the barn and legally shutting the door doesn’t mean much.

It is always risky to psychologize any kind of historical figure, especially one like Sulla where we do not have any of his own speeches or writing and no real contemporary information, but one wonders – given the pattern of his actions and reforms – if Sulla was incapable of recognizing that he, himself, represented part of the problem in the republic and so was equally incapable of addressing any of the weaknesses he exploited. Because if he exploited them – and he is axiomatically good – then how can those weaknesses be bad?

Thus, as noted above, the problem with individuals holding repeated commands, chaining together years in office with pro-magistrate commands to more or less never be a private citizen, is not meaningfully addressed even though this was crucial to how both Marius and Sulla became threats to the res publica.

Worse yet, the overall effect of Sulla’s changes to the Senate was to make them more reliant on these sorts of men, rather than less. Sure, there were a lot more senators – twice as many – but the rate at which the system produces men qualified to handle provincial commands had only gone from 8 (6 praetors, 2 consuls) to 10 (8 praetors, 2 consuls), but of course with the consuls and praetors of the year removed.

In a ‘steady state’ system, the old 300-person Roman Senate would have had about 35 consulars and about 75 former/current praetors at any given time (taking life expectancy into account), out of that body of 300. Sulla’s new Senate has 600 members, but is still going to only have about 35 consulars and roughly 95 current and former praetors in any given year, but of course you’ve also lost two consuls and four praetors being regularly available for overseas commands, so in practice you’ve doubled the Senate, but ‘eligible provincial commanders’ has gone from ~110 to ~125. That is simply not a meaningful increase in the number of available commanders.

Worse yet, the Senate isn’t in a steady-state. It is instead recovering from the significant butchering by the Marians and then the far more substantial butchering by Sulla. And unlike in the Second Punic War – where Roman losses had depleted the Senate – there’s no sense Sulla refilled its membership from more junior men who had proved themselves in battle. He’s refilled it with his cronies, wherever he can find them, while rendering the family of the proscribed ineligible. So the overall level of talent here has gone down, but also it is going to take years – probably decades – for this new Senate to work its way back up to being able to marshal the same number of eligible commanders as the Senate might have done back in 197 when there were just four permanent Roman provinces. Whereas under Sulla there are now eight and by 63 there will be twelve.

So this new, weakened Senate ends up turning to the same small handful of ambitious military men over and over again: Lucius Licinius Lucullus, Pompey, Crassus and eventually, Caesar. Whereas Scipio Aemilianus and Gaius Marius had been aberrations, after Sulla, these sorts of careers become the rule and both the Senate and Roman voters (some of these exceptional commands are conferred by law) get pretty accustomed to responding to any real military difficulty with these longer, extraordinary commands. As a result, the norms about rotating commanders regularly – which Sulla has done nothing to reinforce – weaken further.

Even more notably unresolved was the ability of a general to secure their loyalty of their army through promises of wealth and land. Securing land for veteran soldiers had been a key issue in the crisis of 100 (Saturninus and Marius) and – again, if our sources are to be believed – the potential wealth to be gained in a war in the East was the major inducement Sulla used to get his army to march on Rome in 88 and was crucial to securing their loyalty to do the same in 83. That problem is not made any better by reducing the voice of the common Roman citizenry – who, you will recall, still filled the ranks of the army – in the actual running of the republic, thus potentially detaching them further from a government that now really was more of an oligarchy of the upper-classes.

What was needed was something to realign the interests of the soldiers with that of the state, which probably meant more democratic feedback rather than less, but equally taking the rewards of service largely out of the hands of their generals. We’ll see Augustus do just this, regularizing army pay and establishing a treasury to pay out standard retirement bonuses, thus realigning the state (in the form of the emperor) with the loyalty and self-interest of the soldiery. There’s no reason this couldn’t have been done earlier, with a regular colonial settlement program or cash bonuses at campaign’s end, funded from Roman revenues, administered by junior officials (the quaestors, presumably) at the direction of the Senate on a regular (rather than general-specific) basis, thereby realigning the loyalty of the soldiers with the state (in the form of the Senate and assemblies). But this too isn’t done.

The result is that Sulla not only is incapable of abolishing his own example, he leaves the door wide open for whoever would follow.

We’ve alluded to the travails of this Sullan Republic already, but a brief narrative is useful here.

Sulla retires in 80 but exerts a strong influence on the elections for 79, so 78 is the first year with reasonably free elections. Marcus Aemilius Lepidus (cos 78, not the triumvir) wins the elections and then leads a rebellion from Etruria – the Etruscans had largely sided against Sulla and he had punished them by taking a bunch of their land to settle his veterans, which produced continued unrest which will smolder into the 60s BC. Lepidus is defeated but ‘the new republic has its first attempted self-coup two years in’ was hardly a good omen.

Gnaeus Pompeius had been part of Sulla’s army – raising a legion as a private citizen, for which Sulla rewarded rather than punished him – in 83. Sulla kept him in command through 80, refusing to disband his army until Sulla gave him a triumph, which Sulla did, rather than punish him. Pompey was then given another illegal pro-praetorian command (against Lepidus) in 78, before being given another illegal pro-praetorian command (against the Marian dead-ender Sertorius) in 77 which Pompey kept until 72. On his return to Italy in 71, he was given another illegal pro-praetorian command in 71 (against Spartacus) before being illegally elected consul for the year 70 (with Crassus), after which he was given an can-you-believe-it-actually-legal-this-time pro-consular command against the pirates in 67, extended to allow him to deal with Mithridates. Pompey exceeded his mandate and remained in the East until 62 to comprehensively reorganize Roman affairs there, without consulting the Senate.

Meanwhile, the log-jam at the consulship and smoldering unrest in Etruria enabled Catiline’s attempted coup in 63, put down by the consuls of that year, Marcus Tullius Cicero and Gaius Antonius Hybrida. Pompey, returning in 62 and unable to get the land he promised his soldiers (it was being blocked in the Senate) forms the First Triumvirate in 60 with Julius Caesar and Crassus, leading to Caesar being consul in 59 and then holding a continuous, unbroken command in Gaul from 58 to 49 at which point, having had nine years to secure the loyalty of his army, he turned it against the state, functionally extinguishing the republic and reigniting the civil wars which would continue non-stop for the next eighteen years.

Assessing Sulla

It is relevant to begin any assessment of Lucius Cornelius Sulla with some acknowledgement that he was essentially handed difficult times not of his own creation. The actions of the ‘Marians’ – Marius himself, Sulpicius Rufus, Cinna and Carbo – largely created the difficult conditions that Sulla was effectively forced to respond to. I think it is worth keeping in mind that Sulla’s first alternative in both 88 and 83 was “do nothing and let these other guys rule Rome through violence.” Not an attractive alternative.

That said.

First, it should not go unsaid: Sulla was a vengeful, brutal, rapacious man. Our accounts of him are full to the brim of shocking moments: he burned and plundered Athens (Plut. Sull. 14), brutally carved his way across Boeotia, destroying at least three poleis (Plut. Sull. 26; Anthedon, Larymna and Halae), largely let his actual enemy Mithridates off the hook for political expediency while plundering Greece also for political expediency. Returning to Rome he pardoned effectively no one, murdering thousands of his political opponents (Plut. Sull. 31, “murders without number or limit filled the city”), inflicting something approaching genocide on the Samnites, enriching himself and his cronies on their property and settling his own veterans in a manner sufficiently disruptive and rapacious that their presence continued to stir up trouble – particularly in Etruria – two decades later.

A coin issued by Quintus Pompeius Rufus, Sulla’s grandson (through his daughter, Cornelia Sulla), with Sulla on the obverse. The reverse features Q. Pompeius Rufus’ other grandfather, also a Quintus Pompeius Rufus, who was Sulla’s co-consul in 88.

There is a reason that the ancient source tradition is universally hostile to this guy. Even men of his broad political leanings and faction – Cicero comes to mind – do not defend him.

And there is a certain sort of fellow who looks at all of that and thinks that it is smart and hard-nosed and ‘based,’ but the brutal truth of it is that all of the butchery and slaughter and greed was for nothing and no one. It was all piled into creating a new political system so weak and fragile that it began dying in its own crib. Indeed, the river of blood which created Sulla’s political order is part of what weakened it, both in that it robbed the Senate of the talent it needed to function properly but it also very clearly robbed this new beginning of the legitimacy it needed to establish itself. Even beyond that, the political order that Sulla envisaged was clearly unworkable, in part because of Sulla’s evident inability to address the problems that led to Sulla himself.

On some level, as Syme says, Sulla could not abolish his example but it also matters here that he doesn’t seem to have cared to do so either. I’ll be honest, combined with the rest of the personality, I find this suggestive of the sort of fellow so incandescently convinced of his rightness that he could not bring himself to close the door on his own methods, to the ruin of his new republic.

