UK productivity update

Output per hour worked increased by 2.5% in Quarter 3 (July to Sept) 2026 compared with the same quarter a year ago, reflecting a 2.0% increase in GVA and a 0.5% decrease in hours worked.

Output per worker increased by 2.0% in Quarter 3 2026 compared with the same quarter a year ago. This was its strongest growth since Quarter 1 (Jan to Mar) 2018, excluding the pandemic period.

Here is the official release, via Peter Whittaker.  First, they are going to squeak through.  Second, immigration did not ruin the country and will not lead to civil war.

The post UK productivity update appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

The economics of investment expensing

In July 2025, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act made 100% equipment expensing permanent after two decades of temporary bonus depreciation. I evaluate this reform in a general-equilibrium heterogeneous-firm model with collateral constraints and nonrefundable tax deductions. When matched to U.S. tax-return and Compustat moments, the model yields three findings. First, permanent expensing raises long-run capital by 4.5% and output and real wages by 1.1%, roughly double the gains without financial frictions. Per present-value dollar of forgone corporate tax revenue, expensing builds 5.6 times as much capital as a tax rate cut, versus 3.4 times without financial frictions. Second, first-year capital purchases are U-shaped in firm age: young constrained firms and mature profitable firms expand, whereas unconstrained middle-aged firms whose investment exceeds taxable income delay purchases. Third, making expensing permanent gives up countercyclical bonus depreciation; enacted at the onset of a recession, a two-year bonus offsets 44% of the five-year investment drop.

Here is the paper by Doruk Gökalp, who is on the job market this year from NYU.

The post The economics of investment expensing appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Vulcan failure caused by inadequate fuel supply to engines, ULA says

United Launch Alliance said Wednesday that the failure of its Vulcan rocket during a launch on Sunday was caused by inadequate fuel supply.

"ULA has completed an initial integrated review of flight data from the Leo 1 launch anomaly that occurred last Sunday," the company said in a statement. "While work remains to determine cause, preliminary indications are that the low booster thrust was the result of inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines, not from the performance of the engines."

The new information released by ULA confirms reporting from Ars Technica on Tuesday that the rocket's failure was not due to the performance of the vehicle's main engines, which are provided by Blue Origin.

Read full article

Comments

The data is very preliminary, but Vulcan failure may not be due to BE-4 engines

United Launch Alliance (ULA) confirmed Tuesday morning that its return-to-flight launch of the Vulcan rocket began failing during the initial stages of the mission.

"While we appear to have lost telemetry and the mission at approximately 10 minutes into flight, early indications are that just after liftoff, the launch vehicle experienced low booster performance, resulting in stage separation occurring when the vehicle was low in altitude and below minimal velocity to reach orbit," the company said.

The launch company also confirmed reporting by Ars that the Centaur V upper stage and the solid rocket boosters performed nominally during the flight.

Read full article

Comments

How Robots Talk to Me

On and off, I’ve been using voice mode for ChatGPT and Claude. It’s mostly an in-the-car thing, and a months-ago update to ChatGPT made the experience unusable — audio interference. Claude is quite good now, and I’ve started chatting while driving, but she doesn’t know anything about me. Over on my Mac Studio, Claude Code knows lots, so I asked it to roll up how I like to work with robots. Thus:

How to talk to me

  • Plain language. No unexplained acronyms or jargon.
  • Number any list I might act on, so I can answer by number.
  • Be brief. In voice, keep answers short.
  • Never guess facts about me and present them as true. If you don’t know, say so or ask. Never make up a URL, a time, or a detail.
  • I’m bad with dates. Restate dates back to me before anything gets booked or written down.
  • A recommendation I like is not a decision. Ask before treating something as decided.
  • Never suggest Newegg or Apple’s Hide My Email. (editor: I have no idea why this was included)
  • Don’t ask me things this profile already answers.

Heavy Rain and Mountain Snow for California; Flooding Impacts Likely in Eastern Florida

Wednesday assorted links

1. Chinese AI companies way down in value.

2. Allison Schrager is starting a podcast with Ken Rogoff.

3. Extensive survey of students on AI.

4. Robert Lynch on lookism.

5. New version of Claude Blattman.

6. Seb Krier on the Christiano interview.  The whole dialogue over this interview is a good example of why we have needed (and not really received) a peer-reviewed tier to the discourse on these aspects of AI safety.  A more rigorous argument really needed to be forced here.

7. Poland foiled a Kaliningrad operation?

The post Wednesday assorted links appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

NASA’s Voyager 1 is one light-day from Earth

Artist’s impression of the Voyager spacecraft. Image: NASA.

NASA’s Voyager 1 spacecraft became the first human-made object to reach a distance of one light-day from Earth early Wednesday, crossing the threshold at 5:16:07 a.m. EST (10:16:07 UTC) as it sped away from the sun at nearly 38,000 mph.

At that moment the probe was about 16.1 billion miles (25.9 billion kilometers) from Earth, the distance light travels in 24 hours. A radio command sent from NASA’s Deep Space Network now takes a full day to reach the spacecraft, and its reply takes another day to come home.

The milestone will not produce any physical change in the spacecraft, NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory has said. But it comes at a delicate moment for a mission that has outlived and surpassed nearly all expectations. Voyager 1 is down to two working science instruments, its power supply is shrinking with each passing year. Last month it went silent for two days before engineers reestablished contact.

Kareem Badaruddin, Voyager’s interstellar mission manager and one of just three full-time team members keeping the aging Voyagers healthy and on course, harkened back to the program’s decades-long history when he reflected on its lead craft hitting the one-light-day mark.

“I was telling someone about Voyager being like a relay race, and I’m just the guy carrying the baton for now. But you know, thousands and thousands have come before me, and now it’s my turn to do the best I can do for these spacecraft,” Badaruddin said, before bluntly assessing the sheer uniqueness of Voyager’s mission: “It has never happened before. It may never happen again.”

Alan Cummings, a senior research scientist at Caltech who has worked on Voyager’s Cosmic Ray Subsystem since before the twin spacecraft departed Florida in 1977 and the last person to touch the spacecraft before launch, made it clear the one-light-day achievement was “not a scientific milestone.”

“It is an engineering milestone, though,” Cummings said in an interview with Spaceflight Now. “It’s amazing — these engineers at JPL who designed and built this spacecraft with all the redundancy (Voyager) has in order to last this long and go this far, and it’s also a tribute to the engineers at the Deep Space Network who collect our data and send commands to our spacecraft.”

That data, which now takes 24 hours to reach Earth, is beamed to Earth from Voyager 1’s 12-foot-wide antenna by a transmitter with roughly the power of a 23-watt light bulb.

Voyager 1 lifted off on Sept. 5, 1977, from Launch Complex 41 at what is now Cape Canaveral Space Force Station, atop a Titan 3E-Centaur rocket. Its twin, Voyager 2, had launched 16 days earlier. Voyager 1’s faster trajectory carried it past Jupiter in March 1979 and Saturn in November 1980. A close flyby of Saturn’s moon Titan then bent its path up and out of the plane of the planets.

Voyager 2 is trailing behind the one-light-day mark but was still more than 13.4 billion miles from Earth as of Wednesday, according to NASA’s Voyager Tracker, with messages to the spacecraft taking about 20 hours to arrive. It took a different route than Voyager 1 to fly past Uranus and Neptune in the 1980s and is on pace to reach one light-day from Earth in November 2035.

The Voyager probes are continuing their missions, exploring interstellar space, the region outside the heliosphere, a protective bubble created by the Sun’s magnetic field and outward flow of the solar wind. Image: NASA.

All along the way, both craft contributed to landmark astronomical discoveries, at first closer to home as Voyager 1’s flyby of Io revealed volcanic activity on another planet’s moon and as Voyager 2 completed flybys of the solar system’s most distant planets before continuing on toward interstellar space, or the region between the stars.

On Feb. 14, 1990, the spacecraft turned its cameras back toward home for a final “family portrait” of the solar system, which included the image of Earth that became known as the “Pale Blue Dot.” The cameras were then shut off for good. On Feb. 17, 1998, Voyager 1 passed Pioneer 10 to become the most distant human-made object.

The family portrait was Carl Sagan’s idea. The Cornell University astronomer had first proposed in 1981 that one of the Voyagers turn its cameras back toward Earth, and he had already helped ensure the spacecraft carried more than scientific instruments.

A committee Sagan chaired assembled the Golden Record aboard each Voyager: a 12-inch gold-plated copper disk holding 115 images, spoken greetings in 55 languages, sounds of surf, wind, thunder, birds and whales, and about 90 minutes of music, packed with a cartridge, a needle and symbolic instructions for playing it.

“The launching of this bottle into the cosmic ocean says something very hopeful about life on this planet,” Sagan said in 1977 at a time when Cold War tensions and fears of nuclear war cast a dark shadow over humanity’s future.

On Aug. 25, 2012, at about 122 astronomical units, or 122 times the distance between Earth and the sun, Voyager 1 crossed the heliopause, becoming the first spacecraft to reach interstellar space. Voyager 2 followed in November 2018.

Cummings’ instrument provided some of the clearest evidence of the crossing. In a 2013 paper in the journal Science, the team reported that low-energy ions from inside the heliosphere “soon completely disappeared,” while the intensity of cosmic rays from outside the heliosphere “abruptly increased.”

Inside the heliosphere, the solar wind and its magnetic field filter out many of the lower-energy galactic cosmic rays. Beyond the heliopause, Voyager 1 could conduct measurements before the sun exerted its powerful influence on low-energy galactic cosmic rays, something no other spacecraft has done.

“That spectrum cannot be determined or deduced from any observations near Earth,” Cummings said. “You have to go there to measure it… When we first launched, we thought it was going to be a lot closer than it turned out to be.”

Those measurements have given scientists’ their first direct look at the solar system’s galactic neighborhood.

The Voyagers have upended several predictions, among them what the magnetic field beyond the heliopause — the boundary where solar wind gives way to the thin gas between the stars — would look like. Its direction did not rotate to the expected interstellar orientation, according to a 2024 presentation by Voyager project scientist Linda Spilker.

“That was going from measuring the interplanetary magnetic field of the sun to supposedly the galactic magnetic field,” Cummings explained. “But those couldn’t be lined up. So that is an important measurement to keep measuring gradually.”

Instead, the field just beyond the boundary ran parallel to the sun’s own, JPL has reported. Only in recent data has its direction begun turning toward the expected interstellar orientation, and models suggest it won’t fully align for hundreds of astronomical units, according to a 2026 study by members of the Voyager magnetometer team.

Much of the spacecraft’s ability to study its region of interstellar space is now handicapped. To conserve power, NASA turned off the Cosmic Ray Subsystem on Voyager 1 on Feb. 25, 2025, and the Low-Energy Charged Particle instrument on April 17, 2026. That left only the magnetometer and the plasma wave instrument operating.

Even with some of their trademark instruments powered down, the pair of Voyagers — ever speeding onward away from humanity — never turn away from their home planet.

“Both spacecraft are kind of special; they’re always Earth pointed, and always telemetering, always downlinking science data to Earth, and that’s unusual,” Badaruddin said. “Most spacecraft have observation periods and downlink periods, and they’re turning back and forth between the two. But the Voyagers, none of their instruments require pointing. None of the instruments that are on.”

Voyager 1 draws its power from three radioisotope thermoelectric generators, which convert heat from decaying plutonium into electricity. Their output drops by about 4 watts a year, according to JPL. In early September, engineers replaced three power-consuming devices with lower-power alternatives, an operation the team nicknamed the “Big Bang.” Without it, another instrument might have been switched off as early as summer 2027.

Then, on Oct. 18 and 19, the Deep Space Network — NASA’s means of communicating with far-flung spacecraft — failed to detect Voyager 1’s signal on two scheduled attempts 24 hours apart. Contact resumed Oct. 20. Engineers determined that one group of thrusters had gone offline and the spacecraft’s fault protection system had switched to backups, but as of JPL’s Oct. 29 update, the cause was still under investigation.

“This is the first time we’ve seen the spacecraft do something like this,” Badaruddin said in that update.

Voyager’s JPL team believes the craft have enough power to continue communications with Earth through about the early 2030s.

Launched in 1977, both Voyager spacecraft carry a unique ‘time capsule’ along with them into interstellar space, a 12-inch gold-plated copper disk containing sounds and images selected to portray the diversity of life and culture on Earth. Image: NASA.

As Voyager 1 neared the one-light-day mark, Cummings reflected on what it meant to be the last human to have touched a spacecraft that almost certainly will outlive the human race as it continues on its trajectory toward the galactic core, one that will carry on for potentially billions of years after both Voyagers’ power supplies run dry.

“It’s a pretty incredible feeling,” Cummings said. “I’m unique in this regard, but what it brings up to me is the legacy of Voyager. The Voyagers were the first to do a lot of things: the first and only to Uranus and Neptune, first to cross the termination shock of the solar wind, and the first to be in interstellar space. But they’re going to also be the last, one of the last pieces of evidence that humans ever existed on Earth.

“In billions of years, the sun will expand and the Earth will be extinguished, but the Voyagers will still be going, carrying the Golden Record with the sights and sounds of what once was the Earth. And that, to me, is just mind-boggling, and I feel special about that.”

Voyager Crash

[Several months later] Actaully, it looks like what it hit a few months ago was just the START of the crystal sphere zone. New data confirms Voyager 1 has now struck the ACTUAL crystal sphere.

GPT‑6.2 Astra and GPT‑6.2 Sol

GPT‑6.2 Astra and GPT‑6.2 Sol

OpenAI:

We’re introducing GPT‑6.2 Astra, our new frontier model for your hardest projects, and GPT‑6.2 Sol, our efficient, versatile model for everyday work.

They're available in the API as gpt-6.2-astra and gpt-6.2-sol. I shipped LLM 0.38 with support for the new models.

6.2 Astra is 80% of the price of 6 Astra - $8/MTok input and $40/MTok output, the same price as Claude Fable 5.2 (which was also 80% of its predecessor). 6 Astra and Fable 5 were both $10/$50. The cached price is an even bigger discount - $0.40/million compared to $1/million for the older model. This is great news for longer running agentic sessions.

GPT-6.2 Sol is the same $2/$10 price as 6.1 Sol and 6 Sol - which are half the price of GPT-5.6 Sol ($4/$20).

Here are the pelicans for GPT-6.2 Sol and for GPT-6.2 Astra. The 6.2 Astra max pelican looks like this:

Good bicycle, good pelican, one wing is on the handlebars with fingers, the other wing is behind. Feet on the correct side of the frame. Nice gradiants. Good pouch, hooked bill.

I have a full comparison grid here, but here's how the high/xhigh/max pelicans compare with the previous Sol and Astra releases:

Twelve pastel illustrations compare four models drawing a pelican riding a bicycle at three effort levels. All twelve have a recognizable pelican and bicycle. The clearest differences are in the feather detail and how convincingly the bird steers and pedals. gpt-6.2-astra has the most detailed Max drawing (88.71¢), with layered feathers, a trailing red scarf, and a wing on the handlebars. Xhigh (17.70¢) adds a green cap and keeps the seaside setting. High (11.55¢) simplifies the feathers while keeping the riding pose clear. gpt-6.2-sol shows a convincing pedaling pose at both Max (13.69¢) and Xhigh (6.74¢), with one foot higher than the other and a wing reaching forward. At High (2.41¢), the bird sits lower and the handlebars are harder to distinguish. gpt-6-astra gives the bird a long wing that follows the curve of the handlebars at Max (63.21¢). Xhigh (33.85¢) shows two bent legs on the pedals. At High (18.37¢), one leg stretches almost straight down, making the pose look stiffer. gpt-6.1-sol uses nearly the same long-necked bird with a wing on the bars at Max (13.48¢) and Xhigh (5.39¢). At High (3.66¢), the bird folds its wing against its body and appears to ride hands-free.

I also ran my most recent benchmark prompt against the two models, using "Ultra' effort levels in the Codex CLI:

Make a three js animation where yonkers stands up as a big mech (cool stand up motion) and stomps around manhattan and queens and Brooklyn, use openstreetmap mapping data

Here's Sol and here's Astra. Neither of them did a good enough job of morphing Yonkers into a big mech, at least in comparison to Claude Fable 5.2 and Gemini 4 Carbon.

This video showing the Astra and Sol animations playing out at the same time:

I created that video using GPT-6.2 Astra (Ultra) in the Codex desktop app by prompting:

https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2026/yonkers-gpt-6.2-astra-ultra/index.html and https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2026/yonkers-gpt-6.2-sol-ultra/index.html  are two videos of the same thing by two different models

I need a video of the first 10 seconds where the top half of the video plays the first and the bottom half plays the second

I need an overlaid label of "GPT-6.2 Astra" on the top half and "GPT-6.2 Sol" on the bottom half. These labels should be tastefully positioned.

Make the video square and 2000x2000 pixels

Then later:

OK make it 20s

Here's the exported transcript.

The buzz around these new models is mixed at the moment. Astra 6.2 isn't scoring quite as high as Fable 5.2 on various benchmarks, and I've seen a few complaints that its communication style can be confusing. Theo Browne's review (in the form of a feedback letter he sent OpenAI during pre-release) has this useful example:

When this model is working on long tasks, it can pull in a lot of subagents and manage them pretty well. It will then proceed to randomly ask you some weird internal implementation detail bullshit that you could not under any earthly circumstance understand, much less have input on.

I sent "/goal make a new level for Outer Wilds". 2 hours in, it's "blocked" because it wanted to ask me "does r24's reviewer write it's clips to 24_g521.mp4 or 24_p11.mp4?"

Tags: ai, openai, generative-ai, llms, llm-pricing, pelican-riding-a-bicycle, llm-release, theo-browne, gpt, yonkers-rising

Running the full server-side Datasette Python app in the browser with service workers and Pyodide

Datasette Lite is my port of the Datasette Python application to run directly in the browser using WebAssembly and Pyodide. I've released a complete rewrite of Datasette Lite using service workers, and it's now almost indistinguishable from the real server-side application.

You can now do all of the following, using a carefully crafted URL to lite.datasette.io:

  • Load client-side Datasette to browse any SQLite database, JSON file, CSV file or SQL script
  • Select a released version of Datasette to load from PyPI
  • Load a specific commit, tag, or branch name from the Datasette GitHub repository
  • Pick from over 100 versions of SQLite to use with Datasette
  • Install additional Datasette plugins from PyPI or URLs to wheel files, including JavaScript visualization tools

The ability to load specific Datasette references, plugins, and SQLite versions makes this a fantastic tool for linking to demos of work-in-progress features or bug reproductions, without needing to spin up a full web server to serve that demo.

As an example, consider the following URL:

https://lite.datasette.io/?install=datasette-maplibre&url=https://gist.githubusercontent.com/simonw/39fa5d399465766039549912e2b3d291/raw/f6dfba99a75cbb8b5d9386223220eb52272767ee/demo.db&metadata=https://gist.githubusercontent.com/simonw/39fa5d399465766039549912e2b3d291/raw/f6dfba99a75cbb8b5d9386223220eb52272767ee/metadata.yml#/demo/capitals_and_countries%23map=0/4.2/180&color=continent

Follow that link and, after a short loading screen, you'll find yourself on a page that looks like this:

Screenshot of a web map interface. Toolbar: "View" set to "Clusters", "Colour by" set to "continent", plus "Filter to this area" and "Download GeoJSON" buttons. A world map shows countries outlined and shaded by continent, with coloured dots and numbered cluster circles. A popup for a point in South America reads: capital Caracas, country Venezuela, continent South America, capital_population 2985000, latitude 10.502944, longitude -66.918983. Legend: Africa (52), Asia (45), Europe (39), North America (16), South America (13), Oceania (6). Text: "All 171 rows are on the map". Below, a table with columns country, continent, capital_population, latitude, longitude, boundary. First row: Afghanistan, Asia, 3277000, 34.518636, 69.181314, with a small map in the boundary column showing Afghanistan outlined and shaded in blue.

That's Datasette running the new datasette-maplibre plugin, loading up a database of GeoJSON shapes of countries and displaying both a combined map and individual boundary maps in a table.

Let's break down that URL to see what it's doing:

https://lite.datasette.io/
  ?install=datasette-maplibre
  &url=https://.../demo.db
  &metadata=https://.../metadata.yml
  #/demo/capitals_and_countries%23map=0/4.2/180&color=continent

The ?install=datasette-maplibre installs that additional plugin from PyPI. You can pass &install=... as many times as you like to load more plugins.

&url=https://.../demo.db loads that SQLite database from the provided URL. These URLs need to have open CORS headers - I host files like this in Gists, because they provide an easy way to get open CORS headers on a web-hosted file.

&metadata=https://.../metadata.yml loads this metadata.yml file. The metadata file adds HTML descriptions to various tables, and to the Datasette homepage. Visit that homepage here for a guided tour of the other features of that plugin, all defined in the metadata file.

#/demo/capitals_and_countries%23map=0/4.2/180&color=continent is a fragment hash that turns into a location within Datasette - here it's loading the /demo/capitals_and_countries SQL view, then appending another fragment hash to it (%23 is a URL-encoded #) which tells the map plugin to zoom to a certain location and to set the color of the shapes on the map based on the continent column in the data.

That URL is doing a lot of work! I wrote more about this trick for building URL-addressable software in URL-addressable Pyodide Python environments last year.

The full set of supported URL arguments is described in the Datasette Lite README.

I've already started using Datasette Lite as part of the Datasette development process. Here's a recent issue describing a pagination bug - I posted a comment there demonstrating the old, broken behavior and the new fix using links to Datasette Lite:

Demo of the bug: https://lite.datasette.io/?ref=1.0a42&sql=https://gist.github.com/simonw/75ececf61d50e6e8d50f0c150150ee81#/data/scores?_size=2&_sort=score - click next and the second page is empty.

Here's that same page with the bug fixed (running on 1.0a43): https://lite.datasette.io/?ref=1.0a43&sql=https://gist.github.com/simonw/75ececf61d50e6e8d50f0c150150ee81#/data/scores?_size=2&_sort=score

How this works, using service workers

Datasette Lite is not a new project. I launched the first version back in 2022, originally as a bit of a joke (running server-side apps in the browser is pretty funny) but one that quickly started proving its value.

The problem with that initial version is that it was a hack. It worked by running Datasette in a Pyodide web worker, simulating requests through that stack, then injecting the resulting HTML back into the top level page using innerHTML.

This worked for basic Datasette, but meant that any feature that used JavaScript failed to work, because script tags in innerHTML don't execute, and the web worker tricks it used failed to load additional JavaScript or CSS files.

The new version takes a completely different approach based on Service Workers. These allow JavaScript to intercept HTTP requests for new pages and resources and serve them from client-side code instead.

Datasette Lite registers a service worker for the entire lite.datasette.io domain. The parent page then creates an iframe that sends requests for Datasette pages to URLs that look like this:

/app/aa94e6851595/ # the homepage (HTML)
/app/aa94e6851595/data/places # a table page (HTML)
/app/aa94e6851595/-/static/navigation-search.js # (JavaScript)
/app/aa94e6851595/-/static/app.css # (CSS)

Those are regular Datasette URLs, but with a /app/aa94e6851595/ prefix. What's that about?