It is a verdict which leaves effectively nothing to salvage in the man: a solidly workmanlike general of the sort that the Roman Republic had churned out reliably in batches since at least the 340s, whose cruel and vindictive streak led him to further weaken the republic he very clearly believed in and wished to save. Sulla exists in our ancient sources largely as a negative more example, as a cautionary tale.

And while you all know I love caveating and complicating our ancient sources, here I think their verdict is broadly correct: Sulla was a monster and there are no real grounds for his rehabilitation.

Friday Squid Blogging: The Largest Squid Ever Filmed

This is the story of the largest squid ever filmed, in December 2006 near Japan’s Ogasawara Islands.

As usual, you can also use this squid post to talk about the security stories in the news that I haven’t covered.

Blog moderation policy.

Links 11/20/26

Links for you. Science:

Where Have All The Spiny Oysters Gone?
How Kennedy let measles run wild in America
It’s official: Measles is endemic again in the US
Neil the Seal Management Plan (lmfao)
Eagles Are Killing Baboons the Size of Our Early Ancestors. That Wasn’t Supposed to Be Possible
Analysis finds no definitive link between hantavirus that caused cruise ship outbreak and outbreak strain in Argentina
A new drug could be the beginning of the end for sleeping sickness

Other:

Jeffries endorses lowering Medicare age, adding benefits and universal coverage for kids
Trauma, Not Dignity: What Federal Employees Experienced with the “Voluntary” Resignation Program (note the importance of working from home, at least part time)
The Revenge of the Girls Under the Bleachers. In memory of Susie Madrak.
The Democrats’ First Move After Their Big Win? A Giveaway to Big Oil.
To appoint the next comptroller general of the United States, follow the law
Unobserved Contributions and Political Influence: Evidence from the Death of Top Donors
Schumer urged Biden to go. Now it’s his turn. After the ‘blue wave,’ new direction and leadership should take precedence over his ego.
Climate Change, the Mother of All Affordability Problems
Bank CEOs, NSA Tell Congress That AI-Driven Patches Are Behind Outages
Run It Like a Business
Why We Can’t Let Enormous Weirdos Regulate AI
A spoiler in Alaska – but not who you think. Will a convicted felon disrupt the U.S. House race?
AI Probably Didn’t Cause the National Ground Stop, And It’s Big Tech’s Own Damn Fault No One Believes It
Catching AI’s mistakes is a mental burden – and a drag on productivity
Trump Has a Secret ICE Slush Fund—and His Plan for It Is Unnerving
She retired early to care for family. New work rules for food aid disrupted that
Trump Census Rule Change Could Leave Millions of Americans Uncounted. The new proposal would leave out millions of U.S. citizens in addition to many noncitizens. (this is another Republican power grab)
The Wachowskis Are Reclaiming ‘The Matrix’
They Were Just Admitted to the Bar. Now They’re Federal Prosecutors. Meet Trump’s New DOJ.
The Far-Right’s Big Conference Showed Christian Nationalism Isn’t Ready for Primetime Yet
Fed Governor Cook Won’t Attend White House Hearing Without Changes
Five Things to Know About Aparna Raj, DC’s Next Ward 1 Council Member
A Peek at What We Still Don’t Know About the Worst of Trump II … So Far
Senator opens investigation into evidence RFK Jr ‘unlawfully lied’ to Congress
The MAGA Manosphere Is Breaking Apart
Dirt, Death, and Triumph in Mississippi: What Scott Colom’s win does — and does not — tell us about race in the Deep South
RIP Susie Madrak
The Mind of a Megalomaniac
Ground Stop Came as Duffy Pushed to Rapidly Upgrade Aviation Systems
Excuse me. The Patriots Wore Blue. (lmfao)

What should I ask Walter Isaacson?

Yes I will be doing a Conversation with him, in part to celebrate the reissue of his earlier book The Innovators: How a Group of Hackers, Geniuses, and Geeks Created the Digital Revolution.  And also to celebrate his new podcast, The Builders.

He has other books too!

So what should I ask him?

The post What should I ask Walter Isaacson? appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Plate Maintenance

First we're going to have to relieve the built-up strain, but we'll do it one hemisphere at a time, so you'll just need to briefly move all your fragile stuff like buildings over to the other hemisphere while we work.

Quoting Levent Alpöge

I believe I have, working with Claude, discovered a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis. In fact, the method easily extends much further, resolving the so-called Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, and I expect, with more time, the Extended Riemann Hypothesis too. Claude and I have also formalized the arguments without assumptions. It is natural to feel that this is an end, in my case a loss of a principal guiding light, but what I saw during the course of progress so amazed me that I believe it is one dawn across science of something far greater. [...]

Claude and I have had a great time together with such breadth in recent months, but this time Claude far outpaced me near the finish line. No, Claude flew, and danced, and sparkled near that finish line.

— Levent Alpöge, alpo.ge/remark.pdf

Tags: anthropic, claude, generative-ai, mathematics, ai, llms, levent-alpoge

Token fraud is here and it’s BAD (YouTube)

Token fraud is here and it’s BAD (YouTube)

Claire Vo runs ChatPRD, an AI platform that helps product managers "turn an idea into a spec". The product has been live since the GPT-4 era, and Claire has been building it in public for much of that time.

In this YouTube video (see also the accompanying Twitter post) Claire describes the flood of token fraud she has seen from groups abusing the product's free trial, sometimes just to get free AI usage but often to resell tokens or run other commercial enterprises on top of the ChatPRD agent.

I am funding a international Roblox and Fortnite map studio. They run a loop of free trials and promo codes and then tunnel to my agent and use it to build Roblox and Fortnite maps.

Apparently one of the common prompts Claire saw running through her agent involved SVGs of pelicans riding bicycles! Presumably the token scammers are using that to help sniff the underlying models - different model families have a definite signature, and I've used it like this in the past to try and guess the identity of stealth preview models on platforms like OpenRouter.

Claire is winding down her free trials entirely, which sadly looks like the right decision in the face of this abuse.

Tags: youtube, ai, generative-ai, llms, pelican-riding-a-bicycle, ai-misuse

Does it really matter if there’s an intelligence explosion?

Vernor Vinge is possibly my favorite science fiction author of all time.1 The Singularity, which he famously predicted would happen somewhere between 2005 and 2030, features heavily in most of his stories. It usually happens the same way: an Intelligence Explosion, of the type envisioned by I.J. Good — the smarter AI gets, the faster it’s able to make itself even smarter, meaning that AI becomes godlike nearly instantaneously once it reaches a certain threshold of capability.

Almost every discussion about AI safety that I hear in San Francisco or read in the tech blogosphere centers around this sort of event. The discussions are all about whether recursive self-improvement (RSI) is near, and whether we should “pace the frontier” — i.e., deliberately slow down or pause AI progress — to stop RSI from creating an intelligence explosion.

As I’ve listened to these arguments, I’ve grown increasingly skeptical that this is the right discussion we should be having. But before I explain why, let me quickly summarize the debate itself, to give an idea of what the arguments look like.

The intelligence explosion debate, in brief

In fact, I’ve published some pieces of that discussion on this blog. Back in September, Ramez Naam wrote a guest post arguing that an intelligence explosion is not imminent:

His basic arguments were:

  • OpenAI data show that AI is still only able to automate short chunks of the AI research process.

  • AI research is subject to diminishing returns, so that each increase in AI capability should buy less of a speedup in the pace of automated research.

  • Diminishing returns also mean that accelerating AI progress will require exponentially more of other resources, such as compute and money.

  • There’s no sign yet of an acceleration in the rate of AI progress.

In a follow-up post, Ramez did a deeper dive on the topic of agent swarms, arguing that they’re not as effective as many people believe.

Theo Jaffee echoed these arguments, noting that OpenAI’s data shows that AI hasn’t even been able to fully automate smaller research tasks yet:

Source: OpenAI via Theo Jaffee

Luis Garicano and Alex Imas also wrote a post downplaying the likelihood of an intelligence explosion:

Silicon Continent
Are we approaching an intelligence explosion?
(Dear reader: this is an unusual post; it gets a bit technical. Alex and I are trying to do something hard here: look at the data and try to understand what they tell us about the intelligence explosion. There is math, Greek letters, and two models. So please bear with us, and if you are bored, apologies. We think it is worth making an exception here…
Read more

Their arguments are more economic in nature. They show that although AI progress has accelerated, it also shows diminishing returns in terms of research spending, meaning that every unit of progress has come with a higher price tag:

They also estimate an economic model of RSI,2 and conclude that ideas in AI research are probably getting harder to find, reducing the likelihood of an intelligence explosion.

On the other side of the debate, we have the recent METR report about Anthropic’s internal progress in automating AI research. The report uses Anthropic’s own internal measure of AI capability, AECI, rather than the better-known public ECI. It also relies on data that aren’t public, meaning that deciding how much of the report to believe requires a lot of guesswork and assumption-making. But the basic story METR tells is that Claude is already speeding up Anthropic’s research process by a lot:

As we describe below, we were able to confidently determine that the acceleration [of AI progress in late 2025] was not due to an acceleration in the rate of growth of training compute…We guess that a majority (perhaps ≈80%) of the current…acceleration is due to AI.

Dwarkesh Patel, meanwhile, argues that AI research isn’t that different from math, and that the same factors that made AI suddenly go from useless to godlike at math will happen soon with AI’s own self-improvement:

Dwarkesh Podcast
The avalanche that hit math is coming for AI development
Read more

He writes:

It’s crazy how fast we went from, in 2023, “This model can’t reliably add four-digit numbers,” to…about a month ago, “Okay, it fucking solved a Millennium Prize problem in 88 hours.”…

AI research is actually surprisingly similar to the type of mathematical progress that current AIs are disproportionately good at: unlocking a ton of low-hanging fruit by applying a combination of incredible persistence and a superhuman capacity to connect ideas from lots of adjacent domains…In every domain where we can check answers and give AIs thousands of rounds of practice—for example, competitive programming contests, or well-scoped open math problems—they’ve gone from worse than most humans to better than the best humans within a few years…AI research has those same verifiable properties…

Once AI is as good as the best humans at AI research, algorithmic progress will get radically faster…Today’s AIs already do work at about 10 times human speed. And automated researchers would also be working around the clock, nights and weekends included. As a result, each individual automated researcher will be cramming in roughly 50x more work every calendar week than a human researcher can do…During the intelligence explosion, automated engineers will build tens of thousands of times more [reinforcement learning] training environments than we have currently.

So that’s the debate. Basically, it depends on whether ideas get harder to find faster than AI gets better at finding ideas, and only time will tell which one wins.

But as I said, while this debate is intellectually interesting, I’m not sure how much it matters.

How useful is this debate?

Whether an intelligence explosion happens is obviously very important. A sudden unfathomable leap in AI capabilities to godlike levels would be, to put it mildly, a very big deal. But that doesn’t mean an intelligence explosion is the thing we should be thinking and arguing about.

First of all, if an intelligence explosion is possible, it’s going to happen, and there’s probably just not much we can do to affect how it all shakes out.

Although people disagree about AI’s contribution to its own uplift, everyone agrees that AI capabilities are improving at a steady, rapid rate. Here’s Epoch AI’s ECI number, the most common measure of AI capabilities:

Source: Epoch AI

Most discussions about AI safety policy revolve around the idea of “pacing the frontier” — i.e., using government policy and AI labs’ own decisions to bend that trendline of progress downward. The usual reason given is that this will allow alignment research time to catch up, so that more powerful AI is safe by the time it arrives.

But this approach simply can’t deal with an intelligence explosion. If there’s some threshold at which AI gets good enough to start an intelligence explosion, that threshold will be reached. Even if we “paced the frontier” and slowed the rate of AI progress down by half, that would mean we’d hit the intelligence explosion in 2037 instead of 2032, or 2030 instead of 2028, or something like that. It would only buy us a few extra years.

I guess two years or five years isn’t nothing — we could use it to hang out with our loved ones and try some cool new restaurants while we waited for the arrival of the computer gods. But ultimately, it seems like small potatoes, especially if you’re an AI safety type who thinks an intelligence explosion would be a catastrophic event for humanity.

If an intelligence explosion is possible, the only way to prevent it is to halt AI progress completely, rather than just slow it down. In 1993, Vernor Vinge made a powerful argument as to why that’s impossible:

But if the technological Singularity can happen, it will. Even if all the governments of the world were to understand the “threat” and be in deadly fear of it, progress toward the goal would continue. In fiction, there have been stories of laws passed forbidding the construction of “a machine in the form of the mind of man”. In fact, the competitive advantage -- economic, military, even artistic of every advance in automation is so compelling that passing laws, or having customs, that forbid such things merely assures that someone else will get them first.

I’m a little more optimistic than Vinge here — I think we could engineer an AI slowdown if we got sufficiently scared — but I don’t for one minute believe we could engineer a complete halt.

Nor do I believe that alignment research will be able to make an intelligence explosion safe. “Pacing the frontier” so that alignment research can catch up might be effective in a world of steady linear AI progress.3 But in a world of sudden superexponential progress, AI alignment research will immediately be left behind. Even if there is a Singularity for understanding alignment, in a world with an intelligence explosion it will be the superintelligent AI, not us, that carries out that Singularity and decides on its alignment for itself.

A second point is that it’s not obvious why an intelligence explosion would be more dangerous than — or even distinguishable from — the type of rapid, non-explosive progress we’re already getting. Remember, AI going from “can’t add two numbers together” to “solves problems too hard for all human mathematicians combined” in three years is not counted as an intelligence explosion!

It’s clear that at the current rate of steady progress, AI will become superhuman in most domains in a fairly small number of years. Even robotics and other physical tasks look conquerable with the current type of AI that powers Claude and GPT. This means that AI will basically look like a god within our lifetimes, whether or not it looks like the kind of infinitely self-improving gods that populate Vernor Vinge novels.

This is why I’m not sure what an intelligence explosion means for our economy. It’s easy to write down a model in which smoothly increasing AI capabilities drive a smooth increase in GDP. But why should we believe a model like that? Other technologies haven’t really worked that way.

Usually, technologies reach some threshold of usefulness where adopting them makes economic sense. When they hit that threshold, their local contribution to productivity growth becomes very rapid, but also finishes fairly quickly. Fiszbein et al. (2024) shows this for electrification, Bartel (2005) shows it for IT-enabled machines. Each new invention creates a whole bunch of little local Singularities. It’s only when you add all these up across the economy that you get something that looks like a big smooth wave of growth.

A suddenly superintelligent AI isn’t really limited by locality — it could, essentially by definition, take over all or most human tasks if it wanted to. Whereas if an intelligence explosion doesn’t occur, these takeovers are likely to be staggered and irregular. But they will still happen, and the economic effect after the first few years probably won’t be that different.

In other words, I think:

  • The AI we’ll get from our current trend of improvement will look about as godlike — and as economically important — as an AI that suddenly bootstraps itself to godhood.

  • It’s not possible to stop AI improvement completely, and so if an intelligence explosion is possible, it’s going to happen to us soon.

  • Slowing down the rate of AI progress will not help us deal with post-Singularity superintelligence.

This is why I think this whole debate is misplaced. We need to be thinking about how to deal with the AI we already have, and the one we’ll almost certainly get soon — an AI that’s smarter than all humans at most economically important tasks. We need to think about how to regulate that actually existing superintelligence, how to prevent AI-enabled bioterror, how to make sure the economic benefits of AI are widely shared, and so on. We need to think about competition policy, to make sure the benefits of AI don’t exclusively go to one company.

I think we need to accept that nobody is “pacing the frontier” enough to prevent the emergence of superintelligence — and that nobody is likely to do so. If the machine god awakes, then it awakes, and we’ll simply deal with it. In the meantime, we need to focus on dealing with the AI we have now.


Subscribe now

Share

1

The other contender would be Lois McMaster Bujold, who writes a very different kind of sci-fi.

2

This estimation is done with only 16 data points, so I don’t really trust it. But we’re basically flying blind here, so this is the best we’ve got.

3

In fact, I invested in a company called Goodfire that’s at the forefront of AI alignment research.

Friday assorted links

1. Markets drive moods, and not vice versa?

2. AI literary scandals and the future of the Latin American novel.

3. New Stripe Press website.

4. Does Claude’s constitution mean anything?

5. Did the Baby Boom help cause the later divorce boom?

6. “Social adversity in early life has minimal, predominantly positive long-term consequences for social behaviour in mountain gorillas.”

7. University of Austin hiring in economics.

8. Good book on the Riemann hypothesis, whether or not it turns out to have been proved.  An interesting related question is whether this rumor (or is it more than that?) will at all budge the Anthropic share price, as Claude was running the proof.  Also claims of Unforced Navier-Stokes.

The post Friday assorted links appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

An Unusual Triple System ‘Close’ to Home

I’m always interesting in discoveries unusually close to the Sun, maybe because I keep hoping that there really is a brown dwarf or rogue planet much closer to our system than Proxima Centauri. In the absence of that discovery, let’s talk about the unusual triple-system that has just turned up thanks to work at the University of Montreal, where the Trottier Institute for Research on Exoplanets (IREx) brings together research from a number of Canadian institutions.

Located some 28 light years from Earth, the system has been dubbed Welopōʻai, which is a Hawaiian coinage from the Imiloa Astronomy Center of Hawai’i, an institution whose existence explains some of the Polynesian names that have begun appearing in our astronomical catalogs. In this system, then, we have Welopō‘ai Aa, Welopō‘ai Ab and Welopō‘ai B. I had to resort to AI to retrieve the pronunciation here, and found that it’s weh-loh-POH-eye, which linguistically combines a notion of lineage with the circle depicting an orbit.