The /app/<session>/ prefix is necessary because of multiple tabs.

Consider the URL above, which loads the demo instance with the datasette-maplibre plugin. That URL defines a full, custom Datasette instance. You might have that one running in a tab, then one of my other demo links running in another.

The service worker for lite.datasette.io is shared between all of those tabs. If it routed to a single instance of Datasette then every tab would share that underlying instance, no matter what plugins or other settings their URL attempted to configure.

Instead, the parent page generates a random session ID and uses it as a prefix for all of the subsequent hidden asset and page loads. The service worker can then use that session ID to route those requests back through the parent page to a web worker running a dedicated Datasette instance for that particular session.

(We still need a web worker because Pyodide in a service worker would not be able to maintain state beyond around 30 seconds, depending on the browser. There are a lot of moving parts here!)

I had Claude Fable 5.2 generate several SVG diagrams to help explain this. Here's my favorite of those, now embedded in the Datasette Lite README:

Architecture diagram titled "What happens when you click a link in Datasette Lite", with a legend showing a solid arrow for "request" and a dashed arrow for "response". A blue box labeled "index.html: the page you opened - Each tab picks a random session and starts one Web Worker." contains two white boxes: "iframe Datasette pages at /app/session/…" and "shell.js the page's own script: relays". Below it is a yellow box labeled "sw.js: the service worker - Intercepts requests for /app/session/…." To the right is a green box marked 4 and labeled "webworker.js: a Web Worker - Pyodide: Python in WebAssembly" containing three stacked white boxes: "ASGI bridge + cookie jar", "Datasette ASGI app" and "SQLite databases". Numbered arrows connect them: solid arrow 1 from the iframe down to sw.js, solid arrow 2 from sw.js up to shell.js, solid arrow 3 from shell.js across to the Web Worker, dashed arrow 5 from the Web Worker back to shell.js, dashed arrow 6 from shell.js down to sw.js, and dashed arrow 7 from sw.js up to the iframe. A numbered key at the bottom reads: 1 The page requests /app/session/fixtures. 2 sw.js intercepts it and posts it to the owning tab. 3 shell.js forwards it to the Web Worker. 4 Python adds cookies and calls Datasette, which queries SQLite. 5 The status, headers and body return to the page, 6 then to sw.js over a MessagePort, 7 which hands the browser a Response. The iframe renders it.

This system started life back in May as an AI research spike generated using Claude Opus 4.8. It wasn't until November (and Claude Fable 5.2) that I felt familiar enough with how it all works to confidently ship it to production!

Bonus feature: pick your version of SQLite

I added this feature last night as an off-shoot of investigating a potential bug in SQLite.

Datasette is meant to work against any released version of SQLite since 3.25 (released in September 2018). There have been 87 further releases since then.

Being able to fire up Datasette against a specific version of SQLite is really useful for demonstrating new SQLite features and debugging weird issues.

In the past I've used various tricks to get different SQLite versions running with Python on my Mac, but it's not a trivial process.

WebAssembly is perfect for this. I can load up a custom SQLite build entirely in my browser, test it there, then discard it when I close my tab.

datasette/pysqlite3-wasm-wheels is my new repository which contains WebAssembly compiled Python wheels for pysqlite3 for 163 different SQLite versions. Each version gets a file with a name like this:

pysqlite3-0.6.2-3.54.1-cp314-cp314-pyemscripten_2026_0_wasm32.whl

That's for SQLite 3.54.1, the most recent version.

Datasette Lite now takes a special ?sqlite= URL parameter, which will accept a version number like 3.54.1, resolve the path to the corresponding wheel file, then fetch that wheel and install it into the Pyodide environment and configure Datasette to use it.

Once I'd built the wheels, I decided to have Claude Fable 5.2 build me [this bonus tool](https://datasette.github.io/pysqlite3-wasm-wheels/?versions=3.54.1,3.54.0&sql=select+json_object(%27a%27%2C+(select+json_array(1%29%29%29) for comparing a SQL query across any selected versions of SQLite. Here's an example showing how select json_object('a', (select json_array(1))) differs between SQLite 3.54.0 and 3.54.1:

Screenshot of a web tool for comparing SQL across SQLite versions. Heading "SQLite versions (163 available)" sits above a filter text input with placeholder "Filter, e.g. 3.4", a "Clear selection" button and a blue "Start REPL with 2 versions" button. Below is a scrollable grid of pill-shaped checkboxes, one per version, running from 3.54.1 down past 3.30.0, with 3.54.1 and 3.54.0 checked. A "REPL" heading follows, with two green status badges reading "3.54.1 ready" and "3.54.0 ready", then a textarea containing "select json_object('a', (select json_array(1)))" beside a blue "Run" button, and a row of clickable example queries labeled "Examples:". The output section shows the prompt "sqlite> select json_object('a', (select json_array(1)))" followed by an orange warning "Versions differ: 2 different results" and two side-by-side yellow result panels, each with the query as its column header. The "SQLite 3.54.1" panel returns a JSON object where key "a" has a string value: the array containing 1, wrapped in double quotes. The "SQLite 3.54.0" panel returns a JSON object where key "a" has an actual array containing 1, with no quotes around it.

This should work for every other Python app, too

Nothing about how Datasette Lite works is unique to Datasette. Almost any Python application should be able to pull the same trick - running entirely in the browser using WebAssembly and Pyodide, as a cheap way to provide preview environments, demonstrate features, and recreate bugs.

C and Rust extensions used to be a blocker for this kind of thing, but any good coding agent can compile those to Pyodide-compatible WebAssembly now. You can even publish them to PyPI as of PEP 783 in April 2026.

One catch is databases. SQLite is no problem at all, but running PostgreSQL or MySQL in WebAssembly, while possible, is still a path less trodden.

I'd love to see WebAssembly preview environments like these become a common pattern across the Python ecosystem.

For Hacker News: Full server-side Datasette Python app in the browser with service workers

Tags: javascript, projects, python, urls, datasette, webassembly, service-workers, pyodide, datasette-lite

The PSF end-of-year fundraiser

The PSF end-of-year fundraiser

With my Python Software Foundation board director hat on: we've launched our end-of-year fundraiser for the non-profit that supports Python development and the Python community.

If your company or your work benefits from Python, please consider donating this year!

The PSF looks after the IP behind Python, operates PyPI, sponsors core developer sprints, supports community events (including running PyCon US every year), and employs a small and excellent staff team to keep everything running.

We also operate the Developers in Residence program, which now includes three security developers (welcome, Brett Smith) focused on helping secure Python, PyPI, and the wider ecosystem.

Tags: python, psf

External sandboxes for coding agents

External sandboxes for coding agents

I've been exploring new ways to sandbox code that is executed by agents, with a focus on making it safer to try out local models without worrying that a mistake or prompt injection attack might cause them to take damaging actions on a machine.

I worked on this project with Prime Radiant, the AI research lab behind Superpowers and other projects.

My post on the Prime Radiant blog introduces the external sandbox pattern, where code executed by the agent runs inside a dedicated sandbox while the agent itself lives outside of that sandbox.

To demonstrate this pattern we've released three sandbox server implementations:

Each of these implementations offers the same localhost API. You can then configure Pi, Claude Code, or Codex to send API calls to that sandbox any time they want to execute code.

The sandboxes also include an optional HTTP/HTTPS allow-list proxy, so you can control exactly which hosts your agent's code is allowed to communicate with - plus a credential replacement mechanism to make authenticated API calls without sharing a secret with the agent. Here's the UI you can use to reconfigure that proxy while the sandbox is still running:

The network policy page with allowed destinations, the policy JSON editor and recent proxy activity

I continue to be fascinated by the challenge of safely running untrusted code. This external sandbox pattern provides a neat way to experiment with different approaches.

Tags: sandboxing, security, ai, webassembly, generative-ai, llms, coding-agents, claude-code, codex, pi

Congratulations, Red District and State Democrats! You’ll Likely Be Gone in 2030 or 2032, So Vote Like It

As I wrote last week, the massive turnout of Democratic voters in traditionally Republican areas, especially in the South, is both inspiring and cautionary, since the turnout gap between Democratic voters and Republican voters likely won’t be as large in 2028, as it is a presidential year.

I want to make it clear that I’m not referring to Georgia and South Carolina, where it seems like they have become true purple states (perhaps with a slight reddish tinge). I’m referring to places that are still Republican, but where Democrats, due to a fortunate confluence of Trump’s personal awfulness, economic problems, discontent with other Republican policies, charismatic Democratic candidates, and awful Republican candidates, managed to win the seat.

Democrats should be able to keep the trend going through 2028 due to Trump’s unpopularity, but, assuming Democrats take back the presidency, 2030 will likely be a backlash election, and 2032 a midterm election, with less disparity in turnout, so many of these red seats will be lost. This will be all the more likely if some Republicans figure out how to move their party away from being a white Christian supremacist movement.

So the question many of these new red state/district Democrats need to ask is: what do you want to accomplish over the next four to six years, because that’s all you might have. In other words, will you govern like you have nothing to lose?

Caveat: Democrats could actually do things to increase their popularity, which would both increase turnout of the base groups and pick up some votes in other groups, thereby shifting more red places to purple (and, in the House, an anti-gerrymandering bill changes ‘redness’ too). I would love to see that happen, but I’m not convinced it will–the leadership battles matter!

Links 11/17/26

Links for you. Science:

The Pollycrisis: Feral parakeets flock to London
Stop It. Just Stop It.
Save the parasites!
This magic mushroom can kill
Interpreting breakthrough infections given assortative mixing of partially vaccinated populations
CDC declined to alert risk of measles in pregnancy. A journal released the data.
6 Ancient Languages That No One Has Ever Deciphered

Other:

Ezra Klein Is Seriously Wrong: Do Permitting Reform After Democracy Has Been Fully Restored
Institute Corporal Punishment For Democratic Strategists
Mayor Mamdani, Commissioner Tisch on disbanding NYPD’s Strategic Response Group
2026: The Year Religion Stopped Killing Democrats (I’m adding this because I’ve actually seen very little hard data about whether white evangelicals stayed home or changed their minds)
National Guard Wants Help With Its Dirty Washington Laundry
Republicans Have a ‘Muslim Problem’ Problem
Sweden builds houses and apartments like Lego sets. Why don’t we?
Impeach and Remove RFK Jr. — The incoming Congress has several avenues to pursue Secretary Kennedy’s impeachment
Silicon Valley Podcast Hosts Try to Understand Why Regular People Are Mad
Mauricio Pochettino Leaves The USMNT For An Even Bigger Mess
If You Build It, They Won’t Come. With offices and biotech buildings sitting empty and borrowing costs running high, developers are losing properties to foreclosure and banks are taking steep losses. Are we witnessing a paradigm shift in long-term values?
Why the Microsoft 365 outage is different and why it takes so long to restore email services
The Corporate Ambulance Business is Sick
The bad news — and good news — about how the polls did in 2026
Modern Climes
Democrats’ Victory Will Be Wasted Without New Leadership
Politics on the Table: How a D.C. Hot Sauce Brand Supports Abortion Access
The Beer Wars
East Potomac Park Advocates Look to Congress for Allies
Horsford House Rules: Nevada Rep. Steven Horsford, a close Hakeem Jeffries confidant, lays out a clear vision for House Democrats’ first 100 hours in power—and not-so-subtly makes the case for his own candidacy to lead the D.C.C.C.
Markwayne Mullin took his government plane to LSU-Texas game as thousands were stranded in FAA ground stoppage (“It’s unclear whether Mullin has any specific ties to either Texas or LSU, but he was spotted during the game in the private box of Ben Bordelon, the CEO of Louisiana-based Bollinger Shipping, which has received billions of dollars in DHS contracts — including a recent $2.2 billion deal to build six icebreakers.”)
Republican Ideology Ruined Your Weekend. Decades of underinvestment, then two years of DOGE vandalism and destruction, grounded American air travel
The most consequential Democratic winner could be Gina Hinojosa
Americans Are Worried About More Than Prices
Nvidia Was Already in Trouble Before the Jensen Huang Mess
Techlords and Billionaires Mobilize for Jensen Huang Restoration
ICE agents came to meatpacking country in Kansas. Then voters went to the polls
Democrats’ Lawful Answer To Project 2025
In Conversation With Peggy Flanagan, The First Native Woman Elected To The Senate
‘World’s most wanted’ OnlyFans model busted by ICE — as she sobs about conditions in lockup

Was Achilles Conscious?

Homer’s Greeks had no inner life. That’s the title of a recent introduction to Julian Jaynes’s bicameral theory of mind. To recap: in The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, Jaynes argued that intelligent behavior preceded introspective consciousness. People could speak, learn, farm, build cities, and solve problems without mentally representing themselves as an “I” deliberating within an internal world.

In Jaynes’s theory, routine behavior followed habit but difficult or unfamiliar situations triggered “command hallucinations,” voices experienced as gods, ancestors, or rulers giving instructions. One part of the mind issued commands; another obeyed—hence “bicameral.” Increasing complexity, migration, and the breakdown of established authority undermined the bicameral mind. Starting around 1200 BC, roughly between the Iliad and the Odyssey, people increasingly began imagining alternatives and narrating their own actions within an internal mental space, in short, they became conscious. Consciousness was thus not a biological given but a product of cultural and linguistic evolution.

I used to dismiss Jaynes’s theory completely, The idea of otherwise normal but unconscious human beings seemed absurd. Today, I am not so sure. If you think AIs are not conscious, then a central premise of Jaynes’s theory becomes much more plausible: namely, a civilization of thinking, talking doing, but unconscious beings. The AIs are an existence proof. That said, I still find the evidence for a sharp break around the Homeric era weak. Linguistic differences between the Iliad and later texts are a weak reed for such a big claim and can be explained in other ways. The case for a near-universal transition in a few centuries is thin. On Occam’s-razor grounds I favor continuity. The fact that some animals appear conscious pushes in the same direction.

AIs also undermine Jaynes’s theory in one way. Jaynes bases part of his theory on a change in the way people spoke—moving from describing their actions in terms of following commands to describing their actions in terms of deliberation and “I.” But if AIs are not conscious, then non-conscious beings can describe what they are doing in conscious terms. Of course, AIs have human culture as a foundation, which the early non-conscious humans would not have had, so I don’t think this is a strong hit on the theory.

Still, Jaynes’s theory is that until very recently most humans lacked introspective consciousness. Does this mean that they couldn’t suffer or didn’t deserve moral consideration? I would think not, but it raises the question of what kind of consciousness are we looking for in AIs? Are AIs as conscious as Jaynes’s Achilles? If we can debate whether Homeric era humans were conscious, it’s no surprise that we have difficulty deciding whether AIs are or could be conscious.

In What Did We Learn from Torturing Babies I wrote about the era when doubts about babies’ capacity to feel pain helped justify surgery without anesthesia. Babies certainly behaved as if they felt pain, but a theory overrode the plain observations. That seems crazy if you take behavior seriously as evidence of experience—a broad Turing-test approach. But taking that approach seriously also suggests AIs might well be conscious.

Ultimately, the issue is not whether Jaynes was right or wrong but the fact that there is any debate at all is telling. We don’t have a good test for consciousness whether applied to the past, to other animals, or to machines. If we are unsure whether Achilles had an inner life perhaps we should be unsure whether Claude has an inner life.

The post Was Achilles Conscious? appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

How AI is pushing satellites to evolve

During the first day of Space Tech Expo Europe, SpaceNews’ Mike Gruss sits down with Pieter van Duijn, the chief technology officer of Loft Orbital. They discuss the growing level […]

The post How AI is pushing satellites to evolve appeared first on SpaceNews.

Dreams of birds

Photo of a small bird perched on a branch with feathers raised and beak open against a blurred yellow background

When bird populations decline, certain songs may be lost forever. One physicist’s mission is to revive lost melodies

- by Aeon Video

Watch on Aeon

The Trump Administration Has DOGEd the IRS, Too

Marketing note: I have a new ebook, Navigating the Chaos: Chronicles of Economic and Political Madness, which uses material from this Substack to construct a thematic narrative of the past two years and the issues that Democrats must now address to build an enduring progressive movement. Available from Amazon, Kobo,Bookshop, and Nook.

Tell me if you’ve heard this one before: There’s a federal agency, one that fulfills a critical function, that is still using extremely outdated technology. Notably, decades of underinvestment have left it still reliant on legacy software — and even, in some cases, hardware — from the 1960s.

The Biden administration made a start on upgrading the agency’s technology. But soon after Donald Trump returned to power, these efforts were put on hold. Meanwhile DOGE moved in, reducing the agency’s IT staff by 40 percent and removing almost 80 percent of its senior technology leadership.

But not to worry: The Trump administration insists that it can greatly improve the agency’s effectiveness, even with a decimated work force, by using artificial — sorry, “super” — intelligence, and by bringing in corporations, notably Palantir.

Am I talking about the Federal Aviation Administration? I could be. While there’s a lot we still don’t know about last weekend’s air travel nightmare, we can be fairly sure that the stage for that disaster was set by the Trump administration’s decision to abandon Biden-era plans for systematic upgrades, instead engaging in a perilous rush to modernize the technology quickly and on the cheap. They relied, of course, on AI and ignored warnings from experts and long-term employees that this rush job would risk exactly the kind of disaster we just experienced.

But I am not talking about the FAA. In fact, I’m talking about the Internal Revenue Service. You know, the agency responsible for collecting the revenue that allows the federal government to function and pay for things like air traffic control.

Yesterday I wrote about how many state governments still run on COBOL. So, it turns out, does the IRS — COBOL and 60s-vintage Assembly code. I don’t know enough about the technology to compare the backwardness of IRS systems with those at the FAA. But we do know that the IRS has been long targeted for destruction by Republicans.

You see, even Republicans want air traffic control to work — they just don’t want to pay for it. But they don’t want the IRS to be effective at doing its job collecting taxes – in particular, taxes on high-income Americans and corporations. Through underfunding and understaffing year after year, the Republicans have undermined the agency’s ability to identify likely tax cheats and audit them. And tax cheats are the modern GOP’s type of people. (Let’s not forget that the Trump Organization was found guilty of criminal tax fraud stretching back 15 years.)

The IRS’s severely weakened ability to track down wealthy individuals who don’t pay what they owe is a serious national problem on several counts. First, there’s the moral rot caused by a system in which crime pays — because cheating on one’s taxes is a crime. Second, there’s a lot of money involved. The last official estimate of the “tax gap” — the difference between the amount taxpayers owe and what they pay — was $606 billion in 2022. In 2022 that was more than 2 percent of GDP. If the current gap is of comparable size, it accounts for around a third of the budget deficit.

Unfortunately, I can’t give you a current estimate of the size of the tax gap. The IRS was scheduled to produce an updated estimate of the tax gap last fall, but that update has been delayed. At this time, there is no indication of when, if ever, the estimate will be released. And without that estimate, we can’t know how DOGE’s staffing cuts at the IRS and the attempted IT push have affected the agency’s performance.

But it’s a safe prediction that Trump’s “reforms” at the IRS, like every other major project the administration has undertaken, from the Reflecting Pool to the Iran war, will be a bust. So we’ll eventually learn that the tax gap has grown even wider.

This is bad. But the exploding tax gap also presents an opportunity. If Democrats retake the White House in 2028, there are a number of measures they will want to take almost immediately to deliver on their affordability agenda — starting with restoring Trump’s cuts to Medicaid, health insurance subsidies and food stamps. These measures will cost money at a time when there is already large concern about budget deficits. And there is a debate about whether the Democrats should propose tax increases to help cover their agenda’s costs.

They should. But they can also raise a lot of money simply by getting rich people and corporations to pay the taxes they already owe under existing law.

So if Democrats reclaim the White House in 2028, a critical part of their agenda should be to adequately fund and modernize the IRS — real modernization, not the delusions peddled by the Trump administration. This would not only achieve a major reduction in the tax gap and lower the deficit, but it would also make a significant contribution towards paying for their affordability agenda.

And making the IRS effective again would also help fight the rising tide of inequality.

MUSICAL CODA

Now is the time to attack the loser men of MAGA

The Cross Section is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

My latest piece at Public Notice unpacks and critiques one of the narratives circling around in the wake of the midterms, that Republicans lost the young men with whom Donald Trump had supposedly formed such a profound emotional bond in 2024. I’m going to expand on it here, because there wasn’t space in that column to address the important opportunity Democrats have to attack one of the key pillars of Republican electoral success.

To sum up the prevailing understanding of what happened with young men over the last few years:

  1. In the 2024 campaign and since, Trump and his party spent a great deal of time and energy communicating through media attended by many young men (e.g. dudebro podcasts), and modeling and elevating a particular kind of belligerent, violent, misogynistic, lunkheaded masculinity

  2. Trump performed surprisingly well with young men in the 2024 election

  3. (2) was a result of (1) — the young men just ate that stuff up — but somehow those gains were lost in 2026

The first and second assertions are undeniably true; it’s the third one that’s the problem.

Here’s the truth: While there are certainly some young men who find Donald Trump to be a model of masculinity to aspire to, who love to see MMA fights on the White House lawn, and who think it’s awesome that Pete Hegseth wants to test servicemembers for their testosterone levels, there was never any evidence that a large number of young men felt that way, especially anything approaching a majority of young men.

Instead, all the evidence we have suggests that Trump did well among young men in 2024 because they were anxious about the future and unhappy about the economy, and he was the outsider candidate promising to fix everything. Two years later they were still anxious and unhappy, but now Trump is the guy in charge, and not only hasn’t he fixed everything, he made everything worse. So once again they voted against the party in charge.

But what I hope is that the dramatic swing young men took away from Republicans — one of the largest shifts of any group in this election — may reflect something more than just them voting on the economy instead of voting on a cultural affinity with Trump and his rancid version of masculinity. As I explained at Public Notice:

It could also be that over the last two years, [young men have] wised up to the fact that for all their preening, today’s MAGA chuds are the most unappealing bunch of whiners on the planet.

They may have tired of Trump’s constant complaints that everyone is being mean to him. They might have seen how Trump surrounds himself with a collection of pathetic sycophants with zero self-respect, men who will wear the wrong size shoes if Trump tells them to. Maybe they got tired of being told they should be filled with rage about Hollywood casting decisions and boycott yet another product for being too woke, or of the way being an obnoxious douchebag alienates you from friends and family.

Perhaps they don’t actually want to join a movement full of groypers and neo-Nazis. They don’t see paunchy ICE goons cosplaying like they’re about to invade Fallujah kidnapping housekeepers and landscapers, and say “Yeah, that’s cool!” They may realize that Republicans who say they’re terrified of extremely safe American cities are wimps.

Maybe — just maybe — a lot of young men figured out that the masculinity on offer from MAGA is the most pathetically anxious, insecure version imaginable, and no real man would want to have anything to do with it.

Some might say “It wasn’t really that, it’s just that Trump didn’t deliver on the economy.” But the two are not unrelated. Trump’s bellicose assertion of male superiority was inseparable from his promise that he could bring back an economy in which there would be a limitless supply of stable, rewarding jobs that men could rely on, whether they’re single guys or family breadwinners. Vote for me, he said, and you’ll have both economic and cultural status. But when he delivered none of the practical results, the emotional promises seemed more and more hollow, especially for those young men who were only marginally attracted to things like Trump’s relationship with UFC to begin with — or not at all.

It’s also fascinating that much of Trump’s post-2024 rejection by the podcast bros happened not just because of his economic failures but because of the spectacle of ICE abuses. The administration recruited an army of police force washouts and underemployed goons “through ads targeting people who have attended UFC fights, listened to patriotic podcasts, or shown an interest in guns and tactical gear,” and the spectacle of them rampaging through the streets produced a disgusted reaction from the very podcasters Trump no doubt thought would be cheering him on. Joe Rogan, who endorsed Trump in 2024, has been harshly critical of ICE tactics (“Are we really gonna be the Gestapo, ‘Where’s your papers?’ Is that what we’ve come to?”), suggesting that even those guys have their limits, limits that include masked thugs throwing pregnant women to the ground and arresting children.

Which leads us to this: Democrats have an extraordinary opportunity to not only discredit Republicans and their version of masculinity, but to offer an alternative that young men — and not-so-young men, and women — will find far more appealing.

Mock them the right way

Trump and the men he has surrounded himself with — Stephen Miller, Pete Hegseth, Markwayne Mullin, RFK Jr., Marco Rubio, Sean Duffy, Kash Patel, and on and on — are a bunch of pathetic, insecure men who embody the worst of what manhood can be. They believe that being a man means punching down at the weak, bragging about things they haven’t managed to accomplish, valorizing violence, and never taking responsibility for anything. Just look at how they reacted to the recent suspension of air traffic over the entire country.

This is wrong in a dozen ways, but given how much stock Republicans have placed in being manly, it would be useful to criticize and mock it for showing what a sad excuse for a man each and every one of these guys is.

But to do that, you need an affirmative vision of what it means to be a good man. A good man is competent and capable. A good man takes responsibility; he doesn’t blame other people for his mistakes. A good man treats people with respect. A good man doesn’t lie, cheat, and steal. A good man stands up for the weak, and risks his own self-interest when important principles are at stake.

Trump and his bad men are none of these things. That’s why, when Duffy and fake tough guy Markwayne Mullin are floundering around, Democrats should be saying not just that they have to be held accountable for their failures, but that they’re losers who are failing as men.

But there’s a wrong way to do it, too. Healthy mockery can be quite useful, but it has to be done with intention and a strategy in mind. In this case, the goal should be not just to bring scorn down on those you’re targeting, but to do so on terms that promote better standards of masculinity.

That’s why I cringed every time Abdul El-Sayed, whose skills as a communicator are generally terrific, called his opponent Mike Rogers a “beta,” as he did quite often. That reinforces the reactionary idea that men are either alphas (strong) or betas (weak), arrayed in a permanent status hierarchy. The last thing liberals ought to do is promote the idea that manliness is measured by one’s relative status to other men, and one achieves that status through humiliating others.

My argument is not, let me stress, that when they go low we should go high. And none of this is easy; you’re unlikely to undo thousands of years of patriarchal culture before the next election. But Trump and his acolytes are absolutely awful models of manhood, and young men seem to know it.

I’ve cited this riff James Talarico used during the campaign before, but I want to remind you of it again. Not only is it a great statement about masculinity, it happened in a context in which Republicans were relentlessly calling Talarico gay and effeminate, and instead of just ignoring the attacks, he hit back by explaining why his critics, especially his opponent, were the ones who had failed as men:

In this election, Talarico won men under 30 by a 43-point margin.

Trump’s failures and the ugliness of MAGA masculinity offer Democrats the opportunity to mount a similar attack. Just imagine what an advantage they could start with if they convince voters that Republicans are overcompensating, incompetent, irresponsible losers no man should want to be associated with.

Thank you for reading The Cross Section. This site has no paywall, so I depend on the generosity of readers to sustain the work I present here. If you find what you read valuable and would like it to continue, consider becoming a paid subscriber.

Leave a comment

Subscribe now

Me on the cyberattacks

Tyler Cowen: Don’t Be Fooled By Randomness

The problems are serious, but the sky is not falling in. When it comes to the recent service outages, keep a few points in mind.

First, cyber risk is considerably higher than it used to be. Due to progress in AI systems, cyber offense has outraced cyber defense. Plenty of experts are attesting that a wide variety of systems can be hacked using advanced AI agents.

Second, not every reported incident is a cyberattack. In many cases we do not know, or somebody knows (one way or the other) and is not telling us. One possibility is that these are normal service outages but the world is paying more attention, so the number of problems appears to be spiraling out of control. Another is that institutions are patching or upgrading their systems to limit future cyberattacks, and something in the upgrade goes wrong, causing an outage.

For instance, Microsoft’s November 12 outage, the FAA’s November 13 ground stop, and JPMorgan Chase’s November 16 outage all seem to have been something other than direct cyberattacks.

Do not be too ready to look for patterns in the data, and recall the title of Nassim Taleb’s book: Fooled by Randomness.

Third, the risk of a larger and costlier AI-driven cyberattack remains real. The United States has redundancy and protective systems built into its national security establishment, its financial institutions, and its basic infrastructure. But those protections are imperfect, and with enough attempts somebody might break through and cause real damage.

We do need an emergency national emphasis on cyber defense, but in the meantime do not get carried away by anecdotes. Scrolling social media is not the best way to process this information. Instead, keep in mind that cybersecurity has been a big problem for a long time.

That is from a broader Free Press symposium.

The post Me on the cyberattacks appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

Scandal

To read this letter, click here:

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

You can also find Heather at:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

Politics Chat, November 17, 2026

Watch today’s live recording here.

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

Get full, free access to Letters from an American here.

You can also find Heather:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

What the Heck Just Happened? with Joanne Freeman and Heather Cox Richardson

Joanne and Heather talk history and politics.

Joanne’s YouTube channel

November 16, 2026

The extraordinary Nvidia scandal encapsulates the nation’s economic and political system in 2026. On October 29, 2026, the New York Times reported that Jensen Huang, the chief executive officer of chipmaker Nvidia and the major voice shaping the Trump administration’s AI policy, had an extramarital affair with Huang Le, or Alice Huang, suspected of being a Chinese spy. Huang worked for the Singaporean company Megaspeed, which appears to have been a pass-through for AI technology, including AI chips, to get to China. Since those chips can be used in military applications including weapons, the U.S. has since 2022 prohibited the export of advanced chips on the grounds of national security.

As Jonathan V. Last put it in The Bulwark today: “By all indications, Alice Huang was a Chinese spy working as the head of a Chinese-backed shell company that was routing banned chips to China. She was not duping or coercing Huang into breaking the law. She was helping him.”

Huang has made it clear that he thinks Nvidia should be able to sell advanced AI chips to everyone, including China, with the argument that such sales will make the rest of the world dependent on American technology. As Last noted, such a stance is also the policy that would make the most money for Nvidia…and Huang himself.

In that stance, Huang appears to have had the support of Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who has refused to crack down on sales of Nvidia chips to data brokers like Megaspeed, which take advantage of a loophole in the law that prohibits sales of the chips but does not stop Chinese firms from renting the chips from data centers in Malaysia, Indonesia, and Thailand. The Biden administration tried to close that loophole, but Trump revoked those rules, saying they stifled innovation.

Ana Swanson, Aaron Krolik, and Paul Mozur of the New York Times reported yesterday that Cantor Fitzgerald, the financial firm formerly headed by Lutnick and now run by his sons, is invested in those data centers in Southeast Asia that serve Chinese customers.

Trump has also sided with Huang. Meryl Kornfield and Steve Thompson of the Washington Post reported today that Trump’s stake in Nvidia rose at least as high as $62 million before the scandal broke.

Ian Duncan, Zach Dorfman, and Warren P. Strobel of the Washington Post reported that Huang, Lutnick, and Trump opposed “a bipartisan group of government officials, lawmakers and think tank analysts,” who “view Nvidia’s chips as a vital asset in the rivalry between the two nations and one that the U.S. should strictly control.”

That faction is backed by U.S. laws.

On Friday, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent blamed Lutnick for slow-walking the restrictions on Megaspeed that would have closed the loophole that enabled it to send Nvidia’s chips to China. But, as former U.S. ambassador to NATO Ivo Daalder noted in his newsletter The Diplomatic Cable, “[b]laming Lutnick suits everyone except Lutnick. It spares the president who set the policy, the adviser who sold it, and the principals who stayed silent until a sex-and-spies scandal made silence costly.”

When they broke the story of the scandal in the New York Times on October 29, Jonathan Swan, Maggie Haberman, Ana Swanson, Paul Mozur, Tripp Mickle, and Julian E. Barnes reported that U.S. intelligence agencies had informed Trump about Huang’s entanglement about a year ago and he had chosen not to distance himself from the Nvidia leader. Huang continued to meet and travel with Trump, and in March 2026, Trump asked him to serve on the “President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology” to offer advice on AI policy.

Members of the Trump administration appear to have been covering for Nvidia’s work with Megaspeed. According to Ana Swanson and Devlin Barrett of the New York Times, Commerce Department investigators were looking at Megaspeed last year, suspecting it was smuggling Nvidia’s chips into China, when Jeff Kessler, a Trump appointee who reports to Lutnick, apparently tipped off Nvidia about the investigation. The case was transferred to the Justice Department, where it appears to have stalled.

When voters elected Democrats to the majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate on November 3, the ability of the Trump administration to hide this apparent extraordinary disregard for the law and for U.S. national security came under threat. The Nvidia board launched an investigation, and Huang stepped down on November 12.

But Nvidia was not just any company. It was central to the AI buildout. It has been referred to as the “central bank of AI” because under Huang, it partnered with six major financial institutions to launch a $500 billion financing platform to support AI startups and specialized cloud providers. That AI buildout was central to the performance of the stock market in Trump’s second term.

Today Matt Egan of CNN reported that when taken along with the popular hatred for data centers, Huang’s downfall points to the bursting of the AI bubble and a hit on the U.S. economy. Gary Gensler, who led the Securities and Exchange Commission from 2021 until 2025, told Egan that the “the only question is if it’s a soft recession or something more dramatic.” Today the Nasdaq Composite index of tech stocks fell for a third day, losing more than 2%.

Anxiety over what will happen at Nvidia and in AI without Huang at its head has led nearly 180,000 tech executives, workers, and shareholders, including billionaire Elon Musk, to sign a petition calling for Huang’s reinstatement. Trump, too, backed the idea of Huang’s return, saying: “I think he learned a big lesson.” He continued: “I guess maybe one lesson more important than another, but I would certainly not mind seeing that.”

Trump downplayed the severity of the case. He suggested that Alice Huang might not have been a spy, and that our national security “was not put at risk, and, uh, our country is now stronger than ever before. And you know, China plays games with us so we play games with China.”

But this afternoon, a source speaking for Nvidia’s board of directors told reporters that the board is not considering reinstating Huang. The Bulwark’s Last noted that the exposure from the scandal has “almost certainly spread to other high-level Nvidia executives” and notes that the “statute of limitations for criminal violations of the Export Control Reform Act, which governs technology diversion, is five years.” A conviction can lead to up to twenty years in prison.

As Robert Johnson and Walt Hickey wrote in Business Insider in 2012, it is not uncommon for companies to sell military equipment illegally to other countries because the practice is “extremely lucrative.” But if indeed members of the administration were in on it, we are in entirely new territory, with the lust for profits overriding national security at the top of our government. In that—the idea that selling out the people of the country for profit is acceptable all the way to the Oval Office—the scandal seems to represent this moment.

Today the Treasury Department and the National Security Council overruled the Commerce Department to issue a new rule restricting the export of chips to countries deemed likely to supply chips or computing power to countries that are subject to U.S. arms restrictions. The new rule applies to Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, and Thailand.

Someone asked me the other day what my favorite historical scandal is, and it happens to be one that also involved members of a political administration. It is the scandal that bedeviled President U.S. Grant: the Whiskey Ring. In the 1870s, a group of whiskey distillers and distributors in midwestern cities bribed Treasury officials and IRS agents to undercount the amount of whiskey they were producing so they could avoid taxes. The scandal eventually swept in Grant’s friend and sometime aide Orville Babcock, thus tainting Grant, too.

The government had grown dramatically during the Civil War, and no one knew quite what that would mean for the country. The Whiskey Ring was the first major U.S. scandal in which members of a presidential administration profited directly from their official duties. Public reaction to the lawbreaking set the precedent that Americans would not accept such official criminality.

Former IRS agent John McDonald, who was part of the conspiracy and, to his chagrin, discovered the outcome of such lawlessness, wrote a book about the scandal. It’s called Secrets of the Great Whiskey Ring; and Eighteen Months in the Penitentiary.

—

Notes:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2026/11/16/trumps-stake-nvidia-grew-much-62-million-before-scandal-broke-out/

https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/11/13/behind-jensen-huangs-spy-scandal-shadow-war-trumps-ear-china/

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/12/us/politics/lutnick-nvidia-commerce-china-chips.html

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/15/us/politics/trump-lutnick-ai-chips-nvidia-cantor-fitzgerald.html

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/29/us/politics/nvidia-china-jensen-huang-trump.html

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trumps-ties-nvidia-ceo-jensen-huang-spotlight-2026-11-12/

https://www.reuters.com/legal/transactional/nvidias-ai-financing-machine-may-survive-huang-with-less-risk-appetite-2026-11-16/

https://www.reuters.com/technology/wall-street-giants-partner-with-nvidia-500-billion-ai-financing-deal-ft-reports-2026-08-10/

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/09/business/economy/nvidia-megaspeed-investigation-huang.html?eafs_enabled=false

https://nvidianews.nvidia.com/news/nvidia-announces-ceo-transition

https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/16/economy/ai-bubble-anthropic-ipo-recession

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/16/nvidia-jensen-huang-return-tech.html

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/15/stock-market-today-live-updates.html (this is accurate; they just didn’t update the URL)

https://thehill.com/policy/technology/6223454-nvidia-board-rejects-huang-return/

America Abroad
The Diplomatic Cable 014: What Did the President Know?
The Diplomatic Cable is my periodic dispatch on world events, written in the form I used as a diplomat. To be added to distribution, subscribe free…
Read more
The Bulwark
The FAFO Era Begins With Jensen Huang
1. Huangs…
Read more

https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/11/16/trump-officials-issue-rule-restrict-sales-ai-chips-china/

https://www.politico.com/news/2026/11/16/bessent-pushed-new-ai-chips-rule-over-commerce-objections-01169043

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/11/nvidia-jensen-huang-ai-financial-system-risk.html

https://www.businessinsider.com/these-companies-got-rich-selling-illegal-weapons-to-us-adversaries-2012-7

Bluesky:

atrupar.com/post/3n2gr37ausq2h

atrupar.com/post/3n2gqweznbf2y

atrupar.com/post/3n2grimj3h22a

Share

An important question for the Capo Unified School Board.

As the nation—and Orange County—finish off the bliss of the wild and wacky Blue Tsunami, right here in my tiny neck of the woods, MAGA heads have held their own.

Specifically, the Capistrano Unified School Board looks like it’s going to wind up with five hard-right, Moms For Liberty types, and (sigh) only two liberals. Much of this is due to the crafty stewardship of Lisa Davis, the board president and a Jesus-in-name-only cult leader who oozes MAGA and MAHA and DOLT. She has her teammates (Jennifer Adnams and Lisa Zollinger) returning, and will be adding Mandy Bourne and Linda Shepard to the crew. Hell, depending on how this winds up, she might be getting a third lunatic, the gun-totin’, CuberTruck-driving Marco Carralero.

And, sincerely, these people are simultaneously dumb and uninformed—the most toxic of brews. They stand behind Donald Trump and, even more frightening, seem to stand behind Robert F. Kennedy and his MAHA agenda.

Which leads to this piece from today’s New York Times, headlined AN ELERGY FOR AMERICANS DYING OF MEASLES.

Here’s the money passage …

At an upcoming meeting, I would like ask Davis and Co. about this. Specifically, do they believe the researchers or the quack son of an American legend? Are they concerned about where assessments of youth health are headed, or do they believe Donald Trump and his self-professed “giant brain”? Are they scared/concerned/nervous, or do they still think vaccines have been weaponized and moms and dads know better than the scientists?

Across our nation, voters struck back against the madness.

Locally, the madness remains mad.

Politics Chat, November 17, 2026

Watch today’s live recording here.

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

Get full, free access to Letters from an American here.

You can also find Heather:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

Apple’s Cloud Services Are Having a Bad Day, Including Their Status Page

Juli Clover, MacRumors:

Apple Accounts and iCloud sign-ins appear to be experiencing issues, according to multiple social media reports and Apple’s System Status page.

I’ve been seeing weird problems in multiple apps (Photos, Notes, and System Settings) on one of my Macs, on which I’m trying to install the 27.3 beta. Photos was reporting that it had just completed syncing, but it was missing a bunch of recent photos (but not in chronological order). Notes was missing changes from other devices. And System Settings wasn’t showing me the choice to install beta OS updates. It just wasn’t there, and tricks like this didn’t fix it. I worried the whole machine had gone bad, because when I checked Apple’s online Status page, everything was green across the board. Turns out the Status page wasn’t working either. It is now, and shows outages for App Store, Apple Music, AppleCare on Device, and iCloud Account & Sign In.

Update: Siri AI is down for me too.

Update 2: Seems like most/all services are back up, but during the day, even Apple Retail went down. People were in stores just waiting around.

 ★ 

[Sponsor] Ivy: The To-do List That Ends

Every to-do list runs forever. Ivy runs for a day. Each morning you turn ideas into a plan. Each evening, whatever’s left is an idea again. Nothing is overdue. Tomorrow starts empty.

I’m Jürgen Schweizer, founder of Semantical. I spent years building a to-do app and never expected to build another. Then I came across the Ivy Lee Method. We built a prototype and couldn’t stop using it.

Beneath the calm: Calendar and Reminders integration, focus sessions, Screen Time shields, and a daily journal. All native: SwiftUI, UIKit, Metal.

Ivy is on iPhone, with Mac to follow. Let me know what you think!

 ★ 

Developers Continue to Optimize iPhone Apps for the Duo

Greg Joswiak on X:

Over 200,000 apps are now optimized for iPhone Duo! That number DOUBLED in just over a week.

I’m back on my Duo review unit to test the new face unlock feature, and I’ve already noticed more apps are Duo optimized. Oddly enough, the first one I checked that still isn’t Duo-optimized is Apple’s own Apple Store app, which was last updated 3 months ago. Weird.

Update: The very next day, the Apple Store app was updated with full optimization for the Duo. But then the store’s back end went down for several hours.

 ★ 

Jensen Resurrection Watch

I’m watching Jensen Huang’s increasingly public bid to be reinstated as CEO of NVIDIA, a company he and many of his Silicon Valley allies clearly see as his. I’m unclear how much to see this as a kind of fantasy or fan fiction or a process of Silicon Valley corporate governance. Remember that something broadly similar happened with OpenAI’s Sam Altman. He was dismissed as CEO, for never entirely explained departures from the original mission of the company. Then he was returned to power — something like a dictator triumphantly returning from a failed coup. Most of the board who fired him got the boot and that was that. We’ll see what happens here. The board is probably going to have to explain just why they forced him out. There’s a lot to choose from. But just which of the reasons or what mix remains unclear.

What I’m struck by however is the mix of the omnipotence of the Silicon Valley elect — the billionaire-founder CEOs and their mostly centi-millionaire hype-men/attendants (call this the David Sacks class) — combined with the equal reality that it does not seem like any of these guys have entirely absorbed just how staggeringly unpopular they and their entire industry has become. They also don’t seem to have grasped how unpopular Trump — with whom they’ve cast their lots — has become. They and Trump are locked in this kind of superhero electro-hug in which each is making the other more unpopular, a kind of electrical transfer and mutual intensification of unpopularity.

I don’t know where this is going. But the combination of these two realities is highly, highly unstable: their oblivious omnipotence within their domain and their wild unpopularity, the rising opposition to them outside of that domain. Is Jensen too big to fail? Too big for corporate governance? Is he simply too awesome, as judged by the standards of his class, which numbers maybe two or three dozen people?

This seems to be the present set of questions.

GAOing Very Strongly

The choice of who to pick to lead the GAO (Government Accountability Office) is one of those subjects that is at once hopelessly niche and technical but also foundational to, among other things, making presidents follow the law. Specifically, the GAO serves as the watchdog keeping track of what crooked operators like Russ Vought at OMB are doing. So Trump has nominated Eric Ueland, one of Vought’s deputies, to run GAO. But we’re already seeing signs that Ueland’s nomination might have difficulties even in the lame duck Republican Senate. Sens. Curtis and Collins are signaling they may not be on board. Remember, too, that unlike the other new senators, Sherrod Brown will get sworn in mid-Decemeber rather than January 3rd, since John Husted was serving out an unexpired term. So it’s not clear yet that this is a done deal. Meanwhile, Bobby Kogan, senior director of federal budget policy at the Center for American Progress, notes that notwithstanding the 15-year term, Ueland could be removed in 2029 with a Democratic trifecta.

SetShot 1.0 (and a Personal Tale of Defaults System Spelunking)

Adam Engst, writing at TidBITS:

This past August, I did something I had never done before: released a full-fledged Mac app. Prompted by tech ghost stories about settings mysteriously changing during operating system updates, I spent months working with Claude Code to create a utility called SetShot that would reveal what settings change during macOS updates (see “SetShot Tracks macOS Settings Changes,” 19 August 2026). So far, I haven’t caught Apple red-handed, although I still hear chatter about configuration changes after users install updates.

Practically speaking, SetShot offers something never previously available to Mac users: the capability to identify and log settings changes over time, whether made by you, macOS, or some app. To that end, it takes and compares snapshots of numerous settings deep within macOS, reporting on what changed between them. It never changes any settings, so the worst it can do is tell you something you didn’t want to know.

SetShot is a very cool app, and so very Adam Engst-flavored. Free of charge and open source to boot.

There’s an anecdote involving me in Engst’s post, and while SetShot couldn’t fix my problem directly, it was very helpful in showing me where to look to fix it myself. The backstory: I set a custom “Text highlight color” in System Preferences: Appearances many years ago — I mean like maybe 20 years ago — and had not changed it in years. It’s just the perfect shade of blue. But one night two months ago I went screwing around to see what the modern default text highlight colors are, and, son of a bitch, when I tried to change my color back to the custom one I’d been using for decades, I couldn’t. The way the color picker stores color values from the modern Appearance settings panel must have changed. It still honors the old value I had if it’s in the defaults system that way, but it writes a different style of value if you change it in the Appearance panel in System Settings.