So let’s take this complicated system into focus. Using the SPectropolarimètre InfraROUge (SPIRou) spectrograph at Mauna Kea, the researchers led by the University of Montreal’s Étienne Artigau had been looking for the signature of exoplanets around the red dwarf IRAS 21500+5903 in the constellation Cepheus. The velocity change found via SPIRou dwarfed what they expected from an exoplanet, leading to the conclusion that there must be a massive companion object, one which would have to total as much as half a solar mass. Follow-up work using the Gemini North telescope turned up the image of a white dwarf.

This was interesting indeed, for IRAS 21500+5903 was already known to be part of a binary system, with a second white dwarf considerably farther away from the primary than the new discovery. Using the new nomenclature, we can call the outer white dwarf, which is about 124 AU from the red dwarf, Welopōʻai B. The newly discovered white dwarf, which we can now call Welopōʻai Ab, is a scant 4.6 AU from the primary, a bit less than Jupiter’s distance from the Sun.

Intriguing, no? Patrick Dufour, who specializes in white dwarf stars at Montreal and is a co-author of the paper on this work, points to its allure:

“We have no clean explanation for how it got here. That is the question driving our next observations.”

Image: Observations of the Welopōʻai triple-star system, located 28 light-years from Earth. The image on the left shows the two components of the system: Welopōʻai A, a closely orbiting red dwarf and white dwarf pair, and Welopōʻai B, a second white dwarf located much farther away. The image on the right provides a close-up view of the inner pair, revealing the faint white dwarf companion (Ab) detected using the Gemini North telescope’s ‘Alopeke instrument. The overlaid curves illustrate the stars’ orbital paths. Credit: Pan-STARRS1/STScI/MAST (left); International Gemini Observatory/NSF.

The assumption is that the inner white dwarf in this system was once about 40 percent more massive than the Sun, which would mean at some point it became a red giant, so that the red dwarf near it would be engulfed. Yet the red dwarf clearly survived, and is in what appears to be a stable orbital configuration with its close companion. The paper suggests that Kozai-Lidov oscillations involving the outer of the three stars could result if that object’s orbit were sufficiently tilted. Such interactions could have profound effects on the orbital eccentricity of the inner stars, but it will take more observations to figure out whether this explanation fits and how such interactions evolved over time.

The team’s video so impressively uses sound to depict the system’s orbital interactions that I’ll add not only the video but their lengthy description.

Image: Animated simulation and sonification of the Welopōʻai triple-star system, illustrating how the gravitational interactions between its three stars could influence their orbits over time. The animation begins with a close-up of the inner red dwarf and white dwarf pair before zooming out to reveal the more distant second white dwarf. It then explores the possibility of Kozai-Lidov oscillations, a phenomenon in which the gravitational influence of the outer star causes the inner pair’s orbit to cyclically change in shape and orientation. Although these oscillations are expected to occur in the Welopōʻai system, observations have yet to confirm how pronounced they are.

The accompanying sonification translates the stars’ orbital motions into sound, allowing listeners to hear the changing rhythms of the system. Musical tones accompany the stars as they move along their orbits, with changes in the timing and character of the sounds reflecting their evolving motions. As the inner orbit becomes more elongated and then more circular again, these changing patterns in pitch offer an audible representation of the gravitational dance between members of this stellar family. Credit: Heidi White, Trottier Institute for Research on Exoplanets (IREx), Université de Montréal. Simulation data from Alexandre Correia, University of Coimbra.

Being surprised by our observations is hardly a new phenomenon, as Galileo demonstrated when he decided to look at Jupiter and found its moons, and as the paper on this work points out, the first exoplanet around a main sequence star (51 Pegasi) was confounding because the idea of a ‘hot Jupiter’ had little traction in the scientific community. Now we have an oddball survivor, an M-dwarf that somehow survived the red giant phase of a close neighbor and returned to a stable orbital arrangement with it. We’ll soon be learning more, as the collaborators on this find intend to tighten up the numbers using further Gaia data as well as archival-plate astrometry and JWST observations.

That work may also resolve an unexpected infrared excess at Welopō‘ai Ab which may involve a debris disk, although the authors consider this a tentative conclusion. Fortunately, JWST photometry is made to order for the follow-up.

Thanks to my good friend Antonio Tavani for the pointer to this discovery. The paper is Artigau et al., “Welopō‘ai: A peculiar triple system 8 pc from the Sun,” Astronomy & Astrophysics Vol. 715, A321 (November, 2026). Full text.

A Great Week for D.C.’s Crime Stats

As of 9am Friday, there were no homicides in D.C. this week, bringing the total to 86* homicides this year. Last year, during the same time period, we had 120 homicides, and in the surge year of 2023, there were 247 homicides during that same time period.

Both violent and property crimes were level this week.

2026 will be the first year since the last year of Biden’s presidency where homicides don’t decline by 33%.

Hoping for another great week next week.

*Three of the 89 murders reported this year actually occurred in other years (e.g., a missing persons case from 2023 turned into a homicide case this year with new evidence).

Why Are Tech Lords Rallying Around a Man Who Sold Out America?

Nvidia will lose deals without Jensen Huang, says Elon Musk

Marketing note: I have a new ebook, Navigating the Chaos: Chronicles of Economic and Political Madness, which uses material from this Substack to construct a thematic narrative of the past two years and the issues that Democrats must now address to build an enduring progressive movement. Available from Amazon, Kobo,Bookshop, and Nook.

You might think that billionaires are completely self-interested, that their attention is exclusively focused upon making themselves richer. But that’s unfair. Because quite a number of the wealthiest men in America are now banding together and advocating for the greater good — that is, the greater good of the billionaire class. Billionaires such as Elon Musk, Sam Altman, Bill Ackman and Greg Brockman have been showing vociferous support for Jensen Huang, the disgraced former CEO of the chip giant Nvidia, and demanding that he be given his job back.

It’s true that Huang’s fall has been particularly shocking. Before his fall, he was a virtual potentate in the world of AI. He controlled access to the most sophisticated chips for AI data centers and, critically, the financial backing that his customers needed to purchase those chips. More so that any other single person, Huang both engineered the chips that made AI possible and inflated the AI financial bubble that looms over the economy.

But as we now know, Huang had an extended affair with Alice Huang (no relation), who has been identified by U.S. intelligence as a likely Chinese asset. Alice Huang is the controlling shareholder of Megaspeed, a Singapore-based data center company that provides compute to Chinese companies and, quite possibly, to entities tied to the Chinese military.

Yet the focus on Huang’s apparent fall into a Chinese honeytrap obscures the fact that Nvidia was systematically undermining U.S. security for financial reasons, not just carnal ones.

Nvidia’s advanced chips are one of the few major advantages America has in its technology competition with China — a nation that is not an outright enemy, yet has consistently worked to undermine America’s interests globally, including providing significant technological and financial support to Iran. Moreover, China is an autocratic surveillance state that has bolstered anti-democratic forces around the world. The U.S. has had a policy, initiated by the Biden administration, of denying China access to the most sophisticated chips, Nvidia’s in particular.

Then Jensen Huang intervened. Huang successfully lobbied the Trump administration for a relaxation of Biden’s export restrictions, after contributing $25 million to Trump’s hideous ballroom. Howard Lutnick, the Commerce secretary, appears to have played a special role in undermining U.S. sanctions. Members of Congress have leaked data showing that Commerce approved the sale of hundreds of thousands of advanced chips to Chinese companies, including some with known ties to the Chinese military.

Furthermore, Nvidia also sold chips to third-party buyers — Megaspeed in particular — which appear to have smuggled these chips to China. On Monday the Justice and Commerce departments revealed that they have launched a criminal investigation into Megaspeed. Announcements of investigations in progress are rare; obviously Trump officials are scrambling to contain the political damage from the Huang revelations. Scott Bessent, the Treasury secretary, said in an interview last week that he had been pushing for months to have Megaspeed on a trade blacklist, but that Commerce — “which has the pen” — failed to act.

Cantor Fitzgerald, the financial company run by Lutnick’s sons, reportedly has a large financial stake in Nvidia, and Congressional Democrats are investigating. Lutnick looks like a prime target for impeachment once Democrats take control of Congress.

For a lot of money was involved in Nvidia’s dubious dealings: In fiscal 2025 customers with a billing location in Singapore, which accounts for only around 0.5 percent of world GDP, accounted for 18 percent of Nvidia’s revenue. Presumably the bulk of those purchases went to other nations, especially China.

So regardless of whether you want to frame it as a honeytrap or a moneytrap, Huang was effectively selling out U.S. national interests. (Democracy too.) Yet rather than make it clear that they would never betray America the way Huang (and apparently Lutnick) has, the tech oligarchy has rushed to his defense.