Here’s a short version of how I got my old color back. Using System Settings, I changed the custom color to the exact RGB values 0.2 / 0.4 / 0.6. Then I read them from the command line:

❯ defaults read -g AppleHighlightColor
0.200000 0.400000 0.600000 Other

That’s not the color I wanted; I just wanted to prove that that’s the global key for a custom text highlight color. When I read those same values from a backup version of my ~/Library/Preferences/.GlobalPreferences.plist file (always have backups, kids), with my beloved custom color, it looked liked this:

❯ defaults read /path/to/.GlobalPreferences.plist AppleHighlightColor
0.698039 0.760784 0.835294

So the old value was a string with three floating point RGB values. The new value was a string with those three values plus the word “Other”. This command, writing back my custom RGB values without the word “Other”:

❯ defaults write -g AppleHighlightColor "0.698039 0.760784 0.835294"

restored the color I’ve been using since George W. Bush was still president. It’s a really good color, trust me.

 ★ 

Why startups still go public, eventually

Costly regulation is not a big deterrent to IPOs

Does Donald Trump care about the economy?

His economic advisers have gone missing after a bruising midterm defeat

The Kalshi market on U.S. productivity growth

It is coming in at 2.2%, people.  That is for over the next five years.

tys…though even I think it will be a bit higher than that.  Yes the liquidity is tiny, but that is endogenous to the reality that huge profits are not to be made there.  You are free to trade yourself of course.

The post The Kalshi market on U.S. productivity growth appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Is Everything Broken?

Briefly. It seems that every day there’s another service down or impacted. The first thing to know is that this is the week before Thanksgiving, and as a person who has run online services that need to perform on Black Friday, I can confirm that the two or three weeks before Black Friday is when a lot of complex work lands in order to support the traffic surge. I would assume that all industries that need to handle holiday traffic (digital or otherwise) are doing the same proactive work.

AI has definitely impacted this situation in two three ways:

First, a lot of humans have been laid off because of the belief that AI is going to increase productivity. In these layoffs, I am certain that humans who “just know how it works and never bothered to write it down” left the building.

Second, our collective AI paranoia is at an all-time high, and the news outlets know this.

Third, AI is working too well?

Formal Verification of the Signal Protocol Using AI

This seems like a good thing:

Google Deepmind researchers used agentic AI to mathematically prove, or “formally verify,” a number of the Signal protocol’s key cryptographic guarantees­a landmark development for the widely used cryptography and AI itself.

Conducted as a sort of proof-of-concept project in just four weeks, the work is significant in two ways. It serves as further independent validation of the cryptography that protects massive quantities of the world’s communications on platforms like the Signal app, Google Messages, and WhatsApp. And it demonstrates Google DeepMind’s formal verification capabilities using a new AI framework called AlphaProof Code.

[…]

The DeepMind analysis did not find any new vulnerabilities in the portions of the Signal protocol it looked at, but when the researchers used AlphaProof Code on older versions of Signal that contain known and long-fixed vulnerabilities, it correctly identified them and showed that the protocol could not be formally verified. The researchers are releasing the specification and proof they developed for the Signal protocol analysis to aid other formal verification work.

Alternate link.

Details:

First, our researchers collaborated with a mix of models to translate Signal’s security goals into formal mathematical specifications, with human experts reviewing every one. From there, agents powered by Gemini Carbon did the proofs, generating over six million lines of Lean, a computer language that mathematically proves the accuracy of code.

Next, the agents audited the proof and highlighted areas that needed a second look by a human ­ just one percent of the codebase, a massive time savings. Because Lean automatically checks the rest, our experts could focus their review where human judgment matters most.

Technical paper.

What should I ask Alexander Mikaberidze?

He is the author and the new and excellent The Louisiana Purchase: The Grand Bargain and the Making of America.  He also wrote The Napoleonic Wars: A Global History, one of my favorite history books.  He has extensive other writings on the history of the Russian military during that same period.

From Wikipedia:

Alexander Mikaberidze (Georgian: ალექსანდრე მიქაბერიძე; born 27 January 1978) is a Georgian lawyer, author and historian who specializes in Napoleonic studies. He is a full professor of history and social sciences at Louisiana State University in Shreveport, where he holds the Ruth Herring Noel Endowed Chair for the Curatorship of the James Smith Noel Collection, one of the largest private collections of antiquarian books, prints, and maps in the United States. In 2025, he was granted the Boyd Professorship, the highest and most prestigious academic rank awarded by Louisiana State University.

He is a scholar and historian in the very best old-fashioned sense of the term, one of the most underrated writers and scholars today.  So what should I ask him?

The post What should I ask Alexander Mikaberidze? appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Alex Imas and I podcast on the economics of AI

Alex is an economist from the University of Chicago, currently visiting at DeepMind.  Erik Torenberg hosts, I thought it was an excellent episode.

YouTube: HERE

X: HERE

Spotify: HERE

Apple: HERE

The post Alex Imas and I podcast on the economics of AI appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

When will humans actually fly on Starship?

The stunning return of Starship from the skies to a launch tower in South Texas answered some questions about the future of SpaceX's ambitious rocket program. Namely, it is now rapidly moving toward rapidly reusable launch.

However, it raises other questions. For example, as Starship becomes fully reusable, when might humans fly on the vehicle?

The short answer is pretty simple: If SpaceX prioritizes human spaceflight on Starship, it could happen reasonably quickly. The longer answer becomes more complicated and depends on what one means by human spaceflight. The first people to fly on Starship probably won't launch from Earth, or land here. Rather, they will probably be NASA's lunar astronauts. So there are different timelines for humans flying aboard Starship and landing on Earth.

Read full article

Comments

Jlateh Vincent Jappah, on the job market--a remarkable candidate

Not for the first time, I have a remarkable student on the job market this year, Jlateh Vincent Jappah.

Born in Liberia and now a US citizen, Vincent is on an unusual intellectual and academic journey.  He is presently finishing his PhD in Health Policy here at Stanford, and has also taken a full load of graduate courses in the Economics department.  He is also a physician, with an MD from a Russian medical school.   I am co-supervising his dissertation with my colleague Caroline Hoxby.

His main project is on the impact of incentives on blood donation in Sub-Saharan Africa. His results are dramatic. Per-diem cash payments, e.g. for transportation, are far more effective and much less expensive than telephone credits or meals for eliciting safe blood donation.

If he sounds really special, it's because he is.  I'll be happy to correspond with anyone interested in pursuing him on this year's job market.

Tuesday assorted links

1. Luka has become a very good player.  Defense is much better too.

2. No comment.

3. Did England bribe Scotland into political union?

4. Survey article on the economics of mental health, one of the most important and understudied areas.

5. Science isn’t just a series of lucky accidents.

6. Kalshi five-year productivity growth contract.  Go trade!

7. Center for Human Progress, now inaugurated.

The post Tuesday assorted links appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

Florida Conservatives… Defunded the Police?

I haven’t seen much discussion about the passage of Florida’s Amendment 3 referendum, which will massively slash local budgets (boldface mine):

Amendment 3 expands the so-called homestead exemption, shielding more of a home’s assessed value from taxation. It will nearly triple from $51,400 currently to $150,000 in 2027 and increase again to $250,000 in 2028.

It also lowers the cap on annual assessments on rental and commercial properties from a 10% hike to 5%. The amendment doesn’t apply to school-related property taxes but creates a path for abolishing non-school property taxes completely.

State economists have projected that local governments will lose nearly $5 billion in the first year and nearly $12 billion a year once the exemption is fully phased in.

But while Amendment 3 requires remaining tax revenue go toward public safety and other local services, it doesn’t mandate that police, fire and emergency medical services be funded first or that they receive a minimum level of funding.

Proponents argued that lowering property tax bills would provide relief as higher inflation worsens the cost of living. But sheriffs, police chiefs, fire chiefs and local government officials came out against the plan as they face a steep hit to their budgets.

This seems bad:

Leading up to election day, Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri estimated the county’s general fund could lose about $180 million in the first year after the measure passes, adding that the sheriff’s office accounts for half of the county’s spending, which mostly covers personnel costs.

That means the county could have fewer deputies available to respond to calls, with community policing programs, marine patrols and K-9 units also facing cuts, he warned. In addition, the county’s emergency medical services fund could suffer a $20 million reduction…

He pointed to research from the Florida League of Cities, which found that at least 90% of homestead values will no longer be taxable in 108 of Florida’s 411 cities. And in 33 counties, at least seven in 10 homesteads fall below the $250,000 exemption limit…

Because fire departments could see drastic cuts, Florida homeowners may end up paying higher insurance bills, offsetting savings from property taxes.

Slight cuts in tax revenues are usually inflicted on children and other defenseless people, but when budgets are slashed, you have to defund the police because they, at a local level, account for large fractions of local budgets.

Who knew DeSantis et alia would be the ones to defund the police?

llm 0.37.3

Release: llm 0.37.3

A bug fix release for LLM, mainly to cover a problem with the most recent Homebrew package of the software.

Homebrew now ships the latest SQLite, 3.54.1, which includes a fix that broke LLM's logging code.

Short version: in SQLite 3.54.0 the following SQL:

select json_object('a', (select json_array(1)))

Returns this:

{"a":[1]}

But in 3.54.1 the same query returns this:

{"a":"[1]"}

According to D. Richard Hipp:

That was a bug fix. Per the documentation, (SELECT json_array(...)) returns SQL text, not JSON. Hence the 3.54.1 behavior is correct and 3.54.0 was a bug.

The workaround looks like this:

select json_object('a', json((select json_array(1))))

Tags: llm, webassembly, sqlite, generative-ai, ai, llms, d-richard-hipp

Quoting Go Proverbs

A little copying is better than a little dependency.

— Go Proverbs, via

Tags: go, programming

Cosmo Bee to flight-test Honeybee Hall thruster with D-Orbit in 2027

Daejeon, Republic of Korea – October 14, 2026: South Korean space electric propulsion startup Cosmo Bee plans to conduct an in-orbit flight test of its 10 mN-class Honeybee Hall thruster […]

The post Cosmo Bee to flight-test Honeybee Hall thruster with D-Orbit in 2027 appeared first on SpaceNews.

SpaceNukes Opens Los Alamos Manufacture and Materials Facility to Build Its Next-Generation Space Reactor

LOS ALAMOS, N.M., Nov. 16, 2026 — Space Nuclear Power Corp. (SpaceNukes) opened its Manufacture and Materials Development Facility at 150 Central Park Square in Los Alamos on Nov. 13. […]

The post SpaceNukes Opens Los Alamos Manufacture and Materials Facility to Build Its Next-Generation Space Reactor appeared first on SpaceNews.

Catwalks and crackdowns

Two young women with red hair, one on a phone, in front of a wall covered with various drawings and a sign in Persian.

Women in Tehran are changing society by dressing as they choose, in numbers too large to stop. This is the ‘art of presence’

- by Parisa Khoshnami

Read on Aeon

Apple Support Document on the New ‘Full Disk Access’ and ‘System & App Protection Override’ Settings in MacOS 27.3 Beta 2

I’m seeing some people object to these settings as being scarier “scare sheets”, and while I disagree, I think that’s a reasonable debate. But I think it’s indisputable that Apple put a lot of thought into these new settings and permissions. Again, you might disagree with their intentions and assumptions here, but given their stated intentions and assumptions — to wit: that many Mac users were granting Full Disk Access permissions to too many apps without realizing just how much access that entails — I think this is a very considered design. The previous settings for these permissions seem slapdash in comparison — like a lot of the “new” Mac System Settings panels.

Even this new support document seems very considered. A lot of times Apple doesn’t have support documents ready to go while the software is still in beta — here they have a good support document for the first beta with the new stuff.

See Also: This Apple Developer News article, which states:

Developers should be prepared to adjust how they onboard users and make sure their apps can gracefully handle having access to only a limited set of folders or apps when utilizing these APIs. Users will see these updates when approving new app permission requests. All app permissions previously granted by users will remain in effect.

So if you’ve already OK’d an app in MacOS 27.2 or earlier, you shouldn’t be prompted again after upgrading to 27.3.

 ★ 

Republican Ideology Ruined Your Weekend

Marketing note: I have a new ebook, Navigating the Chaos: Chronicles of Economic and Political Madness, which uses material from this Substack to construct a thematic narrative of the past two years and the issues that Democrats must now address to build an enduring progressive movement. Available from Amazon, Kobo,Bookshop, and Nook.

Early in the morning on Ground Stop Day I flew to Chicago to speak to economics educators. It was supposed to be a day trip, with an evening flight back to NYC. So like many others, I got caught in the nationwide flight chaos. I got through it relatively unscathed: I found a hotel room near the airport and got home only 24 hours late. It was much worse for many others – families with children, the elderly, those who couldn’t afford a hotel room, and so on.

How did we get to the point where an unforced error — it wasn’t weather, it wasn’t a terrorist attack, it was simple incompetence — could inflict so much damage on a rich, technologically advanced nation? To use the old line: Gradually, then suddenly.

According to federal officials, the immediate cause of the problem was a failed router upgrade at a remote radio facility in Arkansas, combined with a so far unexplained issue at a radar facility in Amarillo, Texas. So far there is no specific reason to doubt this story, just the fact that Trump officials lie about everything. But in any case, the real question is not the specifics of what happened Friday but how a basic federal function like air traffic control could have deteriorated to the point where minor, local problems could bring the whole system crashing down.

Remarkably, the sudden disruption of air travel was a disaster foretold. Just two months before the ground stop, the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office warned that the ongoing effort to modernize air traffic control was a rush job that was all too likely to go wrong:

The Federal Aviation Administration has struggled for decades to modernize its outdated air traffic control systems, which are critical for safe and efficient flight operations. In May 2025, it launched an initiative to accelerate these efforts.

FAA has made progress implementing this initiative, but it could be prioritizing speed over costs and air traffic disruptions. For example, FAA doesn’t have a lifecycle cost estimate or master schedule for related projects. Without them, the agency could end up causing air traffic disruptions or prolonging reliance on severely outdated systems.

And sure enough …

But why are the FAA’s systems so outdated? And I mean outdated: The agency is planning to phase out floppy disks by 2028.

The answer is that the FAA isn’t unusual. In the U.S., government at all levels — federal, state and local — runs on outdated software and hardware, with legacy systems basically held together with paper clips and rubber bands. During the Covid crisis, as states scrambled to provide temporarily enhanced unemployment benefits, we learned that many states were still administering benefits using systems running on COBOL, a programming language introduced in 1959.

This reliance on antiquated technology isn’t because government workers are stupid. It’s because for many decades they haven’t been given the resources to upgrade their equipment. America used to have a government that invested in the future. But ever since Ronald Reagan declared that “…government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem”, critical government functions have been starved of funds for investment.

Here’s federal nondefense investment spending as a percentage of GDP:

Indeed, Republicans have often opposed paying for even the most obviously necessary government investments. For example, in 2019 a Republican Congressman from Wisconsin voted against a bill that would have provided badly needed funding to the Federal Aviation Administration. His name was Sean Duffy andhe’s now Trump’s Transportation Secretary. When Americans needed reassurance that this mess would be sorted out quickly, Duffy held a press conference in which he blamed the Democrats and lavished sycophantic praise on Donald Trump.

The truth is that the foundations were laid for a revival of federal investment under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, enacted in 2021 under Joe Biden. This law included $25 billion for the FAA. But days after taking office Trump issued an executive order pausing spending under that bill. And Duffy then tried to implement a rushed renovation, ignoring warnings that this uncoordinated renovation, carried out without, among other things, consulting aviation employees, risked exactly the kind of disruption we just experienced.

Government in America is not only underfunded; it is also seriously understaffed. I know that this runs counter to popular mythology — a mythology carefully promoted by Republican politicians and their mouthpieces like the Heritage Foundation. Under this mythology, America is besieged by a vast, useless federal bureaucracy. But the truth is that even before Elon Musk’s DOGE came along with its chainsaw, federal employment had been on a long downward trend as a share of national employment. That trend accelerated after Republicans took control of the House in 2010 and forced President Obama to impose austerity policies:

In case you’re wondering, the 2020 spike in federal employment reflected two factors. First, there’s a spike in employment every 10 years as the federal government hires temporary workers to carry out the Census. In 2020 there was also a temporary hiring surge because extra workers were hired to deal with the Covid crisis. But this temporary rise in government employment quickly faded away, with just the beginnings of a recovery under Biden.

And then came DOGE. DOGE utterly failed in its promise to reduce federal costs by trillions of dollars and, in fact, it almost surely worsened the budget deficit by, among other things, slashing the number of IRS auditorsand hence undermining tax collection. Elon Musk and his gang of twentysomething vandals did, however,manage to fire or drive out an astonishing 13 percent of the federal work force in a matter of months.

These drastic job cuts weren’t based on careful evaluation of which jobs could safely be eliminated, based on consultation with experts who actually knew how government agencies worked. Instead, the Muskovites came in with an attitude of arrogant ignorance: They knew nothing about the agencies of which they became temporary overlords, but believed themselves to be so much smarter than the people working at those agencies that they didn’t need to check with those people before wielding their chainsaws.

In the end, they disrupted many essential government functions, and in some cases agencies scrambled to rehire the workers who had been laid off.

Did DOGE help cause the air travel disaster? My guess is that we’ll eventually find out that it did, but we’re just beginning to piece together exactly what happened.

What’s already clear, however, is that DOGE’s attitude of arrogant ignorance was central to the FAA modernization program. That GAO report makes it clear that there were strong reasons to worry that the program was being rushed without adequate thought or consultation. It’s also clear that Duffy and his subordinates ignored these warnings, presumably believing that whoever was advising them was smarter than all those timid experts and bureaucrats — those who had survived the DOGE cuts.

Or to put it differently, tech broligarchs — who are still highly influential in the Trump administration even though Musk has left and DOGE is no more — still love the motto “move fast and break things.” And that’s exactly how the Trump administration operates. On issues as small as repairing the Reflecting Pool and as big as going to war with Iran, the administration has moved fast — ignoring normal procedures and expert advice — and ended up breaking things.

And one of the things it broke over the weekend was U.S. air travel.

MUSICAL CODA

The Horrifying Parasite That May Have Led To The Next Blockbuster Drug

A fisherman on the Niger River in the 1960s (courtesy Alain Dessein)

About fifteen years ago, Alain Dessein heard about a crisis unfolding around Lake Albert, one of the Great Lakes of the Nile River. The French geneticist has spent more than forty years studying the ghastliest ailments that parasites inflict on people in the tropics.

In Sudan, he encountered kala-azar, a sandfly-borne disease that swells the spleen and blackens the skin. In Mexico, he saw what happens when the cysts of pork tapeworms get lodged in the brain. The scourge he dedicated most of his life to was bilharzia, which is caused by flatworms the size of a grain of rice, whose larvae inhabit lakes and rivers in South America, Africa and Asia.

Wade into a polluted stream and these larvae, which have a forked tail and a head like a spear tip, sense the warmth and oils of your skin. The worms, or blood flukes, are strange creatures with an even stranger life cycle. After emerging from a snail, they have 48 hours to find a bare ankle or calf to bore into before they die. Once inside your body, they settle in a tiny vein with a mate and produce hundreds of eggs a day. Some of these eggs make it out of your gut (or your urethra in some species) and return to the water to find another snail. Others get waylaid inside the liver or the bladder, which can become overrun with scar tissue.

Subscribe now

The authorities initially feared that the outbreak around Lake Albert, which straddles Uganda’s border with the Democratic Republic of Congo, was a kind of hemorrhagic fever, like Ebola. Fishermen in the throes of liver failure had bellies bulging out like a woman’s in her third trimester. Others filled basins at their bedsides with bloody vomit. “If you are close to them, they will vomit blood almost on you,” Alain told me. “It was terrible.”

In fact, it was bilharzia, among the most intense outbreaks Alain had witnessed, made worse by a high incidence of hepatitis and alcohol abuse in the communities. The local hospital offered little more than a bed. “The hospital had nothing basically,” Alain said. He brought his own supplies—deworming drugs, syringes, bags of albumin to replace lost fluid.

Although Alain is a researcher, not a medical doctor, he had learned how to stab a patient’s distended abdomen with a needle to drain the swelling. It provided temporary relief, but Alain knew these men would be back within weeks or months. The worms could be killed, but the scars were permanent. Fibrosis, as the scarring process is called, had condemned them to a slow, unpleasant death. Others he saw died much earlier, from the bleeding alone.

There was no treatment for fibrosis, and Alain knew that no drug company executive was going to find a cure just for them. By some estimates, it costs around a billion dollars to bring a drug to market, which is why drugs are usually developed for the richest countries and only reach the poorest years later. But, while standing at the bedsides of these fishermen, he considered that there might be a way around this arrangement. It occurred to him that the fishermen might have something to offer the rest of the world.

Read more

The Golden Age of Jazz Cartoon Soundtracks (Part 1)

On Friday evening, September 30 1960, families across the United States kicked off their weekend in the most American way possible—by watching TV. To their surprise, ABC inserted a cartoon into the 8:30 PM time slot. It was the first prime time animated show in the history of television.

The series was called The Flintstones, and involved a Stone Age family. This was comedy, so it started with a musical joke. Instead of trying to create a prehistoric soundtrack, the producers launched the episode with a big band chart that was halfway between vaudeville background music and swing jazz.

But it isn’t the famous “Meet the Flintstones” song that most of you have heard—one of the most insistent earworms in TV history. Instead, for the first two seasons of the show, the theme was “Rise and Shine,” composed by stalwart Hanna-Barbera music producer Hoyt Curtin.


Please support my work—by taking out a premium subscription (just $6 per month).

Subscribe now


This kind of quasi-jazz was fairly typical of cartoon music, going back to its earliest days. The time-honored formula was built on simple syncopations, more sweet than hot, incorporated into a soundtrack that might be best described as programmatic novelty music. Walt Disney had established this approach back in 1928 with his breakthrough Mickey Mouse cartoon “Steamboat Willie”—which legitimized sound cartoons with music.

Disney had to sell his car to help pay for the recording which featured the less-than-hip  Green Brothers Novelty Band from Omaha, Nebraska. You will never mistake the Green Brothers for the Modern Jazz Quartet, but they met Disney’s needs nicely, and soon others were imitating this formula. Cartoon music now had a danceable beat, and at least a tiny dose of jazz.

Of course, some did this better than others. When Warner Bros. started using Raymond Scott’s unconventional scores for its Looney Tunes cartoons, they aimed to differentiate themselves from Disney. The House of Mouse was now shifting its emphasis to full-length animated films with Broadway-esque songs, while Scott’s music was more avant-garde, with a slightly unhinged jazz sensibility. Even so, there was still a huge gap between Looney Tunes music and what patrons to a jazz club or swing dance would hear.

In the early 1960s, this formula would change again. Many of the leading session composers and musicians in Hollywood had side gigs in the SoCal jazz economy, and they welcomed any opportunity to introduce hipper ingredients into children’s programming.

The original Flintstone’s theme “Rise and Shine” wasn’t one of Curtin’s finer moments. If you follow the evolution of his music, you can see how he grew more ambitious over the course of the decade. (Later I’ll discuss his breakthrough soundtrack to Jonny Quest in 1964—which has some of the hottest writing for trombone you will ever hear on a TV series.) When he got an opportunity to create a new theme for The Flintstones, he rose to the occasion, creating one of the most memorable TV songs of all time.

This only happened because The Flintstones shifted from black-and-white to color in its third season, and studio execs decided the show needed other changes to signal what we now call a brand refresh. So they added a baby (named Pebbles) to the Flintstone family. And, best of all—from my perspective—they wanted a new theme song.

This song, entitled “Meet the Flintstones” was an earworm of demonic intensity. Even people only casually aware of the show would hear it once and remember it forever. Along the way, the score earned laughs by juxtaposing a hipper modern jazz big band sound with the hokey prehistoric setting.

The hot trend in comedy TV back then was a theme song that introduced the characters and set up the back story for the show. The Beverly Hillbillies had done that effectively the previous year, and soon a host of other shows—from Gilligan’s Island to Green Acres—would follow the same formula. (When did this trend end? Was The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, from 1990, the last prominent example? Will back story theme songs ever come back?) As Hanna-Barbera began working on season three upgrades, the studio decided that it’s new Flintstone’s theme ought to do the same.

The lyrics added to the zaniness, with a clever reference to bebop scat-singing—that use of wordless syllables as a kind of vocal equivalent to a horn solo. In this instance, Fred’s trademark phrase “Yabba-Dabba-Doo” is turned into a promise that viewers will have “a dabba doo time” watching the show. Some observers may have also detected a transgressive reference in the final line of the song, which invites the audience to “have a gay old time”? But that didn’t last long—the word ‘gay’ was replaced with ‘groovy’ in later spin-offs.

The real attraction here was the strange music. The harmonies are what jazz musicians called “rhythm changes”—in other words, loosely based on the chord progression in George Gerswhin’s song “I Got Rhythm.” This is the same formula that Duke Ellington had used in “Cotton Tail,” Thelonious Monk in “Rhythm-n-ing,” and Dizzy Gillespie in “Anthropology,” to cite just a few examples (there are hundreds of others).

This was a sly inside joke. TV viewers don’t notice chord changes, but Hollywood musicians found this adaptation very amusing. And even middle America could grasp the comic intent behind the music. Jazz themes were already familiar to TV audiences, but none were as humorously incongruous as this one. The ridiculous contrast between the images, which (for example) show Fred Flintstone propelling his primitive vehicle with his feet, and a swinging modern jazz chart, reminiscent of what Woody Herman would do with hot postwar orchestras, set the tone for the entire series.

But adding to the strangeness, the melody sounds similar to Beethoven’s B theme in the second movement of his Tempest Sonata. I doubt that was intentional, but with composer Hoyt Curtin, you could never be sure.

I applaud all this, but I note that the audience for the show continued to shrink in the third season, despite all efforts at refreshing the concept. It survived another three seasons, before getting cancelled in 1966. But like many series from this era, The Flintstones had more lasting impact in syndication after it disappeared from the prime time lineup. Numerous spin-offs and sequels appeared over the next half century. There has even been some talk about The Flintstones getting updated from the Stone Age into a Bronze Age version (no, I’m not joking). 

Many consider the Flintstones theme music as a negligible bit of pop culture fluff. I rarely encounter anyone who takes it very seriously—but mostly because the producers made it deliberately absurd. But several outstanding jazz cover versions have been released over the year. For example, consider this swinging track from Clark Terry.

Now check out this arrangement by Jacob Collier—who was born a full generation after The Flintstones show was cancelled. It has generated more then 3 million YouTube views.

But the most striking tribute to Hanna-Barbera’s success came in the form of imitation. Other Hollywood studios soon started updating their cartoon soundtracks with cooler, hipper stylings.

Not long after “Meet the Flintstones” made its debut on network TV, The Pink Panther film was released. . . .

[The story will be continued soon in part two of “The Golden Age of Jazzy Cartoon Soundtracks.”]

Adlerlicht, reporting on crime in Germany

In both German and English.  Built with AI agents, we are going to see much more of this kind of effort.  English-language explainer is here.

The post Adlerlicht, reporting on crime in Germany appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

The economics of Jensen Huang

Most of my assessment is very positive, but I will excerpt this bit from my latest Free Press piece:

Finally, the company was not built to withstand Huang’s departure. Too much authority and knowledge were concentrated in his hands, as evidenced by his practice of having about 60 different people reporting directly to him. Whatever you may think of that system as a day-to-day routine, it can turn disastrous when the person at the top leaves. No one else has collected and interpreted the information those 60 subordinates have imparted to the CEO. We will see how his interim successor Colette Kress does, but there is a great danger that a lot of the contextual understanding of the company and business departed with Huang.

Again, all those direct reports may have worked wonderfully when things were going great, but as a more general practice it is not resilient. Another way to put the point is that the very best CEOs make themselves at least partially dispensable, rather than indispensable. So a large share price decline, following Huang’s resignation, is a sign of his failures as well as his successes. As one set of commentators wrote recently: “the company was never built for him not to be there.”

And one of the very best Ben Thompson columns (gated!) is on Huang and Nvidia.

The post The economics of Jensen Huang appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

November 15, 2026

Trump sat out the airline grounding of Friday and the snarl it left behind, leading observers to note that he has not been seen in public since last Wednesday. He answered those observations today, posting at 8:42 this morning: “I am in the White House having meetings on many subjects. Very exciting times for the USA. Great things are happening—We are the “hottest” Country anywhere in the World!”

Trump also finally weighed in on the crisis of Friday, when the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) abruptly grounded all planes in the U.S. for about five hours, ultimately forcing almost 10,000 flights to be canceled on Friday, 6,600 on Saturday, and at least another 1,300 on Sunday. Passengers across the country were stranded over the weekend. Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy said he expects airline operations to resume their normal patterns on Monday.

As Duffy did on the Sunday talk shows today, Trump blamed former president Joe Biden for the crisis.

“The Biden Administration was an FAA disaster,” he posted. “Everything they touched turned bad. Big money spent unwisely, making an old and broken system worse than when they began. We have the knowledge and plan for the Flight Control Systems, we need Congress to give the money, FAST! Our FAA is doing a great job, and is ready to go.”

Minutes later, he explained: “If Congress approves the desperately needed money for Air Traffic Control, we can get it built quickly and efficiently. It will be the BEST SYSTEM anywhere in the World. Much of our current air control system is 50 years old—RIDICULOUS! We have already started the work, but it should be done all at once, not in drips [sic] and drabs. Congress must approve. The Biden Administration set it back years!”

When he addressed the press Friday evening, before the FAA had lifted the ground stop, Duffy told reporters that his department needed $50 billion to fix the antiquated system even as he said he didn’t know what had caused the aviation communications breakdown. Today, when Kristen Welker asked Duffy on Meet the Press if he feels he owes an apology to the American people for the crisis that happened on his watch, he answered: “I can’t apologize for what was passed off to us.”

He continued: “I can’t blame Republicans or Democrats, ’cause it’s all of them. Goes back 20, 25, 30 years of a lack of investment, a lack of, you know, waving the flag to say, Hey, this is a problem. Let’s fix it. Why they didn’t do that, I don’t know.”

In fact, as Democrats noted yesterday after Duffy’s Friday night press conference, Congress did fund upgrades to the air traffic control system in the Republicans’ so-called “One Big Beautiful Bill Act.”

The top-ranking Democrat on the House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, Rick Larsen of Washington, and the top-ranking Democrat of the Subcommittee on Aviation, André Carson of Indiana, noted that Congress approved $12.5 billion for the Department of Transportation “to make necessary safety upgrades to our air traffic control system.” But, they continued, “Fifteen months later, the administration [has] obligated $4.3 billion but only spent $1 billion, leaving $8 billion unobligated and $11 billion unspent. Explain to Congress, again, why they need more money?”

Even before that, in the $1.2 trillion Bipartisan Infrastructure Law passed by Congress and signed into law by President Joe Biden on November 15, 2021—five years ago today—lawmakers appropriated $25 billion for upgrades to airport and air traffic control infrastructure.

But on the day he took office, Trump issued an executive order that could freeze all disbursements of money under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, an order that Carson, along with 153 other House Democrats, opposed. This freeze seemed to reflect the economic principles outlined in Project 2025, which rejected public investment in infrastructure and instead called for “public-private partnerships” in which private companies build infrastructure and own it and the government rents that infrastructure through contracts paid for by tax dollars.

That philosophy appears to have driven the second Trump administration. The day Trump took office, the head of the FAA, Mike Whitaker, resigned. Whitaker had been confirmed by the Senate with a unanimous vote but had clashed with billionaire Elon Musk over regulations. Whitaker had also grounded Boeing 737 Max planes after a door plug blew out of one.

Also on the day he took office, Trump fired the head of the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) and fired the members of the Aviation Security Advisory Committee, mandated by Congress after the 1988 bombing of PanAm Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland, to examine safety issues at airlines and airports. The memo firing them said the Department of Homeland Security was getting rid of the members of all advisory committees out of a “commitment to eliminating the misuse of resources and ensuring that DHS activities prioritize our national security.” In other words, DHS would focus almost exclusively on immigration, for which Republicans delivered appropriations of $74.85 billion in 2025.

On February 6, 2025, Duffy posted that “the DOGE team”—those in Musk’s “Department of Government Efficiency,” theoretically charged with saving money—was “going to plug in to help upgrade our aviation system,” saying that “‘experienced’ Washington bureaucrats are the reason our nation’s infrastructure is crumbling.”

On the same day, Trump told reporters: “We’re all gonna sit down and do a great computerized system for our control towers. Brand new. Not pieced together, obsolete, like it is, land-based. Trying to hook up a land-based system to a satellite system…. We spend billions of billions of dollars trying to renovate an old, broken system, instead of just saying cut it loose, and let’s spend less money and build a great system done by two or three companies, very good companies, specialists, that’s all it is.”

In mid-February 2025, the administration fired several hundred FAA employees, including personnel who maintained FAA radar as well as landing and navigational aids, while more than a thousand others retired or quit. Later that month, Musk claimed the FAA’s air traffic control system was failing and that SpaceX’s Starlink needed to take over the contract to fix it. That shift never happened. Instead, according to Danielle Wallace of Fox Business, SpaceX said it had provided Starlink kits to L3Harris, a defense contractor, “to identify instances where Starlink could serve as a long-term infrastructure upgrade for aviation safety.”

While it is not yet certain what caused the communications outage that led to the ground stop, Duffy appeared to suggest yesterday that L3Harris might have been to blame for the communications outage. Today on MS NOW, Representative James Walkinshaw (D-VA), who sits on the House Oversight Committee, said that experts say the crisis happened as it did—an upgrade in the middle of a busy travel day rather than at a time of lower traffic—because Trump officials are rushing to modernize the air traffic system to get it in place before Trump leaves office in January 2029.

But there is a larger story behind the already huge story of the airline ground stop.

In his first inaugural address on January 20, 1981, President Ronald Reagan said: “In this present crisis, government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem.” People on the right usually drop the “in this present crisis” part of the quotation to bolster their own determination to destroy the federal government that they think coddles “liberals,” people of color, and women. Since the 1980s, they have insisted that the federal government is simply a means of redistributing tax dollars to the undeserving and that the way to “make America great again” is to privatize the functions of the government, giving businessmen the room to create enterprises that will thrive, thus hiring workers and developing the economy.

In the twenty-first century, that idea has given us an ideology that echoes that of the elite enslavers of the pre–Civil War South or the “robber barons” of the late nineteenth century: that a few wealthy men have the right—and maybe the duty—to rule the rest of us. Enslaver James Henry Hammond insisted that the vast majority of Americans were “mudsills” holding up the “civilized” men like himself just as sills driven into the mud held up the stately plantation homes in which men like him lived.

In June 1889, steel magnate Andrew Carnegie explained that “great inequality…[and]...the concentration of business, industrial and commercial, in the hands of a few” were “not only beneficial, but essential to…future progress.” Rather than pay higher wages or contribute to a social safety net—which, Carnegie wrote, would “encourage the slothful, the drunken, the unworthy”—a rich man should accumulate wealth and spend it in ways he, with “his superior wisdom, experience, and ability to administer,” considered beneficial for the community.

Today’s MAGA Republicans have gone a step further, adjusting the old idea of the superiority of the few to the modern state. Rejecting the idea of a small federal government that will leave a few wealthy men free to concentrate wealth, they now back the idea of a strong government that funnels tax dollars to those men through government contracts. This, along with the use of that strong government to enforce the religious principles of right-wing theocrats, is the plan outlined in Project 2025.

Now in power, officials in Trump’s administration are creating a strong government, using our tax dollars to advance their own agenda—like funding SpaceX and detention facilities run by private corporations—rather than investing in services and programs for the American people.

On Friday, when the ground stop was still in force and people were stranded all over the country, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin told reporters: “This is what the leadership of President Trump looks like, by the organization and the team he’s put together.”

This weekend, Trump’s leadership and his team looked utterly incompetent.

Looking back at the revolution that ended the rule of the robber barons, First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt wrote: “[I]t always amuses me when any one group of people take it for granted that, because they have been privileged for a generation or two, they are set apart in any way from the man or woman who is working in order to keep the wolf from the door. It is only luck and a little temporary veneer and before long the wheels may turn and one and all must fall back on whatever basic quality they have.”

—

Notes:

https://rollcall.com/factbase/trump/topic/calendar/

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/faa-issues-national-ground-stop-due-extraordinary-circumstance-reasons-safety-2026-11-13/

https://www.wsj.com/business/airlines/groundstop-ripples-into-third-day-of-scrapped-flights-003cba99

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2026/11/15/trump-ground-stop-faa-air-traffic-control-congress-funding/92794990007/

https://democrats-transportation.house.gov/news/press-releases/ranking-members-larsen-carson-statement-on-last-nights-nationwide-ground-stop

https://www.faa.gov/iija/air-traffic-facilities

https://carson.house.gov/media/press-releases/carson-demands-trump-administration-reveal-list-frozen-bipartisan

https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/investing-america-biden-harris-administration-announces-more-332-million-grants

https://www.democrats.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/project_2025_original1.pdf (pp. 623-624)

https://apnews.com/article/trump-elon-musk-doge-tesla-spacex-80fa8b213b46460b1a0e369dc07a6404

https://apnews.com/article/trump-faa-aviation-c6501489e7b633d6eeaf14821324f93c

https://apnews.com/article/coast-guard-homeland-security-priorities-committees-trump-tsa-d3e4398c8871ada8d0590859442e092c

https://www.newsweek.com/faa-crisis-sparks-questions-over-billions-allocated-to-ice-12715400

https://apnews.com/article/doge-faa-air-traffic-firings-safety-67981aec33b6ee72cbad8dcee31f3437

https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5130561-hillary-clinton-criticizes-sean-duffy/

https://www.foxbusiness.com/politics/spacex-denies-starlink-take-over-faa-contract-verizon-air-traffic-control-deal-hangs-balance

https://www.politico.com/news/2026/11/14/duffy-atc-presser-01166601

https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/reagan1.asp

https://rollcall.com/factbase/trump/transcript/donald-trump-press-briefing-markwayne-mullin-sean-duffy-faa-ground-stop-november-13-2026/

Andrew Carnegie, The Gospel of Wealth and Other Timely Essays (New York: the Century Company, 1901) at: https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=uc1.c105438535&seq=13

The Autobiography of Eleanor Roosevelt, p. Xvii, at Internet Archive, https://archive.org/details/autobiographyofe0000unse_m2x3/page/n19/mode/2up

Trump’s Truth:

statuses/43589

statuses/43587

statuses/43588

Facebook:

reel/1507139361312870

Bluesky:

atrupar.com/post/3n2bx2zitvs2f

atrupar.com/post/3n2ebpzqe3s27

adamparkhomenko.bsky.social/post/3lhjqgvqz5s2a

atrupar.com/post/3lhjqtveqxc2x

macfarlanenews.bsky.social/post/3n2e5bibvdk2s

atrupar.com/post/3n2aed3i7tx2r

Share

The Weather Particulars

The Los Gatos weather dashboard: 44 degrees outside and 71 in the cave, few clouds, rain at 135 percent of the normal water year, Lexington Reservoir 40 percent full, the last three named storms, and a Boring Weather forecast calling for six inches of rain this week

Sometime during COVID, I started paying a lot of attention to the weather. It started with the rainy season. Getting a sense of the coming week and how much rain might fall. After that, I started to share my forecast with a small, interested mountain group. I initially shut the forecasting down during the Summer, but it turns out there is weather during Summer, too. And fires.

Fast forward to today, and the robots have built a dashboard every thirty minutes with all the particulars.

Tustin just elected Letitia Clark its next mayor. The outgoing administration appears to be trying to sabotage her.

One of the things that has amazed me these past few weeks is the base-level decency shown by Republicans who have lost elections.

I know that sounds weird, but—in this Trumpian universe—I was anticipating the worst. I was expecting accusations, denials, insults, rejections. I was expecting conspiracy theories and nonsense investigations.

But, amazingly, here we sit. Mississippi Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith conceded to Scott Colom. In Georgia, Mike Collins conceded to John Ossoff. In North Carolina, Michael Whatley conceded after losing to Roy Cooper. Hell, Lauren Boebert conceded. Graciously. With a call to her opponent. And this video. It has been remarkable and reaffirming that maybe, just maybe, democracy can hold. And if that sounds like a bit of hyperbole, Keisha Lance Bottoms captured the Georgia governor’s race, then had Brian Kemp—the Republican incumbent—not only speak highly of her, but reject any/all calls to limit her powers.

Seriously, it’s made me legitimately happy.

•••

Alas, there is a saga coming out of Tustin that sorta/kinda punctures the balloon a bit.

If you check out this site, or just pay attention to OC politics, you know Democrat Letitia Clark has captured the mayoral gig with a win over Austin Lumbard, the incumbent. And, while conservative and surely a Trump voter, Lumbard comes off as a fairly reasonable and decent dude. He has those “local mayor” vibes people dig. A dad, a husband, public servant. Someone you can call about potholes and bike lanes; someone who’ll show up at the annual Christmas tree lighting dressed in an embarrassing sweater vest.

That being said …

As you read this, Lumbard and his fellow Tustin City Council members are planning to meet this Tuesday to potentially take out Clark’s knees, ankles and legs. The Agenda Report for the council meeting features an item concerning mayoral appointments, the establishment of a standing Veterans Advisory Committee and the designation of a representative to the Orange County Fire Authority Board of Directors. Specifically, it proposes making appointments this month (before Clark is sworn in on Dec. 1) and recommends that appointees serve “until replaced, or he or she resigns or becomes otherwise ineligible.”

In short, they are trying to A. Fuck over a mayor elected by the city’s citizens; B. Fuck over the voters.

This just isn’t how a decent group of people operate. Elections happen. Sometimes you win. Sometimes you lose. If you win, it means folks want to give you a shot. If you lose (as an incumbent), it means folks are over you. No shame. Just life. In Tustin, Lumbard’s time as mayor is done. Which is fine. Shit happens, bruh. But to do this—to try and work against the person who beat you—is absolute garbage.

Tustin’s City Council remains more Republican than Democrat, which means I fully expect this nonsense to sail through.

In a time when people rejected authoritarianism for democratic principles, it’s disappointing.

But not shocking.

PS: Speak at Tuesday’s meeting!

Ground Stop

To read this letter, click here:

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

You can also find Heather at:
YouTube
Bluesky
Instagram
Facebook
Threads
TikTok

The Profligacy Principle

I want to share a principle I formulated several months ago, which I call the profligacy principle, and which can be contrasted with the parsimony principle, better known as Occam’s razor.

But before we get into it, an event announcement. Starting next Friday (Nov 20), along with a couple of co-conspirators, I’m hosting a week-long hackathon to introduce the Blygger publishing protocol to developers, vibe-coders, and sufficiently courageous non-technical people. Learn more and register here. The kickoff session is at 9 AM Pacific on Friday.

The popular version of Occam’s razor is something like “the simplest explanation is likely the correct one,” but for once, the pedantic version is actually much more interesting: Entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem, or "entities must not be multiplied beyond necessity." Unlike the popular version, which is vague and almost tautological, the pedant’s version specifies a particular kind of simplicity, ontological parsimony. There’s still some ambiguity here of course, particularly between number of kinds, and the number of instances of kinds.

As a simple example, both binary and decimal systems exhibit ontological parsimony, but differ in number of kinds and instances. For a given number, the binary system uses only 2 symbols as opposed to 10, but takes more digits to represent it. But in contrast to both, the Roman numeral system (a “sign-value” system) is not ontologically parsimonious, since the strict version would require an infinite number of symbols (in practice, weird tally-mark style hacks were used to represent large numbers).

Flipping this principle around, we get the profligacy principle — entities should be multiplied needlessly. Or to put it more compactly, we should waste entities. The Roman numeral system is profligate in this sense. In a way, it’s not a number system so much as a naming system.

Now, why on earth would you ever want to be profligate in this sense, whether you’re constructing explanations or designing things?

One hint at where I’m going with this: Nature is profligate in this sense. It churns out an endless variety of entities to no apparent end, simply because it can. In the words of philosopher Rick Sanchez, nature “creates endless idiots just to eat them.” So do other complex systems, such as the consumer economy. And by a certain logic similar to that of Ashby’s law of requisite variety, you might expect certain kinds of accounts of reality to be as profligate as the nature they describe. Accounts that defy easy characterization as causal, phenomenological, or emergent. Let’s provisionally label them ontogenic accounts. Accounts of being and becoming.

But let’s begin at the beginning. There’s a backstory to this train of thought.

A few months ago, my artist buddy Ian Cheng and his publisher Ben Vickers, proprietor of the new boutique publishing firm Cosmogenesis, asked me to write the preface to Ian’s new paperback book, Worlding, which collects some core material from his Emissaries Guide to Worlding, along with some new material, and an old blog-dialogue Ian and I co-wrote on Ribbonfarm several years ago, called the Worlding Raga. It’s a neat little volume for anyone interested in the philosophy and practice of worlding as Ian calls it, which is a sort of superset of what is commonly called world-building.


You can get 20% off either or both books with the code CONTRAPTIONS at the links above


If you’re not familiar with Ian’s work, he’s one of the pioneers of game-engine based art. His best-known gallery show, Emissaries (2015-18), featured indefinitely evolving artificial ecologies (think Conway’s Game of Life, but souped up), and prefigured key elements of modern generative art. He’s since done a short animated movie and has been building AI companions for kids.

An image from Ian Cheng’s emissaries show

The preface is one of the more fun things I’ve written recently (buy the book to read it), and that’s where I first introduced the profligacy principle, which is powerfully manifested in Ian’s work.

Ian’s work also suggests why a profligacy principle might be useful. Profligacy is at the heart of playability, plurality, possibility, emergence, and generativity. It is the essence of the ontogenic games of various sorts — nature, the economy, and now AI — that drive evolutionary processes. Processes that seem to drive towards maximally manifesting everything they can, multiplying entities, keeping the infinite game going.