As the Wall Street Journal reported, at the latest New York Times Dealbook conference, “the technorati” — notably including Elon Musk — “took turns praising Huang.” David Sacks, the former White House technology czar, has defended Huang and argued that the “real story” is the leak of intelligence concerns to the New York Times. And of course Donald Trump himself has expressed support for Huang.

What’s going on here? As a number of observers have pointed out, many people in the tech-bro elite believe that corporations should be run in “founder mode,” in which one Big Man basically gets to do whatever he wants. And this is regardless of whether the company is publicly traded and thus legally obligated to act in its shareholders’ best interests.

As a recent op-ed by Amit Seru and David Larcker puts it, “some of Silicon Valley’s largest companies are basically authoritarian realms.”

So when these corporate strongmen see Huang fired for bad behavior that compromises national security, they see it not as a necessary corrective but as an implicit threat to their own authority. In their Ubermensch world view, only the little people need to obey the rules — including the rule of law. And of course they have an ally in Trump, the ultimate example of someone who revels in breaking rules and laws.

But do they realize how dangerous this kind of arrogance is about to become? Josh Marshall of Talking Points Memo, who has been writing along similar lines, doesn’t think so:

[I]t does not seem like any of these guys have entirely absorbed just how staggeringly unpopular they and their entire industry has become. They also don’t seem to have grasped how unpopular Trump — with whom they’ve cast their lots — has become.

Indeed. YouGov’s latest poll finds that Americans who believe that Huang’s affair compromised national security outnumber those who believe it hasn’t three to one. And most people probably don’t know how much Nvidia appears to have profited from chip-smuggling; if they did, their anti-Huang views would surely be even stronger.

In the aftermath of the midterm blue tsunami, quite a few tech lords will soon find themselves testifying before Congressional committees, as well as their businesses under greater regulatory scrutiny. So it’s a hell of a time for them to publicly rally for autocratic impunity. But, hey, that’s what they did when their tied their fates to Donald Trump.

Going forward, just as in the case of Elon Musk and Starlink, the Jensen Huang debacle shows that critical national security assets cannot be controlled by one person, no matter how impressive a businessperson he or she is. Just as the midterms results signaled the death throes of MAGA, let’s hope that the Jensen Huang debacle, along with Democratic investigations, will mark the beginning of the end of autocratic founder syndrome — and the self-dealing that so often goes with it — in the tech world.

MUSICAL CODA

“Failures in philosophy have brought me to this door”

Rocket Report: A weekend of ups and downs; Stoke celebrates engine milestone

Welcome to Edition 9.20 of the Rocket Report! Last weekend was a picture of the US launch business in miniature, and emblematic of the opposing trajectories of two of the nation's most experienced rocket makers. First, on Saturday, SpaceX completed a perfect midair catch of its Starship upper stage at its launch pad in Texas after spending nearly a day in orbit. The Super Heavy booster was lost at sea, but SpaceX proved it can recover that piece of the rocket on previous flights. While SpaceX showed it is well on the way to fielding a fully reusable rocket, United Launch Alliance suffered its first-ever total launch failure with the Vulcan rocket. That is terrible news for not only ULA, but also the US Space Force and Amazon, which have booked some 70 launches on Vulcan over the next few years. Your faithful correspondents will take a break from the Rocket Report next week for the Thanksgiving holiday, so we'll see you again the first week of December.

As always, we welcome reader submissions, and if you don't want to miss an issue, please subscribe using the box below (the form will not appear on AMP-enabled versions of the site). Each report will include information on small-, medium-, and heavy-lift rockets as well as a quick look ahead at the next three launches on the calendar.

Europe's leading satellite startup eyes Italian rocket maker. Finnish satellite developer ICEYE announced Tuesday that it is seeking to buy Italian rocket-maker Avio for more than $2.2 billion in a transaction aimed at creating Europe’s first true vertically integrated end-to-end space company, Ars reports. Avio builds the Vega C rocket, a solid-fueled launcher designed to carry up to 3.3 metric tons (7,300 pounds) of payload to low-Earth orbit. ICEYE is, by far, the most successful space startup in Europe, with a valuation of more than $12 billion after the company's most recent fundraising round in June.

Read full article

Comments

Alliance for Paired Kidney Donation-20th anniversary in Toledo

I'm blogging this morning from Toledo Ohio, where I've come to help celebrate the 20th Anniversary of the Alliance for Paired Kidney Donation (APKD), its founder Mike Rees, the U. Toledo Medical Center, and the city of Toledo.

 I gave an after-dinner talk last night, commemorating some of the APKD's milestones. Below are a few of my slides. Quite a few of the donors and recipients in the chains pictured below were present. Some of them I met for the first time.  It was a great event.

I 




 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

My grandmother was a seal

Abstract painting of a figure swimming underwater with fish and light beams illuminating the scene.

Many Irish families believed they descended from selkies. Their stories reveal the violence and grief in our kinship with nature

- by Jordan Lee Borgman

Read on Aeon

Cool flex AI bro

I am tickled by reports that, among elite AI researchers, cigarettes are back.

The logic goes like this:

If you really believe in AI and that AI will hit recursive self-improvement and achieve super-intelligence,

and that it will solve all disease,

and that all of this will happen imminently (or at least imminently enough that you have nothing to fear from smoking-related diseases),

and you want to show that you, yes you, are close enough to the action to have come to this conclusion, and you are a true believer,

then a really great way to signal this is to conspicuously take up smoking cigarettes.


Actually I think that smoking cigarettes shows great strength of character.

Or at least that’s the gag I say to my smoking buddies when they light up.

Given everything we know about what smoking does to you, and the relentless, gruesome anti-smoking ad campaigns for years and years, and the smell and the cost and the social shunning and the logistical difficulty of actually finding a legal place to stand, and the easy alternatives like vaping, you must be really independently-minded and strong-willed to stand up to all that and still be on the cigs.

Well done you, I say, well done.

This joke no longer works given the AI flex so I’ll have to stop using it. My friends, thoroughly fed up with me by now, will be relieved.


Another flex:

If your girlfriend isn’t a Chinese honeytrap, does your AI startup even matter?

The story goes that Nvidia founder Jensen Huang’s extra-marital girlfriend is actually a Chinese spy.

(What’s the benefit to China of her being a spy? Surely not just for lobbying. But to get access to Nvidia GPUs – which her company has been funnelling to Chinese AI labs, it turns out, breaking US export bans. The point being that frontier models can be trained only on cutting edge Nvidia chips, and this is a way for China to keep up, and there is forensic proof that this is what has happened. The second question to ask: why was this disclosed now? We can only guess.)

Rumours of this sort of thing have been bubbling for a while.

Female spies are waging ‘sex warfare’ to steal Silicon Valley secrets, The Times (October 2025). "China and Russia are sending attractive women to seduce tech workers…"

Even Elon Musk made a gag about it last year: "If she’s a 10, you’re an asset."

So if your startup isn’t even worth state-sponsored espionage, why are you bothering.

But if on the other hand you have have mysteriously out-of-your-league hotties (on whatever combination of axes you prefer, they have the psych analysis) sliding into your DMs, and you want to flex that, then heck take them on dates to very fancy, very public restaurants, let everyone notice. Ride the crocodile and watch your pillow talk. You’ll have VCs blowing up your messages, they’ll want in on that.


Remember. It’s only a Chinese honeytrap if she’s from honeytrap province in China otherwise it’s just sparkling industrial espionage.


What makes a flex work is that it is costly in some way.

Like, syphilis sores used to be fashionable:

the symptoms remained limited to a few painless sores on the genitals and face, which for a time were even a status symbol and indicated that the wearer had had a lot of sexual experience. A sore on the forehead, the ‘Crown of Venus’, was worn with pride.


Another social cost flex, more contemporary, fewer oozing sores: the hierarchy of wristwatches on Wall Street, Business Insider (2016), by OG finance bro anon Goldman Sachs Elevator.

The social signalling and potential faux pas on the ladder of intern, analyst, associate, VP, etc go as you’d expect:

You’re out of the analyst and associate compensation bands now and starting to make real money. It’s time to go pick up a Rolex Daytona ($12,500) – the quintessential investment banker watch. It’s not that expensive, but there’s an unwritten rule that you can’t have one until you’re at least a VP.

Reading this, you get the sense that everyone is clocking everyone’s wrists like all the time.

But when - if - you make partner, it flips:

Your Patek Philippe is at home. You gave your Panerai to your deadbeat brother-in-law, and your Rolex Yachtmaster is in the Hamptons. Just as Sam Walton drove a Ford truck and Warren Buffett drives a Lincoln, get yourself a Swatch ($66) like Lloyd Blankfein or a Nike sport swatch ($85) like Hank Paulson.

Or better yet, don’t wear one. The power move is to have a few watches stuffed away at home, and then, rarely, if ever, wear one. When you control time, you don't need to know what time it is.

Here’s a paywall busting link.


Not caring about time is truly the best flex.