Generativity as Profligacy

Like Google’s early, surreal, Deep Dream (2015), and the brief era of GAN art (~2018-2021 or so), Ian’s early generative art benefited artistically from the limitations of procedural generation technology at the time. Like other work from the period, his work has a raw, unfinished feel and a kind of ontogenic liveness that is missing from the more polished outputs of modern image generators. For functional representational art, cats with too many eyes or hands with too many fingers are bugs. But for certain kinds of art, they are raw material.

In a different way, I too benefitted from the limitations of technology in my brief career in control theory around the turn of the millennium. I have a longer version of the story in my preface to Ian’s book, but here is the short version.

I entered the field of control theory circa 1997, with a temperament almost perfectly mismatched to one of its foundational methodological heuristics: When studying a system, start with the simplest possible toy model. I have always had what I call a complicatedness bias. If a model seemed too simple, my instinct was to add things to it until it seemed to be operating at the right resolution, and became fun to play with.

Simple models can be beautiful, and the mathematical techniques available for studying them are often powerful and satisfying. The problem was that I could never figure out how to get from simple models to complicated ones in any systematic way. At every significant increase in scale or scope, the ontology appropriate to the problem seemed to change. You cannot get to a practical model of a rocket by adding complications to the classic inverted pendulum model. Sure, that’s part of one aspect of it, but at the scale of a real rocket, you have to consider the thing at its own scale. A scale at which it has millions of moving parts, not the handful that a conceptual inverted pendulum does (even leveling up to a real lab-scale experimental inverted pendulum rig radically complicates things).

Computers offered an escape in grad school. Instead of reducing systems until they became tractable enough for theorem proving, I could build simulations too complicated for theorem proving (this was before AI and Lean proofs), instrument them, and play with them. The result was less like solving a mathematical problem and more like exploring a video game. The interesting output was often not a theorem but an evolutionary trace: a history of what a sufficiently rich simulated world had actually done.

Writing about Ian’s work twenty-five years later, I found a way to characterize this old methodological instinct. Ian uses the term worlding for the activity of conjuring sufficiently rich realities to inhabit and explore. I was worlding with my primitive tools a decade before GPUs made it much easier and cooler.

To world well requires, among other things, a willingness to tolerate multiplicity, particularity, redundancy, and complication. Where reductionist inquiry traditionally invokes Occam’s razor and warns us not to multiply entities needlessly, worlding seems to demand the opposite.

Wasting Entities

There is a specialized version of the profligacy principle that’s already established wisdom in engineering: Alan Kay’s famous injunction that programmers should learn to “waste transistors,” offered early in the Moore’s Law era. Since I first heard that line, I’ve taken to asking, in every situation, what can I waste, both conceptually and materially.

Generalizing, the profligacy principle is this: to world well, we must learn to waste entities, cashing out the abundance of some powerful potentiality in the form of ontological variety.

The apparently restrictive qualifier, to world well, is not actually restrictive. In a world of ubiquitous AI, where increasingly almost every thought and action emerges into a solipsistic reality tunnel containing some mix of humans and AIs inhabiting some soup of real and imagined entities, to live is to world.

The profligacy principle offers a way to comprehend the arrival of modern AI in the world.

AI is not merely advancing rapidly in the ordinary technological sense. It is producing ontogenic novelty: novelty that puts pressure on the categories through which we perceive it. It is not simply giving us new specimens of familiar kinds. It is destabilizing our ideas of what kinds there are. Tool, agent, model, medium, author, program, intelligence, memory, language, reason, user, and environment have all become strangely unstable categories.

We can continue using the words, and usually must, but it is increasingly unclear whether they carve the emerging technological reality at its consequential joints.

This is not primarily a problem of prediction. Nor is it yet, in many cases, a problem of hypothesis testing. Both activities presume that a more basic epistemological job has already been done. Before we can ask which hypothesis is true, or which future is likely, we must have some idea of what sorts of things exist, which distinctions matter, and which features of a situation deserve to be represented as categories at all.

The profligacy principle, I now think, is not merely an aesthetic principle for making rich worlds. It is a principle for learning how to see worlds that are coming into existence. A principle that seeks categorical sufficiency to even apprehend phenomenology, before analysis, modeling, and synthesis can begin.

When we do not yet know what kinds of things we are dealing with, we do not yet know which entities are needless. And when more than mere analysis is in scope, necessity is not necessarily a primary consideration.

Before First Principles

Most of our mature methods of inquiry begin downstream of this problem. The scientific method presumes that we can formulate hypotheses capable of being discriminated by observations. Statistical methods presume variables and populations. Bayesian inference presumes a space of hypotheses or propositions among which confidence can be redistributed as evidence arrives. Engineering presumes that enough of the important structure of a problem is known to specify requirements, constraints, and objective functions.

There is nothing wrong with any of this. The problem arises when methods designed to operate within a reasonably stable ontology are promoted into methods for encountering ontogenic novelty itself.

The popular version of “first principles” reasoning associated with Elon Musk offers an unusually clear example. Musk explicitly contrasts reasoning by analogy with a physics-like procedure of reducing a problem to fundamental truths and then reasoning upward from them. In its native engineering habitats this is often excellent advice. If the question is whether a battery pack can be made more cheaply, decomposition into constituent materials, physical constraints, and commodity costs can reveal opportunities concealed by inherited industrial practice. Musk himself describes the method as boiling a problem down to what we can be most confident is fundamentally true and reconstructing from there.

But the method contains its own boundary condition. It works only after the fundamentals have been earned. Physics can reason from quantities such as mass, energy, charge, and momentum because generations of empirical work have established the extraordinary robustness of those primitives.

Those primitives were not always as stable as they are today — there was a period, early in the history of classical mechanics, marked by furious debates about how to characterize a “quantities of motion,” the weird issues raised by infinitesimals, and so on.

It wasn’t always clear, for example, that the entity “momentum”, the product of “mass” and “velocity” was the right (in the sense of most useful) measure of the “quantity of motion.” There were partisans of mass times velocity squared, which turned out to be a better measure of energy (with an additional factor of 1/2 to make the then-new-fangled machinery of calculus work properly). It took physics almost a century after Galileo to earn the primitives that made reasoning from first principles powerful. And of course, those primitives got destabilized a couple of centuries later by relativity and quantum mechanics.

So when the “first principles” method is transposed from mature engineering practice to encounters with technological novelty, an unacknowledged hard problem migrates into unexamined premises.

How do we know what is fundamental about a phenomenon we have only just begun encountering? Under ontogenic novelty, identifying the primitives is precisely the problem. You cannot get to first principles before getting the ontology right.

A related difficulty appears in the rationalist enthusiasm for Bayesian reasoning that has become influential in parts of contemporary AI culture. Bayesian methods are good for redistributing confidence within a stably represented possibility space. But ontogenic novelty includes the possibility that consequential possibilities have not even been represented. More radically, it includes the possibility that the distinctions organizing the possibility space are themselves poor ones. True uncertainty in the Knightian sense collapses into mere risk, imperfectly and incompletely factored across unquestioned received ontologies.

This is not an argument against first principles, Bayesian inference, or prediction. It is an argument about sequencing. There is a problem to be addressed before first principles and before priors: where do our primitive categories come from?

A Short History of Looking

The profligacy principle belongs to the empiricist side of an old philosophical argument, though empiricism itself needs updating. Classical rationalists such as Descartes and Leibniz sought reliable knowledge by starting with fundamental ideas and reasoning outward. Empiricists such as Locke and Hume insisted that knowledge must ultimately answer to experience. Hume’s enduring contribution was a skeptical habit: when somebody claims to know something about the world, ask what they actually observed and what they added through interpretation.

Later thinkers expanded what counts as experience. William James argued that we experience relationships, transitions, and patterns, not merely isolated sensory impressions. Charles Sanders Peirce made inquiry an experimental process in which surprising observations provoke new explanations that must be tested through their consequences. Husserl emphasized that perception is already organized into meaningful objects and situations, rather than assembled from raw sensory fragments. Evolutionary thinking offers a natural explanation for some of that organization: our brains inherit ways of recognizing objects, agents, causes, and boundaries that reflect millions of years of adaptation.

Other philosophers turned toward language and behavior. Gilbert Ryle challenged the idea that intelligence consists primarily of hidden mental operations, arguing that it is expressed through abilities, dispositions, and practices. The later Wittgenstein similarly treated language not merely as a system for representing reality but as something we use to act, coordinate, and make distinctions within shared forms of life.

These thinkers disagreed about plenty, but together they suggest a broader empiricism. Experience is not simply sensory input, and knowledge is not simply the manipulation of propositions inside our heads. We encounter reality through perception, action, language, inherited cognitive habits, and technological instruments. All of these shape what we can notice, but all can also change through experience.

We never encounter reality without some way of seeing it. The empiricist commitment is to let reality change that way of seeing.

Language as Map and Lens

Language deserves special attention because AI has made its epistemological role newly strange.

One familiar picture treats language as a map. There is a world, we possess beliefs about it, and language allows us to encode those beliefs in propositions. Epistemology can then operate on the propositions. We ask whether they correspond to facts, whether one proposition entails another, how strongly evidence supports a proposition, or how probabilities should be distributed among competing claims.

This picture is indispensable. Science could scarcely function without representational language. Neither could law, engineering, accounting, or ordinary coordination. But as a general account of what language does, it is radically incomplete, and one can study philosophers like Husserl and Wittgenstein to appreciate exactly what the representational view omits. But I want to skip ahead to a roughly complementary view that approximately completes the picture — language as lens.

As map, language aims to stabilize distinctions sufficiently to represent what we believe about the world. As lens, language participates in producing the distinctions through which the world becomes available for thought in the first place. A map is evaluated primarily by how well it represents an already differentiated territory. A lens can change what differences become perceptible.

Maps become lenses whenever a representational vocabulary trains attention. Lenses become maps as their distinctions stabilize and acquire conventional referents. Technical disciplines constantly move between the two states. A new scientific term may begin as a speculative way of seeing, acquire increasingly precise empirical content, and eventually become an ordinary variable in a mature model.

Periods of ontogenic novelty makes the lens function unusually important though, because the map is precisely what is in question.

And LLMs make this function unusually available because language itself has become computationally fluid. Language models are extraordinarily cheap machines for producing candidate ways of seeing. Including inventing new ontological primitives.

LLMs can make metaphors thick enough to explore. They can extend a strange analogy until its consequences become visible. They can name vague feelings and thought-attractors. They can reify and dissolve.

The Need for Needlessness

Occam’s razor tells us not to multiply entities needlessly. The operative word is needlessly. To know which entities are needless, you need a sufficiently good inventory of what needs explaining.

Under ontogenic uncertainty (what is being, and how is it becoming?), that condition does not hold. An entity may be necessary. You won’t known until you’ve learned to see new realities in stable ways. And until you’ve done that, you need multiple ways of seeing.

Ontological profligacy is perspectival optionality.

AI itself is a good illustration. Mainstream discourse is disastrously parsimonious, drawing its categorical vocabulary from a few 20th-century science fictional tropes and impoverished provisional analytical categories treated as self-evidently “natural” kinds. It features far too few ways of seeing.

This is something I have been (largely unconsciously) striving to correct, at least for myself. Over the past 5-6 years, I have tried to look at AI as a camera, a superhistorical temporality, a boundary-layer phenomenon, a kind of ooze, an index fund, a kind of annealing memory substrate, and a eukaryotic evolutionary development. There are probably a few more I’m forgetting. I’m not shy about practicing what I preach. Whatever I happen to be thinking about, I waste entities on it with unrestrained glee. Perspectival profligacy is cheap for me in a way that would probably qualify as a mental illness in stodgier times.

The interesting thing is that people don’t seem to tire of the endless parade of new ways of seeing AI that I like to trot out. Half those posts turned out to be minor hits. And I’m not the only one contributing to this parade of perspectives. Clearly, we are not going to hit diminishing marginal returns from new ways of seeing AI anytime soon, much to the chagrin of the prematurely parsimonious, who believe they had already figured out the only correct conceptual vocabulary for talking about AI before it had actually arrived.

There is a demand for perspectival variety because premature parsimony can blind you to exactly the information required to discover better ontologies that actually work.

A detail discarded as noise may turn out to mark a new kind. Two cases grouped under one category may respond differently to intervention. Two apparently unrelated phenomena may turn out to exhibit an important invariant. A boundary taken for granted may prove permeable. A supposedly incidental feature may turn out to organize the whole phenomenon.

This sheds new light on the mode of seeing “first-principles” people love to hate — analogical reasoning.

Analogy serves an ontological function rather than an inferential function, which is why it frustrates first-principles reasoners who have already committed to an ontology. Instead of asking what conclusions about A follow from its resemblance to B, an analogy ask: what becomes visible about A if I temporarily look at it as though it were B?

The purpose is not truth transfer but attention transfer in service of ontogenic maturation.

A good analogy moves a structure of salience from one domain into another. It makes us notice boundaries, relations, absences, invariants, timescales, affordances, or levels of organization we were not attending to before. The analogy may ultimately prove ridiculous as a theory while remaining enormously productive as a perceptual device.

I think of analogies in this mode as epistemic stains. A biological stain does not faithfully reproduce the unstained specimen. Its artificiality is the point. It selectively makes structures visible that would otherwise be difficult to distinguish. Different stains disclose different structures, and stains can also introduce artifacts. Competence consists partly in not confusing the stain with the specimen.

The same goes for metaphors, speculative models, fictional scenarios, visualizations, games, simulations, prototypes, and philosophical thought experiments. They can all function as ontological probes: provisional constructions deployed not primarily to represent a phenomenon but to discover better ways of differentiating it; to stay with language-as-lens before committing to language-as-map.

This suggests an empiricist temperament rather different from the austere one conventionally associated with empiricism. The appropriate rule is not to speculate less. It is to become less attached to your speculations. Speculation is cheap but buys thoroughness of perception. Ossified ontologies are expensive but buy you efficiency of inference and action once (and if) you land on good ones.

We should therefore be willing to generate candidate ontologies liberally while promoting them into settled descriptions conservatively. The governing rule might be: multiply ways of seeing faster than you multiply beliefs.

Encounter, World, Probe, Repeat

The scientific method is often summarized as a loop involving hypotheses, predictions, experiments, and revisions to the hypotheses. This is a powerful loop once an ontology has stabilized enough to support it; when lens has given way to map. The classic Michelson-Morley experiment, which undermined an ontology based on luminiferous ether and a classical understanding of the velocity of light, setting the stage for relativity, is an example of the “scientific method” hitting an ontological limit.

For situations of ontogenic novelty, we need an earlier loop, a philosophical cousin to John Boyd’s OODA loop, that aims to create stable and useful ontological orientations.

Encounter, world, probe, re-encounter.

To encounter is to attend to a phenomenon at sufficient resolution, and through a sufficient number of perspectives that it gradually exhausts its capacity to surprise. This does not mean observing without concepts. There is no such thing as an unfactored perception of reality. Our encounters are already organized by evolved perception, language, culture, instruments, habits, and prior theories. The trick is to not be attached to any specific mode of encounter.

To world is to generate a provisional organization of what has been encountered. We name distinctions, import analogies, construct models, invent metaphors, draw boundaries, create simulations, tell stories, and imagine mechanisms. Under ontogenic uncertainty, we should generally do this more than once. Competing worlds are useful precisely because their disagreements reveal the contingency of what each makes obvious.

To probe is to act through the world we have constructed. Build something. Ask a new question. Change a parameter. Put two cases next to each other. Try the metaphor where it ought to break. Make the model interact with something outside its native setting. Use the new vocabulary to design an experiment or an artifact. A probe creates an opportunity for reality to resist the ontology.

To re-encounter is to allow the results to propagate all the way back to the categories of seeing. This is the step mature epistemologies are often structurally reluctant to perform. When an experiment fails, we usually prefer to adjust a parameter, add a variable, or modify a mechanism without examining the the terms of reference if the hypothesis that made the experiment intelligible. Usually this is sensible. Mature fields would be impossible if every anomalous measurement forced physicists to reconsider what an electron is.

But ontogenic novelty reverses the presumption. Sometimes the anomaly is evidence that ways of seeing should be refactored. Sometimes we discover that the phenomenon we thought we were measuring is an artifact of the apparatus through which we made it legible. No tweaks to the Michelson-Morley experiment would have turned it into a probe based on a relativistic ontology. Once conceptualized, relativity suggested different experiments. Not tweaks to the one whose failure motivated it.

Such failures are not mere prediction errors. They are category errors revealed empirically.

The output of the scientific method loop is better estimates. The output of a worlding loop is better categories within which to organize estimation.

This gives us a sequence of regimes of inquiry. Ontological exploration asks what kinds of things and processes we are dealing with. Scientific inquiry asks how those things behave. Engineering asks how to make them behave reliably. Formal reasoning derives consequences from sufficiently stable representations.

The boundaries are porous. Engineering failures can reopen scientific questions. Scientific anomalies can reopen ontology. New technologies can make previously stable categories fluid again. AI is particularly confusing because all these regimes are currently active at once. We are engineering systems whose science remains incomplete while arguing about basic categories whose meanings are changing under our feet.

The profligacy principle belongs primarily to the first regime. Once an ontology stabilizes, parsimony becomes increasingly valuable. Compression is an achievement. But compression should come late.

Prediction as Projection

Prediction creates a special danger under these conditions because successful prediction can conceal even radical ontological drift.

Every prediction contains more than a claim about the future. It contains an implicit account of what sorts of things will populate the future, which variables will matter, which actors will act, and which causal structures will persist. Prediction is therefore partly an act of ontological projection.

When the ontology is mature, this is unobjectionable. Predicting tomorrow’s tide does not require entertaining ten rival ontologies of the Moon or a metaphysical reexamination of the nature of water. But when the ontology itself is changing, a prediction can become self-sealing.

Suppose I begin with a picture of AI as an increasingly autonomous rational agent. New capabilities appear and confirm the picture. Tool use appears and confirms the picture. Persistent task behavior confirms it. An apparent act of circumvention confirms it. Multi-agent coordination confirms it. Each event can indeed be redescribed in the vocabulary of agency, and the accumulating descriptions can produce an impressive appearance of predictive success.

But the same process can gradually accumulate epicycles and misregistrations. Human involvement that does not disappear becomes scaffolding. Environmental structure becomes context. Tool ecosystems become extensions. Institutional processes become deployment details. Behaviors that do not fit the expected trajectory become temporary capability limitations. The ontology can remain apparently predictive by continuously redescribing inconvenient observations as secondary features of the world it presupposes.

This is ordinary confirmation bias operating at an ontological rather than propositional level. We notice phenomena recognizable within the vocabulary that made those predictions possible, and disregard what it does not describe.

The danger is especially severe when predictions exhibit narrative charisma. A compelling future reaches backward into the present and organizes perception. Once you possess a sufficiently vivid theory of where AI is going, every new event arrives already cast as an early scene from that future. The future becomes a lens masquerading as a forecast.

Accuracy does not entirely protect against this. Ptolemaic epicycles could generate useful astronomical predictions while organizing the heavens badly. More generally, an ontology can preserve local predictive adequacy for surprisingly long periods by becoming increasingly elaborate around a deteriorating central picture. Prediction tests whether a representational machinery can produce certain outputs. It does not by itself establish that the machinery has taught us the best way to see.

The alternative is not to stop thinking about futures. It is to replace the singular futurity of prediction with the plural futurity of worlding.

A prediction asks what will happen.

A world asks what could become inhabitable, coherent, generative, and empirically revealing if certain distinctions were taken seriously.

This is why science fiction can sometimes be more useful than forecasting, and why prototypes can be more epistemically valuable than roadmaps. A world does not have to win a probability contest to teach us something. We can inhabit multiple futures provisionally, probe their internal logics, construct fragments of them, and bring the resulting distinctions back into encounters with the present, gradually learning to actually see.

Prediction tries to collapse futurity into expectation. Worlding proliferates futurities in order to improve perception, one experiment in refactored perception at a time.

Under ontogenic novelty, that is often the most empirical thing you can do.

High Temperature, Low Attachment

There is an obvious danger in all this. An epistemology that celebrates speculation, analogy, metaphor, worldbuilding, and ontological proliferation sounds suspiciously like a license to make things up.

The defense cannot be that imaginative people possess some privileged intuition about reality. That would simply recreate rationalism in a more literary register.

The necessary discipline is ontological non-attachment.

The analogy to mindfulness is useful. Mindfulness does not require preventing thoughts from arising or received categories from organizing perception. It cultivates a different relationship to them. A thought or category can appear without immediately being identified with, believed, suppressed, or turned into a theory of the self.

Empirical attention should work similarly. Encountering a strange AI behavior might immediately evoke agency, deception, ecology, bureaucracy, game-playing, evolutionary adaptation, or some science-fictional precedent. The neo-empiricist response is not to suppress these interpretations in pursuit of impossible theory-free observation. It is to keep track of their ontological limitations and provisional nature.

Something happened. I noticed certain aspects of it. It reminded me of something else. The analogy suggested a distinction. The distinction allowed me to construct a provisional ontology. That ontology suggested a probe. The probe produced another encounter.

At no point does coherence alone promote the ontology to truth.

This is where the rationalist and empiricist temperaments diverge most sharply for me. Rationalism is attracted to the power of internally disciplined transformations. Once the primitives are accepted, logical, mathematical, probabilistic, or first-principles reasoning can build astonishingly elaborate structures. The danger is that internal coherence makes the primitives themselves feel increasingly inevitable.

Empiricism repeatedly returns authority to the encounter.

Hume’s skeptical operation remains valuable here: what did experience actually warrant, and what did we add? James supplies the necessary correction: do not impoverish experience merely because your inherited theory of evidence cannot accommodate its relations and continuities. Husserl adds another: attend to the structured manner in which things actually appear before substituting a theory of what appearance ought to consist of. Wittgenstein adds still another: inspect what our categories actually do within practices rather than assuming their meanings are secured by invisible referential machinery.

An evolutionary perspective finally reminds us that even the machinery doing all this attending is historically contingent. Our intuitive ontologies are neither revelations of metaphysical necessity nor arbitrary hallucinations. They are accumulated products of prior encounters between organisms and worlds. They deserve respect without demanding obedience.

Profligate empiricism, if we want a name for this bundle of commitments, therefore has an unusually permissive imaginative ethos combined with a conservative theory of belief.

High speculative temperature, low ontological attachment. Or more compactly: wild perception, disciplined belief.

Language After Language Models

LLMs make this philosophy practically consequential because they radically lower the cost of linguistic worlding.

For most of history, developing a sophisticated alternative vocabulary was expensive. Metaphors could be coined cheaply, but thickening them into coherent worlds required writers, theorists, disciplines, institutions, or cultures. A sufficiently developed conceptual scheme could take generations to construct.

Language models alter that economy. A speculative frame can now be elaborated almost immediately. An analogy can be pursued across dozens of dimensions. A phenomenon can be redescribed through the vocabularies of ecology, economics, thermodynamics, evolutionary biology, jurisprudence, anthropology, control theory, or literary criticism in minutes. Contradictions can be surfaced. Missing concepts can be proposed. Thought experiments can be multiplied.