19th century Paris, the ambling dandy, the quintessential man about town observing the hustle and bustle of society with nowhere to be, the flaneur.

The flaneur, who cares so conspicuously little about needing to be anywhere at all that:

"Around 1840 it was considered elegant to take a tortoise out walking."

More here.


brb strolling my tortoise to the corner shop to grab a pack of Camels.

Phonics-based Instruction and Student Achievement

That is a new NBER working paper by Alex Hollingsworth, Alberto Ortega & Nikolaos Zirogiannis.  Abstract:

Reading is a foundational skill, yet fewer than one in three US fourth graders read at a proficient level. How best to teach reading and improve educational attainment has been an active policy debate for decades. Recently, phonics-based approaches have surged in popularity, even though the largest attempt to put similar methods into classrooms was previously abandoned out of concerns that the program was ineffective. This paper studies Reading First, a nearly $1 billion per year federal program established under No Child Left Behind that promoted phonics-based instruction in K-3 classrooms. Exploiting administrative data from Texas and program eligibility formulas, we estimate effects via difference-in-differences and instrumental variables specifications. We find that eligibility increased third-grade reading test scores by 0.1 standard deviations and that effects persisted through at least the eighth grade. An analysis of digitized exam questions shows that treated students outperformed peers on questions that required basic decoding skills and those with more words, a benefit that also drove improvements in math scores. We follow exposed cohorts into early adulthood, finding that the program increased on-time high school graduation, college enrollment, four-year college completion, and adult earnings at age 25.

As with many “ban cell phones in schools” papers, I find these results underwhelming.  Nonetheless phonics education always has made sense to me.

The post Phonics-based Instruction and Student Achievement appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Politics Chat, November 19, 2026

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

Get full, free access to Letters from an American here.

You can also find Heather:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

November 19, 2026

Democrats who will soon be at the head of congressional committees are indicating to members of the administration that they will soon be answering questions about their actions during the past two years. On November 18, Representative Robert Garcia (D-CA), who is expected to chair the House Committee on Oversight and Governmental Reform, sent letters today to a number of Trump administration figures demanding they preserve all records, communications, and information pertaining to future investigations.

Those letters went to Donald Trump Jr. concerning alleged conflicts of interest, his stake in the World Liberty Financial cryptocurrency venture, and the fact a Russian oligarch close to Russia’s president Vladimir Putin paid for his wedding party; to Eric Trump concerning alleged conflicts of interest and World Liberty Financial; and to Jared Kushner over alleged conflicts of interest, his control of the private equity firm Affinity Partners—which received a $2 billion investment from Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund and is a major stockholder in an Israeli company that has hundreds of millions of dollars invested in Israeli defense contractors—and allegations that he has used his role in the government to enrich himself and his companies.

The letter to Kushner arrived on the same day Ariel Sabar of The Atlantic reported that Affinity Partners updated a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission on November 5, two days after the midterm elections, revealing that it also owns a $32 million stake in a U.S. defense contractor that makes crucial components for the U.S. systems deployed in the theaters in which Kushner has been acting as Trump’s negotiator. That information appears to have been so late it violated legal requirements.

Letters went to Kimberly Guilfoyle about pay-to-play schemes during her tenure as U.S. ambassador to Greece and to Trust for the National Mall chief executive officer Catherine Townsend on the $600 million in both taxpayer money and private donations from those with business before the government that are supposed to be funding Trump’s ballroom.

Letters went to White House chief of staff Stephen Miller about abuses by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and Immigration and Customs Enforcement under his direction, to former DHS secretary Kristi Noem about abuse of funds and corruption, and to Noem’s advisor Corey Lewandowski regarding corruption and self-dealing, steering of lucrative contracts to allies, and his role in DHS and ICE abuses.

Letters went to Vice President J.D. Vance and former White House chief of staff Susie Wiles about the cover-up of the Epstein files; to Attorney General Todd Blanche about the cover-up of the Epstein files, the failure of the Department of Justice (DOJ) to comply with the Epstein Files Transparency Act, the DOJ’s botched release and review of documents, and the decision to transfer Jeffrey Epstein’s associate Ghislaine Maxwell to a minimum-security prison camp; and to Federal Bureau of Prisons Director William K. Marshall III and Federal Prison Camp Bryan Prison Warden Tanisha Hall about Maxwell’s transfer just days after she offered favorable testimony about Trump, as well as the privileges she has enjoyed since the transfer.

Garcia’s list is just a starting point. More news will continue to drop. Just today, Avi Asher-Schapiro, Andy Kroll, and Alex Mierjeski of ProPublica reported that Trump officials appear to have figured a way around the prohibition on the slush fund Trump wanted to create over the leaking of tax information by an IRS contractor during his first term. While the law allows a $1,000 payment to victims of such a leak, Trump appointees at the Department of Justice signed paperwork that settled with five individuals and companies connected to Trump for $2.5 million, with more plaintiffs on the way.

Administration figures are sending their own messages to the Democrats, either to bully them into backing down or to draw favorable attention from Trump and his allies. White House counsel William Scharf and U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas Aaron Reitz have sent public letters to Democrats warning that their promises to conduct oversight may be unconstitutional and illegal.

On Monday, Scharf sent an extraordinary memo to the general counsels of executive departments and agencies telling them that no personnel may agree to appear before any congressional committee without approval from the White House Office of Legislative Affairs and the Office of the White House Counsel: that is, himself.

A White House official told Liz Landers of PBS: “The Trump Administration will not be extorted, intimidated, or threatened into submission by politically motivated baseless investigations. We are ready to engage with Congress, this process ensures reasonable requests are respected, but baseless political attempts to undermine our mission will not be accepted as the status quo by Democrats’ [sic] who want to slow the administration down from its historic work.”

Legal commentator Liz Dye wrote in Public Notice that “this is a radical departure from prior policy, contrary to both law and precedent.” On November 11, Dye noted that Attorney General Todd Blanche, Trump’s former criminal defense lawyer, has been “desperately assuring” those who stick with the administration that “he’s got their backs.”

On the Fox News Channel he said: “If you work in this administration, you have a lawyer. It’s me.” Dye also noted that in fact, Blanche is likely going to protect Trump and himself rather than the little guys and that in any case, the lawyers leaving the DOJ since the election are well aware that “while a presidential pardon might keep them out of jail, it won’t save their law licenses.”

Reitz has targeted Garcia, as well as Senators Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), Elissa Slotkin (D-MI), Adam Schiff (D-CA), and Elizabeth Warren (D-MA). They are having no part of it. Slotkin noted that his public threats against members of Congress who have explicit constitutional protection for their speech “is evidence that your threat of investigation is more about publicity and your political ambitions than any sort of legitimate inquiry.”

Today Kyle Cheney of Politico reported that six experts in congressional power and constitutional law say Reitz’s threats are “farcical.” One said the administration’s attack on Congress is “even more laughable than usual.”

As Judd Legum reported in Popular Information on Tuesday, November 17, Reitz has repeatedly vowed to use the law to hurt “libs” and enemies of “our Christian values,” saying “it’s either kill or be killed.” In 2025, when he was running for the office of Texas attorney general, he told a group of supporters that those on “the left” “are deadly threatened by what’s coming. They know that I’m going to destroy them. If I can’t sue you, I’m going to investigate you. If I can’t investigate you, I’m going to drag you into so much trouble, you might as well just declare bankruptcy now.”

Reitz makes it clear that key administration figures remain tied to Trump. Senator Blumenthal has taken to asking Trump’s judicial nominees if they are willing to say that voters elected Joe Biden president in 2020 or if the U.S. Capitol was attacked on January 6, 2021. They still are not. As Blumenthal notes, Trump’s appointees’ refusal to acknowledge the fact that Biden won in 2020 indicates that they lack the objectivity and independence the justiciary requires.

Indeed, rather than moderating their positions after the historic midterm election made it clear how unpopular they are, Trump loyalists appear to have decided to hammer through their policies, despite their rejection by the American people on November 3. New White House chief of staff Stephen Miller, a white nationalist who describes immigration as an “invasion,” has said he intended to expand the administration’s deportation program despite its unpopularity.

And yet, in Strength in Numbers on November 17, pollster G. Elliott Morris explained that while much ink has been spilled about voters turning against Trump over rising costs in 2026, voters turned against Trump over immigration and deportations in 2025. That shift was especially clear in the Hispanic voters who helped to put Trump in office in 2024. Angry at sweeping deportations rather than the removal of violent criminals they thought Trump promised, they moved 28 points toward Democrats, helping to turn Texas, as well as other states, blue.

MAGA members of Congress are also doubling down on their ideology, especially after more moderate Republicans were swept out of office in November. In the House, Republicans have chosen MAGA bombthrower Jim Jordan, who is simply a messaging agent and who in almost twenty years in Congress has never sponsored a bill that became a law, to be their leader.