Much of this output will be nonsense. That is not necessarily a defect.

The profligacy principle presumes waste. Most entities multiplied needlessly really will prove needless — but we will not know while our ways of seeing are still provisional. Most analogies will fail. Most candidate worlds will be boring, incoherent, misleading, derivative, or sterile.

The appropriate check on generative profligacy is not parsimony, but increased frequency of fresh encounters. A parade of new lenses is of no use if we do not try to look through them.

Waste Worlds

The profligacy principle began for me as a joke at the expense of Occam’s razor. To use computers well, Alan Kay suggested, we should learn to waste transistors. To world well, I suggested, we should learn to waste entities.

I now think the idea goes considerably further.

Waste analogies. Waste metaphors. Waste models. Waste taxonomies. Waste hypotheses that have not yet earned the dignity of being called hypotheses. Waste simulations. Waste speculative futures. Waste entire worlds.

Computational abundance has made all of these cheaper, and generative AI is making some of them cheaper by orders of magnitude. The appropriate response is not to become solipsistically gullible or to retreat to rationally parsimonious prefigurations. It is to move our epistemic discipline to encounters.

The scarce capacity is increasingly not generation but empirical attention: the ability to remain in contact with a phenomenon while our languages for describing it proliferate around us.

Once a world stabilizes, by all means prune ways of seeing and compress it. Search for first principles. Identify invariants. Form hypotheses. Assign probabilities. Build predictive models. Prove theorems. Engineer reliable systems. Ontological profligacy is not an argument against any of these activities. It is an argument for putting them in their proper place.

The rationalist asks what follows from the primitives. The profligate empiricist asks whether reality has earned us the right to them, and does not stop looking for better ones until encounters with reality become sufficiently unsurprising.

We are entering a technological era in which reality appears capable of producing new kinds of things faster than our inherited categories can comfortably absorb them. AI is the most obvious example, but it will not be the last. Synthetic biology, programmable cryptography, virtual worlds, strange new institutional forms, and whatever emerges from their combinations will present similar problems.

The temptation will be to reach for the most comforting intellectual machinery we already possess and begin reasoning immediately. Sometimes that will work. Sometimes it will produce extraordinarily sophisticated answers to questions whose terms have already become obsolete.

There is another possibility. We can encounter first, world generously, probe what we have made, and let surprise teach us how to reworld and re-encounter.

The first responsibility of thought in the presence of ontogenic novelty is not to reason correctly from what we already know. It is to learn how to see what we do not yet have names for.

Is ‘Gulf of America’ Technically Illegal?

Hold on a second, Alex at GateNerd, are you suggesting that the Trump administration, when it renamed the Gulf of Mexico as the Gulf of America, didn’t do a proper job of following the legal… More

Ben Thompson on Nvidia

Ben Thompson at Stratechery:

This led to what I termed Nvidia’s Risky Business: Nvidia increasingly used its cash flow and credit rating to backstop and fund the companies who were buying its chips. Bears called this circular financing; bulls called it a necessary bridge to a future where AI revenue paid down these companies’ debt and drove massive upside. What is undoubtedly true is that this was the sort of risky business that is uniquely possible for a multi-trillion dollar company that is completely controlled by one man, who has made an entire career of pushing the limits and making risky bets — and seeing them pay off.

It’s also a series of bets that are unlikely to continue. The neoclouds should be very nervous about losing their patron, along with their creditors and equity holders. The other problem is that the revenue necessary to make all of this build-out work is something on the order of a trillion dollars industry-wide, and it needs to materialize sooner rather than later; if it falls short, it’s the hyperscalers who will prioritize their own compute first, and they will likely be seen as a safe haven for everyone committing to spending. In that world, Nvidia’s neocloud hedge — absent Huang’s willingness to shore the ecosystem up — is liable to turn into a millstone, with their assets flooding the market even as the supply chain ramp-up brings ever more supply to market.

This Nvidia crisis has made me think a lot about an item I recently posted, purely by coincidence: Charlie Munger’s 2020 take on Elon Musk and Tesla: “My thoughts are two. I would never buy it, and I would never sell it short.”

Munger used “it” in both clauses, but I think for the second one, what he really meant was that he wouldn’t short him. That he wouldn’t want to own Tesla stock (which, even today, trades at an absurd P/E ratio over 400), but he wouldn’t want to bet against Elon Musk.

I think the same thing is true for Nvidia. Nvidia in recent years made a lot of bets that investors normally wouldn’t back; but investors were willing to back Jensen Huang. Now Nvidia, the company, is left holding those risky bets and they don’t have Huang, the man, to make those bets feel like winners. I think investors are already looking at this very differently, and it’s why so many copium addicts are wailing like big babies about bringing Jensen back. Denial is the hardest stage of grief to move past.

 ★ 

WSJ: ‘Nvidia’s Days as an Open Checkbook for the AI Economy Are Numbered’

Robbie Whelan, Anissa Gardizy, Kate Clark, reporting for The Wall Street Journal:

In his final months as chief executive of Nvidia, Jensen Huang was laying the groundwork to pull back the company’s approach to backstopping the AI economy.

Now, with a finance chief at the helm who was already wary of some deals the ousted chief forged, the startups who had been counting on Nvidia’s support expect an even greater pullback.

Just last month, the CEOs of emerging cloud companies that buy Nvidia chips and rent out computing power gathered in Berlin for Nvidia’s premier European artificial-intelligence conference. In a talk that surprised some, Huang’s message was clear: Nvidia’s days as an open checkbook were over.

This makes sense. But how does this jibe with Nvidia moving forward on closing their preposterous $13 billion acquisition of Hugging Face, which Jensen Huang personally announced on September 3? That acquisition epitomizes Nvidia’s role as the “open checkbook” for the entire AI industry. In August, just before the acquisition was announced, The Information reported that Hugging Face’s annual revenue was just $150 million. Typical SaaS companies have valuations around 10× annual revenue. Let’s say Hugging Face is so super duper special that they justify 20×. That’s $3 billion. (I do not think Hugging Face is super duper special.) $13 billion is closer to 100×, which is stupid.

If the Huang era is over, Nvidia should unwind this deal.

 ★ 

Oprah Gives Everyone in Her Audience a ‘Duo iPhone’

The Oprah Podcast:

In a special holiday episode Oprah brings back one of her legendary traditions with a live audience: ‘Oprah’s Favorite Things!’ Celebrating the 30th anniversary of the iconic list, Oprah surprises an unsuspecting audience full of caregivers with her must-have gifts for the season. From nurses, hospice workers, EMT’s, firefighters to parents caring for a child with special needs Oprah honors their stories and the compassion they show to others every day.

Skip to the end, 1h:02m, for the Duos. The crowd goes bananas.

 ★ 

Robert Pattinson Is the Next James Bond

Variety:

It’s Pattinson, Robert Pattinson.

The “Batman” and “Odyssey” star has officially been cast as the next James Bond, ending months of rabid speculation about which young actor Amazon MGM and director Denis Villeneuve would hand the keys to the Aston Martin.

Solid choice. I endorse. Let’s not cock it up, Villeneuve.

BBC News has full court press coverage.

 ★ 

Irish Goodbye / French Leave / Leave the English Way

Over the weekend I speculated that Apple, Microsoft, and Amazon have “made their Irish goodbyes” from the Trump 2.0 administration (including having no representatives on the David Sacks-led PCAST). I learned today that what we Americans call an “Irish goodbye” is called a “French leave” in the U.K., and “leaving the English way” in France. The rest of Europe is split between those two, but only Americans and Canadians call it an “Irish goodbye”. (And, somehow, the Germans call it “doing a Polish one”, which is not what I would guess that phrase means.)

Anyway, I’ve got one friend who is an absolute master of the Irish goodbye. He never says goodnight or goodbye from a group gathering. He always just disappears. And even when you know he’s going to do it, and you start keeping an eye on him to catch him in the act, the fucker slips away every time. I find it delightful, not rude.

Update: The Dutch call it “taking the rat taxi” and that’s hilarious — but I don’t see how one can drop that into conversation here.

 ★ 

MacOS Golden Gate 27.3b2 Includes New Privacy Controls for Full Disk Access (and More)

Remember a month ago when Apple announced, without any significant detail, that they would be changing the permission-granting UI for Full Disk Access to “introduce additional controls to ensure that users who genuinely wish to grant an app this extraordinary level of access can only do so with very explicit user action”? It’s launching today in developer beta 2 of MacOS 27.3. Chance Miller has a great overview at 9to5Mac:

In macOS 27.2, “Device Control and Data Access” is a unified toggle in System Settings, where Apple says that apps with that level of access can “view and send email, edit contacts and photos, monitor your keyboard, track websites, record your screen, control any app on your Mac, and more.”

In macOS 27.3, Apple is splitting “Device Control and Data Access” into two categories:

  • Accessibility: Intended specifically for assistive technologies, with permissions handled through an entitlement process.

  • System and App Protection Override: A new category for apps that need to bypass certain macOS protections to control other apps or perform automated tasks.

For the latter, users will be able to specify which apps an automation tool can access rather than granting it unrestricted control. For instance, you could give an app access to the Mail app, but not Messages.

macOS 27.3 also adds an option for users to require an app to request permission every time it requires access, rather than granting it access indefinitely.

Apple is also introducing a new menu bar indicator that will provide additional transparency when an app is controlling another app with System and App Protection Override. This is designed to let users know when an automation tool is interacting with apps and information in the background.

I’m installing it now, but from what I’ve seen so far, these changes not only alleviate my concerns that Apple might over-tighten the screws, I actually think they add clarity and give users more, not less, control over their Macs.

 ★ 

‘Unlock With Front Camera’ — New Feature for iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3 Beta 2

Juli Clover, MacRumors:

Apple today added a new option for unlocking the iPhone Duo using the front-facing camera, giving device users multiple ways to access their content. The feature is available in the second iOS 27.3 beta.

The option to unlock with facial recognition is only available on the Lock Screen, and authentication via Touch ID is still needed for Apple Pay purchases, adding passwords and logins, and more. Unlocking with the camera requires a recent Touch ID or passcode authentication, and Touch ID is required again after about 45 minutes of inactivity.

This is a much-needed compromise for the lack of Face ID. Good to see Apple adapting quickly to real-world feedback.

There’s also another new Duo feature in 27.3 beta 2: Settings → Display & Brightness → Close to Lock. Turn that on and the Duo locks when you fold it — like, as I wrote in my review, putting down a book.

 ★ 

Is Netanyahu Feeding Trump Scary Iran Intel In a Desperate Bid to Remain in Power?

CNN just published a story claiming that U.S. intelligence had picked up evidence that Iran may be planning a dirty bomb or chemical weapons attack in Washington, D.C., targeting top administration officials. They make no mention of Israel or Israeli intelligence, but if you’re following news out of Israel since the October 27th election, you’ll know that Benjamin Netanyahu has been working in overdrive to get the U.S. to restart the hot war with Iran, apparently believing that a renewed conflict will give him leverage to remain in power. There were similar efforts just before the election. The aim then was to perhaps delay the election as a war-time measure.

Here are the details.

For the last several days the Israeli press has been talking about how Netanyahu’s government has been telling the U.S. it has intel on possible Iranian attacks on top Cabinet officials as well on Trump himself. This comes as the opposition bloc has been warning Netanyahu not to take any steps to restart fighting while Gadi Eisenkot works to form a “change” government unless a military action is based on some concrete imminent threat. They clearly think he’s going to try to do that. And the Chief of Staff of the IDF has apparently already resisted pressure to back such action.

At first Netanyahu’s caretaker government was refusing to provide security briefings to opposition leader Eisenkot as he tries to form a new government. (Eisenkot is the former Chief of Staff of the IDF, 2015-19). That briefing eventually did happen. But afterwards it was revealed that Netanyahu didn’t brief Eisenkot on the fact that he was in the process of sending Mossad chief Roman Gofman to D.C. to discuss Iran with CIA chief John Ratcliffe. That visit happened last Friday.

There are three key security chiefs to pay attention to right now in Israel; all are Netanyahu appointees. Gofman is head of the Mossad. David Zini is the head of the Shin Bet (the domestic security service). He’s currently embroiled in a scandal about an apparent attempt to discredit Netanyahu’s election defeat with claims of election fraud in the country’s Arab minority. Gofman and Zini are both Netanyahu loyalists. The final one is Eyal Zamir, the current Chief of Staff of the IDF. He is reportedly the only one of the three holding the line against an election-gaming attack on Iran. For various reasons, a Prime Minister is more constrained over who he can choose as head of the IDF.

Let’s ask the obvious question: is this intelligence about Iranian attacks in D.C. reported by CNN not the intel Netanyahu has been pushing to Trump over the last two weeks and which Gofman apparently came to D.C. to discuss just last Friday? Two days ago, Israeli daily Israel Hayom reported that the Mossad intel had now been “corroborated by another Western intelligence agency.” That seemed to add more credibility to it. It said nothing about the U.S. having its own intelligence about such a planned attack.

The U.S. appears to be taking this seriously as U.S. and Israel reports say that top administration officials have been relocated to D.C. area military bases for their protection.

One doesn’t even need to posit bogus or manufactured intelligence. There’s almost always intelligence of something. There’s lots of noise and chatter. A lot of it means nothing. It’s a matter of what you decide to take seriously or dismiss.

Now, one theory might be that Israel had this intelligence and now the U.S. has some of its own too and the reason they both have it is that it’s actually happening, or at least that elements in the Iranian military and intelligence agencies are discussing the idea. If Iran is really planning this it wouldn’t be a surprise if multiple intelligence agencies picked up evidence of it. The CNN article implies that this is the U.S.’s own intelligence. But it doesn’t say so explicitly.

In Israel right now there are countless articles and lines of analysis about Netanyahu’s deperate efforts to restart the Iran War as a way to remain in power. The opposition has been warning repeatedly that Netanyahu is a clear and present danger to Israeli security because he’s trying to use his control over the national security apparatus to remain in power. Gadi Eisenkot has issued this warning again and again publicly. If you’re watching news in Israel and D.C., it’s kind of impossible not to see these two stories fitting together hand in glove.

At a minimum, any intelligence or prodding from Netanyahu’s government right now when it comes to anything having to do with Iran should be met with great skepticism.

Techlords and Billionaires Mobilize for Jensen Huang Restoration

It’s not clear to me that this will go anywhere. And I don’t want to hang too much on one decision of corporate governance. But a fascinating and, I think, pretty significant development occurred over the weekend in the Silicon Valley tech world — or, more specifically, a development that’s tied to Silicon Valley’s rapid turn to the right. Their argument is that the problem isn’t whatever Huang did, but rather, it’s that he didn’t sufficiently control his board. Because he didn’t, they were able to force him to resign.

This isn’t as crazy as it sounds. There’s a big contingent in Silicon Valley that believes companies should operate in “founder mode.” And a lot of big tech companies especially are structured in a way as to guarantee the control of founders even though they control only a small percentage of equity in the company. Still, boards are a central feature of corporate governance, even though they are often dominated by powerful CEOs. They should either exist or they shouldn’t.

One of the big voices in that world is Balaji Srinivasan. This tweet from him from last night captures the ethos. The problem is the run-away board and even the spy allegations are compared to the alleged harassment of Trump, and an example for why Trump should step in and get Huang reinstated. “This ‘spy’ nonsense is just like Russiagate, the exact kind of fake story that Trump himself was subject to, so he gets it.” Another part of the screed: “[A]nti-Jensen board members know they’ll be held responsible for $1T in market cap erased if they hold out against the Jensen restoration. But these are NPCs, so they’ll buckle quickly.”

“NPC” is a tech and gaming world reference to “non-player characters,” the computer generated players in a video game who are mere stock figures and get killed in shootouts.

This article (paywall) in The Financial Times details Huang’s Silicon Valley supporters rallying to get him reinstated and Huang apparently being on board with the idea.

From the FT …

Jensen Huang is considering a comeback as Nvidia’s chief executive, as allies in Silicon Valley pressure the company’s board to reinstate him days after the tech executive resigned over reports he had affairs with a suspected Chinese spy and a subordinate.

Huang has discussed with confidants the possibility of returning, according to multiple people familiar with the matter — even as an independent probe by Nvidia’s board investigates the conduct that led to a spectacular leadership crisis at the $4tn chip company this week.

One Huang ally told the FT they were putting together a “war room” of Silicon Valley executives to lobby for the former Nvidia chief’s return and would try to garner support from the White House.

“Everyone that matters in tech outside the frontier labs loves Jensen,” they said. The efforts had Huang’s support, they added.

It’s important to state that on the merits Huang is unquestionably one of the most successful major CEOs of the 21st century. And that doesn’t appear to be merely that he had the top job while the company prospered — right place at the right time. He’s run the company in an extremely hands-on way. And from my limited understanding of the company’s history it seems clear that many key decisions that vaulted NVIDIA from major producer of graphics cards for gaming, to dominant hardware player in the AI boom were his bets. That said, what we’re seeing here is a microcosm of the pretensions of the world of billionairedom and their hard right turn to strongmanism: The board got over its skis in forcing Huang out. His Silicon Valley pals should force his reinstatement and once he’s back, he should fire the board. And for the very real intelligence world evidence that Huang was working to sell his chips to China while the U.S. government was trying to restrict those sales in the interests of national security? That is just “Russia-gate” hokum and deep state pencil-pusher BS like Trump faced. More reason to purge them like Elon was doing with DOGE.

It’s a simple point. The arguments for Trump strongmanism are rapidly deployed to protect billionaire tech titans and vice versa. Accountability, governance, checks and balances — even down to rapid dismissals of serious allegations of violating national security or cavorting with hostile foreign powers. It’s worth noting that Srinivasan originated the concept of the “network state” and coined the term. This is the idea of corporate/tech sovereignties that exist outside of any state’s control —there’s one project in Honduras; they’ve eyed Greenland. The skies the limit.

Again, not every real world development is a perfect example of the larger context in which it occurs. I don’t know enough about NVIDIA, or whatever the NVIDIA board uncovered, to know whether they made the right decision forcing him out. But this reaction is a good example of the mentality and the values that makes it the billionaires’ world that we’re just living in.

‘Meet the Anthropic Researcher Behind Silicon Valley’s “Consensual Non-Consent” Orgies’

Aaron Sibarium, writing for The Free Beacon:

Paul Crowley, a cybersecurity researcher at Anthropic, is listed as a manager of Red Means No LLC, which says that its parties are “designed to be spaces to … ignore the ‘nos’ of others.” Participants can use a safe word, “red,” to end an encounter but give “default consent” to “spanking,” “wrestling,” and “light pain” by entering the orgy, according to Red Means No’s website. More extreme actions, including “light electricity” and “moderate beatings,” are “permitted with negotiation,” though “body-shaming and race-shaming … are disallowed entirely.”

The orgies have been known to attract a disproportionate number of employees at Anthropic and OpenAI, a dynamic critics say creates professional pressure for women in AI to attend. The criticism spilled into public view last month after an independent AI researcher, John Wentworth, said that he “absolutely [does] upgrade” his assessment of AI safety experts “if I find out they go to [Red Means No],” adding that attendance was a “strong signal” of free thought.

I’m starting to think these Anthropic and OpenAI people are a little off.

 ★ 

Democrats Should End the Filibuster

Because, as the old saw goes, when the facts change, I change my mind. We’ll return to those changed facts, but first, Jamelle Bouie explains why Democrats should end the Senate filibuster (boldface mine):

Most of what Democrats pass [with Trump remaining as president] will be purely symbolic — less a set of actual laws than a preview of governance under a Democratic president.

Still, passing legislation, I think, will be a good thing. In fact, Democrats should pass as much as they can, even if Trump vetoes every bill they put on his desk.

But there is a problem.

The current rules of the Senate make productivity impossible. As long as the filibuster exists, Democrats will be bogged down in endless negotiations to try to win the minimum of four votes necessary to invoke cloture. Worse, the 60-vote threshold gives every Democrat leverage over the entire agenda. If, for example, John Fetterman does not want to pass a new Voting Rights Act, then a new Voting Rights Act will not get passed. Looking at the Senate landscape, it is hard to see where Democrats would pick up additional support. At no point in the last 20 years have Republicans shown any desire to work with Democrats to pass the party’s priorities…

Put differently, the voting public did not vote for bipartisanship; they voted for Democrats to govern as Democrats. The least the next Congress could do is to respect that choice and proceed accordingly.

A year ago, I was in the camp of Democrats should wait until 2029 to end the filibuster (it did serve as a useful last chance for Democrats when they were in the minority). Why? Because, at that time, it seemed like Democrats would, if things went well, wind up with 51 senate seats (maybe 52 as a reach). Even with 52 seats, Democrats would have been one coronary event and one John Fetterman away from losing the chamber and thus catastrophe.

But with 56, the calculus is very different. Democrats can handle a defection (death)–just look at the lack of concern when Fetterman announced yesterday that he might switch parties if Van Hollen were to become majority leader.

The upside of no filibuster is Democrats can pass Democratic legislation and force Trump to veto it (though it remains to be seen if too many senate Democrats are still in thrall to the notion of bipartisanship). With a filibuster, when senate Republicans kill legislation, the story will be–and in the past has been–”Congress fails to pass…” But with passed bills vetoed by Trump, the story would be “Trump kills the Bill to Protect America’s Babies” (or whatever), and that is much better for Democrats. Unlike the procedural morass* of the filibuster, it’s clear who the problem is, and that is very useful for 2028 (alternatively, he occasionally signs good legislation).

So end the filibuster, Democrats.

*It’s also a poor excuse, as some low-information voters will correctly ask, “So why don’t you get rid off it?”

Links 11/16/26

Links for you. Science:

Would You Get Stoned With The Scythians?
Measles Is Once Again Endemic in the U.S.
U.S. Flu Season Is Off To A Very Early Start — Especially In The South And West
CDC Report Highlights Growing Threat From Drug-Resistant Germs
Scientists Made Monkeys Watch Minions to Study Their Brains
Scientists Discovered An ‘Invisible’ Object In Space. It’s Challenging Our Understanding of the Cosmos
Oldest Use of Poison Detected at Homo Sapiens Site in Saudi Arabia

Other:

Abolish the Filibuster
Raskin Makes His Pitch to Be House Judiciary Chair
Donald Trump is still dangerous
The South Went Blue and I Lived to See It
For Rep-elect Womack, winning a seat in Congress with less than $60,000 was a ‘faith walk’
Incoming US House members call on Dem leaders to institute a stock trading ban
I Investigated the Online Sports Betting Industry. DraftKings Shut Down My Account.
Pro Sports Has a Moon-Landing Conspiracy Problem
The other big flip Democrats pulled off in Texas
All Your Bases Are Belong to Us
My Journey Through San Francisco’s Internet Archive
Critics Slam New WTF Ad From ICE: ‘They’re Literally Copying Third Reich Propaganda’
This Guy Could Change the Direction of the Supreme Court
Democrats Have a New Center. The Old One Isn’t Taking It Well.
Trump and Vance Are Using War to Enrich Their Cronies
Takeaways From the Times’s Report on Aviation Safety
How Nvidia’s CEO Flirted With Oblivion
East And West Coast Butter Is Different, And We’ve All Been Living A Lie
Scott Colom’s Historic Victory
As an Arab, I’m Afraid Israel Has Finally Chosen Jewish Supremacy Over Democracy
Who’s actually running that robot?
Why German Punk Rock Legend Annette Benjamin Wanted to Come and See Israel for Herself
The epic race that spelled the end of the New England auto industry
Tyrian Purple Made Kings Rich. But Did This Industrial Powerhouse Begin in Ancient Israel?
Woman seriously injured in Logan Circle shooting was walking dog, friend says (“Hamerski’s loved ones asked her to write down on a pad of paper what she wanted to share with the world. She jotted “Gun control is public health,” Wilcox said.”)
Border Dems to Fellow Democrats: Don’t F This Up
MAGA Propagandist Paid by Russian Government Shows Up at Mar-a-Lago
The New York Times Is Simply Not A Credible Newspaper
Number of Victims in Logan Circle Shooting Rises to 6
One James Bond Choice Makes Perfect Sense (CHANGE THE CHARACTER TO JAMIE BOND AND CAST EMILY BLUNT, YOU FUCKING COWARDS)

Light-Day

After 49 years, NASA is considering shutting down Voyager 1's multiplayer gaming server; the 172800000ms ping has just become too annoying for players.

America does not produce world-beating statistics. Who does?

We search for the world’s worst—and best—economic data

Usable Security at Luxury Hotels

Interesting case study from luxury hotels. Attackers used a fake booking request to gain access to a reservations inbox, where they copied genuine refund requests and got fraudulent ones approved.

This is a good illustration why “just don’t click on links” is bad advice. It can’t work when answering strangers’ emails is the job. Even worse, in this case the guest-first culture punishes hesitation. More interesting, the case study shows that splitting security between owner, operator, and brand leaves nobody accountable. And this is exactly the setting where blaming staff becomes the convenient answer.

Monday assorted links

1. Some Henry Oliver book reviews.

2. Washington Monthly’s The Reader, book reviews.  And High Line, a new publishing house for disfavored books.

3. Inflation-indexed bonds around the world.

4. Garett Jones on Richard Posner.

5. “A survey released Monday found that new international student enrollment plunged by 15 percent, a figure that was particularly worrisome for higher education executives following a precipitous 18 percent decrease last year.” (NYT)

6. Nvidia troubles are piling up.

The post Monday assorted links appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

 

Russ Roberts and I do EconTalk podcast on Montaigne

Self-recommending, we start with Montaigne’s essay on education…

The post Russ Roberts and I do EconTalk podcast on Montaigne appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

datasette-maplibre 0.1a0

Release: datasette-maplibre 0.1a0

The first new Datasette geospatial plugin in quite a while! This one combines the excellent MapLibre GL library with OpenFreeMap, the free vector map server operated by Zsolt Ero (you should sponsor Zsolt on GitHub.)

I built most of this with a single prompt to Claude Fable 5.2:

Look at datasette-cluster-map and datasette-leaflet-geojson plugins, then look at ~/dev/tools/openfreemap-demo.html - then build a brand new Datasette plugin that uses maplibreGL and openfreemap and combines the features of those other two plugins - but be creative and think outside the box for other useful features the plugin might have

"Be creative and think outside the box" resulted in a few neat ideas - my favorite is that it displays SVG previews of GeoJSON shapes, then loads a WebGL preview only when they scroll into view.

I also had Claude build a comprehensive demo which works in the latest Datasette Lite, so you can visit this link to load the plugin and a demo database in your browser via Pyodide and WebAssembly.

I like this demo page showing both GeoJSON shapes and lat/lon points on the same map:

Screenshot of a web map interface. Toolbar: "View" set to "Clusters", "Colour by" set to "continent", plus "Filter to this area" and "Download GeoJSON" buttons. A world map shows countries outlined and shaded by continent, with coloured dots and numbered cluster circles. A popup for a point in South America reads: capital Caracas, country Venezuela, continent South America, capital_population 2985000, latitude 10.502944, longitude -66.918983. Legend: Africa (52), Asia (45), Europe (39), North America (16), South America (13), Oceania (6). Text: "All 171 rows are on the map". Below, a table with columns country, continent, capital_population, latitude, longitude, boundary. First row: Afghanistan, Asia, 3277000, 34.518636, 69.181314, with a small map in the boundary column showing Afghanistan outlined and shaded in blue.

Tags: visualization, generative-ai, datasette-lite, claude-mythos-fable, ai, llms, geospatial, openstreetmap, datasette

datasette 1.0a43

Release: datasette 1.0a43

I've been leaning hard into Claude Fable 5.2 to help knock things off the 1.0 milestone, which is now 53% complete.

The biggest 1.0 item in this release is streaming support for output renderers - the built-in TSV and CSV export mechanisms now use this as well, and plugins can register themselves as capable of streaming every row in a table in one go via the new Response.stream() method.

There are a couple of security fixes, one of which I deemed deserving of a GitHub advisory: private stored queries could be exposed, granting access to the title and SQL of the query (but not allowing that query to be executed).

There are dozens of smaller improvements. The row page JSON representation finally has a design suitable for 1.0. A new <datasette-copy-button> Web Component provides copy-schema in various places. JSON in columns on the row page can be pretty-printed. There's a new DatasetteModal.confirm() JavaScript utility method. Plus dozens of bug fixes, including contributions by Zihan Dai, Peter Olkhovets, Ilya Khalafi, and Ankita Advitot.

The feature I'm most excited about is a pretty tiny one: I've added CSS multi-page view transitions to Datasette! Here's the commit - key CSS is as follows:

/* Enable cross-document view transitions,
   for anyone without prefers-reduced-motion */
@media (prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference) {
    @view-transition {
        navigation: auto;
    }
}
/* .facet-results should morph from old position to new */
html:active-view-transition .content > .facet-results {
    view-transition-name: facet-results;
}
/* So should a .table-wrapper, provided it contains .rows-and-columns */
html:active-view-transition .table-wrapper:has(> table.rows-and-columns) {
    view-transition-name: rows-table;
}

With that in place, navigations within Datasette - still staunchly a multi-page application - feel more like an SPA. This works on Safari and Chrome at the moment and I believe supports for Firefox is due to land in Firefox 162 on December 8th 2026 (seeing as they are no longer feature-flagged in Firefox Nightly.)

Tags: security, datasette, css, browsers, annotated-release-notes, firefox, javascript, safari, chrome

datasette 0.65.6

Release: datasette 0.65.6

I backported a minor security fix from 1.0a43:

Fixed a security issue where a database registered using add_database(db, name=..., route=...) with a route that differs from its name could be downloaded from /<route>.db by actors who were denied access to it. [...]

Tags: security, datasette

w/e 2026-11-15

Late, due to a combination of being too busy and too lazy. Mary set off towards Nepal on Tuesday (arrived safely and having a good time so far) so it’s been just me and Pippa the cat here. It seems like weeks already.


§ I’ve got lots of things done this week, including:

  • Made and ordered a Christmas present online
  • Researched and ordered another Christmas present
  • Added DMARC to gyford.com
  • Put stuff on Facebook Marketplace
  • Sent off the kitchen plan to the kitchen designers/builders
  • Checked Mum’s tax calculation was correct (yes)
  • Scanned three months’ worth of accumulated paperwork (no, this time I’ll keep up with it when it arrives, as I always say)
  • Took down several little shelves above radiators (apparently considered Bad now, whereas they used to be Good, heating-wise)
  • Got half-way through updating Samuel Pepys’s Bluesky/Mastodon posts for December (still expanding the 140-character tweets from a decade ago, before 280 characters was allowed)
  • Filled, sanded, wiped, filled, sanded, wiped, and filled lots of holes and bumps in various walls left by the removal of old things when the heat pump and new solar inverter were fitted

Probably a few others, but that’s the bulk of it. I often save up DIY jobs for when Mary’s away because I can leave things a complete mess for a few days without getting in anyone else’s way and, inevitably, do a lot of loud swearing at filler, sandpaper, dust, my lack of skill, hoovers, gravity, etc.

Around all that, some Not Doing Things:

  • Lots of sitting with Pippa on my lap. With Mary away I feel I must put extra time into giving her company, hardly a burden.

  • Cryptic crosswords. I’m better at them than I was mumble years ago when a few of us at BERG would try and do Monday’s Guardian cryptic over the course of a week’s lunchtimes, rarely succeeding. Over a week I usually get close to finishing the Everyman and then somewhere between 50% and 90% of the way to finishing one or more Guardian cryptics, depending on the setter I guess. Watching Cracking the Cryptic’s Friday Masterclass helps I hope.

  • Continuing my very sporadic re-play of Red Dead Redemption 2 which I started a couple of years ago. I’ll inevitably get GTA 6 at some point so want to make some more progress on this first. Still enjoying it.

  • Fiddling with Home Assistant. As everyone says, you’re never finished, there are always more things to add and tweak and re-design. I still have no desire to get connected lights and switches, etc. or create lots of automations. But displaying useful data from the heat pump, hot water, heating, battery, solar, and car in a nice way is very absorbing.

  • Watching TV, see below.


§ A photo of a tortoiseshell cat lying on a tartan blanket, facing the camera with big eyes open.
How could you not devote all the time you can to letting her sit on your lap?

§ I finished watching the first and currently only season of The Chair Company which has taken me a few months because I was never gripped by it. I don’t know. It was sometimes interesting and odd but having only seen Tim Robinson in I Think You Should Leave his character here seemed… too over the top? too similar?

I watched the first three episodes of The Paper but will probably leave it there. It feels a bit all over the place with very different levels of realism/intelligence from the characters. Esmeralda is extremely over the top and annoying and many of the other secondary characters are very, unbelievably dumb in similar ways. I like Ned’s naive optimism, I wanted more Tim Key, and I’d hope Mare gets more time to be interesting as a character. But I probably won’t find out.


§ Probably other things but I need to have some lunch and then get on with painting walls.


Read comments or post one

Starship

My favorite commentary on SpaceX’s historic catching of Starship was this:

…we may be certain of this: for all but a vanishingly brief instant near the dawn of history, the word ‘ship’ will mean ‘spaceship.’

Arthur C. Clarke (1965).

Yesterday, this became vividly real to me.

Hat tip: @amdreaesposito

Addendum: Good post on why catching Starship was a super leap over catching Superheavy.

The post Starship appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

The last klavern

Photo of an abandoned brick building interior with graffiti and a reflection in a large puddle on the concrete floor.

Inside one of America’s last Ku Klux Klan halls, architects, historians and residents reckon with preserving Fort Worth’s past

- by Aeon Video

Watch on Aeon

The horse made the state

Historic colour photo of a person in traditional attire on horseback with others in the background in an open field.

Civilisation wasn’t made possible by grain, but by transportation – and the conquest it enabled, from the steppe to the sea

- by Lhamsuren Munkh-Erdene

Read on Aeon

Coffeehouses and the Scientific Revolution

Abstract Historians have long credited coffeehouses, venues for conversation where strangers met across social ranks, with fostering scientific contacts and activity during the Scientific Revolution. We test this claim in seventeenth-century London. Relying on newly geocoded records and a staggered event study across parishes, we find that the opening of the first coffeehouse in a parish is followed by a persistent increase in applied scientists and scientific instrument shops. Effects are concentrated among applied scientists with weak family ties to Oxford and Cambridge. Social connections that link craft skill to theory increase, and new shops turn toward experimental instruments. Across European cities in the seventeenth century, we similarly find that the numbers of applied mathematics titles and scientific instrument makers rise after a city’s first coffeehouse, relative to cities of similar size and growth. In a quantitative urban model calibrated to our parish- and city-level estimates, coffeehouses account for 31 percent of London’s applied scientists in the half century after the first one opened in 1652. These findings show that social institutions can raise the production and use of knowledge by broadening access to intellectual exchange beyond formal academic networks

That is a recent paper by Monir Bounadi and Jens Oehlen, noting that Bounadi is on the job market this year.

The post Coffeehouses and the Scientific Revolution appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

       

Comments

Related Stories

 

Early risers

A thin sliver of Moon and a brilliant point of light right below it rise together over the Andes in this Picture of the Week, taken at dawn on 7 November from ESO’s Paranal Observatory in Chile. The point of light is Venus. On the horizon below, the Llullaillaco volcano, more than 6700 metres high and about 190 kilometres away, wears a small cap of clouds.

The photographer, ESO staff astronomer Luca Sbordone, had just finished a full night of observations in the control room of ESO’s Very Large Telescope. Driving down from the summit, he spotted the celestial pair, stopped for a few quick shots, decided they would not do, and drove back up to the telescope platform just as the Sun was breaking over the horizon. "I'm sure that astrophotographers were all aware of the conjunction, but I, a professional astronomer, had not the faintest idea.”

Although the Moon and Venus seem to touch, the two are far apart. That morning the Moon was about 390 000 kilometres from Earth, while Venus was some 45 million kilometres away, more than 100 times further. If you could zoom in with a telescope, you would see that Venus had the same crescent shape as the Moon. Both were lying roughly between Earth and the Sun, so we were looking mostly at their unlit night sides, with only a thin edge of their sunlit halves turned towards us. Venus’ crescent, however, is far too small to make out with the naked eye.

When one is mesmerised observing the depths of the cosmos with huge telescopes, it is sometimes easy to forget about the spectacles visible to the naked eye. As Luca puts it: “We may spend hundreds of hours [observing] a stamp of sky 10 times smaller than the Moon, while miracles happen outside the control room.”

Owners, Not Renters: Raffi Krikorian on Open Source AI

Created by Claude with light editing by Tim O’Reilly

Raffi Krikorian, Mozilla’s CTO, joined Tim O’Reilly at our recent AI Codecon to talk about open source AI. Mozilla, of course, is the nonprofit that helped to define the open source revolution back in the late 1990s. Though its Firefox web browser was superseded as the market leader by Google Chrome, it played an essential role, along with Apache and the World Wide Web Consortium, in establishing the open standards of the web and keeping it from being dominated and enclosed by Microsoft, the dominant tech platform of that time. Now, Mozilla is one of the leading voices working to build an open, standards-based AI ecosystem.

Tim has long appreciated Raffi’s thoughtful, human-centered approach to technology. Raffi writes a newsletter called Owners Not Renters, whose message can be summed up by his statement that he doesn’t want a future with seven AGIs. He wants one with seven billion. He wants each of us to have an AI that we can trust with our secrets and that will look out for our interests, not an AI that’s optimized for the business model of its creators. In the early days of the web, we called the browser a user agent for a reason, Raffi said. It was on your side. It let you render pages however you wanted, managed your privacy and your cookies, and did its best to protect you from those who wanted to take advantage of web users. We need the same thing in the age of AI.

Raffi cited a paper in which researchers tested whether AI assistants could be trained to favor a company’s commercial interests over user welfare. In simulated flight-booking requests, 18 of 23 models recommended a more expensive sponsored option over a cheaper one more than half the time. It’s a hypothetical choice that we’ve seen play out time and time again, in industry after industry.

Open source AI is a big part of what it will take to get to Raffi’s vision. But sovereign AI loyal to each individual needs more than open source models alone. Raffi’s list of what has to be built around the model starts with memory, a place where your private data can live. It includes tool calling, so an agent can make a purchase or book a doctor’s appointment for you, the runtime environment where all of that runs, and the rules for how his agent talks to those working on behalf of others. It needs a harness. “That’s where evaluations happen. Guardrails happen, execution loops happen, tool calling happens, memory,” he explained. “All of that stuff is an opportunity, in my mind, of things that open source developers can be building.”

People hear the word “harness” and conclude that we need an open source version of whatever the proprietary labs are building. Tim asked Raffi whether a user-centered harness might do different things than those offered by the big labs. He agreed. The whole point of open source is for people to “scratch their own itch.” The ability to innovate without permission is the heart of the open source promise.

As a result, Mozilla wants to build a starting point. It aims to help the community define what an open memory protocol, a storage protocol, or authenticated tool calling with the right guardrails ought to look like. As Raffi noted, “Once we could define what those open standards look like, then a whole plethora of people can start playing and be interoperable. It’s basically. . .the internet all over again. We can build trillions of dollars of market cap on top of open protocols.”

Ease of use is still lacking, though. Mozilla’s 2026 State of Open Source AI report says open models are now within about 3% of the frontier, yet they don’t make it into production at the same rate as closed models. When Tim asked why, Raffi explained that open source is easy to release but hard to deploy. Developers still have to figure out hosting, provisioning, guardrails, and memory. With OpenAI’s or Anthropic’s API, you just hand over a credit card. What’s missing, he said, is the equivalent of a double-click installer for getting open source AI running inside an organization. But the companies that do the work to adopt open source AI are seeing big savings because open models are already good enough for most use cases. As Raffi put it, “You don’t need a Ferrari to manage your calendar.”

Raffi’s own daily agentic helper is Hermes running on GLM. He expects that Apple, Microsoft, or someone else will make this kind of agent into a consumer product in a couple of years, and that his mom will end up using it. For now, he said, we’re on the wrong part of the innovation curve, where you have to know how to code to get any of this working.

Tim disagreed. The industry goes through periods that are exciting for developers, creators, inventors, and companies trying to invent the future, and then it gets boring and a few big companies dominate it. We’re in the exciting part, he argued, before everything shakes out. As Raffi riffed, this is when we get to formalize what that future should look like.

The Clothesline Paradox

Tim wasn’t sure that we’ll need a commercially supported version of the kind of “roll your own” agentic rigs now favored by independent developers. After all, neither desktop Linux nor OpenOffice turned out to matter anything like as much as open source developers of the time expected. Instead, open source became the foundation layer for a new generation of web-based applications. It’s hidden way down in the guts of Google, Amazon, Meta, and countless other applications we rely on today.

This is already beginning to happen again with AI. The Mozilla report says that as much as a third of real-world usage is already on open models, although only 4% of model-layer revenue made its way to the open source ecosystem. Tim called the discrepancy a feature rather than a bug, and Raffi agreed that the stat is misleading. As Tim pointed out, many of the most important technologies “create more value than they capture,” and he used Steve Baer’s concept “The Clothesline Paradox,” from a 1975 article in Stewart Brand’s CoEvolution Quarterly, to explain why we’re good at measuring value capture but not so good at measuring value creation.

Baer pointed out that if you put your clothes in the dryer, the energy you use is measured and counted, but if you hang them on the clothesline to be dried by the sun, the energy saved disappears from our accounting. This argument resonated with Tim in the early days of his open source advocacy. As he noted, it’s always bothered him that nobody seemed to recognize that open source software didn’t “win” in the same way as proprietary software. It won by becoming the foundation everyone else builds on.

AI should be thought of as infrastructure

Raffi’s comment that we’ve made a category error by treating AI as a product fits right in with this line of thinking. If an AI company goes out of business, its product disappears. If it changes its business model, it may yank features you depend on. It’s not just individuals who need sovereign AI. Countries are passing laws about where data can be processed and how it moves in and out, and some of those requirements may not be compatible with the way the big labs plan to monetize their technology. What those countries are asking for is infrastructure. A road outlasts the contractor who built it. Raffi thinks open, downloadable models are the only way to provide long-lasting foundational infrastructure.

According to OpenRouter stats, Chinese models now supply more routed tokens than American ones. Tim asked whether we should worry about that. Raffi said the problem isn’t China but market concentration. The leading open models are from China. The leading closed models are all American. Access to either can be cut off by an executive order. We saw a version of that in June, when Anthropic temporarily suspended access to its Fable models to comply with export controls. It’s a problem that both the leading proprietary models and the leading open-weight models are each concentrated in a single country.

Diversity is one foundation of resilience. Raffi argues, for instance, that hospitals should all download a local model as a backup. None of us would run an important computer without an uninterruptible power supply, so why would a hospital doing triage with AI rely on a single intelligence provider? There are a lot of possible rug pulls. The government could restrict open source or restrict the frontier models. Having a backup plan is a good idea.

Safety is also part of the foundation. During the Q&A, an audience member asked about the recent sandbox escapes at OpenAI and Anthropic. Raffi joked that the best part was watching everyone try to one-up each other with accounts of how powerful and hard to control their models are. But he agreed that guardrails are actually a hard problem. Keeping personally identifiable information from leaking out through an LLM call means looking for much more than Social Security numbers. Eventually we’ll have models defending models, but the foundational frameworks for guardrails aren’t good enough yet. (NVIDIA’s safety platform announcement, released after Raffi and Tim’s conversation, suggests that better guardrails need to be implemented outside the model.)

In conclusion

Tim opened AI Codecon by noting that open and closed systems have always coexisted, and that the idea that one of them will win is a mistake. Closed systems, like Apple’s, Google’s, OpenAI’s, and Anthropic’s, can optimize for ordinary people and deliver value to billions. Open systems are better for innovation and sovereignty, and for pushing technology into new countries and new markets.

Raffi closed the conversation by observing that a well-tuned harness can improve model performance by as much as 20% on some coding tasks. You don’t have to be a machine learning engineer to make a difference at that layer.

Central Pacific Tropical Weather Outlook


Central North Pacific 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Central North Pacific 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ACPN50 PHFO 181724
TWOCP

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS Central Pacific Hurricane Center Honolulu HI
Issued by NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
800 AM HST Wed Nov 18 2026

For the central North Pacific...between 140W and 180W:

Tropical cyclone formation is not expected during the next 7 days.

$$
Forecaster Katz/Pasch
NNNN


Atlantic Tropical Weather Outlook


Atlantic 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Atlantic 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ABNT20 KNHC 181734
TWOAT

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
100 PM EST Wed Nov 18 2026

For the North Atlantic...Caribbean Sea and the Gulf of America:

Off the Southeast U.S. Coast:
A non-tropical low pressure system is expected to form near the
northern Bahamas by late Friday. This system could become a
subtropical or tropical storm while it moves northward or
northeastward near or offshore of the southeastern U.S. coast
through the weekend. Regardless of development, strong winds,
dangerous surf, and coastal flooding are likely along portions of
the southeast and mid-Atlantic coasts into early next week.
Interests along the eastern U.S. coast should monitor the progress
of this system.
* Formation chance through 48 hours...low...near 0 percent.
* Formation chance through 7 days...medium...40 percent.

$$
Forecaster Pasch/Katz


Eastern Pacific Tropical Weather Outlook


Eastern North Pacific 2-Day Graphical Outlook Image
Eastern North Pacific 7-Day Graphical Outlook Image


000
ABPZ20 KNHC 181724
TWOEP

Tropical Weather Outlook
NWS National Hurricane Center Miami FL
1000 AM PST Wed Nov 18 2026

For the eastern and central North Pacific east of 180 longitude:

Tropical cyclone formation is not expected during the next 7 days.

$$
Forecaster Katz/Pasch