In the Senate, Republicans today declined, once again, to stop Trump’s war on Iran. While Senate majority leader John Thune (R-SD) blamed Trump for his party’s losses in the midterms, Senator Ron Johnson (R-WI), who in January 2021 tried to get a false slate of Trump electors into then–Vice President Mike Pence’s hand just before Congress began the counting of electoral votes, seemed to dismiss voters’ demand for affordability. Yesterday, on Fox Business, he called Social Security “grotesque” and a “Ponzi scheme.” He added: “You can’t fix it. You just shut it down and hope you can recover some of your money.”

Trump administration officials are trying to rig government programs in their own favor by replacing the acting comptroller general of the Government Accountability Office (GAO), the nonpartisan independent office that audits federal programs, with MAGA Republican Eric Ueland. Ueland is an ally of Office of Management and Budget director Russell Vought, who has been withholding funds for programs he doesn’t like despite congressional appropriations. Norman Ornstein of The Contrarian says the Republicans’ attempt to force Ueland into the GAO is “a middle finger to the law and to Congress.”

At the state level, as Kate Riga of Talking Points Memo reported today, Republican MAGA officials are rushing to restrict voting before 2028.

The doubling down of MAGA political figures on their ideology stands in marked contrast to the right-wing figures trying to distance themselves from Trump and MAGA in the wake of the election.

Alex Karp, the chief executive officer of tech giant Palantir, who shifted rightward to ingratiate himself with the Trump administration, used the word “progressive” eight times when he talked to Politico’s Playbook after the election. “I’ve been a Democrat my whole life,” he said, adding “I know more about being a progressive than almost anybody on the planet.” He said the Democrats have “absolutely” corrected enough in 2026 that he could support them in 2028.

Billionaire Elon Musk put close to $300 million into the 2024 elections on behalf of Republicans, slashed government jobs when he headed Trump’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), and pumped close to a half a billion dollars—that we know of—into the 2026 midterm elections to make sure Republicans continued to control the Senate and Texas, where Musk has located his businesses. And yet, in an interview at the New York Times 2026 DealBook Summit, Musk distanced himself from Trump and the Republicans, insisting he is “not MAGA.”

It turns out that some of those who cooperated with Trump and his allies now appear eager to work with incoming Democratic investigators. Michael S. Schmidt of the New York Times reported today that Kirkland & Ellis, one of the elite law firms that, under threats from the administration over its “diversity, equity and inclusion (D.E.I.) related employment practices,” agreed to do $125 million in pro bono work for charitable causes Trump supports, actually has done close to $12 million in free work for the Trump administration. This arrangement seems to have enabled the administration to circumvent Congress.

According to Schmidt, in its seven-page letter to Congress, the law firm noted that it hired a lobbying firm close to the White House to cut the deal with a deputy to Stephen Miller and that, apart from a social media post by Trump, the agreement had never been written down.

—

Notes:

https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/news/press-releases/incoming-oversight-chairman-robert-garcia-launches-document-preservation-letters-on-trump-family-corruption-corporate-corruption-dhs-misconduct-and-epstein-cover-up

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/10/us/jared-kushner-saudi-investment-fund.html

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/2026/11/jared-kushner-affinity-arxis/689488/

https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-settlement-golf-pro-shelby-lowman

https://www.democracydocket.com/news-alerts/who-is-aaron-reitz-trump-doj-prosecutor-says-hes-working-with-main-justice-as-he-threatens-democrats-for-conducting-oversight/

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/read-the-full-white-house-memo-requiring-agencies-to-get-approval-before-testifying-in-front-of-congress

https://d3i6fh83elv35t.cloudfront.net/static/2026/11/GC-Letter.pdf

Public Notice
White House prepares to give Congress the finger
Read more
Public Notice
Memo to MAGA: Todd Blanche is not your lawyer
Read more

https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/6229401-slotkin-slams-reitz-investigation/

https://www.politico.com/news/2026/11/19/democrats-trump-oversight-aaron-reitz-letters-01173711

Popular Information
What the U.S. attorney threatening Democratic senators said when he thought only Republicans were listening
Over the last week, Aaron Reitz, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas, has sent letters to three U.S. senators suggesting he could criminally prosecute them if they investigate the Trump administration…
Read more

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/nov/17/david-horowitz-stephen-miller

Strength In Numbers
ICE may have cost Republicans more votes than inflation did in 2026
This is Part 2 of 2026 By The Numbers, a series that uses our bespoke polls, voter-file data, and election returns to explain how Democrats won the 2026 midterms and learn the real lessons of their victory. Read the whole series…
Read more

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/nov/06/latino-voters-midterms-republicans-trump

https://www.businessinsider.com/jim-jordan-never-had-a-bill-enacted-may-become-speaker-2023-10

https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2026/11/19/congress/senate-gop-war-powers-fail-01176132

https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/6229795-john-thune-gop-midterm-losses-voter-issues/

https://www.politico.com/news/2022/06/21/jan-6-panel-trump-overturn-2020-election-00040816

https://www.ms.now/opinion/ron-johnson-social-security-retirement

The Contrarian
The Senate Cannot Allow Partisanship at the GAO
When I arrived on Capitol Hill in 1969, I had never heard of the GAO, then called the General Accounting Office. But that ignorance did not last long. As soon as I started to work on legislation, I learned about the vital organs of Congress that drove the deliberation, provided the history, and were vital to oversight, honesty, and competence in governm…
Read more

https://talkingpointsmemo.com/the-franchise/red-states-rush-to-restrict-voting-before-2028-elections

https://www.politico.com/newsletters/digital-future-daily/2025/11/06/the-maga-evolution-of-palantirs-ceo-00639832

https://www.politico.com/newsletters/playbook/2026/11/11/the-tech-right-pivots-left-01160648

https://www.mediaite.com/media/news/im-not-maga-elon-musk-scrambles-to-distance-himself-from-trump-in-bizarre-pivot-at-ny-times-forum/

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/19/us/politics/kirkland-ellis-law-firm-trump.html

YouTube:

watch?v=pem4xfD8q7I&t=6681s

X:

USAttyReitz/status/2120632462686711838?s=20

Bluesky:

atrupar.com/post/3n2mamadli227

wired.com/post/3n2mvhv75nc2y

Share

Politics Chat, November 19, 2026

Watch today’s live recording here.

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

Get full, free access to Letters from an American here.

You can also find Heather:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

AIs vs. humans in economics papers

Is agentic research any good? Dr Yanagizawa-Drott and his colleague, Olaf Willner, used an AI verifier to check 1,000 APE papers. None was error-free; 842 contained at least one severe error, including ones invalidating headline results. To see roughly how Ape stacks up against human primates, The Economist teamed up with Refine, the research-verification firm founded by Dr Golub. Refine chose 100 papers at random from those accepted for publication in the top five journals (including QJE and JPE ) in the first nine months of 2026. It then subjected them to thorough review using several frontier AI models plus a once-over for serious errors by a human reviewer. The exercise flagged 4,158 issues in the 100 papers. One in ten papers contained at least one grave error (other problems concerned interpretation or inconsistencies between tables and text).

The two exercises are not directly comparable, but human economists’ lower error rate might give them some hope. In ideas, too, people retain the edge. One experiment, by Alexis Akira Toda of Emory University, found that when considering papers on economic theory alone, AI lowers the cost of checking for a candidate flaw but “does not yet reliably substitute for the human judgment that locates the flaw in the first place”. Another, which compared APE papers with published papers found the difference is mostly in ideas, not execution. In a further study, Michele Zampa of the Geneva Graduate Institute used an AI referee to grade 981 AI papers and 41 human ones on things like the novelty of research questions and acknowledgment of methodological limitations. AI did better in crowded fields with lots of existing research to digest. Humans performed at the same level regardless of the size of the literature.

…Benjamin Kohler of ETH Zürich, another Swiss university, and colleagues, let AI reproduce 48 social-science papers, using only the studies’ raw data and a description of the method. The discrepancies between the original papers and the AI versions were due in roughly equal measure to problems with the AI and human work. But the better the AI model, the more the balance tilted against humans.

Here is more from The Economist, interesting throughout.

The post AIs vs. humans in economics papers appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

SpaceX launches classified payload for the U.S. Space Force

SpaceX’s Falcon 9 rocket stands at Space Launch Complex 4 East at Vandenberg Space Force Base ahead of the launch of the USSF-317 mission. Image: SpaceX

Update Nov. 20, 11:45 p.m. EDT (0445 UTC): SpaceX landed its booster on the drone ship.

SpaceX launched an undisclosed number of satellites on a Falcon 9 rocket on behalf of the U.S. Space Force on Friday night. SpaceX scrubbed the launch Thursday night, but didn’t state the reason why.

The mission, designated USSF-317, flew from Space Launch Complex 4 East at Vandenberg Space Force Base at 8:20 p.m. PST / 11:20 p.m. EST (0420 UTC on Saturday, Nov. 21). The rocket took off on a south-easterly trajectory upon leaving the pad.

This is the latest in a series of ‘R’ missions assigned to SpaceX. So far, there have been five previous such missions which include:

  • Aug. 16 – USSF-366 (R-1)
  • Sep. 10 – USSF-153 (R-2)
  • Sep. 26 – USSF-385 (R-3)
  • Nov. 06 – USSF-432 (R-4)
  • Nov. 12 – USSF-627 (R-5)

Following each of these launches, 23 satellites have been catalogued. To date, the U.S. Space Force hasn’t confirmed details about these satellites and has not made statements following these launches to confirm successful deployments.

SpaceX launched the USSF-317 mission using the Falcon 9 first stage booster with the tail number B1100. This was its 11th flight following the launches a NROL-105-, USSF-385, and eight batches of Starlink satellites.

A little more than eight minutes after liftoff, B1100 landed on the droneship, Of Course I Still Love You. This was the 235th landing on this vessel and the 679th Falcon booster landing to date.

SpaceX is scheduled to launch at least two more missions for the U.S. Space Force before the end of the month.

Heavy to Excessive Rainfall and Flooding in East Florida; Monitoring for Storm Potential Near the Southeast Coast

Owners, Not Renters: Raffi Krikorian on Open Source AI

Created by Claude with light editing by Tim O’Reilly

Raffi Krikorian, Mozilla’s CTO, joined Tim O’Reilly at our recent AI Codecon to talk about open source AI. Mozilla, of course, is the nonprofit that helped to define the open source revolution back in the late 1990s. Though its Firefox web browser was superseded as the market leader by Google Chrome, it played an essential role, along with Apache and the World Wide Web Consortium, in establishing the open standards of the web and keeping it from being dominated and enclosed by Microsoft, the dominant tech platform of that time. Now, Mozilla is one of the leading voices working to build an open, standards-based AI ecosystem.

Tim has long appreciated Raffi’s thoughtful, human-centered approach to technology. Raffi writes a newsletter called Owners Not Renters, whose message can be summed up by his statement that he doesn’t want a future with seven AGIs. He wants one with seven billion. He wants each of us to have an AI that we can trust with our secrets and that will look out for our interests, not an AI that’s optimized for the business model of its creators. In the early days of the web, we called the browser a user agent for a reason, Raffi said. It was on your side. It let you render pages however you wanted, managed your privacy and your cookies, and did its best to protect you from those who wanted to take advantage of web users. We need the same thing in the age of AI.

Raffi cited a paper in which researchers tested whether AI assistants could be trained to favor a company’s commercial interests over user welfare. In simulated flight-booking requests, 18 of 23 models recommended a more expensive sponsored option over a cheaper one more than half the time. It’s a hypothetical choice that we’ve seen play out time and time again, in industry after industry.

Open source AI is a big part of what it will take to get to Raffi’s vision. But sovereign AI loyal to each individual needs more than open source models alone. Raffi’s list of what has to be built around the model starts with memory, a place where your private data can live. It includes tool calling, so an agent can make a purchase or book a doctor’s appointment for you, the runtime environment where all of that runs, and the rules for how his agent talks to those working on behalf of others. It needs a harness. “That’s where evaluations happen. Guardrails happen, execution loops happen, tool calling happens, memory,” he explained. “All of that stuff is an opportunity, in my mind, of things that open source developers can be building.”

People hear the word “harness” and conclude that we need an open source version of whatever the proprietary labs are building. Tim asked Raffi whether a user-centered harness might do different things than those offered by the big labs. He agreed. The whole point of open source is for people to “scratch their own itch.” The ability to innovate without permission is the heart of the open source promise.

As a result, Mozilla wants to build a starting point. It aims to help the community define what an open memory protocol, a storage protocol, or authenticated tool calling with the right guardrails ought to look like. As Raffi noted, “Once we could define what those open standards look like, then a whole plethora of people can start playing and be interoperable. It’s basically. . .the internet all over again. We can build trillions of dollars of market cap on top of open protocols.”

Ease of use is still lacking, though. Mozilla’s 2026 State of Open Source AI report says open models are now within about 3% of the frontier, yet they don’t make it into production at the same rate as closed models. When Tim asked why, Raffi explained that open source is easy to release but hard to deploy. Developers still have to figure out hosting, provisioning, guardrails, and memory. With OpenAI’s or Anthropic’s API, you just hand over a credit card. What’s missing, he said, is the equivalent of a double-click installer for getting open source AI running inside an organization. But the companies that do the work to adopt open source AI are seeing big savings because open models are already good enough for most use cases. As Raffi put it, “You don’t need a Ferrari to manage your calendar.”

Raffi’s own daily agentic helper is Hermes running on GLM. He expects that Apple, Microsoft, or someone else will make this kind of agent into a consumer product in a couple of years, and that his mom will end up using it. For now, he said, we’re on the wrong part of the innovation curve, where you have to know how to code to get any of this working.

Tim disagreed. The industry goes through periods that are exciting for developers, creators, inventors, and companies trying to invent the future, and then it gets boring and a few big companies dominate it. We’re in the exciting part, he argued, before everything shakes out. As Raffi riffed, this is when we get to formalize what that future should look like.

The Clothesline Paradox

Tim wasn’t sure that we’ll need a commercially supported version of the kind of “roll your own” agentic rigs now favored by independent developers. After all, neither desktop Linux nor OpenOffice turned out to matter anything like as much as open source developers of the time expected. Instead, open source became the foundation layer for a new generation of web-based applications. It’s hidden way down in the guts of Google, Amazon, Meta, and countless other applications we rely on today.

This is already beginning to happen again with AI. The Mozilla report says that as much as a third of real-world usage is already on open models, although only 4% of model-layer revenue made its way to the open source ecosystem. Tim called the discrepancy a feature rather than a bug, and Raffi agreed that the stat is misleading. As Tim pointed out, many of the most important technologies “create more value than they capture,” and he used Steve Baer’s concept “The Clothesline Paradox,” from a 1975 article in Stewart Brand’s CoEvolution Quarterly, to explain why we’re good at measuring value capture but not so good at measuring value creation.

Baer pointed out that if you put your clothes in the dryer, the energy you use is measured and counted, but if you hang them on the clothesline to be dried by the sun, the energy saved disappears from our accounting. This argument resonated with Tim in the early days of his open source advocacy. As he noted, it’s always bothered him that nobody seemed to recognize that open source software didn’t “win” in the same way as proprietary software. It won by becoming the foundation everyone else builds on.

AI should be thought of as infrastructure

Raffi’s comment that we’ve made a category error by treating AI as a product fits right in with this line of thinking. If an AI company goes out of business, its product disappears. If it changes its business model, it may yank features you depend on. It’s not just individuals who need sovereign AI. Countries are passing laws about where data can be processed and how it moves in and out, and some of those requirements may not be compatible with the way the big labs plan to monetize their technology. What those countries are asking for is infrastructure. A road outlasts the contractor who built it. Raffi thinks open, downloadable models are the only way to provide long-lasting foundational infrastructure.

According to OpenRouter stats, Chinese models now supply more routed tokens than American ones. Tim asked whether we should worry about that. Raffi said the problem isn’t China but market concentration. The leading open models are from China. The leading closed models are all American. Access to either can be cut off by an executive order. We saw a version of that in June, when Anthropic temporarily suspended access to its Fable models to comply with export controls. It’s a problem that both the leading proprietary models and the leading open-weight models are each concentrated in a single country.

Diversity is one foundation of resilience. Raffi argues, for instance, that hospitals should all download a local model as a backup. None of us would run an important computer without an uninterruptible power supply, so why would a hospital doing triage with AI rely on a single intelligence provider? There are a lot of possible rug pulls. The government could restrict open source or restrict the frontier models. Having a backup plan is a good idea.

Safety is also part of the foundation. During the Q&A, an audience member asked about the recent sandbox escapes at OpenAI and Anthropic. Raffi joked that the best part was watching everyone try to one-up each other with accounts of how powerful and hard to control their models are. But he agreed that guardrails are actually a hard problem. Keeping personally identifiable information from leaking out through an LLM call means looking for much more than Social Security numbers. Eventually we’ll have models defending models, but the foundational frameworks for guardrails aren’t good enough yet. (NVIDIA’s safety platform announcement, released after Raffi and Tim’s conversation, suggests that better guardrails need to be implemented outside the model.)

In conclusion

Tim opened AI Codecon by noting that open and closed systems have always coexisted, and that the idea that one of them will win is a mistake. Closed systems, like Apple’s, Google’s, OpenAI’s, and Anthropic’s, can optimize for ordinary people and deliver value to billions. Open systems are better for innovation and sovereignty, and for pushing technology into new countries and new markets.

Raffi closed the conversation by observing that a well-tuned harness can improve model performance by as much as 20% on some coding tasks. You don’t have to be a machine learning engineer to make a difference at that layer.